The Best Argument Against Dividends - And Why It's

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Aug 5, 2013 at 5:21 PM

The Best Argument Against Dividends - And Why It's Wrong

Marc Lichtenfeld, Chief Income Strategist, The Oxford Club

The most common argument I hear from investors who aren't interested in dividends is that the company should be able to find something better to do with its cash than to give it back to shareholders.

They say that the funds should be used to grow the business either by investing in the business itself or by acquiring new ones.

As Vice President Joe Biden would say, "That's a bunch of malarkey!"

Let's look at why that argument doesn't hold water.

Obviously, I'm not opposed to a management team investing in its business for growth or even buying other companies if it will add to long-term profitability and cash flow.

But often, executives spend shareholders' capital on ill-fated acquisitions because the money is there.

In my book Get Rich with Dividends , I mentioned a discussion I had with Community Bank Systems (NYSE: CBU) CFO Scott Kingsley. He explained to me why the company has a policy of consistently returning capital back to shareholders in the form of dividends.

He said, "We are very 'capital efficiency' conscious. We believe 'hoarding' capital to potentially reinvest via an acquisition or some other use can lead to less-than-desirable habits."

He went on to say that because of the company's dividend policy, when management wants to make an acquisition, it usually must go to the capital markets for financing, which forces them to closely examine whether the transaction really makes sense.

Let's Make a (Bad) Deal

How many horrible acquisitions can you name?

Chances are, management made them because it had the cash on hand, so what the heck? Gotta spend it on something, right?

In 1994, Quaker Oats (now part of Pepsi) bought Snapple for $1.7 billion. Just three years later, the company sold Snapple for $300 million, losing 82% of its investment. That means that $25 per share of Quaker Oats' shareholders' money went out the door and into the pockets of Snapple's owners.

Would Quaker Oats' shareholders have preferred a dividend instead? I'm not a mind reader, but I'm going to guess yes.

Similarly, in 2007, Clorox (NYSE: CLX), which does have a solid track record of returning cash to shareholders, paid $925 million to acquire Burt's Bees. Four years later, it took an impairment charge on the acquisition of $250 million or $2 per share. Would Clorox's shareholders have appreciated a $2 per share dividend? I'm sure they would have.

Now, that doesn't mean Clorox would have issued a $2 dividend had they paid the right price for Burt's Bees, but you can see that companies can be easily tempted to spend shareholders' money, no matter the price, in order to land a prized acquisition.

Dividends = Stronger Earnings

Studies have shown that companies that pay dividends have more reliable earnings than those that don't.

Douglas J. Skinner and Eugene F. Soltes, professors at the University of Chicago and Harvard University respectively, concluded, "We find that the reported earnings of dividend-paying firms are more persistent than those of other firms and that this relationship is remarkably stable over time. We also find that dividend payers are less likely to report losses and those losses that they do report tend to be transitory losses driven by special items."

So non-dividend payers may use their cash to acquire growth, but the dividend-paying companies have stronger and more consistent earnings. And a vital rule of investing is stock prices follow earnings.

If earnings are better and more reliable for dividend-paying companies, that should mean dividend-paying companies' stocks perform better.

And we know that they do.

View larger image
The above chart shows that companies that grow their dividends outperformed the general market by 155% over the past 40 years. While the stocks that did not pay dividends barely budged over the same time period.

Dividend stocks beat the pants off of those that don't pay dividends, while at the same time shareholders receive income while their stocks are in the process of issuing said beating.

So the next time a friend says a company should have better things to do with its cash than pay dividends, wish them luck with their investing and just know that you'll likely be picking up the tab for lunch in a few years - because you'll be the one who can afford it.

Best,

Marc Lichtenfeld
Chief Income Strategist, The Oxford Club

Citadel EFT Inc (CDFT) Stock Research Links

CDFT Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Why Ghosts Don’t Spook Homebuyers Anymore

By Caleb Price Updated Oct 28, 2026 Category News Views 145

Haunted Houses—A New Norm in Real Estate? In what's becoming a spooky trend in real estate, more than half of Americans are game for buying haunted houses. Imagine that! Suddenly, Casper and his ghostly pals are claiming space in the housing market. With home prices soaring, folks are getting creative. Could a phantasmal presence really tip the scales for cash-strapped...

Flex LNG Readies for Crucial Q3 Earnings Reveal

Anticipation Builds for Flex LNG's Upcoming Q3 Reveal The air's thick with expectation as Flex LNG gears up to lay its cards on the table for the third quarter of 2026. Come November 11, the company will spill the beans on its financial dance over the last few months, promising to unfurl the numbers early in the morning like a farmer checking crops at dawn—07:00 CET...

JumpCloud Tackles Compliance in the AI Era

By Kelly Martin Updated Oct 28, 2026 Category News Views 131

Compliance in a Changing Tech Landscape JumpCloud's stepping up in this brave new world riddled with tech and AI agents. They've got fresh platform features in their arsenal that'll keep organizations audit-ready day in and day out. Now, if you think compliance is just for the accountants to fret over, think again. In the agentic era, these advanced marvels—AI agents...

SoftwareOne Triumphs in 2026 GitHub Partner Awards

SoftwareOne Nabs Prestigious GitHub Honor Outta nowhere, SoftwareOne's been lashed onto the center stage, bagging GitHub's Global Channel Sales Partner of the Year for 2026. This ain't just another shiny trophy on the shelf; it's a solid nod to their grit and strategy. Now, if good old GitHub says you're their top dog, you're obviously doing something right. Not bad for a...

Proton Therapy: A Game-changer in Breast Cancer Treatment

Understanding the Radiation Conundrum When it comes to breast cancer, there's no sugarcoating it—the diagnosis alone can shake the foundation of anyone's life. But once the dust settles, another layer of decisions begins. One of the trickiest questions patients face is, "What radiation options are out there?" That's where proton therapy comes in, and it's high time we...

Factory-Built Homes Take Center Stage in New Doc Short

Housing is one of those things we all think we understand until we start peeling back the layers of its history, especially when factory-built homes are involved. Here's a new angle: Clayton has just released the teaser for their documentary short, "Built: A Story of Factory-Built Housing in America," and it's turning the lights on a sector that's often left in the...

Bluevua Partners with Orlando Solar Bears

Bluevua Takes Aim at Bigger Waters Bluevua's move to partner with the Orlando Solar Bears ain't just some casual sponsorship. It’s a statement, loud and clear, that they're ready to play in the big leagues. By sliding into this relationship, they’re not only flexing their branding muscles but also tapping into a vibrant sports market. It’s a clever game plan to...

Seasonal Hiring Booms as Firms Eye Long-Term Talent

A Strategic Shift in Seasonal Hiring It ain't just about the holiday rush anymore, folks. Companies are waking up to the idea that seasonal gigs are more than a temporary Band-Aid. This year, nearly 2 out of 5 companies are planning to bring more seasonal folks into the fold compared to last year. That means a good dose of them are looking for longer-term value—like...

PZZA Faces Class Action Over Misleading Sales Outlook

Who's Pointing Fingers at Papa John's? Papa John's International, Inc. (NASDAQ: PZZA) is now headlining a courtroom drama that sounds as crispy as their pizza crust. Last ditch deadline's pinned for November 2, 2026, for grabbing the top spot as lead plaintiff against Papa John’s top brass, Todd Allan Penegor and former CFO Ravi Thanawala. These head honchos reportedly...

Heritage Wines Meet Non-Alcoholic Trend: New Deal

Wine Industry Shifts Gears Well, here's a twist that might just shake up the wine racks. C. Mondavi & Family, from the historic Charles Krug estate, is aligning with Missing Thorn—a name gaining traction in the non-alcoholic wine scene. It’s a move that not only raises eyebrows but could also expand your wine-tasting options come your next sober night out. So what...