June 14, 2015 Disconnect: Kirsten Powers' The Silencing:

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone SaltyMutt #9302
June 14, 2015
Disconnect: Kirsten Powers' The Silencing: How the Left is Killing Free Speech
By David Gayvert



Kirsten Powers’ new book,The Silencing: How the Left is Killing Free Speech provides a thorough account of the hypocrisy, intolerance, and just plain nastiness of what she terms the “illiberal left.”


It is indeed refreshing to read a self-proclaimed “lifelong liberal” call out the abuses of her co-progressives, even if she breaks no new ground in doing so: informed conservatives are already well aware of what regularly goes on in academia, Hollywood, traditional media, and other environments dominated by the left.

In her introductory chapter Powers admits that the systemic phenomenon she reports is only found on the left, though she spends no time there -- or anywhere else in the book -- seriously discussing why that may be so. The ensuing chapters take on the various offenses against speech, logic, honesty, and common decency regularly committed in our universities, media, and public punditry. Powers focuses particular scorn upon hard-core feminist intellectuals who eagerly attack any man and especially woman who may stray from current progressive/feminist pieties. She writes:

When men disagree with illiberal feminists, a favored silencing tactic is to accuse them of “mansplaining.”… liberal feminists have forged the notion of “mansplaining” into a weapon to silence any man who expresses an opinion at odds with feminist orthodoxy. How it works is relatively simple: a “pro-life” man who talks about abortion with a “pro-choice” woman is “mansplaining.” (But a “pro-choice” man agreeing with a “pro-choice” woman is not.)

Powers is also incredulous over the feminist-inspired legitimization of the “micro-aggression” and “trigger warning” regulations increasingly infecting college campuses today, lamenting the left’s focus on “protecting” students from thought that may trouble them, rather than insisting that they encounter and rigorously engage such thought. As she observes:

If a college student is going to be traumatized by The Great Gatsby, then they are going to find day-to-day life unbearable once they step outside the child-care programs that are passing for universities today.

The remaining examples she provides in the nine chapters of the book are familiar: intimidation of students who hold traditional views on religion, marriage, and morality, the hypocritical dismissal of deeply misogynist insults heaved by leftist males against conservative women, and deliberate misrepresentation and fabrication of “facts” in order to promote the progressive worldview.

Curiously, however, with the exception of noting President Obama’s role in the attempt to delegitimize Fox News, Powers is apparently uncurious when it comes to examining similar abuses against free thought and speech promoted by leftist politicians (e.g., Clinton, Reid, Pelosi, Wasserman-Shultz, to name just the headliners) who regularly demonize their political opponents and actively promote the intolerance and hypersensitivity that Powers eschews.

No doubt Powers is genuinely offended by what she labels the “illiberal” impulses and practices of progressives who attack rather than argue against opinions that do not comport with their own enlightened views. She cites example after example of attempts by these leftists to shame, defame, destroy, and otherwise shut down debate and politicize virtually every issue, public and private. Throughout the book, Powers proudly professes her liberalism, and posits, but doesn’t really argue -- i.e., provide evidence other than her own sensibilities -- that “true” liberalism requires free and respectful debate and consideration of the opinions of others. In this she convinces the reader of her fair-mindedness, if not her clear thinking. She cites a litany of dots, but can’t bring herself to connect them. The reader is left thinking: how can she catalog and condemn all this leftist behavior and not see its connection to its underlying philosophy?

For what is hugely missing in Powers book -- and powerfully present in say, David Mamet’s tale of conversion from a “brain dead” liberal in good standing to a thinking conservative -- is the recognition that the attitudes and practices that she abhors are not a distortion or aberrational trend of her professed political proclivities, but an inescapable consequence. Notwithstanding the lofty rhetoric about helping the downtrodden and the “little guy,” the left has ever been about seizing and holding power to enforce equality of condition upon all but the elite who exercise that power. That goal can ultimately brook no dissent. Powers constantly emphasizes her personal preference for respectful debate, but fails to recognize that with very few exceptions, modern liberals have no interest in engaging in free and fact-based debate to persuade others; they see themselves as possessors of the “Secret Knowledge,” and want to impose it upon the benighted masses who are incapable of leading useful lives without it.

Powers’ conceit of the illiberal vs. the liberal left is a valiant attempt to elide the cognitive dissonance that must gnaw at her -- how can people who share my opinions and basic worldview behave so badly?

It is inarguable that well over a century and tens of trillions of dollars spent on liberal programs to combat poverty and various other injustices by attempting to reengineer human nature and absolve various classes of people from responsibility for their lives and behavior have failed to achieve the left’s espoused goals and indeed have resulted in incalculable harm to millions of their “beneficiaries.” Inasmuch as the nobility of the progressive Vision may not be challenged, all that remains is to blame external factors. Powers would probably cite too little money spent, or perhaps even honest disagreements over policy, rather than mean-spirited, racist, homophobic, white, Republican men who hate children and women, but she is a decided minority. She doesn’t seem to understand what “illiberal” progressives -- which is to say all but a handful of today’s politically active liberals, with whom Powers presumably communes -- manifestly do, even if only viscerally: 1) there are no good objective arguments for the progressive vision for society; and 2) naming and shaming ideological opponents is therefore not only the best option for advancing the Cause, it works!

In fairness, The Silencing is not an argument for the progressive worldview or the efficacy of Democrat policies. It is a call for civility in our public discourse, and as such is welcome, though Ms. Powers acknowledges that it will likely go unheeded by the totalitarians she targets. What she doesn’t say, but must realize, is that in fact, the phenomena she recounts will only get worse, given the influence the left will continue to wield on the nation's campuses for the foreseeable future. A better book would have explored why the left’s intolerance of dissenting opinion is so pervasive, and how the politicians and party leaders she presumably votes for and otherwise supports actively encourage such attitudes. Such an inquiry, of course, raises dangerous questions that could be fatal to Powers’ liberal illusions of how the world actually works.

In the end, Powers’ book is best characterized as a variant of the old joke, “What do you call 1000 lawyers at the bottom of the sea?” Answer: a good start. Kirsten Powers has travelled further towards honesty than most modern liberals ever will, but she still has a way to go if her ultimate destination is to understand reality as it is, not as progressives think it should be.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

MIND Takes Its Copilot Security Bet Across Microsoft 365

Updated Category News Views 92

Copilot’s promise gets a lot less charming the minute confidential files start wandering around unchecked. That is the knot MIND is trying to untie with its expanded, generally available integrations across Microsoft Copilot, Microsoft 365, Purview, Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive, Edge and Exchange. The Seattle data-loss-prevention company announced the collaboration on...

Continue Reading
Arbor Realty's Loan Mess Meets a Dividend Shutdown

Updated Category News Views 89

A dividend suspension lands differently when the loan book is already coughing up smoke. Arbor Realty Trust’s latest disclosed numbers are not the sort that investors can shrug off as one ugly quarter and forget by Friday. The company reported a third-quarter 2026 GAAP net loss of $85.4 million, suspended its quarterly cash dividend effective immediately, and described...

Continue Reading
Banks Face a Choice: Retreat or Fund Climate Resilience

Updated Category News Views 93

A flooded field can turn a prudent loan book into a social retreat overnight. That is the uncomfortable nerve in the Global Alliance for Banking on Values paper unveiled at COP31 in Antalya on November 19, 2026. Banks have become very practiced at mapping physical climate exposure, raising prices, tightening standards and stepping away. Fine, risk discipline matters. But...

Continue Reading
Harbour BioMed's LET003 Gets China's IND Green Light

Updated Category News Views 84

Muscle loss has become the awkward fact sitting beside every blockbuster obesity headline. Harbour BioMed's Nov. 18 announcement that China's National Medical Products Administration accepted its IND application for LET003 matters because the company is aiming directly at that problem: losing fat without giving away too much lean mass along the way. Acceptance Opens a...

Continue Reading
Kuaishou’s AI Push Meets a Brutal Earnings Reality

Updated Category News Views 91

Kuaishou just put a very expensive wrinkle in its AI story. The third-quarter figures are not a minor wobble: revenue dropped 11.1% year over year to RMB31.6 billion, gross margin slid from 54.7% to 48.2%, and the company swung from a RMB4.5 billion profit to a RMB959 million loss. For holders of 01024, that is the sort of earnings release that demands less daydreaming...

Continue Reading
FAMID's Six-Month IVDR Win Opens Europe's Market Door

Updated Category News Views 75

A six-month regulatory sprint is the sort of result that makes a crowded diagnostics field pause and squint. DNV has issued an IVDR certificate to FAMID Biomedical Technology for its E7 Oncoprotein Rapid Test Kit, a Class C in vitro diagnostic intended to aid diagnosis of cervical epithelial cell lesions through detection of HPV E7 oncoprotein in cervical cell samples....

Continue Reading
Northstar's December Test: Metrics Over More Promises

Updated Category News Views 11

A shingle recycler earns its stripes when the machinery behaves, not when the slide deck does. Northstar Clean Technologies is putting Empower Calgary under a brighter light on December 1, pairing its third-quarter 2026 results with a comprehensive production update and a new set of operating metrics. For shareholders, especially those following OTCQB:ROOOF, this is the...

Continue Reading
T. Rowe Price Expands Teams Across 12 Fund Strategies

Updated Category News Views 35

A Quiet Personnel Shift With Real Stakes Twelve strategy changes may sound like administrative wallpaper, but asset managers live and die by who makes the calls. T. Rowe Price is broadening portfolio-management teams across equity and fixed-income offerings while insisting that each strategy's philosophy, process, and risk limits remain intact. Fine. That is the stated...

Continue Reading
Rare Stellar Merger Validates RIT Theory in Nature

Updated Category News Views 82

One star swallowed another’s orbit, and astronomy finally caught the evidence. That is the plain-English punch of the observation called AT 2025abao in the Andromeda Galaxy, and it is a meaningful one for Jason Nordhaus and his colleagues at Rochester Institute of Technology. On Nov. 18, research published in Nature validated a scenario Nordhaus’s team had predicted...

Continue Reading
Vision Marine's Cash Cleanup Meets a Hard Reality Ahead

Updated Category News Views 72

A boat dealer slashing debt by $27.5 million deserves a nod, even when the rest of the ledger still makes your eyebrows climb. Vision Marine Technologies turned fiscal 2026 into a working-capital cleanup job: inventory came down hard, floor-plan financing nearly vanished, and operating cash flow finally turned positive. For NASDAQ:VMAR, that is real progress. It is not,...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Investors Unite: Taking Action Against aTyr Pharma's Misconduct

Updated Category News Views 142

Understanding the Case Against aTyr Pharma, Inc. Many investors have faced uncertainty in recent years, particularly in the healthcare sector. aTyr Pharma, Inc. (NASDAQ: ATYR) finds itself at the center of a securities fraud lawsuit, directed by the Schall Law Firm, designed to or encourage investors who may have been adversely impacted by the company's actions to take a...

Continue Reading
BIC Announces Rob Versloot as New CEO for Future Growth

Updated Category News Views 1055

Exciting Leadership Transition at BIC BIC has recently made a significant leadership transition by appointing Rob Versloot as the new Chief Executive Officer. This shift follows an extensive selection process conducted with utmost diligence and care by the Succession Committee under the guidance of Edouard Bich, the Chair of the Board of Directors. Background on Rob...

Continue Reading
Canadian Market Sees Gains as S&P/TSX Composite Hits Records

Updated Category News Views 167

Overview of the Canadian Stock Market Recently, the Canadian stock market has shown significant progress, culminating in a positive trading session that reflected growing investor confidence. The S&P/TSX Composite Index closed the day up by 0.40%, showcasing lively market activity and enthusiasm across various sectors. Sector Performances Fueling Market Gains Key sectors...

Continue Reading
Three Risky Consumer Staples That Might Struggle Soon

Updated Category News Views 153

Overview of Consumer Staples at Risk As recent market analysis highlights, several stocks in the consumer staples sector may be indicating potential challenges that investors should take into account. While consumer staples are generally viewed as safer investments, certain indicators suggest that this perception may not hold for every stock, especially in the current...

Continue Reading
Healthcare IT Outsourcing Market Projected to Reach $122.72 Billion

Updated Category News Views 156

Understanding the Surge in Healthcare IT Outsourcing The Healthcare IT Outsourcing Market signifies a booming ecosystem, anticipated to reach USD 122.72 billion by 2032, with a notable compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 7.44%. The driving forces behind this remarkable growth are rooted in digital transformation and an increasing demand for operational efficiency....

Continue Reading