2nd book. Rethinking Thinking How a lumpy bunch of

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
PoemStone Shalom Star #2170

2nd book.

Rethinking Thinking

How a lumpy bunch of tissue lets us plan, perceive, calculate, reflect, imagine—and exercise free will.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405297...96396.html

The world of academe is currently in the grip of a strange and worrying ¬epidemic of biologism, which has also captured the popular imagination. Scientists, philosophers and quite a few toilers in the humanities believe—and would have the rest of us believe—that nothing fundamental separates humanity from animality.

Biologism has two cardinal manifestations. One is the claim that the mind is the brain, or the activity of the brain, so that one of the most powerful ways to advance our understanding of ourselves is to look at our brains in action, using the latest scanning devices. The other is the claim that Darwinism explains not only how the organism Homo sapiens came into being (as, of course, it does) but also what motivates people and shapes their day-to-day behavior.

BRAIN2
A composite of X-ray and CT scans showing a human brain and the cerebral and left common carotid arteries.

These beliefs are closely connected. If the brain is an evolved organ, shaped by natural selection to ensure evolutionary success (as it most surely is), and if the mind is the brain and nothing more, then the mind and all those things we are minded to do can be explained by the evolutionary imperative. The mind is a cluster of apps or modules securing the replication of the genes that are expressed in our bodies.

Many in the humanities have embraced these views with astonishing fervor. New disciplines, prefixed by "neuro" or "evolutionary" or even "neuro-evolutionary," have been invented. "Neuro-aesthetics" explains aesthetic pleasure in terms of activity in certain parts of the brain observed when people are enjoying works of art. A propensity for aesthetic brain-tingles, implanted in us by evolution, causes us to tingle to the right kinds of things, such as pictures of landscapes loaded with food.

"Neuro-economics" can explain why we buy things we don't need or can't afford, by identifying ancestral imbalances between the want-it center in the amygdala, deep in the cerebral hemispheres, and the wait-until-you-can-afford-it center in the prudent frontal lobes. Those toxic subprime mortgages, it appears, were in fact "neurotoxic." Conspicuous consumption and our trillion-dollar debts are due to a desire to advertise our genetic health, analogous to a peacock virtually crippled by its meretricious tail.

Who's in Charge?

By Michael S. Gazzaniga
Ecco, 260 pages, $27.99

A brain in good working order is, of course, a necessary condition of every aspect of human consciousness, from basic perception to the most complex constructed sense of self. It does not follow that this is the whole story of our nature—that we are just brains in some kind of working order. Many aspects of everyday human consciousness elude neural reduction. For we belong to a boundless, infinitely elaborated community of minds that has been forged out of a trillion cognitive handshakes over hundreds of thousands of years. This community is the theater of our daily existence. It separates life in the jungle from life in the office, and because it is a community of minds, it cannot be inspected by looking at the activity of the solitary brain.

Biologism commands acceptance in the humanities because it is promoted or endorsed by scientists whose prowess in their chosen field seems to qualify them to pronounce on what are essentially philosophical questions. Thus it is notable when two books written by neuro-biologists of the greatest distinction are nonetheless critical of the simplifications—both scientific and philosophical—of biologism. Both authors look outside the conceptual frameworks upon which biologism depends.

"Incomplete Nature: How Mind Emerged From Matter" by Terrence Deacon, a professor of neuroscience and anthropology at the University of California, Berkeley, does not deliver on its subtitle, but the author acknowledges the depth and complexity of the problem. This mighty work of scholarship is long, slow-moving and peppered with neologisms, but it is infinitely preferable to the flashy tomes of the Professors of Legerdemain who assure us that the mind could emerge from matter in the brain "just like that" simply because "the brain is the most complex object in the world."

Incomplete Nature

By Terrence Deacon
Norton, 602 pages, $29.95

Along the way, Mr. Deacon demolishes fashionable computational theories of the brain. ¬Anyone in the future who is tempted to assert that "the mind is the software of the brain" should reflect on Mr. Deacon's observation that the apparent agency of a computer "is just the displaced agency of some human designer." The use of simplistic analogies to make the mind look machine-like and machines mind-like and thereby solve the mind-brain problem should never again pass unchallenged.

In his approach to the question of how sentience emerged from "dumb" and "numb" matter, Mr. Deacon mobilizes some radically new ideas, taking us back to thermodynamics to show how it might have happened. His key argument, developed over several hundred pages, centers on what he calls a "teleo-dynamic" system—a self-organizing system that "promotes its own persistence and maintenance" by modifying itself "to more effectively utilize supportive extrinsic conditions." He suggests how such a system might spontaneously arise out of thermodynamic processes, as predicted by chaos theory.

Living organisms are such self-organizing teleodynamic systems, and they have a key property. He calls this the absential. An absential is a phenomenon "whose existence is determined with respect to an . . . absence." This sounds somewhat opaque but captures something essential to mind. In the push-pull universe of ¬mechanical causation, only that which is present shapes the course of events. In our lives, by contrast, we are always taking account of things that are no longer present or not yet present or that may never come to pass. Thus "absentials" include our beliefs, the norms to which we subscribe and those great silos of possibility such as "tomorrow" and "next year."

But absentials long precede human consciousness, Mr. Deacon claims. All "teleodynamic systems" are shaped and defined, in great part, by the constraints placed on their development. The constraints are evident in the directed development of organisms or the limited patterns of behavior they may exhibit: Living matter is, as it were, "railroaded" along certain paths. It is through these constraints that, ultimately, "that which is not" asserts its power. Mind emerged not from matter, Mr. Deacon concludes, but from the constraints on matter. These constraints then shaped the emergence of brand-new "higher level" properties—mind and thought—that are not susceptible to reduction.

This argument is not entirely persuasive, precisely because Mr. Deacon sees absentials as defining properties of both life and mind, reaching all the way down to brainless organisms, to which he, surprisingly, ascribes sentience. But brainless complex systems do not experience their own development, or the constraints on their development, in the way that you or I experience the possibilities that shape or constrain our behavior. Mr. Deacon acknowledges that the form of sentience found in animals is different from that of humans but asserts somewhat gnomically that it is "a form of sentience built on sentience."

The author thus takes us from matter to life, but still not from life to mind, even less to the human mind. He asserts that specifically human consciousness emerges from "the flux of intercellular signals that neurons give rise to"— without making it clear how this happens. The word "signals" jumps out: Elsewhere the author criticizes the homunculi (little men), making quite difficult determinations, that pervade putative neuroscientific accounts of the mind; there is more than a hint of a homunculus in the notion of neurons that "signal" to one another. We are back with the old ways of thinking, manifested by a tendency to generate persons from the material world simply by personifying what is happening in living matter.

One of the founding fathers of cognitive psychology, Jerry Fodor, has argued that to solve the puzzle of conscious experience "there's hardly anything we may not have to cut loose from." Mr. Deacon has not cut loose from quite enough yet—in particular from the notion that matter organized in a certain way must be mindful—but he has started to reframe the terms of the discussion. His 500 densely argued pages testify to his awareness of the intractability of the problem.

Where Mr. Deacon looks backward to thermodynamics for answers about the mind, Michael Gazzaniga's "Who's in Charge?" suggests that we look elsewhere—outward, to the human world beyond the stand-alone brain. Mr. Gazzaniga is a towering figure in contemporary neurobiology. It was he who, back in the 1970s, coined the term "cognitive neuroscience"—with colleague George Miller—in the back seat of a New York taxi.

Unlike many in his profession, Mr. Gazzaniga is philosophically sophisticated. He believes that, while the brain "enables" the mind, mental activity is not reducible to neural events. While he states that thoughts, perceptions, memories, intentions and the exercise of the will are emergent phenomena, he adds that "calling a property emergent does not explain it or how it came to be."

Crucially, the true locus of this activity is not in the isolated brain but "in the group interactions of many brains," which is why "analyzing single brains in isolation cannot illuminate the capacity of responsibility." This, the community of minds, is where our human consciousness is to be found, woven out of the innumerable interactions that our brains make possible. "Responsibility" (or lack of it), Mr. Gazzaniga says, "is not located in the brain." It is "an interaction between people, a social contract"—an emergent phenomenon, irreducible to brain activity.

If the mind really were identical with activity in individual brain-bits, which were themselves machines causally wired into the material world, free will would be an illusion. One purpose of Mr. Gazzaniga's book is to reveal the implications of this mistaken notion for one of the most sinister of the neuro-¬prefixed pseudo-disciplines: "neuro-law." Neuro-law aims to replace the untidy processes of the current judicial system with something more biologically savvy. Isn't criminal behavior the result of (abnormal) brain function? If so, the brain, not the defendant, should take the rap.

Mr. Gazzaniga will have none of this, and he deplores "neuroscience oozing into the courtroom." The author savages the uncritical use of neuro-technology in court and ¬laments that juries and judges have little idea of the shakiness of the connections ¬between minor abnormalities on brain scans and the commission of a particular crime. Neuro-law is not merely premature; it overlooks the fact that, as Mr. Gazzaniga says, "we are people, not brains," and brain scans tell us little about our personhood.

Mr. Gazzaniga's incomparable knowledge, along with his mastery of the art of making things clear without oversimplifying them, means that "Who's in Charge?" is a joy to read. Is his book, along with Mr. Deacon's, an indicator that the mighty edifice of philosophically naïve conventional neuroculture is starting to fall apart? Are these books harbingers of a better future in which the task of trying to make sense of what we are is not hampered by a reductive scientism that identifies us with the activity of brains evolved to serve evolutionary success? I hope so. While we are not angels fallen from heaven, we are not just neural machines. Nor are we merely exceptionally clever chimps.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

StoneX Selloff Puts Earnings Quality Under a Harsh Lens

Updated Category News Views 120

A revenue beat can turn downright useless when the profit line springs a leak. StoneX Group delivered operating revenue above expectations and record full-year results, then watched investors hammer the stock after fiscal fourth-quarter diluted earnings per share landed at $0.66. That was $0.15 below the roughly $0.81 consensus cited in the notice, and other estimates...

Continue Reading
Korla Kiln Gains Show How Cement Efficiency Is Won

Updated Category News Views 79

A cement kiln does not care about corporate slogans; it cares whether the flame holds, the bearings stay alive, and the feed keeps moving. That is why the work at Xinjiang Tianshan Cement's Tashidian branch in Korla deserves a closer look. This is not a glossy tale about a futuristic factory appearing overnight. It is an account of an old, unforgiving industrial process...

Continue Reading
Zensar’s AI Forum Puts Operations Before the AI Hype

Updated Category News Views 111

Johannesburg’s AI conversation seems to be shedding its costume jewelry at last. Zensar’s invitation-only CIS Converge 2026 forum, held on November 20, put the attention where it belongs: not on breathless demos, but on whether companies can turn AI into sturdier operations, better customer experiences, and something resembling a measurable return. That is a healthier...

Continue Reading
Shenzhen’s 50-Year Message Carries Real Trade Weight

Updated Category News Views 68

A city once framed as a frontier fishing village is being presented as China’s sharpest recent economic before-and-after picture. At the welcome dinner for the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting in Shenzhen, President Xi Jinping gave guests a compact geographic guide to China’s past: Xi’an for thousands of years, Beijing for 500 years, Shanghai for 100 years, and...

Continue Reading
Duetti, CesiumAstro, and a Busy NYSE Capital Morning

Updated Category News Views 73

Three very different piles of money are jamming up the November 20 NYSE slate, and that contrast is the whole point. Private music catalogs, space-and-defense communications, and a new stock-and-bond ETF do not belong in the same bucket. Yet all three are competing for investor attention before the opening bell, alongside Danaos Corporation's 20th listing anniversary....

Continue Reading
Central Florida Buyers Face the Cash Reality First

Updated Category News Views 94

A house hunt can go sideways before the first showing if the buyer has confused a dream budget with a real one. Tom McKnight’s guidance for first-time buyers in Central Florida lands on the unglamorous stuff, which is exactly where it ought to land: cash, credit, financing, insurance, taxes, and the physical condition of the house. Nobody enjoys staring at lender...

Continue Reading
Mimic Bets Virtual Patching Can Calm AI Patch Chaos

Updated Category News Views 100

Three ugly outages in four days can make even hardened technology buyers reconsider the sacred ritual of “patch immediately.” Mimic’s new Virtual Patching offering arrives squarely in that uncomfortable gap: a vulnerability is known, attackers may be moving fast, and the proper vendor update still needs testing before somebody detonates production. The company’s...

Continue Reading
Saturn and Tileward Put GPU Memory Back to Work Now

Updated Category News Views 31

GPU memory is the tollbooth nobody notices until the whole AI highway backs up. Saturn Cloud’s new partnership with Tileward goes straight at that constraint: use compressed open-model weights, free memory on hardware already installed, and turn that reclaimed capacity into more tokens that an operator can actually sell. It is not glamorous. It may be one of the more...

Continue Reading
PPL's January Dividend Keeps Utility Appeal Intact

Updated Category News Views 85

A dividend notice is rarely thrilling, but it can still separate a steady utility from a story stock peddling fumes. PPL Corporation declared a quarterly common dividend of $0.2850 per share on Nov. 20, payable Jan. 4, 2027. Shareholders must be on the books by Dec. 10, 2026, to receive it. Plain vanilla stuff, yes. Still, plain vanilla is often precisely why utility...

Continue Reading
SQM Investigation Puts Chile Approval Claims on Trial

Updated Category News Views 71

A Regulatory Promise Meets a Rough Earnings Reaction A 5.52% haircut after disappointing quarterly numbers is the sort of thing that makes shareholders stop pretending every loose management comment is harmless. Sociedad Química y Minera de Chile, NYSE:SQM, is facing an investigation by Levi & Korsinsky into public statements concerning regulatory matters, particularly...

Continue Reading