The Feds is "reviewing" it's decision to allow regulated

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
MaxShockeR

The Feds is "reviewing" it's decision to allow regulated banks to trade in physical commodity markets

Quote:
The Federal Reserve is "reviewing" a landmark 2003 decision that first allowed regulated banks to trade in physical commodity markets, it said on Friday, a move that may send new shockwaves through Wall Street .

The one-sentence statement suggests the Fed is taking a much deeper, wide-ranging look at how banks operate in commodity markets than previously believed, amid intensifying scrutiny of everything from electricity trading to metals warehouses.

While the Fed has been debating for years whether to allow banks including Morgan Stanley (MS.N) and JPMorgan (JPM.N) to continue owning assets like oil storage tanks or power plants, Friday's surprise statement suggests it is also reconsidering whether all bank holding firms should be able to trade raw materials such as gasoline tankers and coffee beans.

By referencing its initial decision a decade ago permitting Citigroup's Phibro unit to trade oil cargoes - setting a precedent for a dozen more banks that followed suit - the Federal Reserve has put in question a key profit center for Wall Street's top players, which have already seen multibillion-dollar commodity revenues shrink in the face of new regulations.

On Tuesday, the Senate Banking Committee is holding its first hearing on the issue, asking whether so-called "Too Big to Fail" banks should be taking on additional risks like moving tankers of crude oil or operating power plants.

Amid growing frustration in Washington over regulators' failure to push through new rules five years after the financial crisis, the Fed's widening area of enquiry came as a shock.

"They must be feeling some pressure on this issue if they've felt compelled to issue a public statement," said Saule Omarova, associate professor of law at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Law, who will appear at the hearing.

"Are they using this opportunity to in fact review the entire position of banks in physical commodity markets?"

The pressure may intensify as the U.S. power market regulator levies record fines over manipulating power markets. It levied a $453 million penalty against Barclays (BARC.L) this week and is in talks to settle charges against JPMorgan, which is alleged to have used power plants that it owned or operated to game markets.

"The Federal Reserve regularly monitors the commodity activities of supervised firms and is reviewing the 2003 determination that certain commodity activities are complementary to financial activities and thus permissible for bank holding companies," the Federal Reserve said, its first public statement since a 2012 Reuters report brought the issue to light. (Full story: link.reuters.com/xer86s).

A Federal Reserve spokesperson declined to elaborate or provide any details on the scale or timing of the review.

Spokespeople for Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley declined to comment on the Fed statement.

PHIBRO SET PRECEDENT

In 2003, the Federal Reserve issued a letter to Citigroup, which had been seeking permission to allow its Phibro unit - acquired in 1998 - to continue trading in physical energy markets. The Bank Holding Company Act (BHC Act) normally prohibits banks from engaging in non-financial activities, but Citi had argued that the activities should be allowed.

Regulated commercial banks had long been permitted to trade in commodity derivatives such as futures, but at the time did not enjoy the same freedom in physical markets, unlike investment banks like Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley.

The Fed agreed with Citi, saying that trading in real commodities would allow the banks to "transact more efficiently with customers". It said the trading must be "complimentary" to their main activities, contribute to the public good and should not pose a "substantial risk" to the bank.

That decision, which came at the start of a decade-long boom in commodity trading, opened the door to a dozen more applications from global giants like Deutsche Bank and domestic players like Wells Fargo. With many of the permits, the Fed gave greater and greater leeway in what and how they could trade.

"Maybe the Fed can openly say we think these activities are systemically risky unless they're cut back but I don't know what's going through the Fed's head," said one commodity regulation expert who declined to be named. "This came out of the blue. This has taken everyone by surprise."

Since converting to bank holding companies at the height of the financial crisis, Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley have also been subject to the holding company rules.

But up until now, the Fed's focus was believed to be on their ownership of assets, a more clearly controversial issue.

Under the 1999 decision to repeal part of the Glass-Steagall Act, ending the forced separation of commercial and investment banking, any non-regulated bank that converted to holding company status after 1999 would be allowed to continue to own and invest in assets, as long as they held them prior to 1997. The banks have argued that their activities are "grandfathered" in, or that they are simply merchant banking investments.

It is not clear that argument will hold up under political pressure, which is intensifying ahead of a nominal September deadline for Goldman and Morgan to comply with the rules.

"Reviewing Wall Street's expansion into commercial activities is essential," Senator Sherrod Brown, a Democrat from Ohio, said in a statement. "Congress, regulators, and the public need to understand what has happened in the 14 years since the financial floodgates were opened, and reconsider what we want banks to do."

Large industrial consumers of aluminum have accused banks of boosting prices of the metal through their control of London Metal Exchange warehouses, which have been slow to deliver metal to customers, boosting premiums for physical metal and earning big profits on rent for storing the metal.

Four U.S. congressmen wrote to Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke on June 27 expressing their concern about the issue, and asking for more information on the Fed's position.

Both Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan have explored selling their warehouse businesses they bought in 2010 in recent months, although it is not clear if that is because of increased regulatory pressure.

GETTING PHYSICAL

As commodity prices surged over the past decade, a host of global investment banks piled into the market, pressuring the former duopoly of Goldman and Morgan. At their peak in 2008 and 2009, revenues in the sector reached some $15 billion.

But pressures have mounted over the past few years as regulators crack down on proprietary trading, new capital measures limit trading books and bonus caps shrink.

Commodity revenue from the top investment banks fell to about $6 billion in 2012, consultants Coalition estimated.

While banks generate much of that revenue from trading derivatives - selling indexes to investors or hedging prices for an oil company - many have delved deeply into physical markets in order to get better information on markets, leverage their positions or offer more options to customers.

For instance, many banks are involved in "supply and offtake" arrangements with refineries, providing crude oil to the plant and then selling gasoline or diesel in the market.

The Federal Reserve has generally allowed banks to trade in most major physical commodity markets so long as there is a similar futures contract for the commodity, which means it is regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Crude oil and gasoline, for instance, are allowed but iron ore is not.

Friday's statement calls that into question.

While some consumer groups have been critical of the sway that banks can exert on commodity markets by owning key pieces of infrastructure, it is unclear how many would support barring them from trading commercial markets entirely.

"I want them to have physical business because they play a positive role in the business on balance by providing financing," said one senior executive in the metals market who has been critical of the banks' warehouse ownership.

(Additional reporting by Jeanine Prezioso in New York; Editing by Jonathan Leff, Bob Burgdorfer and Peter Cooney)

By David Sheppard and Josephine Maso


Source REUTERS

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

UAE Trust Model Faces Its Hardest Test During Crisis

Updated Category News Views 371

A country’s reputation is usually invisible right up until the machinery rattles. Then people, investors, trading partners and residents stop listening to polished slogans and start watching whether airports function, services hold up, information arrives, and business can keep moving. That was the useful core of Saeed Al Eter’s remarks at Ajman Media Forum 2026: soft...

Continue Reading
FASTEN Data Offers an Early Look at Ladera Closure

Updated Category News Views 130

Femoral access may be the unglamorous part of a valve procedure, but it is where an otherwise tidy case can turn ugly in a hurry. That makes Ladera Medical's full FASTEN data worth a careful look. The company reported results in 55 patients undergoing transfemoral TAVR/TAVI, and the numbers presented at London Valves 2026 suggest its large-bore closure system may address...

Continue Reading
CARsgen's CT1182 Data Opens a Careful New CAR-T Test

Updated Category News Views 100

Six very sick lymphoma patients are not a victory lap, but they can still make the whole cell-therapy field sit up straighter. CARsgen has disclosed first clinical results for CT1182, an in vivo CAR-T candidate built on its CARvivo platform, and the early package is plainly more interesting than the usual preclinical chest-thumping. The company reported three complete...

Continue Reading
DataBeyond Puts AI Sorting Before a Waste Mountain

Updated Category News Views 191

Trash is a lousy place to look for technological glamour, which is precisely why DataBeyond's COP31 appearance deserves a sober look. On November 19 in Antalya, Türkiye, the Hangzhou-based equipment provider used a China Pavilion event to lay out its case for AI, optical sensing and robots in resource recovery. That is not a magic-green headline. It is a practical...

Continue Reading
Mission Inn’s Lights Enter a Tender New Ownership Era

Updated Category News Views 527

A holiday spectacle can outlive the hands that hung its first bulb. Riverside is about to test that truth in public, under millions of tiny lights and the very large shadow of a family departure. The Mission Inn Festival of Lights returns in 2026 without Kelly and Duane Roberts as hotel owners for the first time in more than three decades. Duane Roberts died in 2025, the...

Continue Reading
PettiChat’s Digital Pet Twin Has Real Consumer Pull

Updated Category News Views 389

A Collar Gadget Is Chasing the Empty-House Problem Leave a dog or cat alone for a few hours and plenty of owners turn into amateur detectives. Did the cat eat? Has the dog been pacing? Why was that one weird noise caught on the home camera? Seattle startup PettiChat is trying to turn that itch into a product category with PettiLive!, a screen-based version of a pet that...

Continue Reading
Lymphatic Research Gains Attention Beyond Wellness Claims

Updated Category News Views 488

Ankles leave little clues after a long day: sock grooves, puffiness, that dull heaviness nobody bothers to name. PureHealth Research wants people to look past the usual salt-and-water explanation and consider the lymphatic system, the body’s comparatively unsung network for gathering fluid from tissues and returning it to the bloodstream. Fair enough. This system does...

Continue Reading
Ajman Memory Gives Heritage a Durable Digital Backbone

Updated Category News Views 303

Archives usually get applause only after somebody realizes a piece of history has vanished. Ajman is trying to skip that miserable part. During the Ajman Media Forum 2026, held November 18 and 19 at the Emirates Hospitality Centre, the emirate launched Ajman Memory, a project built to collect, document and preserve photographs, papers and video recording its development....

Continue Reading
Persistent Dry Eye Symptoms Call for a Closer Look

Updated Category News Views 312

Eyes can turn into a stubborn little nuisance long before people realize something more complicated is going on. A bottle of artificial tears is easy to grab, cheap enough, and often perfectly sensible for a rough day of screens, wind, reading, or air conditioning. But Dr. Harlan Snyder’s point is the one worth sitting with: when dryness keeps barging back despite...

Continue Reading
PHONO's 150 MW RE+ Win Tests Its U.S. Solar Staying Power

Updated Category News Views 534

A trade-show order book is not cash in the bank, but 150 MW is still a number worth circling in red. PHONO used RE+ 2026 in Las Vegas, held November 17 through 19, to celebrate 20 years in business, parade its solar and storage lineup, and announce new U.S. orders. In a solar market that has become touchier about provenance, compliance and delivered economics, the company...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Kochav Defense Offers Class A Shares for Independent Trading

Updated Category News Views 100

Kochav Defense Initiates Separate Trading of Class A Shares Kochav Defense Acquisition Corp. (NASDAQ: KCHVU) has exciting news for its investors! Starting July 21, 2025, holders of the unit shares sold during its initial public offering will have the option to trade their Class A ordinary shares and rights separately. This development is expected to provide additional...

Continue Reading
CITGO Takes Active Steps in Community Safety Drills

Updated Category News Views 234

CITGO Lake Charles Refinery completed a significant emergency response drill back in 2024, engaging over 130 participants including local, state, and federal emergency responders. This Worst-Case scenario drill simulated operations on the waterway to bolster command capabilities during potential environmental incidents. Emergency Preparedness: The Core of CITGO's...

Continue Reading
Exploring Premium REITs for Reliable Cash Flow Generation

Updated Category News Views 196

Understanding High-Yield REIT Investments Investing in high-yield real estate investment trusts (REITs) is a popular strategy for those seeking attractive dividend income. REITs are uniquely designed to channel income back to their shareholders, making them an appealing choice for generating passive income streams. This article will explore several high-yield REITs that...

Continue Reading
Orchestra BioMed Strengthens Board with Industry Veteran

Updated Category News Views 180

Introduction of Christopher Cleary to the Orchestra BioMed Board Orchestra BioMed Holdings, Inc. (Nasdaq: OBIO) is thrilled to announce a significant addition to its Board of Directors. Christopher Cleary, a monumental figure in the medical device industry, has joined the team as an independent member effective January 30, 2025. With over three decades of experience in...

Continue Reading
Microsoft's Latest Buyback Plan: What Investors Should Know

Updated Category News Views 202

Microsoft's Strategic Financial Moves Microsoft is making significant investments in its key areas while also ensuring it rewards its shareholders. As the tech giant ramps up its capital expenditures to improve cloud infrastructure—especially for artificial intelligence (AI)—it’s also keen on providing returns to its investors. Recently, the company announced a 10%...

Continue Reading