Buy or Rent? BMO Economics Says Canadian Home Prices Are

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
Buy or Rent? BMO Economics Says Canadian Home Prices Are Not Highly Overvalued

TORONTO, ONTARIO--(Marketwired - June 14, 2013) - A new report from BMO Economics release today challenged the notion that Canadian home prices are highly overvalued versus the price of renting a home.

Recently a report from the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) claimed that Canadian home prices are 64 per cent overvalued. This has fuelled more debate over Canadian house prices, with much attention focusing on ownership versus renting, and whether or not someone in today's market should opt to rent instead of buy.

"We can confidently dispel the notion that Canadian home prices are egregiously overvalued versus rents, but they're not cheap either," said Robert Kavcic, Senior Economist, BMO Capital Markets. "Renting a Toronto condo is a wise alternative to buying for those with a shorter time horizon. However, young families with a longer time horizon in the detached market should not be deterred from buying, but also shouldn't expect wealth gains like those of the past decade."

The report noted that on a national basis, ownership currently looks only moderately expensive versus renting. Using current market mortgage rates - around 3 per cent for a five-year fixed rate instead of posted rates - leaves valuations almost bang on their long-run norm.

Mr. Kavcic noted that there are regional differences within the numbers:

  • On the west coast, Vancouver valuations have begun to compress from very elevated levels, though ownership still remains expensive versus renting.
  • In Calgary, both housing prices and rent prices are rising, so the gap is stable. Calgary's market looks pricey, but well below levels seen at the height of the energy boom, and resurgent rent growth has helped offset recent price gains.
  • Toronto appears only slightly overvalued compared to historical norms, but not at all at prevailing 3 per cent mortgage rates. Notably, the city is miles away from the severe bubble conditions seen in the late 1980s.

When considering the question of renting versus buying, BMO Economics looked at two scenarios in the Toronto market: a condo with a five-year horizon, and a detached home with a 15-year horizon.

The Short Term

"With a raft of completions potentially hitting the resale market in the coming years and interest rates expected to grind higher, Toronto condos will have to defy some stiff headwinds," noted Mr. Kavcic. "While we would downplay the bubble talk, the risk of buying for a five-year period probably outweighs the potential reward given current market conditions."

The Long Run

For detached houses with a 15-year horizon, current valuations don't appear to be a major deterrent to buying for the long run. "The practical limitations of moving a family among - or even finding - detached properties, associated moving costs every few years, and the likelihood of not actually selling after 15 years - given significant closing costs and mortgage payments stopping after 25 years - all add to the case for buying," said Mr. Kavcic.

"The decision to rent or buy is a very personal one and is determined by a variety of factors that need to be carefully weighed before taking the next step - whether for the short or long term," said Laura Parsons, Mortgage Expert, BMO Bank of Montreal. "A mortgage for some can be seen as a type of savings plan, particularly if they view their home as a financial nest egg for their retirement years, as many Canadians do."

Ms. Parsons noted that those who choose renting over owning property should consider working closely with a Mortgage Specialist to build a more aggressive long term saving and investment plan, as they will not be able to rely on the value of a property to bolster their retirement savings down the road.

About BMO Financial Group

Established in 1817 as Bank of Montreal, BMO Financial Group is a highly-diversified North American financial services organization. With total assets of $555 billion as at April 30, 2013, and more than 46,000 employees, BMO Financial Group provides a broad range of personal and commercial banking, wealth management and investment banking products and solutions.

Media Contacts: Matthew Duffin, Toronto (416) 867-3996 matthew.duffin@bmo.com Peter Scott, Toronto (416) 867-3996 petere.scott@bmo.com Valerie Doucet, Montreal (514) 877-8224 valerie.doucet@bmo.com Laurie Grant, Vancouver (604) 665-7596 laurie.grant@bmo.com Internet: www.bmo.com Twitter: @BMOmedia
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

RBC Grabs Top Honors for Sustainable Investing Leadership

Updated Category News Views 70

A New Feather in RBC's Cap RBC Wealth Management has racked up more accolades, crowned as the Best Private Bank in Canada and celebrated for its prowess in impact and sustainable investing on the global stage. These distinctions flew in courtesy of the PWM Global Private Banking Awards—a heavyweight recognition in the wealth management world. Award Winning Strategy in...

Continue Reading
Innovent's Big Leap: Targeting European Lung Cancer Market

Updated Category News Views 279

Innovent's Regulatory Milestone in Europe They say every underdog has its day, and for Innovent Biologics, that time just might be now. Receiving a positive opinion from the Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) is no small potatoes. Especially when we're talking lung cancer—a notorious heavyweight in the cancer world. The Finer Details of Zybrivo’s...

Continue Reading
Parallels Desktop Tops 2026 Picks for Windows on Mac

Updated Category News Views 59

Diving into the Cross-Platform Conundrum Now, I've been in the trenches long enough to know that when companies start relying on Mac computers but can't ditch their essential Windows apps, they're bound to hit a digital brick wall. Picture this—accounting, enterprise management, all that jazz that still needs Windows to function. For those jumping between these two...

Continue Reading
Net Zero Efforts to Cost Europe €60B Annually by 2050

Updated Category News Views 100

Hefty Prices Loom Over Net Zero Commitments Well, strap in for a wallet buster, folks. Europe's largest players are staring down the barrel of a colossal €60 billion annual bill to clean up their carbon mess by 2050. That's the ticker in Senken's latest report, 'Pace of Change 2026.' Talks like these remind me there's no such thing as a free lunch, especially when...

Continue Reading
Stark Future Amasses €150M, Revving Up Electric Bike Dominance

Updated Category News Views 115

Well, if you've been keeping your eye on electric vehicles, this is a story that might raise those eyebrows. Stark Future, a name perhaps not buzzing on every street just yet, has gone and done it—snagged over €150 million in fresh capital. Breaking Barriers with Record-breaking Numbers Stark Future didn't just make a ripple; they caused a tsunami. This buzzing...

Continue Reading
Trades Workforce Shortage Costs Wallop U.S. Economy

Updated Category News Views 36

The Forgotten Backbone of America Don't sleep on this: America's got itself a trade worker crisis, and it's not just a numerical hiccup. We’re down nearly 1.9 million skilled trades workers, and that's a gut punch to the economy—a hefty $1.2 billion a day in GDP loss. These are the folks who keep the wheels greased, the lights on, and the goods flowing. Without them,...

Continue Reading
Gayatri Pariwar Celebrates 100 Years with Massive Yoga Event

Updated Category News Views 72

An Impressive Centenary for Gayatri Pariwar Sometimes, you get hit by a wave so big you can't ignore it, and Gayatri Pariwar's centennial festival in New Delhi was one such tsunami. Picture this: countless souls gathered to mark a hundred years of spiritual and social reform, not just with chants and talks, but through an awe-inspiring mass yoga event. In my decades...

Continue Reading
Palatin's Game-Changer: MC4R Agonist Hits the Stage

Updated Category News Views 62

Breaking New Ground in Obesity Treatment Palatin Technologies is stepping into the spotlight with some heavy ammunition in the fight against obesity. The company has just unveiled impressive preclinical data about their next-generation melanocortin-4 receptor (MC4R) agonists at the ObesityWeek® 2026 conference. This isn’t just your run-of-the-mill corporate...

Continue Reading
Dar Global Expands Jeddah Portfolio with $267M Project

Updated Category News Views 120

Dar Global's Big Jeddah Move: A $267M Bet Alright, let's dive into what Dar Global's been up to in Saudi Arabia. They've just announced a whopping SAR 1 billion development project in Jeddah, bringing an international luxury brand to the city with an exclusive co-branded residential concept. Now that's something to chew on for any investor eyeing the Middle East's real...

Continue Reading
Ozelle Unveils AI-Powered Hematology Tool at MEDICA 2026

Updated Category News Views 116

Pioneering a New Era in Hematology In the fast-paced world of blood analysis, standing still means being left in the dust. Ozelle, with its AI-powered innovative tool, is making waves at MEDICA 2026 in Düsseldorf. Meet O-Cyte 1, an automated hematology analyzer that's merging high-resolution cell imaging with routine CBC (Complete Blood Count) testing. Sounds like...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Westhaven Gold Secures $3.16 Million Investment for Growth

Updated Category News Views 128

Westhaven Gold Corp. Completes Strategic Private Placement Westhaven Gold Corp. (TSXV: WHN) has successfully closed a non-brokered private placement, raising a substantial $3.16 million to fuel its growth initiatives. This offering comprised the sale of units at a pivotal time for the company, allowing it to enhance its exploration and development capabilities. Details of...

Continue Reading
Revolutionizing Social Media: Alexis Ohanian and Kevin Rose Join Forces

Updated Category News Views 290

Reviving a Social Media Pioneer: Ohanian and Rose Unite In a surprising turn of events, social media titans Kevin Rose and Alexis Ohanian have teamed up to acquire the pioneering social platform, Digg. Both are recognized as early influencers in the tech industry, having co-founded some of the most notable platforms of the early web era. Now, their mission is clear: to...

Continue Reading
Exploring Innovation in CBA's Tech Ecosystem for 2024

Updated Category News Views 1337

Unveiling the Commonwealth Bank of Australia's Tech Innovations In the ever-evolving landscape of finance and technology, Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) stands out as a leader. Their commitment to embracing digital transformation is not just a business strategy; it’s a comprehensive initiative that is reshaping how banking and financial services operate. The...

Continue Reading
Sheralven and Game On Team Up for Messi's Signature Fragrance

Updated Category News Views 167

Sheralven and Game On Join Forces for Messi Fragrance Launch In an exciting partnership that combines sports and beauty, Sheralven, a leader in the beauty industry, has teamed up with Game On Product Group to exclusively distribute the much-anticipated Messi Eau de Parfum in North America. This marks a significant collaboration as the fragrance is the first signature...

Continue Reading
CK Health Plus Secures Direct Selling License in Malaysia

Updated Category News Views 176

CK Health Plus Achieves Milestone in Malaysia CK Health Plus Sdn. Bhd., a subsidiary of EUDA Health Holdings Limited (NASDAQ: EUDA), has recently achieved a significant milestone by securing a Direct Selling License in Malaysia. This achievement reinforces the Company’s commitment to expanding its non-invasive healthcare offerings across Asia. Understanding the...

Continue Reading