Surgeon general’s e-cigarette report panned as ‘truly
Surgeon general’s e-cigarette report panned as ‘truly terrible’(oid)
Insert-tag-herewatchdog.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/blogs.dir/1/files/2016/12/vadm-murthy2-600x763.jpg
The reaction to the U.S. surgeon general’s first-ever report on e-cigarettes has been swift and severe.
“It is truly terrible,” writes Counterfactual’s Clive Bates, a former executive director of Action on Smoking and Health.
“It’s so bizarrely bad,” said Jeff Stier, risk analyst with the National Center for Public Policy Research.
“The Surgeon General has failed the American people,” Gregory Conley, president of the American Vaping Association, said in a statement.
“Full of false, misleading, deceptive statements re #ecigs. Needs a health warning: do not read!” tweeted Derek Yach, a former executive with the World Health Organization.
The primary problem with the 298-page report — E-Cigarette Use Among Youth and Young Adults — according to critics, is that Surgeon General Vivek Murthy ignored science and addressed only risks of e-cigarette use by youth, while neglecting to include the real benefits to adult smokers.
In his scathing review, Bates called the report a “heady mix of emotive propaganda and a completely warped and one-sided account of the science.” He said the findings reveal “a lack of insight into youth behaviors,” as well as ignorance about the tobacco and nicotine market and its consumers.
Murthy acknowledged in the report’s preface that the science is indeed incomplete.
“Gaps in scientific evidence do exists,” he wrote. “[A]nd this report is being issued while these products and their patterns of use continue to change quickly.”
Neither the rapidly changing e-cigarette culture nor the dearth of sound science stopped Murthy from issuing broad policy recommendations to deal with the 900 percent growth in usage among high school students from 2011 to 2015 — “a public health concern,” according to the report.
Among other strategies, Murthy suggests incorporating e-cigarettes into smokefree policies, preventing youth access to e-cigarettes, imposing high taxes and targeting youth with educational programs.
The recommendations stem from what the report considers potential adverse health effects of direct and secondhand exposure to nicotine, chemicals, aerosol and “other particulates.”
While no one thinks young people should use nicotine products, critics say the report fails to show actual harm. “Is this a big deal or not? We have no way to know,” Bates wrote.
He notes that mere exposure to chemicals isn’t enough to show harm, and added that the report “ducks the issue” of whether actual e-cigarette use has negative health effects.
Stier echoed those concerns: “If the surgeon general goes on to make policy recommendations based only on the risk part of the equation, without considering the benefits, he will have failed his fundamental obligation of improving public health.”
Dr. Edward Anselm, senior fellow a the R Street Institute, says use of cigarettes and e-cigarettes is at an all-time low. He also highlighted a link between the two: “Young people who try e-cigarettes are more likely to experiment with other adult behaviors, including smoking. If there were no e-cigarettes, they would go straight to smoking.”
University of Michigan researcher Dr. Ken Warner says the surgeon general ignored a landmark study from England which could be a game-changer for the United States.
“The Royal College of Physicians issued a report in which they concluded that e-cigarettes were likely 95 percent less dangerous than smoking, and should be used by smokers to try to get off of cigarettes, if they have been unable to do so otherwise,” Warner told Watchdog.org.
“The difference in conclusions between these two reports is amazing,” he said.
Warner says the United Kingdom takes a completely different approach to e-cigarettes, viewing vaping as an aid to quit smoking.
“In the U.S., e-cig companies are not even permitted to advertise that their products are less dangerous than smoking because they haven’t gone through the FDA approval process to do so,” he said. “Most of the companies don’t have the resources necessary to get that approval, which requires a long, laborious, and very expensive effort, with no assurance of approval.”
RELATED The FDA’s illogical attack on e-cigarettes
The timing of this report could be fortuitous, as President-elect Donald Trump’s transition team is considering candidates for the next commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration. The next FDA chief could radically overhaul the agency and upend the huge regulatory regime that includes the recent rules on the e-cigarette industry.
Top names under consideration are Jim O’Neill, a former Health and Human Services advisor, and Dr. Scott Gottlieb, a former FDA deputy commissioner and current resident fellow with the American Enterprise Institute.
Murthy is halfway through his four-year post as surgeon general. But in the wake of today’s report, some groups, including Americans for Tax Reform, are calling for Trump to dismiss Murthy. The group’s online petition urges Trump to “fire the Surgeon General and replace him with someone who actually cares about tobacco harm reduction and saving lives.”
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP
Scroll down for more posts ▼
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
Castings are rarely glamorous until nobody can get them, and Mudrick Capital is betting that ugly little industrial reality could make Doncasters worth far more in a takeover than the market currently credits. The event-driven investor, which says it owns roughly 4.3% of DPC Holdings Limited, has asked the board to quietly evaluate strategic alternatives, including a sale...
Continue Reading
A wealth manager’s website rarely earns applause, but a bad one can sure as hell lose trust fast. Vanguard’s move to No. 1 from No. 3 in the 2025 ranking for advised-investor website satisfaction is worth noticing because it hits the unglamorous part of wealth management that clients actually live with: checking accounts, understanding a plan, moving cash, and...
Continue Reading
Personalized cancer vaccines have no shortage of grand promises; seasoned clinical operators are the rarer commodity. That is why BreakBio's appointment of Dr. Greg Lizée as chief scientific officer deserves a closer look, even if nobody should confuse an executive hire with clinical validation. BreakBio is private, its lead program remains in development, and cancer...
Continue Reading
Two compromised user accounts can turn a supposedly contained cyber problem into a boardroom headache in a hurry. Point72 Asset Management, the global alternative-investment firm founded by Steven A. Cohen in 2014, has reported a social-engineering incident involving accounts that were used to copy files from limited portions of its IT systems. This is not a trading-loss...
Continue Reading
A blister-pack code is doing far more work than it ever should. Green Lumber Holdings is recalling Green Lumber Natural Fuel For Men, lot GL01 with expiration 09/27, after FDA laboratory analysis confirmed undeclared tadalafil in additional samples. The company says the consumer-level recall begins November 19, 2026. This is not a cute labeling nitpick or a marketing...
Continue Reading
One partnership can look like a gold mine from across the valley; getting the ore out is another matter entirely. DarioHealth has struck a strategic partnership with WebMD Health Services that could put its multi-condition care platform in front of an enormous commercial ecosystem: more than 3,500 employers and 65 million covered lives. That is a meaningful distribution...
Continue Reading
A moon mission, a 360-voice choir, and Christmas television make an unusual bundle, but that is precisely why this year’s Tabernacle Choir special has some real staying power. Peace on Earth: Christmas with The Tabernacle Choir is not trying to chase whatever noisy trend is chewing up attention this week. It is building a 90-minute holiday event around Apollo 8,...
Continue Reading
A gold pendant moonlighting as a plot device is not the usual luxury pitch, and thank goodness for that. ACOLT, the Denver-based men's fine jewelry house founded by Colton Hindle, plans an international December 2026 launch of its Gold Collection alongside CHRYSON Volume 1: The Arrival, an original science-fiction comic. The actual hand-forged pieces are meant to show up...
Continue Reading
A returned jacket can turn into a household cash-flow problem faster than retailers seem willing to admit. Seel's new survey lands at an awkward moment for online merchants: shoppers are not merely annoyed by slow refunds; many are budgeting around them. Among 1,921 U.S. adults who had shopped online in the prior six months, 63% said waiting for a retailer to receive a...
Continue Reading
Twenty-one years is a long time to keep a corporate promise from turning into wallpaper. L’Oréal Paris gathered its 2026 Women of Worth class at the Ebell in Los Angeles on November 18, recognizing 10 nonprofit leaders working on problems that do not yield to a glitzy evening or a tidy slogan. That distinction matters. Cancer survivorship, trafficking prevention,...
Continue Reading
Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
February 17, 2026, and the buzz is all about India’s AI landscape—open source is the name of the game. The Linux Foundation just dropped a hefty report claiming India’s AI market will skyrocket from $6 billion in 2024 to nearly $32 billion by 2031. Seriously, that’s some jaw-dropping growth fueled by a mix of homegrown talent, strong government support, and an...
Continue Reading
Understanding the UV LED Market Surge The UV LED market is witnessing a remarkable transformation, with projections indicating it will reach a valuation of USD 2.16 billion by 2030. This trend marks a substantial growth from its anticipated value of USD 1.23 billion in 2025, leading to a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 11.9%. Key Factors Driving Market Growth The...
Continue Reading
Revitalizing Three Mile Island with Innovative Solutions Constellation Energy has teamed up with Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT) in an exciting partnership aimed at restarting a unit of the Three Mile Island nuclear plant in Pennsylvania. This initiative marks the first attempt to revive a retired nuclear facility, showcasing the changing dynamics in energy solutions. As...
Continue Reading
WideOpenWest, Inc. Under Investigation for Fiduciary Breaches The DJS Law Group has initiated an investigation on behalf of investors regarding WideOpenWest, Inc. (NYSE: WOW). This investigation is focused on potential breaches of fiduciary duty that may have occurred within the company's board of directors and management. The aim is to determine if the directors have...
Continue Reading
Guidehouse Recognized as Celonis Public Sector Partner of the Year Innovation is at the forefront of modern public sector operations, and Guidehouse has made significant strides in this area. The firm was honored with the Celonis Public Sector Partner of the Year award, showcasing its dedication to transforming government processes through advanced technology. Leading...
Continue Reading