MUST READ: FNMA/FMCC Shareholders Politely Ask For Their

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Pharaoh
MUST READ: FNMA/FMCC Shareholders Politely Ask For Their Companies Back

11 Jun 2013 at 12:16 PM
By Matt Levine

There’s an alternative theory of the 2007-2008 financial crisis in which it was just a minor hiccup that would have worked out fine for all concerned if the meddling U.S. government hadn’t been so trigger-happy in bailing out basically sound but momentarily embarrassed financial institutions .1 I mean, you probably won’t actually run into anyone who believes this theory, because it is a pretty loony theory. And yet! It keeps coming up in court, which I guess means the courts are full of loonies, QED.

Obviously Hank Greenberg is the most vocal and delightful proponent of this theory, since he’s been suing the government for ever and ever for taking over AIG when AIG actually would have been just fine with a little eleven-digit low-interest loan from the government. But Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac shareholders have come on strong of late, with weird lobbying for re-privatization of their shares and, now, a lawsuit filed yesterday seeking $41 billion in damages over their bailout.

The theory here should be familiar if you’ve been following along with AIG; it goes something like this:

Fannie and Freddie were basically fine, a little banged up maybe but definitely going to survive perfectly well on their own;
but the government, for reasons of its own, came to their boards and said “we need to take you over, get 79.99% of your equity , screw your shareholders, and run your business for our purposes”;
the government did not have statutory authority to do these things, nor did it have shareholders’ best interests at heart;
but, what, were the boards going to do, say no?;
so the boards approved a takeover and that was unfair to shareholders, and an unconstitutional taking of private property, so the shareholders should get their money back.

Blah I guess whatever. There are important differences between the AIG and Frannie cases. For one thing, this suit sort of acknowledges that Fannie and Freddie had run into some unpleasantness through their massive purchases of risky mortgages , but then blames the government – in the form of Congress and Frannie’s regulators – for forcing them to do so to prop up the housing market.2 Others would disagree,3 and the evidence suggests “allowing” more than “forcing.” “Fannie and Freddie lobbied their regulators to let them take more risk, then did” is less sympathetic than “the regulators forced Fannie and Freddie to take more risk.”4

For another, while Greenberg’s AIG lawsuit makes the pretty amazing argument that AIG would have been fine if it had only received that eleven-digit loan , and that the unfair part of the bailout was not its existence but the government’s insistence on also taking equity, the Frannie lawsuits argue instead that Fannie and Freddie would have been fine without any government support at all:

At the time the conservatorships were imposed, not only were the Companies adequately capitalized, … but each company’s capital was substantially in excess of its capital requirements. Moreover, each company’s ability to raise capital from the public equity and private capital markets was more than sufficient to allow it to absorb any potential future losses, particularly in the Companies had been allowed to offer terms to potential investors as favorable as those demanded by the Government in exchange for the extremely costly capital it provided upon taking control of the Companies.

“We didn’t need a bailout” is I guess a better argument, legally, than “we needed a bailout but yours was a little too expensive,” but also probably less plausible? Some people, for instance, thought at the time, and think now, that Fannie and Freddie were insolvent when they were taken over, and that even if they weren’t they were well on their way there.5 And “we would have been fine raising billions of dollars in private capital in September 2008? is the sort of argument that it is best to make, um, a long time away from September 2008. Preferably a long time before, rather than after, but you go to war with the imaginary capital markets you have, or something.

But the ultimate point of these lawsuits are the same: the boards of Fannie and Freddie, like that of AIG, were coerced into agreeing to a shareholder-fleecing government takeover, and that government takeover may have been good for the world but was nonetheless bad for private company shareholders.6 Which, for AIG, is, like, an argument, anyway.

But for Fannie and Freddie it seems a little weird. These were “government sponsored enterprises” with a public purposes, and an implicit government guarantee. The implicit deal was, I suppose, that Frannie’s private shareholders got the benefit of that implicit guarantee in the form of cheaper financing costs and more profits during good times, and in exchange they ran the risk of being treated as something slightly less sacrosanct than private property owners in bad times.

I mean, implicitly. Who knows what anyone thought the actual deal was; that tradeoff wasn’t spelled out anywhere, and the plaintiffs here point to lots of Congressional, regulatory and other statements seemingly designed to reassure Frannie equity holders that their investment was safe and their companies were private companies rather than instrumentalities of the government. Maybe someone believed those statements.

It’s not immediately obvious what the relationship is between this lawsuit and the people who now own Fannie and Freddie preferred and common shares and are lobbying to have the companies re-privatized. Lots of those shares have changed hands, suggesting that the plaintiffs who lost money on Frannie shares in 2008 are mostly different from the current shareholders standing to make money on a re-privatization. Casual Googling suggests those shares are generally up today after the lawsuit was filed.

But if you were in Congress or Treasury and pondering whether or not to re-privatize Fannie and Freddie, wouldn’t this suit be a reminder of what a bad idea that would be? Fannie and Freddie were designed to carry out a public purpose while also making money for private shareholders. When those goals conflicted, the public purpose won and the private shareholders were thrown into the abyss. If you’re the government: that’s perfect. Except now those shareholders are suing, as shareholders tend to do. If you’re the government: why would you set yourself up for more of that?

Fannie Mae (FNMA) Stock Research Links

FNMA Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Local Bounti Expands: Acquires CEA Facilities

Updated Category News Views 96

Local Bounti's Strategic Acquisition Move Local Bounti's at it again, shaking up the indoor agriculture scene by snapping up some real estate from Revol Greens. We're talking 30 acres of primo certified-organic greenhouse space across Texas and Minnesota. And they’re picking these babies up right as they’re ready to grow, not like some flashy land grab. Digging into...

Continue Reading
Investors, Portillo's Fraud Claims Demand Your Attention

Updated Category News Views 91

Portillo's Investors Caught in a Tough Spot Ah, Portillo's. You thought those hot dogs were the only spicy thing you're biting into? Try these allegations on for size. Investors are biting back with a securities fraud lawsuit, and the details are saltier than a bucket of fries. The folks who held PTLO shares between September 19, 2023, and May 4, 2026, are in the...

Continue Reading
Cracking Life Insurance Needs: John Dorsa's Insights

Updated Category News Views 137

Life Insurance: A Necessary Puzzle Life’s uncertainties have a way of putting a wrench in our plans, and nothing screams uncertainty like figuring out life insurance. But fret not! HelloNation’s got insights on this financial maze, and they’ve roped in insurance pro John Dorsa from Ridgeland to help out. Calculating Coverage Needs Forget the one-size-fits-all...

Continue Reading
Lear Gears Up for Goldman Sachs Event Spotlight

Updated Category News Views 132

Lear Prepares for the Big Stage in London Autumn leaves and industry insights are falling in full swing as Lear Corporation gets its ducks in a row for the upcoming Goldman Sachs 18th Annual Industrials & Autos Week. Kicking off on December 3, 2026, this gathering in London isn't just another checkbox on their corporate calendar—it's a prime moment in the spotlight....

Continue Reading
Tenax Class Action: Investors Alley Fight for Redress

Updated Category News Views 149

Tenax Therapeutics in Hot Water Over Drug Trial Results Amidst the ever-unpredictable tides of the pharmaceutical industry, here comes a doozy – Tenax Therapeutics, Inc. is neck-deep in a shareholder lawsuit. If you tossed some money at NASDAQ:TENX anytime between November 13, 2023, and August 7, 2026, you might be feeling the sting of regret, and rightly so. What Went...

Continue Reading
Norris Lake's New Kayak Fleet Propels Tourism Efforts

Updated Category News Views 207

Norris Lake Doubles Down on Water Adventures The winds of change are paddling through Norris Dam State Park as they've launched a new fleet of shiny kayaks, hoping to lure more adventure seekers into the heart of Tennessee. These ain't just boats; they're part of a bigger play by local tourism honchos hungry to pump some adrenaline—and dollars—back into the area. A...

Continue Reading
Sabre Unveils AI Travel Tech: A Bold New Frontier

Updated Category News Views 110

Sabre's Game-Changing AI Travel Integration I'm no stranger to bold moves in the travel industry, but what Sabre's rolling out tomorrow might just be the biggest leap we've seen in a while. They're unleashing what's called the first global travel plug-in within Grok Bot, marking a significant shake-up in the travel tech sphere. Too many tech upgrades in this business...

Continue Reading
Ave7® Pioneers AI-Driven Marketplace Evolution

Updated Category News Views 99

AI Reshapes the Agency Paradigm Nobody saw this coming a decade ago, but here we are—AI's taking the wheel, but with humans still riding shotgun. The agency world, particularly the one dealing with e-commerce giants like Amazon, Walmart, and Target, has flipped on its head. Ave7® steps up as the frontrunner, adapting faster than a broker's reflex after a market bell....

Continue Reading
Grupo Supervielle's Q3 2026: Back to Growth Path

Updated Category News Views 66

Mounting Momentum in Loans and Asset Quality Grupo Supervielle, the Argentine financial player, has been tinkering with its gears to navigate the bumpy roads of 2026. In the third quarter, the company reports a gentle uptick in net loans—up 1.3% sequentially. This was particularly felt in September, with loans increasing 3.7%. Holding Their Own Against the Industry...

Continue Reading
Vertiv's 800 VDC Push Gives AI Builders More Choices

Updated Category News Views 48

Electricity is becoming the awkward roommate inside every serious AI buildout, and Vertiv is trying to move it out of the rack before it eats the whole house. The company has expanded its 800 VDC offering beyond the PowerDirect 5000 rack product introduced in May 2026, laying out systems for the rack, the AI compute pod, and the full data hall. For investors following...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Vancity Achieves Remarkable Q2 Performance Amid Strategic Shift

Updated Category News Views 345

Vancity Reports Strong Financial Performance in Q2 Vancity recently showcased its outstanding financial results for the second quarter, demonstrating impressive growth across various metrics and solidifying its commitment to its members. This performance is part of Vancity's transformative vision to enhance member experience while making significant contributions to local...

Continue Reading
Celebrating Courtney Rollings Latham's Exceptional Contributions

Updated Category News Views 283

Honoring Courtney Rollings Latham, M.Ed, BCBA It brings us great joy to acknowledge Courtney Rollings Latham, M.Ed, BCBA, for achieving the status of a Pinnacle Professional Member in The Inner Circle of Excellence. This recognition showcases her steadfast commitment to enhancing the fields of Behavior Analysis and Special Education. A Passionate Educator and Analyst...

Continue Reading
Savers Value Village, Inc. Reveals Sales Growth and Conference Plans

Updated Category News Views 158

Savers Value Village, Inc. Reports Preliminary Sales Results BELLEVUE, Wash. – Savers Value Village, Inc. (NYSE: SVV) has released its preliminary net sales for the recent quarter along with its full year results for fiscal 2024. This announcement coincides with the Company’s upcoming participation in the ICR Conference scheduled for mid-January 2025. Sales...

Continue Reading
Empowering Salon Professionals Through Natural Disasters Support

Updated Category News Views 241

Empowering Professionals in the Face of Adversity Natural disasters can strike unexpectedly, causing chaos and distress. My Salon Suite®, a franchise dedicated to providing beauty, health, and wellness professionals with personal spaces for their businesses, has been at the forefront of community support during such challenging times. As we navigate through the hurricane...

Continue Reading
Major Revenue Surge: POP Culture Group's Impressive FY2025 Results

Updated Category News Views 201

POP Culture Group Achieves Record Revenue in FY2025 In a remarkable financial breakthrough, POP Culture Group Co., Ltd. (Nasdaq: CPOP) has announced its fiscal year 2025 results, showcasing an incredible revenue surge that exceeded $100 million for the first time. This milestone represents a significant leap, with revenue increasing by 127% compared to the previous fiscal...

Continue Reading