Judge Cannon’s Latest Mar-a-Lago Ruling Just Got

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Bhawks Goodspeed65 #92918
867
Judge Cannon’s Latest Mar-a-Lago Ruling Just Got Benchslapped

OUCH


The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals took a sledgehammer to the Trump-appointed judge’s misreading of the law.

https://www.thedailybeast.com/judge-aileen-ca...t?ref=home

Mitchell Epner
Published Sep. 22, 2022 3:03PM ET


Photo Illustration by Luis G. Rendon/The Daily Beast/Getty

In its ruling yesterday overturning Judge Aileen Cannon’s injunction—with regard to the approximately 100 documents bearing classified markings seized from former President Donald Trump’s Mar-A-Lago residence— the 11th Circuit did not merely overrule Judge Cannon, it went out of its way to detail the many ways in which Judge Cannon had fundamentally misstated the law.

In my more than 25 years of practice as a criminal and civil litigator (including three years as an assistant U.S. Attorney), I do not believe that I have read an appellate decision that was more dismissive of the lower court. The 11th Circuit sent a clear message to Judge Cannon and Trump: stop doing this.

Trump’s In La-La Land When It Comes to Executive Privilege
LAW IS A THING
Mitchell Epner
https://www.thedailybeast.com/trumps-in-la-la...-privilege

Let's take them one by one.

1. The 11th Circuit (in Footnote 4 of its ruling) explicitly poured cold water on the idea that the FBI raid was designed solely to harass Trump:

The Supreme Court has recognized an exception to this general rule—where the “the threats to enforce statutes against appellants are not made with any expectation of valid convictions, but rather are part of a plan to employ arrests, seizures and threats of prosecution under color of the statutes to harass appellants.” Plaintiff has not made such an allegation here, nor do we see any evidence in the record to support one.

2. The 11th Circuit absolutely eviscerated Judge Cannon's finding that the prospect of facing criminal prosecution was a harm from which Trump deserved protection:

Second, we find unpersuasive Plaintiff’s insistence that he would be harmed by a criminal investigation. “Bearing the discomfiture and cost of a prosecution for a crime even by an innocent person is one of the painful obligations of citizenship.” Cobbledick v. United States, 309 U.S. 323, 325 (1940).

3. The 11th Circuit literally held that none of the relevant factors favored granting Trump his injunction:

In sum, none of the Richey factors favor exercising equitable jurisdiction over this case. Consequently, the United States is substantially likely to succeed in showing that the district court abused its discretion in exercising jurisdiction over Plaintiff’s motion as it concerns the classified documents.

4. The 11th Circuit also flamed Judge Cannon's attempt to split the baby by holding that the intelligence community could continue the national security review of the 100 documents bearing classified markings, but the FBI could not do any criminal work with those documents:

This distinction is untenable. Through [Assistant Director of the Counterintelligence Division of the FBI] Kohler’s declaration, the United States has sufficiently explained how and why its national-security review is inextricably intertwined with its criminal investigation. When matters of national security are involved, we “must accord substantial weight to an agency’s affidavit.”

5. The 11th Circuit also affirmed the Justice Department’s argument that allowing the Special Master—or Trump’s defense team—to review the 100 documents bearing classified markings would be an "irreparable harm" to the United States.
The United States also argues that allowing the special master and Plaintiff’s counsel to examine the classified records would separately impose irreparable harm. We agree.

The Supreme Court has recognized that for reasons “too obvious to call for enlarged discussion, the protection of classified information must be committed to the broad discretion of the agency responsible, and this must include broad discretion to determine who may have access to it.”

As a result, courts should order review of such materials in only the most extraordinary circumstances. The record does not allow for the conclusion that this is such a circumstance.

6. Finally, the 11th Circuit basically held that the DOJ had already satisfied the most important element of an eventual prosecution under the Espionage Act (18 USC Section 793(d).
Here’s what Section 793(d) states:

"Whoever, lawfully having possession of [a document] relating to the national defense which information the possessor had reason to believe could be used to the injury of the United States or to the advantage of any foreign nation…willfully retains the same and fails to deliver it on demand to the officer or employee of the United States entitled to receive it" violates the Espionage Act and "shall be…imprisoned not more than ten years" for each document willfully retained.

Yesterday, the 11th Circuit held:

The documents at issue contain information “the unauthorized disclosure of which reasonably could be expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security."

The 11th Circuit almost certainly selected that parallel language to provide Judge Cannon and Trump a message: the former president does not have any legal defense to an indictment for violation of the Espionage Act. If he is indicted, the indictment will not be dismissed. If he is convicted, the conviction will not be overturned.

In short, so long as the documents were properly marked as classified in the first place, Trump is screwed.

In summation, my take on the 11th Circuit's response to Judge Cannon's order is best captured by Vincent LaGuardia Gambini in his opening statement in the 1992 film My Cousin Vinny:

“Everything that guy just said is bullshit.”


Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Implantica's U.S. Launch Arrives With Cash Still to Burn

Updated Category News Views 104

RefluxStop has finally stepped onto American soil, and that changes the conversation around Implantica in a very real way. FDA Premarket Approval arrived on August 20, then the first U.S. procedures were completed in early November at the University of Southern California. For a small medtech outfit, clearing that regulatory gate and getting actual patients treated are...

Continue Reading
Decibel's Export Engine Masks a Domestic Sales Slip

Updated Category News Views 73

Decibel’s overseas business is doing the heavy lifting, and it is not doing it quietly. Third-quarter net revenue reached $35.1 million, up 7% from a year earlier, while international sales jumped 44% to a record $12.1 million. That split matters more than the headline. Canadian adult-use sales fell 6% to $23.0 million, which means the company is proving it can find...

Continue Reading
Brightstar Picks Warsop for Its Next CEO Chapter Ahead

Updated Category News Views 99

A Handoff With Plenty Riding on the Rails A lottery supplier changing captains is not usually fireworks, but this one deserves a hard look. Brightstar Lottery has named Thomas Warsop to replace Vince Sadusky as chief executive officer and board member effective January 1, 2027. Sadusky is retiring from both posts on that date. The company is telegraphing an orderly baton...

Continue Reading
Winter Leaks Can Lock In Tarrant Sewer Costs for 2027

Updated Category News Views 86

Silent toilet seepage has a nasty habit of turning winter into a twelve-month utility hangover. Tarrant County homeowners are heading into the period when some local cities use household water consumption to calculate residential sewer charges for the following year. That is not the sort of detail anybody enjoys thinking about during the holidays, but ignoring it can be...

Continue Reading
Rare Stellar Merger Validates RIT Theory in Nature

Updated Category News Views 82

One star swallowed another’s orbit, and astronomy finally caught the evidence. That is the plain-English punch of the observation called AT 2025abao in the Andromeda Galaxy, and it is a meaningful one for Jason Nordhaus and his colleagues at Rochester Institute of Technology. On Nov. 18, research published in Nature validated a scenario Nordhaus’s team had predicted...

Continue Reading
Tigerlily Takes Its Advocacy Model to Ovarian Cancer

Updated Category News Views 90

Ovarian cancer has a nasty habit of hiding behind symptoms people are taught to shrug off. Persistent bloating or pelvic pain can look like any number of ordinary problems, and that ambiguity is exactly why practical, trusted education matters. Tigerlily Foundation's new ovarian cancer initiative is not a flashy breakthrough claim. It is a grounded attempt to help women...

Continue Reading
OFRM Recall Leaves Investors Facing Hard Questions

Updated Category News Views 22

Nothing wrecks a young consumer brand’s glow faster than a recall involving toddlers, and Once Upon A Farm has just learned that lesson in the ugliest possible way. On November 2, 2026, shares of NYSE:OFRM fell 37% to close at $9.44. That left the stock roughly 47% below its $18 IPO price. Those are not the garden-variety bruises of a weak quarter. That is the market...

Continue Reading
Century Lithium Clears a Crucial Nevada Permit Gate

Updated Category News Views 24

Permitting news rarely rings a cash register, but it can stop one from being bolted shut. Century Lithium has received confirmation from the Bureau of Land Management’s Tonopah Field Office that baseline studies for its wholly owned Angel Island lithium project in Esmeralda County, Nevada, are complete. The agency also set the project on the Environmental Impact...

Continue Reading
GFT's Banking Leader Tag Puts Execution Risks Into Focus

Updated Category News Views 82

A banking overhaul is where glossy slides go to die. That is why GFT Technologies being named a Leader in QKS Group's 2026 SPARK Matrix for Digital Banking Services deserves a little more attention than the usual analyst-firm trumpet blast. This is not a prize for making a pretty mobile app. The work described here runs through strategy, architecture, core-platform...

Continue Reading
HLRBO's Data-Heavy Rebuild Changes Hunting Lease Market

Updated Category News Views 95

A hunting lease used to begin with hearsay, blurry photos, and a whole lot of hoping. HLRBO is trying to drag that stubbornly analog process into a data-rich, phone-first marketplace, and frankly, it is about time. The company rebuilt its web and mobile platforms around parcel information, plain-language AI search, mobile lease completion, and its Land IQ™ scoring...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Yourway Learning Raises $9 Million for Innovative AI Solutions

Updated Category News Views 261

Yourway Learning Secures $9 Million in Funding Yourway Learning has successfully closed a $9 million equity funding round, a significant boost aimed at pushing forward its mission of enhancing K-12 education through innovative AI solutions. The company's focus is on providing trusted, teacher-centered technology that addresses the unique challenges of modern educational...

Continue Reading
Investors Complain: Oddity Tech Ltd. Faces Class Action Allegations

Updated Category News Views 97

Concerns for Investors of Oddity Tech Ltd. Oddity Tech Ltd. (NASDAQ: ODD) is currently under scrutiny. Rosen Law Firm, a prominent global law firm focused on protecting investor rights, has alerted shareholders about a class action lawsuit that has been filed on their behalf. This lawsuit includes all individuals who bought Oddity's securities within a specific timeline,...

Continue Reading
Critical Update on aTyr Pharma's Securities Class Action

Updated Category News Views 219

Understanding the Class Action Lawsuit Against aTyr Pharma Investors should be aware of an ongoing securities class action lawsuit involving aTyr Pharma, Inc. (NASDAQ: ATYR), which highlights the importance of understanding legal proceedings that may impact financial interests. This lawsuit has garnered attention due to its implications for shareholders who acquired...

Continue Reading
Ping An Good Doctor's Robust Growth and Future Strategies Unveiled

Updated Category News Views 303

Ping An Good Doctor's Impressive Interim Performance Ping An Healthcare and Technology Company Limited (Stock Code: 1833.HK) has released its interim results, showcasing a remarkable performance for the first half of 2025. The company has reported total revenue reaching RMB2.5 billion, which reflects a substantial year-on-year increase of 19.5%. Moreover, the net profit...

Continue Reading
Revolutionizing Road Safety: The All-New Auto Air Pump

Updated Category News Views 171

Introducing the Auto Air Pump: A Solution for Flat Tires In an ever-evolving world where travel plays a vital role, ensuring safe and reliable journeys is of utmost importance. Few events are as frustrating as dealing with a flat tire, especially when help is far away. The Auto Air Pump has been designed to address this issue effectively. This compact yet powerful tire...

Continue Reading