Somewhere between a checkout button and settlement, an awful lot of money is apparently falling through a trapdoor. Verisave and Canyon Payments say 93% of the 180 merchant accounts they reviewed during one month missed Visa Commercial Enhanced Data Program discounts they could have received. The claimed savings left on the table topped $800,000 for that group in that month alone. That is not a rounding error, and it is not the sort of expense a finance team should lazily file under “cost of doing business.”
The irritating part is that the report does not frame this as merchants needing to rip out their processors or launch some grand technology crusade. Its central argument is much plainer: the transaction data is getting damaged, omitted, or malformed somewhere in the chain. Merchants may capture Level 3 information at the front end, then watch it disappear before settlement. That kind of boring plumbing failure is precisely where big recurring costs hide.
Penalty Pricing Has Become a Nasty Habit
Visa began charging a 5-basis-point participation fee on Level 2 and Level 3 volume in April 2025, then enabled automated data validation in October 2025. The old Level 2 rates for small-business cards ended in January 2026; corporate and purchasing cards followed in April. A year after enforcement began, plenty of businesses seem to have absorbed the higher bills without really checking why.
The report’s example makes the damage easy to grasp. A $500 commercial or purchasing card transaction qualifying for Visa’s verified Product 3 rate costs roughly $8.85 in interchange, including that participation fee. If it is downgraded as non-compliant, the cost rises to $13.60 while the fee still remains. That is a 54% jump on the same $500 sale. Anybody managing thin-margin distribution, business supplies, travel, or e-commerce volume should find that deeply obnoxious.
And this is occurring atop a staggering base. U.S. merchants paid a record $198.25 billion in card-processing fees in 2025, according to Nilson Report data cited by the Merchants Payments Coalition. When the overall pool is that huge, small data defects stop being small in a hurry.
Look at the Payload, Not Just the Statement
Canyon Payments’ point is the one worth underlining: rate tables are not the whole story. The firm says it found structural issues repeatedly in the audited accounts, including order totals that do not reconcile with line items, commodity codes transmitted as plain text, and detailed data that vanishes before settlement. None of that sounds glamorous. It sounds like integration work nobody wanted to own after the original implementation went live.
- Reconcile order totals against the line-item data actually sent downstream.
- Confirm commodity codes arrive in the required format rather than as loose text.
- Trace Level 3 fields from order capture through authorization and settlement.
- Separate genuine interchange changes from preventable CEDP downgrades in monthly reviews.
That last point matters. Rising payment expense gets shrugged off constantly because card acceptance is complicated, processor statements are ugly, and teams assume the network simply changed the price. Sometimes the price did change. But Verisave’s findings suggest that assumption can become a very expensive excuse.
Surcharging Is a Partial Bandage, Not a Cure
One Verisave client, according to the report, was losing nearly $500,000 per month to CEDP and cited the program as the main reason it began adding card surcharges. I understand the impulse. When a cost spikes, passing it through feels tidy on a spreadsheet. Customers, naturally, tend to hate it.
More importantly, the math may not bail the merchant out. Card-brand rules cap surcharges at 3%, while a merchant missing CEDP rates can wind up paying an effective rate above that ceiling. In other words, the merchant can irritate customers and still eat part of the loss. That is a rotten outcome created by a back-office data problem.
The Report Needs a Sensible Read
Investors and operators should keep the sample in perspective. This was an analysis of 180 accounts over one month, produced by two firms that sell payment optimization and integration help. It is not a census of every Visa-accepting merchant, and the report does not provide a full account-by-account breakdown. Skepticism is healthy.
Still, the underlying warning rings true. Verisave says it typically reduces client fees by 10% to 30% and has identified more than $3 billion in savings; Canyon brings deep Visa experience and specializes in payment integrations. Their commercial interest does not invalidate the basic operational lesson. Merchants handling meaningful commercial-card volume should audit the data path before accepting elevated interchange as fate. The processor may not be the villain, Visa may not be the entire problem, and switching providers may be unnecessary. But ignoring the payload while fees pile up? That is just leaving the cash register unlocked at the back door.