October 2026 was a good month to own REITs. Listed real estate posted a total return of 4.7% for the month while the S&P 500 slipped 0.9%, leaving REITs up about 13% for the year, according to Nareit figures reported by WealthManagement.com.
Months like that remind investors why real estate belongs in a portfolio. They also hide a question many people never ask: when you buy "real estate," what are you actually holding, and how will it behave the next time the stock market drops?
There are three main ways in: individual REITs, real estate ETFs and mutual funds, and private real estate funds. Each one works differently. Here's how to compare them.
Option 1: Individual REITs
A real estate investment trust is a company that owns income-producing property such as warehouses, apartments, data centers or medical buildings. You buy shares through a brokerage account, the same way you'd buy any stock.
REITs come with a built-in income feature. Under the rules that let them avoid corporate income tax, REITs must distribute at least 90% of their taxable income each year, which is why many pay meaningful dividends.
What you get: liquidity, low minimums, a choice of property sector and regular dividends.
What you give up: independence from the stock market. A REIT's share price moves with investor sentiment and interest rates, sometimes more than the value of its buildings does. Dividends are also usually taxed as ordinary income rather than at the lower qualified dividend rate.
Option 2: Real estate ETFs and mutual funds
Funds that hold dozens of REITs solve the concentration problem. Instead of betting on one landlord or one sector, you own a slice of many.
This is how most Americans already hold real estate, often without realizing it. Nareit estimates that about 168 million Americans live in households that own REIT stocks, largely through retirement accounts and index funds.
What you get: instant diversification across property types, low costs for index funds and daily liquidity.
What you give up: the same stock market link. A real estate ETF is still a basket of stocks, so its price can fall in a broad selloff even when the underlying properties are performing well.
Option 3: Private real estate funds
Private funds pool investor money to buy, finance or develop properties directly. They don't trade on an exchange, and most are open only to accredited investors.
Their returns tend to look steadier because properties are valued periodically through appraisals rather than repriced every second by the market. Large core private funds tracked by the NFI-ODCE index returned 4.45% gross for the year ended June 30, 2026, according to NCREIF.
What you get: exposure that isn't tied to daily stock prices, access to strategies you can't buy publicly, and often regular distributions.
What you give up: liquidity, transparency and low minimums. Your money may be committed for years, fees are usually higher, and you rely heavily on one manager's judgment. Steadier-looking returns can also reflect slower appraisals rather than lower risk.
The in-between options: non-traded REITs and interval funds
A few products sit between public and private. Non-traded REITs and interval funds are often open to non-accredited investors, don't trade on an exchange, and offer limited redemptions on a set schedule, such as a percentage of shares each quarter.
They can smooth out daily price swings, but they come with their own trade-offs:
-
Redemption limits. If many investors want out at once, the fund can cap or pause withdrawals.
-
Higher fees. Upfront sales charges and ongoing management fees are often higher than an index ETF's.
-
Valuation lag. Share values are set by the sponsor periodically, so they may not reflect market conditions right away.
Read the prospectus closely, especially the sections on fees, how share value is calculated and when you can sell.
Side-by-side comparison
|
|
Individual REIT |
REIT ETF or fund |
Private real estate fund |
|
Who can invest |
Anyone |
Anyone |
Usually accredited investors |
|
Minimum |
One share |
One share or low fund minimum |
Often high |
|
Liquidity |
Daily |
Daily |
Limited, sometimes years |
|
Moves with stock market |
Yes |
Yes |
Less directly |
|
Diversification |
One company |
Many REITs |
Several properties, one manager |
|
Fees |
Low |
Low to moderate |
Higher |
For examples of specific options in each category, along with what each one asks of you, see this rundown of nine real estate funds compared.
How to choose
The right mix depends on the job real estate is doing in your portfolio:
-
If you want income and flexibility, REITs and REIT funds offer dividends you can sell out of on any trading day.
-
If you want broad, low-cost exposure, an index REIT ETF is hard to beat on simplicity.
-
If you want real estate that moves differently from your stocks, private funds may help, as long as you can leave the money in place for years.
-
If you're unsure, start public. You can add private exposure later once you understand how you react to lockups.
Many investors end up with a blend: a REIT ETF for liquid income and growth, plus a measured allocation to private funds sized so a long lockup won't hurt.
Whatever mix you choose, add up your real estate exposure across every account. If you own your home, hold a rental property and have REITs inside your 401(k) index funds, you may already have more real estate than you think. Count those before you add more, and rebalance once a year so one strong stretch for any single holding doesn't quietly reshape your whole portfolio.
What the rest of the world is doing
Investors in other markets are rethinking real estate too. For example, an ASB survey covered in recent New Zealand investor research showed fewer people naming property as their single best investment, with more interest in shares and managed funds. Owning a rental directly isn't the default it once was in many places.
Questions to ask before you buy any real estate fund
-
What do I actually own: shares of companies, a basket of shares, or interests in properties or loans?
-
How quickly can I get my money out, and at what cost?
-
What are the total annual fees, including any performance fees?
-
How is the fund's value calculated, and how often?
-
How are distributions taxed in my situation?
The bottom line
REITs, real estate ETFs and private funds all give you exposure to property, but they behave very differently when markets move. Decide what you need real estate to do for you, match the vehicle to that job, and size any illiquid investment so you won't need the money before it's available.
This article is for educational purposes and isn't investment or tax advice. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal.