Lesson for M&A: If You Want to Grow, Don't Expand NEW

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
Lesson for M&A: If You Want to Grow, Don't Expand

NEW YORK, NY--(Marketwired - Jun 11, 2013) -  For companies that want to succeed at M&A, here's a critical lesson to take to heart: If you want to grow, don't expand.

Mergers and acquisitions are likely to fail if companies follow a standard, popular approach, using M&A to expand into hot new areas in an attempt to jump-start growth. Whenever leaders focus on financial considerations and ignore -- or misjudge -- the fit between the companies' capabilities, failure is almost certain. M&A efforts are most likely to succeed when they are based on, or are designed to strengthen, the capabilities in which a company is already strong. The best use of M&A is to enhance or better leverage the key capabilities that set a company apart from its competitors and enable it to win.

Those are the central findings of Booz & Company's research into M&A. An eight-year study of more than 300 transactions across eight industry sectors shows that deals that either enhance or leverage a company's distinctive capabilities produce a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) that averages 12 percentage points more in annual total shareholder return (TSR) than deals in the same industry and region where the fit between the companies is limited.

In the eight years of the study -- which include the 2008 financial crisis -- deals that leveraged key capabilities produced an average annual TSR 3.9 percentage points above the market index, and deals that enhanced key capabilities outperformed the market by an average of 0.4 percentage points per year. By contrast, deals that had a limited fit -- in which companies did not seek to improve upon or apply their capabilities system in any major way -- underperformed the market index by an average of 9.1 percentage points.

"The research shows that deals made to enhance or leverage the key, differentiating things that companies do exceptionally well consistently outperform deals based on traditional definitions of overlap or adjacency," said Gerald Adolph, a Booz & Company senior partner and a coauthor of the study . Adolph leads the firm's mergers and restructuring practice.

"We call this the 'capabilities premium in M&A,'" Adolph said. "Capabilities are -- and need to be -- the basis for inorganic growth. And the premium is huge: let's just consider a hypothetical market growth of 5 percent. In this case, deals with capabilities fit would generate 8 percent annual returns, whereas deals with limited capabilities fit would actually come in at negative 4 percent TSR per year."

The study classified 320 deals by stated intent and capabilities fit, breaking down the latter into enhancement, leverage, and limited-fit deals. The eight industries surveyed were industrials, electric utilities, consumer staples, media, healthcare, chemicals, IT, and retail.

Among the key insights:

  • What capabilities are and which ones matter. According to Adolph, capabilities need to be strictly defined and clearly understood. "When we talk about the capabilities that matter in M&A, we are referring to the key strengths and differentiators, such as tailored innovation, unique distribution, superior marketing, and unparalleled customer intelligence, that support a company's strategy and enable it to deliver on its promise to customers. We don't mean the basic 'keep the lights on' functions or the competitive necessities that every player in an industry needs to have. Key capabilities are the few differentiating strengths that drive a company's identity and success."
  • How a focus on capabilities sets the winners apart. "Everybody talks about fit in M&A, but the companies that were most successful seemed to have an unusually clear idea of what fit means," Adolph said. "It does not mean traditional adjacency, bringing in a seemingly related product or service that fills a hole in a grocery shelf category, nor does it mean entering a new geography. Those types of acquisitions often underperform if a company's capabilities don't 'travel' well. Rather, fit is related to coherence, the advantage that a company gets when its capabilities work together in a system, aligned to its way of creating value, and applied to its full lineup of products and services."
  • Deals that worked. Disney enhanced its capabilities when it acquired Pixar , adding digital animation to its core capability in motion pictures and strong storytelling to its marketing machine. Google 's acquisition of DoubleClick did the same, giving the online giant a strong display advertising platform. Novartis leveraged its capabilities when it acquired Alcon , folding complementary products in new therapeutic areas into a system of strong, science-driven innovation.
  • Deals that didn't work. Kmart got little value out of its merger with Sears -- the differences in format and brand were too great to allow for synergies. Sara Lee failed to get a lift out of EarthGrains -- the fresh bread business didn't fit with Sara Lee's frozen baked goods lines, let alone other lines like personal care. eBay hoped Skype Technologies would allow it to use the latter's voice technology to let customers close deals faster. But the capabilities didn't match, and eBay sold Skype at a US$1 billion loss. Other famous deals that failed because they ignored capabilities include Quaker Oats' failed acquisition of Snapple and the disastrous AOL acquisition of Time Warner .
  • The questions leaders should ask. Leaders, board members, and investment bankers need to look beyond financial questions when contemplating a deal and also ask themselves:
    • What is unique about the target's capabilities? How does the target create value?
    • How does its capabilities system differ from our own?
    • If we are buying a company for its product and service portfolio, are we sure those products and services will thrive within our capabilities systems?
    • If we are buying a company for its capabilities, can we integrate them with our own?
    • How will the new company generate value out of its evolving capabilities system?
    • What is the risk that the capabilities won't fit?
    • Which assets (facilities, processes, suppliers, and employees) do we need to bring on board to support the combined capabilities?

"To determine whether the other company's capabilities fit, you need to understand your own," Adolph said. "And your due diligence needs to go beyond legal and financial issues to also test technology, organization, and culture fit."

Bio Gerald Adolph is a senior partner at Booz & Company, based in New York. He leads the firm's mergers and restructuring practice. He is coauthor of the book Merge Ahead: Mastering the Five Enduring Trends of Artful M&A and coauthor of the study "The Capabilities Premium in M&A," ( http://www.strategyand.pwc.com/eref/capabilit...-tool.html ) among other publications.

About Booz & Company  Booz & Company ( strategyand.pwc.com ) is a leading global management consulting firm focused on serving and shaping the senior agenda of the world's leading institutions. Drawing on the talents and insights of more than 3,000 people in 58 offices around the world, we help our clients achieve essential advantage by working with them to identify and build the differentiating capabilities they need to outperform.

Contacts: Erin Bowler Senior Manager, North America Marketing Tel: +1-312-578-4697 Mobile: +1-312-560-5176 Email Contact Margaret Kashmir Senior Manager, Global Media & Communications Tel: +1-973-410-7609 Mobile: +1-973-879-7213 Email Contact

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Clear Aligner Results Depend on Discipline, Not Hype

Updated Category News Views 130

A Clear Tray Is Not a Magic Wand Transparent orthodontic trays sell a wonderfully tidy idea: straighten teeth without the metal-and-wire routine, take them out to eat, and carry on. Fair enough. But the useful message from Dr. Theresa Trapp is the part nobody should glide past: clear aligners are a treatment plan, not a cosmetic shortcut bought with good intentions....

Continue Reading
Classic Chevrolet Gives $1.145M to 13 Local Groups

Updated Category News Views 104

A Thanksgiving Check With Some Real Weight More than a million dollars changing hands before lunch is not the usual holiday fluff, and Classic Chevrolet's planned $1,145,040 donation deserves more than a quick nod. On Tuesday, November 24, at 11 a.m. CST, the Grapevine dealership says it will distribute that sum among 13 nonprofit organizations and charitable programs...

Continue Reading
D-Wave Investors Face a December 15 Lead Plaintiff Clock

Updated Category News Views 55

August Put the Story Under a Harsh Light Two ugly August trading sessions are doing a lot of work in the case now confronting D-Wave Quantum. The company sits in a field that attracts big dreams, big headlines, and, frankly, plenty of investor imagination. But imagination does not cushion a portfolio when expectations crack. The lawsuits concern people who bought or...

Continue Reading
Human Frontier Mission Puts AI Research on Display

Updated Category News Views 45

A laboratory notebook is about to become the real product in this AI experiment. Human Frontier Mission, or HFM, says it will launch globally on Nov. 24, opening a research program where domain specialists frame scientific and engineering problems while autonomous AI agents develop and test possible answers. The unusual bit is not merely handing models difficult work. It...

Continue Reading
Lymphatic Research Gains Attention Beyond Wellness Claims

Updated Category News Views 76

Ankles leave little clues after a long day: sock grooves, puffiness, that dull heaviness nobody bothers to name. PureHealth Research wants people to look past the usual salt-and-water explanation and consider the lymphatic system, the body’s comparatively unsung network for gathering fluid from tissues and returning it to the bloodstream. Fair enough. This system does...

Continue Reading
Faex Health Adds Ebola and H. pylori AI Screening Tools

Updated Category News Views 82

A smartphone pointed at a toilet is an awkward place to hunt for medical progress, yet Faex Health is making a serious attempt to turn that daily evidence into an early-warning tool. The company has added investigational pre-screening capabilities for Ebola virus disease and Helicobacter pylori, or H. pylori, bringing its internally validated panel to 18 gastrointestinal...

Continue Reading
Fraud0-FouAnalytics Takes Aim at Legacy Ad Verification

Updated Category News Views 115

Digital ad measurement has spent years grading its own homework, and that little arrangement may finally be getting some daylight. fraud0 and FouAnalytics say their expanded partnership will give advertisers impression-level visibility into where ads actually rendered, whether apparent humans engaged with them, and where wasted Google Ads spend might be recoverable. The...

Continue Reading
University of Phoenix Poll Gets a Useful Reality Check

Updated Category News Views 108

Good Numbers, With the Usual Fine Print Employer approval is the kind of evidence career-focused schools desperately need, and University of Phoenix just put up a pretty loud batch of it. Among managers who directly supervise its graduates, 94% said the university understands employer needs, while 92% said its programs align with workforce demands. Those are stout...

Continue Reading
SEIA's Young Advisors Put Succession Plans to the Test

Updated Category News Views 67

A $166 million average book is not a cute training-program statistic. It says SEIA’s advisors aged 30 to 39 are already carrying serious client responsibility, and that matters because the registered investment advisory business is headed into a succession crunch nobody can solve with a glossy recruiting brochure. You Cannot Hand Off Trust Like a Spare Key Clients may...

Continue Reading
CASEKOO's Montana Story Makes Brand Purpose Personal

Updated Category News Views 50

A blurry Montana kitchen, not a glossy product render, is doing the heavy lifting for CASEKOO this Thanksgiving. That is either a smart bit of brand discipline or a sentimental detour, depending on whether the company can make people feel something without losing sight of why they bought a phone case in the first place. Warmth Takes the Place of Hardware CASEKOO's new...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Digital Utilities Ventures Pioneers Sustainable Farming in Africa

Updated Category News Views 251

Transforming Agriculture with Easy FEN™ Technology Digital Utilities Ventures (DUTV) is making significant strides in sustainable agriculture with its Easy FEN™ modular units. Recently, the company secured a contract worth $3.4 million to deploy these innovative systems, targeting the challenges faced by farming communities in Africa. Sustainable Solutions Addressing...

Continue Reading
Prosafe SE Signs Contract with Ithaca Energy for Safe Caledonia

Updated Category News Views 203

Prosafe SE Secures Major Contract with Ithaca Energy Prosafe SE has recently finalized a significant contract with Ithaca Energy (UK) Limited regarding the operations of the Safe Caledonia. This agreement comes after a Letter of Intent was issued on July 5, 2024, marking a key step in their partnership and commitment to delivering essential accommodation support. The...

Continue Reading
Robert Half Acknowledged for Corporate Responsibility Excellence

Updated Category News Views 201

Recognizing Robert Half's Corporate Responsibility Achievements Global talent solutions and consulting giant Robert Half (NYSE: RHI) has recently received notable recognition from Newsweek, being named as one of America’s Most Responsible Companies for the year 2026. This award is a significant endorsement that highlights corporations that prioritize corporate social...

Continue Reading
Boeing's Job Cuts: Navigating Challenges in the Aerospace Sector

Updated Category News Views 190

Boeing's Significant Workforce Reductions Boeing has made headlines recently with its decision to cut approximately 2,200 jobs. This substantial reduction affects workers in various divisions, particularly in Washington. The downsizing comes as part of a larger strategy to trim about 17,000 positions as the aerospace company faces prolonged financial and operational...

Continue Reading
Exploring the Innovations of Horizon3.ai in Cybersecurity

Updated Category News Views 248

Introduction to Horizon3.ai's Autonomous Security Horizon3.ai has emerged as a pioneering force in the field of autonomous cybersecurity solutions, significantly shaping the landscape for security teams across the globe. The company, recognized for its innovative NodeZero Autonomous Security Platform, is dedicated to improving cyber resilience and enhancing the...

Continue Reading