With the Stroke of a Pen: What Executive Branch Actions

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone

With the Stroke of a Pen: What Executive Branch
Actions Can President-elect Trump “Undo” on Day
One?
11/22/2016

Throughout the campaign, Donald Trump
suggested
that, if elected, he would rescind significant pieces of the Obama
Administration’s domestic policy.

Now that President-elect Trump will assume the duties and powers of the presidency
at noon on January 20, 2017,
questions
have been raised regarding what types of executive branch actions he can, in
fact, unilaterally and immediately revoke. While the Constitution does not permit the President to single-handedly
repeal or amend statutes, there is much that a new President can do to rapidly reverse the policies of a previous
administration.
The process and expediency by which an executive action can be rescinded depends on the type of action in question
and the existence of any statutorily or judicially imposed restraints. Generally, most executive actions can be broken
down into three basic categories:
executive orders
, which are written directives issued by the President that govern the
actions of executive branch officials and agencies;
discretionary agency directives and guidance documents
, which are
agency policy or interpretive pronouncements that are not issued pursuant to formalized procedures and do not have the
force and effect of law; and
agency rules
, which are issued pursuant to delegated authority from Congress—typically
pursuant to notice and comment rulemaking procedures— and have the force and effect of law.
Executive Orders
The President
can immediately revoke, modify, or supersede executive orders issued by a predecessor. In comparison to
statutes and agency rules, executive orders generally can be issued quickly and without compliance with elaborate
procedures or participation from other parties. The trade-off, however, for the expediency of an executive order is its
inherent fragility, especially across administrations. An executive order may be as swiftly repealed as it was issued, and
recent Presidents have traditionally exercised this prerogative. For example, both Presidents
Obama
and George W.
Bush
acted quickly to revoke executive orders issued by their predecessors that did not reflect their own policy goals.
Despite the attention paid to executive orders, not all policy initiatives emanating from the executive branch have been
implemented
via executive order
during the Obama Administration. Some of the current Administration’s more
contentious policies were
instead
implemented pursuant to discretionary agency directives and guidance documents.
Discretionary Agency Directives and Guidance Documents
A new President can also immediately direct the heads of executive branch agencies to withdraw discretionary
directives and guidance documents that were issued by an executive agency during a previous administration. These
pronouncements can generally be identified by the procedures, or lack thereof, employed by the agency prior to their
issuance. For example, these
directives
—which would include agency policy statements, interpretive rules, guidance
documents, letters, and press releases—are not issued pursuant to the
notice and comment rulemaking procedures
of the
Administrative Procedure Act (APA), and thus generally lack the force and effect of law. Like executive orders, the
expediency and ease with which discretionary agency directives and guidance documents are issued contributes to their
lack of permanence. It is unlikely that an agency head would need to comply with many additional procedures in
withdrawing these types of directives, and thus they can generally be withdrawn swiftly.
There are numerous examples of discretionary agency directives and guidance documents issued during the Obama
Administration. These documents form the basis for policies such as the Administration’s
Deferred Action for
Childhood Arrivals
program in immigration; the Department of Justice’s
non-enforcement of federal marijuana laws
in
states that have legalized the drug; and the Department of Education’s
interpretive guidance
governing the application
of civil rights laws to transgender individuals. All of these documents may be revoked by a new administration.
Agency Rules and Regulations
Agency rules and regulations may also be
repealed
by a new administration; however, the repeal process can be time
consuming and must comply with certain mandated procedures. The vast majority of agency “rulemakings” must
comply with the APA’s notice and comment process
, which requires an agency to provide the public with notice of a
proposed rulemaking and a meaningful opportunity to comment on the rule (generally lasting 30 days or more). The
APA explicitly
defines
rulemaking as “the agency process for formulating, amending, or
repealing a rule
.” Thus,
whether issuing a new rule, or amending or repealing an existing rule, agencies are typically required to engage in the
same notice and comment process. The APA provides explicit exceptions to the notice and comment requirements,
including when agencies can show “
good cause
” for why such procedures would be “impracticable, unnecessary, or
contrary to the public interest.”
At times
, agencies have relied on this narrow good cause exception as justification for
not engaging in notice and comment prior to repealing a rule; however, these arguments have typically been
rejected
by
the courts.
In addition, an agency’s repeal of a rule may generally be challenged by an injured party and will be subject to the same
standard of review
as new rules, namely “arbitrary and capricious” review. Under this standard of review, a reviewing
court
will consider whether the agency has “examine[d] the relevant data and articulate[d] a satisfactory explanation for
its action including a ‘rational connection between the facts found and the choice made.’” Accordingly, the
Supreme
Court
has established that “an agency changing its course by rescinding a rule is obligated to supply a reasoned analysis
for the change ....” That “reasoned analysis” must be based on permissible factors and be reflected in evidence included
within the rulemaking record.
In light of these principles, and in the absence of specific statutory requirements, it would appear that a new President
can generally direct executive branch agencies to revoke existing rules. In implementing that direction, however, the
agency will likely have to engage in the notice and comment process to effectuate the repeal, and, in the case of a
challenge to the repeal, provide a “reasoned analysis” for its decision to repeal the rule.
Reports suggest
that that the
Trump Administration may target any number of existing rules for repeal, including rules issued by the Environmental
Protection Agency, Department of Labor, and Food and Drug Administration.
While the repeal of
finalized
rules may take time, recent Presidents have acted immediately to freeze agency actions on
pending
rules. As discussed here
, these moratoriums generally apply to all pending rules that have not yet been
published as final rules in the Federal Register. In addition, although administrative repeals may be subject to some
procedural delay, Congress has the authority, either through the traditional legislative process or in some cases through
the expedited procedures of the
Congressional Review Act
, to enact legislation that immediately terminates a rule.
Lastly, it should be noted that the President’s ability to compel agency action likely differs depending on whether the
agency is a traditional executive branch agency or an independent agency. Although the President’s scope of authority
over independent agencies is not completely clear, the President is
generally viewed
as lacking the direct authority to
order an independent agency to repeal a rule or revoke a discretionary agency directive or guidance document. Over
time, however, the President may be able to appoint members to head the independent agency that will be willing to
implement his viewpoints.
Posted at 11/22/2016 11:22 AM
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Hard Rock Tampa Bets $30 Million on Smoke-Free Play

Updated Category News Views 86

Cigarette smoke is getting treated like a revenue problem in Tampa, and that is a far more interesting signal than another ribbon-cutting photo. Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino Tampa opened The Breeze: A Smoke-Free Experience by Hard Rock on Nov. 19, 2026, following a $30 million transformation aimed at guests who want clean-air casino time from arrival through...

Continue Reading
Five SEAL Medal of Honor Signatures, One Charity Lot

Updated Category News Views 74

A single rifle can carry a staggering amount of meaning when the names on it belong to all five living U.S. Navy SEAL Medal of Honor recipients. Rock Island Auction Company plans to offer that one-of-a-kind custom precision rifle during its December 4–6, 2026 Premier Firearms Auction, and the financial arrangement is unusually clean: 100% of proceeds are slated for the...

Continue Reading
Trip.Best Expands Global Travel Discovery Footprint

Updated Category News Views 64

Sydney just became the map pin for a fairly serious travel-content land grab. Trip.Best, Trip.com Group's ranking brand, has rolled out its 2027 Annual Rankings with coverage of all seven continents for the first time. This is not an earnings release, and nobody should pretend a hotel list magically turns into revenue by lunchtime. Still, the jump from 85 to 98 annual...

Continue Reading
Point72 Breach Puts Cyber Controls Under the Microscope

Updated Category News Views 76

Two compromised user accounts can turn a supposedly contained cyber problem into a boardroom headache in a hurry. Point72 Asset Management, the global alternative-investment firm founded by Steven A. Cohen in 2014, has reported a social-engineering incident involving accounts that were used to copy files from limited portions of its IT systems. This is not a trading-loss...

Continue Reading
Pompeii Fountain Tests the Value of Concrete Durability

Updated Category News Views 79

Nearly 2,000 nozzles throwing water around a public attraction is a fine way to expose every weak seam in a concrete job. The Fontana Danzante in Pompei, completed in late 2025, is not some quiet decorative basin. It is described as Italy's largest fountain, a nearly 200-meter installation near the Pompeii Archaeological Park that continuously stores, circulates and...

Continue Reading
Candel’s BLA Delay Puts Disclosure Timing Under Fire

Updated Category News Views 150

A December filing turned into a mid-2027 wait, and Candel shareholders absorbed the damage in one ugly trading session. On November 13, shares of Candel Therapeutics fell 26% after the company disclosed that its biologics license application, or BLA, for aglatimagene in prostate cancer was no longer expected in December 2026. The revised plan is to submit in the middle of...

Continue Reading
SQM Investigation Puts Chile Approval Claims on Trial

Updated Category News Views 42

A Regulatory Promise Meets a Rough Earnings Reaction A 5.52% haircut after disappointing quarterly numbers is the sort of thing that makes shareholders stop pretending every loose management comment is harmless. Sociedad Química y Minera de Chile, NYSE:SQM, is facing an investigation by Levi & Korsinsky into public statements concerning regulatory matters, particularly...

Continue Reading
Würk's Bryte AI Targets Payroll's Costly Friction Points

Updated Category News Views 104

Payroll mistakes are the sort of paper cuts that suddenly turn into a hospital bill for an employer. Würk’s Nov. 19 launch of Bryte AI goes straight at that ugly reality in cannabis, beverage alcohol, and other heavily regulated workplaces, where a bad time entry, missed document, or misunderstood policy can create a far more expensive mess than ordinary office...

Continue Reading
Caliway's China Clearance Speeds CBL-514's Next Test

Updated Category News Views 135

China's regulator moved faster than the calendar, and that is the one detail worth circling in red ink. Caliway Biopharmaceuticals has received authorization from the Center for Drug Evaluation under China's National Medical Products Administration to begin CBL-0102, its China study of injectable fat-reduction candidate CBL-514. For a clinical-stage company, an...

Continue Reading
Cybersecurity's AI Tailwind Meets a Brutal Market Test

Updated Category News Views 72

Security software caught a bid while the rest of the tape was getting kicked down the stairs. That contrast is the whole story: investors saw Palo Alto Networks deliver a strong fiscal first quarter and raise its fiscal 2027 outlook, then decided cyber defense may be one of the few technology budgets companies cannot casually postpone. With AI helping attackers locate and...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

India's AI Market: Open Source Fueling Massive Growth

Updated Category News Views 195

February 17, 2026, and the buzz is all about India’s AI landscape—open source is the name of the game. The Linux Foundation just dropped a hefty report claiming India’s AI market will skyrocket from $6 billion in 2024 to nearly $32 billion by 2031. Seriously, that’s some jaw-dropping growth fueled by a mix of homegrown talent, strong government support, and an...

Continue Reading
Growth Projections for the Expanding UV LED Market

Updated Category News Views 115

Understanding the UV LED Market Surge The UV LED market is witnessing a remarkable transformation, with projections indicating it will reach a valuation of USD 2.16 billion by 2030. This trend marks a substantial growth from its anticipated value of USD 1.23 billion in 2025, leading to a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 11.9%. Key Factors Driving Market Growth The...

Continue Reading
Microsoft Partners with Constellation to Restart Three Mile Island

Updated Category News Views 136

Revitalizing Three Mile Island with Innovative Solutions Constellation Energy has teamed up with Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT) in an exciting partnership aimed at restarting a unit of the Three Mile Island nuclear plant in Pennsylvania. This initiative marks the first attempt to revive a retired nuclear facility, showcasing the changing dynamics in energy solutions. As...

Continue Reading
Investigation of WideOpenWest, Inc. Over Potential Wrongdoing

Updated Category News Views 152

WideOpenWest, Inc. Under Investigation for Fiduciary Breaches The DJS Law Group has initiated an investigation on behalf of investors regarding WideOpenWest, Inc. (NYSE: WOW). This investigation is focused on potential breaches of fiduciary duty that may have occurred within the company's board of directors and management. The aim is to determine if the directors have...

Continue Reading
Guidehouse Earns Recognition as Celonis Partner of the Year

Updated Category News Views 266

Guidehouse Recognized as Celonis Public Sector Partner of the Year Innovation is at the forefront of modern public sector operations, and Guidehouse has made significant strides in this area. The firm was honored with the Celonis Public Sector Partner of the Year award, showcasing its dedication to transforming government processes through advanced technology. Leading...

Continue Reading