A returned jacket can turn into a household cash-flow problem faster than retailers seem willing to admit. Seel's new survey lands at an awkward moment for online merchants: shoppers are not merely annoyed by slow refunds; many are budgeting around them. Among 1,921 U.S. adults who had shopped online in the prior six months, 63% said waiting for a retailer to receive a return before releasing a refund causes financial stress. That is not a cute customer-service metric. It is a warning that the post-purchase experience is creeping right into the purchase decision.
Refund Timing Has Moved to the Front of Checkout
The pressure is sharpest where one would expect it. Seel says 77% of shoppers aged 18 to 34 and 77% of parents with children under 18 reported stress from delayed refunds. The figure was 74% for households earning under $50,000. Meanwhile, 16% of younger shoppers said they had returned an online purchase during the past year because they needed the money for bills or other expenses. That is grim, frankly, and retailers should resist treating it as an invitation to squeeze return policies harder. A shopper who needs that refund is unlikely to become more loyal after being trapped in a two-week warehouse queue.
For merchants, refund speed is no longer a back-office courtesy; it is part of the value proposition sitting beside price, shipping and selection.
The Returns Problem Is Bigger Than a Generous Policy
Returns already carry a nasty cost burden. The National Retail Federation and Happy Returns projected $849.9 billion in U.S. merchandise returns for 2025, according to the notes. Nobody should pretend that instant refunds, free labels and broad return windows are free money. They invite fraud, tie up working capital, complicate inventory planning and can leave merchants holding goods that are worth less by the time they come back. The sensible investor question is whether a retailer has the systems to distinguish a legitimate, low-risk return from the messier cases without making every honest customer wait.
Seel's polling suggests the old tradeoff is getting stale. Fully 63% said they had kept an unwanted online purchase because returning it cost too much. That rose to 75% among parents. Keeping a bad item may spare a retailer reverse-logistics expense in the moment, but it can also mean a customer quietly decides not to buy there again. Worse, a return policy that feels punitive can make shoppers hesitate before checkout, especially during gift season.
- 81% said a retailer's return policy can determine where they buy.
- 83% said certainty around post-holiday returns, even without the original receipt, would make them more likely to buy a gift online.
- 61% said they would likely pay a small added checkout fee for free return shipping and a guaranteed refund on an eligible purchase.
Bad Return Data Can Produce Bad Merchant Decisions
One number deserves more attention than the usual refund-speed talking points: 47% of respondents said they had given a retailer a reason for a return that was different from the actual reason. Among 18- to 34-year-olds, it was 62%. The reported real reasons still include ordinary retail headaches—26% cited poor fit, while 22% cited damage or defects and another 22% said the item did not match its description. But 12% said the purchase was impulsive, 10% regretted the spending and 9% needed money back for bills or expenses.
That gap matters because merchants use return codes to decide what to stock, how to describe products, whether sizing is broken and where fraud may be lurking. If customers are feeding the system polite fiction, management can wind up fixing the wrong problem. A retailer may blame fit when the real issue is flimsy product photography, buyer's remorse or a household budget stretched to the snapping point. No AI workflow magically cures that. Better tools can organize the evidence, sure, but the underlying policy has to make customers comfortable telling the truth.
Read the Survey With Both Eyes Open
This was an online Harris Poll survey conducted for Seel from October 22 through 24, 2026, with a stated 95% credible interval of plus or minus 2.7 percentage points. Seel sells technology around returns and post-purchase operations, so the company plainly has a commercial interest in highlighting this pain. That does not make the findings useless; it just means investors and operators should separate the broad consumer signal from any implied claim that one vendor is the cure.
The broad signal looks hard to dismiss. Eight in 10 shoppers said they would hesitate to buy gifts online this season, with unfamiliar websites, return-shipping costs and unclear post-holiday windows among the concerns. Retailers that can make refunds predictable without letting costs run wild may win conversion and repeat business. The ones still treating returns as an unloved basement function are gambling with trust at exactly the point shoppers are counting every dollar.