Have Americans Forgotten How To Grow? No, Innovation Is In

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone

Have Americans Forgotten How To Grow? No, Innovation Is In Our DNA

In the face of a stagnating economic activity many economists are trying to explain why the medicine they have been administering these last six years isn’t working. Not capable of accepting theoretical defeat they offer new explanations. The “new” normal is in the process of being explained by nuance con gusto.

We are being told that technology has permitted big corporations to replace manufacturing jobs with either cheap foreign labor (thanks to the global logistics revolution) or the substitution of capital for labor using robotic technology. But, an even grander reason is on offer by Robert Gordon who says that innovation itself is slowing. He argues, much like many before him in similar moments when the mysteries of economic life produced a slowdown that in their minds shouldn’t be, that everything is different because people are living differently, or should be. The predictions of the Club of Rome comes to mind as do visions of President Carter in a sweater telling us the world was exhausting its energy supply. Now, according to Gordon, as a result of relentless waves of innovation all of humankind’s wants and needs are pretty much satisfied.

His model begs us to think of innovation in a demand-pull framework. In fact, innovation happens because more innovators think up more great new ideas and they bring them to the market for judgment. When it comes to innovation we live in a supply-push world.

Gordon’s point might be better taken if he said that innovation was slowing because there were fewer people innovating. As it is, he is only putting a false explanation on an epiphenomenon of a slow-growth recovery continuously teetering on recession. Innovation might appear to be slowing because in the last five years about 30 percent fewer firms are being created to develop new innovations. In the face of greater regulatory uncertainty and the immanent threat of higher taxes to fund government expansions such as Obamacare, the number of new firms committed to bring innovation to market has declined.

What explains why it is that fewer people are coming forward to start businesses to develop and exploit new innovations? The beginning of an answer lies in Jonathan Hughes’ The Vital Few where he makes the case that the economy hangs on a small number of visionary entrepreneurs who bring forth big new ideas. Perhaps fewer such people are showing up. Think about this question using President Obama’s recent explanation of “structural” problems in the economy.

Entrepreneurs are more averse to risk than many believe. Starting a business built on a new innovation is a great deal more risky than it might have been ten years ago for two reasons. The market is much more cautious about buying into new things – recessionary markets always make selling “the new” to customers more difficult. And, if a business fails, the entrepreneur will find it much more difficult to find a job in an economy with chronic high unemployment and a resume that includes two years spent in a failed start up. The odds of finding a job are many times greater than the difference of 5 percent full employment and today’s 8 percent unemployment might suggest.

Government policy has done a great deal to discourage entrepreneurs. When government persistently discriminates against new firm formation (large firms now enjoy the advantage of being exempt from Obamacare!) we can’t expect more new firms at the frontiers of innovation to emerge. Not only do rising tax and regulatory burdens retard entrepreneurship, the government is now actively discouraging innovation in the two areas that have proven to be the most productive fields of invention for decades — medicine and defense. As the administration reduces research spending so it can maintain the service delivery functions of the Department of Defense and the National Institutes of Health (keeping ships on the seas and paying for medical care) support for critical basic research will inevitably lead to a reduction in the nation’s capacity to innovate. Labs have been rightly thought of as “idea factories” and as they shrink the basic ingredient of innovation – ideas — will become scarcer.

A more subtle erosion of the animating spirit of innovation emerges from government action where increasingly citizens must effectively petition local, federal and state authorities for permission prior to simply acting. Just taking a flight requires government permission. In some places the state determines every item served in local school district cafeterias – a reality intentionally made known to every student so they know the state is watching out for them. Speed cameras represent another behavioral modification imposed by a ubiquitous, increasingly watchful government. The arduous task of securing permits for building in many places depresses the housing market. The revelations that the government uses its technology to monitor all levels of personal communications no doubt effects, in unmeasured ways, the freedom that individuals need in dreaming, researching and communicating about what might be revolutionary ideas.

Another dampener on innovation is that we we are no longer thinking clearly about how and where it happens. In every sense the Silicon Valley narrative has effectively overridden the idea that the nation’s innovation is the product of many people in many places. The meme that only bright kids from an elite set of universities have the secret of innovation has enormous consequences in terms of denying to many youngsters and adults the notion that their creative capacity is sufficient to develop a real breakthrough.

In reality, most innovation evolves in the workplace where people confronted with practical tasks and problems begin to think of ways of doing things better. As the size of the American labor force shrinks, currently at its lowest level in decades, the number of people in workplaces where the opportunity to observe, learn and innovate is obviously smaller. Without jobs as a “school” and the incentives to advance the state-of-the-art in, say, manufacturing the speed at which improvements happen is certain to be slower. The current hostile environment faced by new firms, a particularly fertile environment for ideas, presents second order problems. Even as fewer firms are being formed, those that are employ substantially fewer people than they did five years ago, down from approximately 5.5 in their first year to about 4.5 currently. Thus, jobs in companies where people could learn the skills of innovation are fewer than before.

Lastly, America has been besieged for at least a decade by a meme that suggests that other nations are more creative and innovative than we are. Many intellectuals appear to believe the United States is no longer leading the world in inventiveness. (Not surprisingly I continuously encounter intellectuals who believe this is a good thing; arguing that our obvious lead has caused other nations to believe that they are not capable of invention – essentially a nation-state level application of the low self-esteem hypothesis.) Certainly Thomas Friedman’s The World Is Flat urges the idea that the China and India are poised to overtake the U.S. in innovation; arguing that their superior educational culture accounts for their emerging advantage. To the extent Americans are beginning to think our best days of leading on the innovation frontier are behind us a dangerous self-fulfilling prophecy is likely in the making. To paraphrase Henry Ford, whether we think we can innovate or think we can’t, we are right.

What is particularly tragic about this outcome is that it is really not at all a necessary preview of our America’s future. In so many respects innovation is in our DNA. The nation is chock-a-block with people bursting with ideas, eager to dream of starting companies to carry their visions into commerce. But if they are discouraged by years of fewer new firms, of decaying educational performance, of fewer people working in creative environments, and more defeatist memes we will inevitably see a generation of young Americans emerge that has no sense of our nation’s special economic competence.

Barbara Tuckman once observed that politicians have happily walked us into decisions that destroy prosperity because they do not see the costs of their action outside of their ideological vocabulary. As long as our political class celebrates innovation rhetorically while unwittingly inhibiting the forces that drive it, America could loose the particular ingredient that has driven our economic growth for nearly 200 years. We will be lucky to sustain our “new normal” of one percent GDP growth explained properly or not.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Worker Pullback Is a Cost Problem Employers Ignore

Updated Category News Views 86

Somewhere between a job description and an unpaid favor, a lot of corporate productivity appears to be quietly leaking out. MyPerfectResume’s July 2026 survey of 1,000 U.S. workers says 78% have intentionally done only the minimum needed to keep their jobs at least once. That is not a cute workplace-culture headline. It is a warning flare about discretionary...

Continue Reading
Midterm Voters Put Cost Relief Ahead of Washington Wars

Updated Category News Views 78

Gas pumps and medical bills have a way of humiliating every grand political slogan ever printed. Seven Letter Insight's latest post-election survey says confirmed 2026 midterm voters want the 120th Congress to deal with costs first, particularly gas prices, health care, restoring health care tax credits and energy bills. That is not a glamorous mandate. It is, however,...

Continue Reading
YYForce Security Win Adds Recurring Singapore Revenue Base

Updated Category News Views 160

A retail-property security mandate rarely makes anyone pound the table, and frankly it should not. Still, YYForce has landed a tangible two-year contract in Singapore worth roughly S$831,120, with subsidiary Uniforce Security Services set to begin work on December 1, 2026. For NASDAQ:YFOR investors, this is the kind of small, operationally real win that deserves a sober...

Continue Reading
Six LIFE Photographers Bring History Into Florida Focus

Updated Category News Views 55

Seventy photographs can make a pretty loud argument when the historical record has been this lopsided. The Ashley Gibson Barnett Museum of Art at Florida Southern College has brought LIFE: Six Women Photographers to Lakeland, and it deserves more than the usual polite nod given to a traveling museum show. Open since November 14, 2026, and running through March 7, 2027,...

Continue Reading
RLX Revenue Soars, but European Margins Need Proof

Updated Category News Views 111

Revenue can wear a fancy suit while earnings arrive in work boots, and RLX Technology's third quarter is exactly that kind of report. The newly consolidated European distribution business pushed third-quarter revenue to RMB1.92 billion, up 69.7% year over year. That is a real jump, not pocket change. But the same acquisition also changed the mix, squeezed the blended...

Continue Reading
Why Dent Repair Estimates Need More Than a Simple Ruler

Updated Category News Views 118

A dent can look harmless in a parking-lot glare and still turn into a stubborn repair job once somebody examines the metal properly. That is the useful, unglamorous point Jason Phelps of Magic Dent makes in a HelloNation article: visible diameter is not a verdict. Anybody shopping for vehicle repairs, managing fleet costs, or watching the collision-service ecosystem ought...

Continue Reading
Sidus Gains Argotec Order, but Investors Need the Math

Updated Category News Views 72

A Real Customer Signal, Minus the Revenue Figure An updated image is the least interesting detail in this release. Sidus Space has landed a purchase order from Argotec Group to manufacture cable assemblies for the HAWK satellite platform, with delivery expected in the first quarter of 2027. That is a legitimate operational win for NASDAQ:SIDU. It brings in a new...

Continue Reading
S&P Global's UBS AI Conference Slot Deserves Attention

Updated Category News Views 88

Thirty Minutes Can Still Matter A half-hour fireside chat is not a quarterly earnings call, and anybody treating it like one is setting themselves up for disappointment. Still, S&P Global CEO Martina Cheung appearing at the UBS Global Technology and AI Conference on December 2 deserves a spot on the calendar for owners of NYSE:SPGI. This is a company sitting in the middle...

Continue Reading
Pennsylvania Housing Finds Its October Holding Pattern

Updated Category News Views 79

Pennsylvania's October housing numbers have the uneasy stillness of a pond before somebody throws a rock. The statewide median sales price sat at $315,000, exactly where it was in September, while sales barely cleared 10,400 and available listings kept inching higher. Nothing in that mix screams boom or bust. Frankly, that is the point: a market can look calm on the...

Continue Reading
Nansha's Trade Pitch Has Numbers, but Questions Remain

Updated Category News Views 61

A Chilean cherry spending 22 days at sea can tell an investor plenty about where Guangzhou's Nansha District wants to sit in Asia-Pacific commerce. Not glamorous, no. But trade infrastructure rarely is until volumes pile up, routes deepen, and somebody else finds they cannot easily replicate the network. Nansha is using the expected 33rd APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting in...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

AI Adoption Challenges Identify Risks in Asian Financial Sector

Updated Category News Views 141

Understanding the AI Adoption Gap in Asian Financial Institutions The landscape of financial institutions in Asia is undergoing significant scrutiny as the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) remains slow. Despite the clear advantages that AI can provide—particularly in the realm of financial crime prevention—many Asian financial institutions still lag behind...

Continue Reading
Reykjavík Energy's Successful Green Bond Auction Highlights

Updated Category News Views 170

Reykjavík Energy's Green Bond Auction Overview Recently, Reykjavík Energy (Orkuveita Reykjavíkur; OR) successfully completed its latest green bond auction, revealing a positive reception from investors. With total bids reaching ISK 7,785 million nominal value across various bond classes, the auction showcased a robust interest in sustainable finance opportunities....

Continue Reading
SpaceX Rescues Stranded NASA Astronauts from ISS

Updated Category News Views 293

SpaceX Conducts Heroic Rescue Mission for NASA Astronauts SpaceX recently embarked on a significant mission, launching a Crew Dragon spaceship designed to rescue two stranded astronauts in space. This mission exemplifies the advancements and capabilities of private space exploration. Details of the Rescue Operation Typically, the Crew Dragon is built to carry a crew of...

Continue Reading
Legal Action for Investors of Warner Bros. Discovery: WBD Update

Updated Category News Views 93

Understanding the Warner Bros. Discovery Class Action Lawsuit Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. (NASDAQ: WBD) is currently facing a class action securities lawsuit that aims to assist investors who have suffered financial losses. This lawsuit has been initiated by Levi & Korsinsky, LLP, a renowned firm specializing in securities litigation. What is the Class Definition? The...

Continue Reading
Revolutionary Intruder Detainment System Enhances Home Security

Updated Category News Views 105

Revolutionary Intruder Detainment System for Improved Safety In today's world, home security is a top priority, making innovative safety solutions essential. A creative individual from Chicago has developed an exciting detainment system designed to bolster security measures. This new invention, called HELP, can capture intruders in real-time and hold them until law...

Continue Reading