WSJ NEWS(!): The Corker-Warner Housing Reform Won't Work

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Pharaoh
WSJ NEWS(!): The Corker-Warner Housing Reform Won't Work


A new government agency to insure mortgages will ensure the same loose lending that caused the last financial crisis.

July 1, 2013, 7:12 p.m. ET

By
PETER J. WALLISON

The Corker-Warner bill, introduced last week in the Senate, has received a lot of favorable media attention because it's bipartisan. Tennessee Republican Bob Corker and Virginia Democrat Mark Warner are the chief sponsors. Their intent is to eliminate Fannie Mae FNMA +7.09% and Freddie Mac, FMCC +5.19% the two government-sponsored mortgage giants that cratered in 2008 and were bailed out by taxpayers to the tune of $180 billion.

It would be easy to love a bill that gets rid of these two institutions—unless it fosters the same loose lending that led to the housing debacle. By keeping the government in charge, this bill does just that.

The recent financial crisis was the result of government housing policies. Beginning in 1992, these policies required Fannie and Freddie to lower their underwriting standards so people who otherwise lacked the credit standing or financial resources could purchase homes.

These policies set the two enterprises on the course one would expect when the government is your backer—use the taxpayers' credit card and provide what Congress's constituents want. In housing, those constituents are the Government Mortgage Complex: realtors, home builders and community activists.

Fannie and Freddie could take on the risks of these loans only because of the implicit backing of the federal government. But it was a good deal for Congress and two administrations, which could tout their support of wider home ownership. Buy now and pay later was the idea. Later turned out to be 2008, when the bill arrived in the form of unprecedented mortgage defaults that drove down housing prices by 30%-40%.

Now comes Corker-Warner. It will set up a new government agency, the Federal Mortgage Insurance Corporation (FMIC), to insure mortgage- backed securities and wind down Fannie and Freddie as the FMIC becomes operational. As with Fannie and Freddie, investors in mortgage-backed securities will not have to worry about the quality of the underlying mortgages.

A major feature of Corker-Warner is the requirement that the private sector share the insurance risk with the new FMIC. The bill specifies that a private risk-sharer like a bond insurer must take the first losses, no less than 10% on any securitized pool of mortgages. This is intended to protect the FMIC against losses, though it works only if the quality of the mortgages remains high.

But as with Fannie and Freddie, the quality of the mortgages will be the weak link. Realtors, home builders and community activists all want as many home buyers as possible. They are not concerned with fuddy-duddy obstacles like down payments , solid credit scores or low debt-to-income ratios. These interest groups and Congress will press the FMIC to lower its underwriting standards so that more and more loans can be insured.

The private bond insurer or other risk-sharer will understand the downside potential of low-quality loans and will charge for the additional risk. That cost will be incorporated into the mortgage, increasing the monthly payment and making the cost of mortgages too high for many potential borrowers.

The result? Congress or the administration or both will pressure the FMIC to lower its insurance fees so that the maximum number of people will be able to buy homes. Recall that the Federal Housing Administration required 20% down payments when it was born in 1934. It now requires a 3% down payment—and a government bailout.

The scheme envisioned in Corker-Warner will work for a while, as long as housing prices keep climbing, and with more and more people entering the homeownership sweepstakes, they will. As housing prices get higher, houses will look like good investments, which will bring in more investors and drive prices still higher. Eventually, it will all come apart, as it did in 2008.

Then who gets hurt? The investors in mortgage-backed securities are fully covered, so they come out whole. If we assume that investors and mortgage insurers in front of the FMIC were adequately compensated for their risk, they will have profited. Taxpayers could be hurt if the FMIC has not put away enough of its revenues to cover its own losses. And the FMIC won't have done so if, like the FHA, it lowered its rates to satisfy demands from Congress or the administration for riskier mortgages at lower cost.

The only certain losers will be homeowners. Many of them will lose their homes when the collapse in housing prices triggers a recession and they lose their jobs. Others will hang on to their homes even though their mortgages are underwater—but they won't be able to refinance or sell so they can go to where the jobs are. Almost everyone will live in a neighborhood blighted by empty foreclosed homes. Sound familiar?

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Atalanta Takes Formal Verification Into Critical Systems

Updated Category News Views 0

A week of bewildering infrastructure failures is a nasty time to discover nobody can explain the machinery. That was the backdrop for Atalanta CEO and co-founder Anjana Rajan at the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine's Cyber Resilience Forum, which concluded November 20 after two days in Washington. Her central point deserves more attention than the...

Continue Reading
Fervo IPO Lawsuit Puts 71% Share Collapse in Focus

Updated Category News Views 13

Fervo’s $27 debut has turned into the sort of wreckage IPO buyers dread: shares were alleged to have closed as low as $7.79 when the complaint was filed. That is more than a 71% fall from the May 13, 2026 offering price, and it puts a hard, ugly number beside the new securities class action against the geothermal power developer. More Than a Bad Quarter Is Being Alleged...

Continue Reading
Cleveland Picks Golden Key for Citywide Leadership Training

Updated Category News Views 215

A Citywide Bet on Better Management Municipal management rarely grabs headlines until something breaks, which is precisely why Cleveland's decision to bring in Golden Key Group deserves a closer look. Announced November 20, 2026, the arrangement calls for GKG to design and deliver a citywide management training program through Cleveland's Department of Personnel and Human...

Continue Reading
NEWWAVE Turns 15 and Chases a Bigger Tech Partner Role

Updated Category News Views 97

Fifteen years is about when an outsourced engineering shop has to prove it can be more than extra hands on a keyboard. NEWWAVE’s new identity and “Trusted Technology Partner” positioning are an attempt to make that jump: from carrying out software work to helping clients decide what work ought to be done, then sticking around after launch. It is a sensible ambition,...

Continue Reading
TCL CSOT's Oxide Leap Gives LCD a Sharper Fight Ahead

Updated Category News Views 64

Fifty-one point six is the number that makes this announcement worth chewing on. TCL CSOT says it has moved ultrahigh-mobility oxide technology into mass production on an 8.6-generation line, clearing the 50 cm² V?¹ s?¹ threshold that has largely belonged to lab-talk and presentation slides. For display people, that is not decorative science. It could change the old...

Continue Reading
San Bernardino Teamsters Back Their Historic Contract

Updated Category News Views 49

A 90% vote does not whisper; it rattles the filing cabinets. More than 12,000 San Bernardino County members of Teamsters Local 1932 have ratified a new labor agreement with over 90% approval, according to the union’s November 20 announcement. In a public-sector negotiation, that kind of margin matters because it tells management the workforce is not merely accepting a...

Continue Reading
Anduin Opens Its Investor Portal Beyond Early Users

Updated Category News Views 68

Private-market paperwork has long been a swamp of portals, PDFs, email chains, and somebody chasing down a wire change at the worst possible moment. Anduin is taking a swing at that mess by opening its Investor Portal to all customers after building it with leading asset managers and operating it with their investors. The pitch is sensible: give limited partners one...

Continue Reading
Great Rail Journeys Bets Bigger on Luxury Rail in 2027

Updated Category News Views 99

A $19,995 vacation is not selling a seat on a train; it is selling relief from planning, crowds and compromise. Great Rail Journeys is leaning hard into that proposition for 2027 with two additions to its premium Landmark Collection: a Europe-heavy Orient Express and Rhône cruise pairing, plus a South Africa itinerary built around safari, Victoria Falls and rail-flavored...

Continue Reading
Trip.Best Expands Global Travel Discovery Footprint

Updated Category News Views 123

Sydney just became the map pin for a fairly serious travel-content land grab. Trip.Best, Trip.com Group's ranking brand, has rolled out its 2027 Annual Rankings with coverage of all seven continents for the first time. This is not an earnings release, and nobody should pretend a hotel list magically turns into revenue by lunchtime. Still, the jump from 85 to 98 annual...

Continue Reading
CITGO Sign Return Caps Kenmore's Careful Rebuild Work

Updated Category News Views 48

Thirty feet upward and 120 feet eastward is not the sort of move that usually stops a city in its tracks, yet Boston’s CITGO Sign was never merely rooftop hardware. Its public relighting in Kenmore Square marks the final phase of the redevelopment at 660 Beacon Street, and the real accomplishment is less flashy than the lights: a beloved, federally landmarked object...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Class Actions Alert: Key Deadlines for Investors to Note

Updated Category News Views 169

Class Actions Announced for Various Public Companies Investors should be aware of significant class action lawsuits impacting shareholders of Alarum Technologies Ltd. (NASDAQ: ALAR), Venture Global, Inc. (NYSE: VG), Constellation Brands, Inc. (NYSE: STZ), and The Trade Desk, Inc. (NASDAQ: TTD). These actions arise from allegations of false representations made by the...

Continue Reading
Wix Achieves Impressive Q1 2025 Financial Milestones

Updated Category News Views 733

Overview of Wix's Q1 2025 Performance Wix.com Ltd. (NASDAQ: WIX), a leader in the SaaS website-building space, has kicked off 2025 with a remarkable first quarter. The company reported total bookings of $511 million, marking a 12% increase year-over-year. This surge in bookings reflects a strong demand for its solutions and the effectiveness of its newly launched cohorts...

Continue Reading
XKIG Enhances Services with Acquisition of Thomas Contracting

Updated Category News Views 286

XKIG's Strategic Acquisition of Thomas Contracting Acquisition Strengthens Xylem Tree Experts' Position Across the Southeast XKIG, a leader in critical infrastructure services for power and gas utility sectors, recently announced an important acquisition. By integrating Thomas Contracting into its family of companies, XKIG is expanding its capabilities in vegetation...

Continue Reading
Apple iPhone 16 Sales Surge, Strong Competition from Samsung

Updated Category News Views 271

Apple iPhone 16 Sales Soar Amid Market Recovery Apple Inc. AAPL has celebrated a remarkable achievement with its iPhone 16 series, setting impressive sales records during the latest quarter. This surge in sales aligns with a rejuvenation in the global smartphone market, which is experiencing a significant rebound. Market Dynamics and Sales Performance According to the...

Continue Reading
Breakthrough MRD Data from Myriad Genetics at Cancer Conference

Updated Category News Views 260

Innovative Insights into MRD Testing Myriad Genetics, Inc. (NASDAQ: MYGN), a prominent name in molecular diagnostics and precision medicine, is set to unveil exciting new clinical findings related to their Precise MRD test at a significant annual meeting dedicated to cancer research. Presentation Highlights During the conference, Dr. Chad Tang from The University of Texas...

Continue Reading