Two books for deep reading. 1st. 'Free Will Debate:

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board
PoemStone Shalom Star #2170

Two books for deep reading. 1st.

'Free Will Debate: Who’s in Charge?' by Michael Gazzaniga

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2011/11...harge.html

It’s a question that never goes away: do we have it or not? In a new book, Michael Gazzaniga reveals how neuroscience has shattered the debate—and it’s impact on how we make decisions and even criminal justice.

It’s an old debate. It’s a conversation spanning millennia. It won’t go away.

Free will—do we have it or not?

The consensus tilts this way, then that.

But today, in the hot field of neuroscience, the trendy view, Michael Gazzaniga writes, is the “bleak view.”  Everything we do, think, feel, say, or fail to do is determined by our neural circuitry. The brain reigns supreme, tugging the mind along in its wake.

“The underlying contention,” Gazzaniga writes, “is that free will is just happy talk.”

In his new book Who’s in Charge? , Gazzaniga advances a counter argument.

Yet to do this, he proceeds along a surprising route. He devotes the first half of his book to laying out the massive collection of neuroscientific evidence showing that we have absolutely no idea what’s going on in our own brains—let alone control it.

And no one is better positioned than Gazzaniga to speak to this point. He is a veteran neuroscientist best known for his work with split-brain patients—people in whom the structure connecting the left and right hemisphere of the brain has been severed. Typically, this is a surgical procedure performed on people with severe epilepsy. It’s a last-resort technique to cut the corpus callosum, the bridge that joins up the two halves of the brain, in order to prevent seizure activity from spreading between them.

the human brain

Steve McAlister / The Image Bank-Getty Images

In his new book, Gazzaniga gives us an abridged account of the research he’s done on these patients. What’s fascinating about them is that, in many respects, they remain perfectly normal, their intellect, memory, and language abilities intact.

But Gazzaniga’s first great breakthrough was in discovering the places where this left/right disconnect is wildly apparent.

In one of the very first experiments of his career, Gazzaniga tested a split-brain patient named WJ. First he held up a picture of a spoon in such a way that it was only registered by the left half of WJ’s brain—the half that specializes in language. When asked if he had seen anything, WJ responded normally, “a spoon.” But when the same picture was held up so that only WJ’s right brain registered its presence, WJ reported that he hadn’t seen anything at all.

This was the crucial moment that led Gazzaniga deep into the depths of split-brain patient research. What he found was that, once severed, each half of the brain has no idea what’s going on in the other. WJ’s vision wasn’t impaired since the reason he made no mention of a spoon when it was displayed only to his right brain was that his left brain, with its language centers, had no idea it was there.

whos-in-charge-book

'Who’s in Charge? Free Will and the Science of the Brain,' By Michael Gazzaniga, 272 pages, Ecco, $27.95


Years of this kind of research led Gazzaniga to be able to characterize the differences between the left brain and the right brain. The right, he says, “lives a literal life.”  It doesn’t extrapolate, it doesn’t narrate, it doesn’t generalize. It registers in an exact, concrete fashion what’s going on around it.

The left hemisphere plays a different role. It’s our resident storyteller.  “The left hemisphere was the intellectual,” Gazzaniga discovered. It is our brain’s  “interpreter.”

It’s the left brain that spins a narrative out of all the disconnected bits of information swimming up into our conscious view.  The funny thing, however, is that the stories the left brain produces are largely if not entirely wrong.

“The reality is, listening to people’s explanations of their actions is interesting—and in the case of politicians, entertaining—but often a waste of time,” he writes.

The reason for this is that the left brain works with whatever becomes conscious, but consciousness is the ultimate slow poke. It lags behind. It’s walking while the non-conscious brain is sprinting to the finish line, processing what’s happening around us, making a decision about how to respond, even beginning to execute that response. Our conscious awareness is the last to find out.

So what “the interpreter” narrates is necessarily after the fact. Whatever we find ourselves doing, our interpreter will cobble together some reasonable explanation, but it is always a retrospective account.

Besides his own research, Gazzaniga touches upon a huge swath of brain science backing up the basic point that we have no idea what’s going on, but we need to tell ourselves otherwise.

This is the illusion that humans daily entertain: we are the masters of our domain, aware of what we’re doing and why we’re doing it.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Babe Ruth Lots Lead Morphy's $2 Million Collectibles Auction

Updated Category News Views 39

Ruth still pulls money like few names ever will, and Morphy's November 10-12 auction made that plain without any circus tricks. Three lots tied to the Yankees legend produced $136,500 within a Toys, Sports & General Collectibles sale that topped $2 million. That is not some vague nostalgia story. Buyers put real dollars behind a 1932 U.S. Caramel card, a 1933 Goudey card,...

Continue Reading
AMP Pushes Debt Wall to 2029 With €1.3B Green Notes

Updated Category News Views 25

A Refinancing With Some Actual Breathing Room Metal cans may be boring, but a debt wall arriving in 2028 is not—and Ardagh Metal Packaging has moved that problem down the road. AMP priced €1.3 billion of senior secured floating-rate green notes on November 20, 2026. The proceeds are earmarked to redeem $600 million of senior secured green notes due in 2028 and €450...

Continue Reading
Caliway's China Clearance Speeds CBL-514's Next Test

Updated Category News Views 158

China's regulator moved faster than the calendar, and that is the one detail worth circling in red ink. Caliway Biopharmaceuticals has received authorization from the Center for Drug Evaluation under China's National Medical Products Administration to begin CBL-0102, its China study of injectable fat-reduction candidate CBL-514. For a clinical-stage company, an...

Continue Reading
PayPal's New Leadership Map Puts Execution on Trial

Updated Category News Views 75

Four senior appointments and a risk-chief exit can turn a tidy strategy slide into a very real operating test. PayPal has spent months defining three-year plans, simplifying its operating model and assigning clearer accountability; on November 20, it put names beside the jobs. For NASDAQ:PYPL investors, that is more consequential than another broad promise about...

Continue Reading
TCL CSOT's Oxide Leap Gives LCD a Sharper Fight Ahead

Updated Category News Views 64

Fifty-one point six is the number that makes this announcement worth chewing on. TCL CSOT says it has moved ultrahigh-mobility oxide technology into mass production on an 8.6-generation line, clearing the 50 cm² V?¹ s?¹ threshold that has largely belonged to lab-talk and presentation slides. For display people, that is not decorative science. It could change the old...

Continue Reading
Digital Diabetes Care Has a Bigger Prize Than Devices

Updated Category News Views 32

A glucose sensor is becoming less a gadget than a running conversation between patient, clinician and software. That shift matters because diabetes management is leaving the occasional clinic visit and moving into daily life, where the useful product is not merely a reading but a pattern someone can act on. The sector deserves attention from investors, but it also...

Continue Reading
Clear Aligner Results Depend on Discipline, Not Hype

Updated Category News Views 23

A Clear Tray Is Not a Magic Wand Transparent orthodontic trays sell a wonderfully tidy idea: straighten teeth without the metal-and-wire routine, take them out to eat, and carry on. Fair enough. But the useful message from Dr. Theresa Trapp is the part nobody should glide past: clear aligners are a treatment plan, not a cosmetic shortcut bought with good intentions....

Continue Reading
iHeart's 65% Plunge Brings a Fraud Probe Into Focus

Updated Category News Views 17

November 10 did not merely bruise iHeartMedia shareholders; it left the stock closing at $0.61 after a decline of more than 65%. That kind of move gets everybody’s attention, including plaintiffs’ lawyers, and Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman & Herz LLP has opened an investigation into potential securities fraud claims involving iHeartMedia, its officers, and its...

Continue Reading
SHEIN's EU Training Push Targets Seller Compliance Gaps

Updated Category News Views 72

Chemicals buried in a cheap handbag or kids' accessory can wreck a marketplace's credibility faster than any glossy campaign can repair it. That is the uncomfortable backdrop to SHEIN and SPEAC's November 19 session on EU chemical-safety rules for marketplace sellers. This was not a fashion trend webinar; it was a practical warning about high-risk substances, regulatory...

Continue Reading
Oman’s Dhofar II Wind Deal Clears Financing Hurdle

Updated Category News Views 111

Dhofar’s next wind farm has crossed the line that matters: financial close. That is less glamorous than turbines spinning against an Omani skyline, but it is the point where a project stops being an attractive deck and becomes a real contractual obligation. Sembcorp Utilities, alongside OQ Alternative Energy through Naseem Dhofar SAOC, has brought the 125-megawatt...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Settlement Reached for Just Energy Shareholders Amid Controversy

Updated Category News Views 341

Class Action Settlement Overview Recently, a significant settlement agreement was reached by representatives of former shareholders involved in a class action against Just Energy Group Inc. This move is part of the legal proceedings initiated after the company's restatement of its financial statements in 2019. Shareholders have been keenly watching the developments in...

Continue Reading
Texas Southern University Launches Impactful Lawson Endowment

Updated Category News Views 419

New Endowment Established by Texas Southern University Texas Southern University (TSU) is excited to unveil the creation of the William A. Lawson Endowment, a scholarship initiative that pays tribute to the remarkable legacy of Rev. Dr. William A. Lawson, a highly respected figure in the civil rights movement and a guiding light within the community. This endowment is...

Continue Reading
Thailand's Air Conditioner Market: Growth and Innovation Ahead

Updated Category News Views 544

Understanding the Growth Trends in Thailand's Air Conditioner Market Thailand has experienced a significant boost in its air conditioner market, projected to reach a valuation of over US$ 2,937.83 million by 2033, an increase from US$ 1,721.28 million in 2024. This growth translates to an impressive compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6.12% from 2025 to 2033. Several...

Continue Reading
BiomX Achieves Milestones and Reports Q2 2025 Financials

Updated Category News Views 204

BiomX Reports Second Quarter Financial Results BiomX Inc. (NYSE American: PHGE), a clinical-stage biotechnology company focused on developing innovative phage therapies, has shared its financial results and clinical updates for the second quarter of 2025, showcasing pivotal advancements that underscore its position within the industry. Positive Clinical Developments...

Continue Reading
Celebrating Community Heroes: The PuroClean Superhero Initiative

Updated Category News Views 217

PuroClean Honors Local Leaders with Superhero Day Campaign The Paramedics of Property Damage Celebrate Community Heroes Nationwide PuroClean, a renowned leader in restoration and remediation franchises, has recently concluded its captivating National Superhero Day campaign. This initiative celebrated everyday heroes across communities who have dramatically impacted lives....

Continue Reading