June 14, 2015 Disconnect: Kirsten Powers' The Silencing:

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone
June 14, 2015
Disconnect: Kirsten Powers' The Silencing: How the Left is Killing Free Speech
By David Gayvert



Kirsten Powers’ new book,The Silencing: How the Left is Killing Free Speech provides a thorough account of the hypocrisy, intolerance, and just plain nastiness of what she terms the “illiberal left.”


It is indeed refreshing to read a self-proclaimed “lifelong liberal” call out the abuses of her co-progressives, even if she breaks no new ground in doing so: informed conservatives are already well aware of what regularly goes on in academia, Hollywood, traditional media, and other environments dominated by the left.

In her introductory chapter Powers admits that the systemic phenomenon she reports is only found on the left, though she spends no time there -- or anywhere else in the book -- seriously discussing why that may be so. The ensuing chapters take on the various offenses against speech, logic, honesty, and common decency regularly committed in our universities, media, and public punditry. Powers focuses particular scorn upon hard-core feminist intellectuals who eagerly attack any man and especially woman who may stray from current progressive/feminist pieties. She writes:

When men disagree with illiberal feminists, a favored silencing tactic is to accuse them of “mansplaining.”… liberal feminists have forged the notion of “mansplaining” into a weapon to silence any man who expresses an opinion at odds with feminist orthodoxy. How it works is relatively simple: a “pro-life” man who talks about abortion with a “pro-choice” woman is “mansplaining.” (But a “pro-choice” man agreeing with a “pro-choice” woman is not.)

Powers is also incredulous over the feminist-inspired legitimization of the “micro-aggression” and “trigger warning” regulations increasingly infecting college campuses today, lamenting the left’s focus on “protecting” students from thought that may trouble them, rather than insisting that they encounter and rigorously engage such thought. As she observes:

If a college student is going to be traumatized by The Great Gatsby, then they are going to find day-to-day life unbearable once they step outside the child-care programs that are passing for universities today.

The remaining examples she provides in the nine chapters of the book are familiar: intimidation of students who hold traditional views on religion, marriage, and morality, the hypocritical dismissal of deeply misogynist insults heaved by leftist males against conservative women, and deliberate misrepresentation and fabrication of “facts” in order to promote the progressive worldview.

Curiously, however, with the exception of noting President Obama’s role in the attempt to delegitimize Fox News, Powers is apparently uncurious when it comes to examining similar abuses against free thought and speech promoted by leftist politicians (e.g., Clinton, Reid, Pelosi, Wasserman-Shultz, to name just the headliners) who regularly demonize their political opponents and actively promote the intolerance and hypersensitivity that Powers eschews.

No doubt Powers is genuinely offended by what she labels the “illiberal” impulses and practices of progressives who attack rather than argue against opinions that do not comport with their own enlightened views. She cites example after example of attempts by these leftists to shame, defame, destroy, and otherwise shut down debate and politicize virtually every issue, public and private. Throughout the book, Powers proudly professes her liberalism, and posits, but doesn’t really argue -- i.e., provide evidence other than her own sensibilities -- that “true” liberalism requires free and respectful debate and consideration of the opinions of others. In this she convinces the reader of her fair-mindedness, if not her clear thinking. She cites a litany of dots, but can’t bring herself to connect them. The reader is left thinking: how can she catalog and condemn all this leftist behavior and not see its connection to its underlying philosophy?

For what is hugely missing in Powers book -- and powerfully present in say, David Mamet’s tale of conversion from a “brain dead” liberal in good standing to a thinking conservative -- is the recognition that the attitudes and practices that she abhors are not a distortion or aberrational trend of her professed political proclivities, but an inescapable consequence. Notwithstanding the lofty rhetoric about helping the downtrodden and the “little guy,” the left has ever been about seizing and holding power to enforce equality of condition upon all but the elite who exercise that power. That goal can ultimately brook no dissent. Powers constantly emphasizes her personal preference for respectful debate, but fails to recognize that with very few exceptions, modern liberals have no interest in engaging in free and fact-based debate to persuade others; they see themselves as possessors of the “Secret Knowledge,” and want to impose it upon the benighted masses who are incapable of leading useful lives without it.

Powers’ conceit of the illiberal vs. the liberal left is a valiant attempt to elide the cognitive dissonance that must gnaw at her -- how can people who share my opinions and basic worldview behave so badly?

It is inarguable that well over a century and tens of trillions of dollars spent on liberal programs to combat poverty and various other injustices by attempting to reengineer human nature and absolve various classes of people from responsibility for their lives and behavior have failed to achieve the left’s espoused goals and indeed have resulted in incalculable harm to millions of their “beneficiaries.” Inasmuch as the nobility of the progressive Vision may not be challenged, all that remains is to blame external factors. Powers would probably cite too little money spent, or perhaps even honest disagreements over policy, rather than mean-spirited, racist, homophobic, white, Republican men who hate children and women, but she is a decided minority. She doesn’t seem to understand what “illiberal” progressives -- which is to say all but a handful of today’s politically active liberals, with whom Powers presumably communes -- manifestly do, even if only viscerally: 1) there are no good objective arguments for the progressive vision for society; and 2) naming and shaming ideological opponents is therefore not only the best option for advancing the Cause, it works!

In fairness, The Silencing is not an argument for the progressive worldview or the efficacy of Democrat policies. It is a call for civility in our public discourse, and as such is welcome, though Ms. Powers acknowledges that it will likely go unheeded by the totalitarians she targets. What she doesn’t say, but must realize, is that in fact, the phenomena she recounts will only get worse, given the influence the left will continue to wield on the nation's campuses for the foreseeable future. A better book would have explored why the left’s intolerance of dissenting opinion is so pervasive, and how the politicians and party leaders she presumably votes for and otherwise supports actively encourage such attitudes. Such an inquiry, of course, raises dangerous questions that could be fatal to Powers’ liberal illusions of how the world actually works.

In the end, Powers’ book is best characterized as a variant of the old joke, “What do you call 1000 lawyers at the bottom of the sea?” Answer: a good start. Kirsten Powers has travelled further towards honesty than most modern liberals ever will, but she still has a way to go if her ultimate destination is to understand reality as it is, not as progressives think it should be.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Mace Consult Bets on Sawaya for Americas Expansion

Updated Category News Views 15

Concrete, tunnel bores, and data-center campuses rarely wait politely for a leadership transition. Mace Consult has named Mario Sawaya president of its Americas business, and the hire reads less like ceremonial executive shuffling than a deliberate move toward the thickest part of the capital-spending map. Sawaya brings more than 20 years of experience leading...

Continue Reading
Star Catcher Powers a Public-Interest Space Bet Ahead

Updated Category News Views 94

A satellite’s battery budget is a rotten place for humanitarian priorities to die. Common Space and Star Catcher are trying to remove that bottleneck through a partnership that is easy to like on principle and still deserves a clear-eyed look on execution. Common Space, a nonprofit developing an independent, community-governed high-resolution satellite constellation,...

Continue Reading
Travelzoo Turns Thanksgiving Delays Into Member Value

Updated Category News Views 108

Airport gridlock is a miserable place to make a membership pitch, yet Travelzoo has found a pretty shrewd angle for it. On November 18, the company said nearly 20 million travelers will move through airports during the upcoming Thanksgiving holiday, when cancellations and delays can turn an ordinary trip into a long, fluorescent-lit slog. Its offer: qualifying Club...

Continue Reading
JOYY’s Ad Engine Gives Q3 Growth Some Real Teeth Now

Updated Category News Views 107

Three engines are finally pulling the cart at JOYY, and that is a far more interesting sight than another quarter of livestreaming merely holding together. The company reported third-quarter 2026 revenue of US$624.6 million, up 15.6% from a year earlier and 5.7% sequentially. Those are sturdy numbers, especially for a business that investors have long tended to box in as...

Continue Reading
BLLN Faces Fresh Questions After Short-Seller Report

Updated Category News Views 106

A six-percent air pocket is one thing; a disclosure mismatch is another beast entirely. BillionToOne shares fell on November 18 after short-seller Fuzzy Panda Research alleged the company had not disclosed meaningful regulatory scrutiny, including an alleged Tennessee matter in which regulators suspected fraud in 2024. That is an allegation from a short seller, not a...

Continue Reading
Hyster-Yale’s $135 Million Convert Carries Real Cost

Updated Category News Views 82

Forklift makers do not usually get to hide a 7.50% borrowing cost behind glossy financing jargon. Hyster-Yale has priced $135 million of convertible senior notes due in 2031, lifting the deal from the originally announced $125 million. There is also an option for initial purchasers to take another $20 million. For NYSE:HY shareholders, this is not a simple debt cleanup....

Continue Reading
LiberNovo's European Black Friday Sale Tests Demand

Updated Category News Views 139

A €1,339 chair has no business pretending it is an impulse buy, which is exactly why LiberNovo’s Black Friday push deserves a closer look. The Hong Kong-based ergonomic-chair seller has rolled out its Black Friday sale across the European Union and United Kingdom, with the campaign ending November 30 at 23:59 CET in the EU and 23:59 GMT in the UK. This is a...

Continue Reading
Implantica's U.S. Launch Arrives With Cash Still to Burn

Updated Category News Views 77

RefluxStop has finally stepped onto American soil, and that changes the conversation around Implantica in a very real way. FDA Premarket Approval arrived on August 20, then the first U.S. procedures were completed in early November at the University of Southern California. For a small medtech outfit, clearing that regulatory gate and getting actual patients treated are...

Continue Reading
Honda Prelude’s Hybrid Return Tests a Narrow Niche

Updated Category News Views 0

A low-slung coupe showing up in Newfoundland is not exactly a volume-sales thunderclap, and that is precisely why the 2027 Honda Prelude deserves a closer look. Steele Honda in St. John’s is presenting the hybrid two-door as a fresh choice for buyers who want something livelier than the usual practical commuter. For Honda, and for investors watching Honda Motor Co....

Continue Reading
Whole-House Remodels Need a Plan Before Any Finishes

Updated Category News Views 98

A remodel gets expensive the minute somebody falls in love with tile before checking what sits behind the wall. Adam Sherman’s central point in the HelloNation article is refreshingly unglamorous: treat the house as one working system before treating it as a collection of rooms crying out for cosmetic rescue. That sounds obvious until you see how often a kitchen...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Amazon.com: A Detailed Look at Its Sway in Retail Markets

Updated Category News Views 265

Understanding Amazon.com and Its Competitive Landscape In an ever-changing and highly competitive retail space, analyzing key players is vital for investors and industry experts. This article aims to provide an in-depth evaluation of Amazon.com (NASDAQ: AMZN), delving into its performance compared to major competitors in the broadline retail sector. By thoroughly...

Continue Reading
Navigating the AI Landscape: Nvidia and the Future of Technology

Updated Category News Views 210

Nvidia: The Titan Amid the AI Hype Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA) has become a central figure in the tech world, particularly in the booming AI sector. However, some critics argue that the excitement surrounding AI is overshadowing the realistic capabilities of the technology. The true concern lies not with Nvidia, which is currently dealing with constraints in compute resources,...

Continue Reading
Market Insights on Automatic Data Processing's Short Interest

Updated Category News Views 150

Understanding Short Interest in Automatic Data Processing Automatic Data Processing's (ADP) short percent of float has recently dipped by 3.97% compared to its previous report. Currently, the company has reported approximately 4.93 million shares sold short, representing 1.21% of its available trading shares. Based on the current trading activity, it would take traders...

Continue Reading
Thesis Gold Inc. Unveils Compelling Drilling Results for Bingo

Updated Category News Views 159

Thesis Gold Inc. Reports Exciting Drilling Results at Bingo Zone Thesis Gold Inc. (TSXV: TAU) has recently revealed outstanding drilling outcomes from its Bingo Zone, marking a pivotal moment in the company’s ongoing exploration at its wholly-owned Lawyers-Ranch Project. This project is nestled within a highly regarded mining region, and the recent discoveries promise...

Continue Reading
October Distributions Announced by Roundhill Investments ETFs

Updated Category News Views 52

Roundhill Investments Announces ETF Distributions Roundhill Investments, a leading ETF sponsor known for its innovative financial products, recently announced the distributions for several of its exchange-traded funds (ETFs) including XDTE, QDTE, and RDTE, effective this October. This news is particularly relevant for investors looking to stay informed about their...

Continue Reading