WSJournal - In Defense of Carbon Dioxide. The demonized

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
PoemStone

WSJournal - In Defense of Carbon Dioxide .

The demonized chemical compound is a boon to plant life and has little correlation with global temperature.

Of all of the world's chemical compounds, none has a worse reputation than carbon dioxide. Thanks to the single-minded demonization of this natural and essential atmospheric gas by advocates of government control of energy production, the conventional wisdom about carbon dioxide is that it is a dangerous pollutant. That's simply not the case. Contrary to what some would have us believe, increased carbon dioxide in the atmosphere will benefit the increasing population on the planet by increasing agricultural productivity.

The cessation of observed global warming for the past decade or so has shown how exaggerated NASA's and most other computer predictions of human-caused warming have been—and how little correlation warming has with concentrations of atmospheric carbon dioxide. As many scientists have pointed out, variations in global temperature correlate much better with solar activity and with complicated cycles of the oceans and atmosphere. There isn't the slightest evidence that more carbon dioxide has caused more extreme weather.

The current levels of carbon dioxide in the earth's atmosphere, approaching 400 parts per million, are low by the standards of geological and plant evolutionary history. Levels were 3,000 ppm, or more, until the Paleogene period (beginning about 65 million years ago). For most plants, and for the animals and humans that use them, more carbon dioxide, far from being a "pollutant" in need of reduction, would be a benefit. This is already widely recognized by operators of commercial greenhouses, who artificially increase the carbon dioxide levels to 1,000 ppm or more to improve the growth and quality of their plants.

Using energy from sunlight—together with the catalytic action of an ancient enzyme called rubisco, the most abundant protein on earth—plants convert carbon dioxide from the air into carbohydrates and other useful molecules. Rubisco catalyzes the attachment of a carbon-dioxide molecule to another five-carbon molecule to make two three-carbon molecules, which are subsequently converted into carbohydrates. (Since the useful product from the carbon dioxide capture consists of three-carbon molecules, plants that use this simple process are called C3 plants.) C3 plants, such as wheat, rice, soybeans, cotton and many forage crops, evolved when there was much more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere than today. So these agricultural staples are actually undernourished in carbon dioxide relative to their original design.

At the current low levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide, rubisco in C3 plants can be fooled into substituting oxygen molecules for carbon-dioxide molecules. But this substitution reduces the efficiency of photosynthesis, especially at high temperatures. To get around the problem, a small number of plants have evolved a way to enrich the carbon-dioxide concentration around the rubisco enzyme, and to suppress the oxygen concentration. Called C4 plants because they utilize a molecule with four carbons, plants that use this evolutionary trick include sugar cane, corn and other tropical plants.

Although C4 plants evolved to cope with low levels of carbon dioxide, the workaround comes at a price, since it takes additional chemical energy. With high levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, C4 plants are not as productive as C3 plants, which do not have the overhead costs of the carbon-dioxide enrichment system.

That's hardly all that goes into making the case for the benefits of carbon dioxide. Right now, at our current low levels of carbon dioxide, plants are paying a heavy price in water usage. Whether plants are C3 or C4, the way they get carbon dioxide from the air is the same: The plant leaves have little holes, or stomata, through which carbon dioxide molecules can diffuse into the moist interior for use in the plant's photosynthetic cycles.

The density of water molecules within the leaf is typically 60 times greater than the density of carbon dioxide in the air, and the diffusion rate of the water molecule is greater than that of the carbon-dioxide molecule.

So depending on the relative humidity and temperature, 100 or more water molecules diffuse out of the leaf for every molecule of carbon dioxide that diffuses in . And not every carbon-dioxide molecule that diffuses into a leaf gets incorporated into a carbohydrate. As a result, plants require many hundreds of grams of water to produce one gram of plant biomass, largely carbohydrate.

Driven by the need to conserve water, plants produce fewer stomata openings in their leaves when there is more carbon dioxide in the air. This decreases the amount of water that the plant is forced to transpire and allows the plant to withstand dry conditions better.

Crop yields in recent dry years were less affected by drought than crops of the dust-bowl droughts of the 1930s, when there was less carbon dioxide. Nowadays, in an age of rising population and scarcities of food and water in some regions, it's a wonder that humanitarians aren't clamoring for more atmospheric carbon dioxide. Instead, some are denouncing it.

We know that carbon dioxide has been a much larger fraction of the earth's atmosphere than it is today, and the geological record shows that life flourished on land and in the oceans during those times. The incredible list of supposed horrors that increasing carbon dioxide will bring the world is pure belief disguised as science.

Mr. Schmitt, an adjunct professor of engineering at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, was an Apollo 17 astronaut and a former U.S. senator from New Mexico. Mr. Happer is a professor of physics at Princeton University and a former director of the office of energy research at the U.S. Department of Energy.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

SAP Execution Can Steady Operations Beyond Spreadsheets

Updated Category News Views 87

Spreadsheets breed little kingdoms, and SAP is often left outside the gate. That is the operational mess Martin Rowan, managing partner at Reveal USA, Inc. in Naperville, is taking aim at in a Nov. 19, 2026 HelloNation feature. His central point is not terribly glamorous, but it is dead right: a company gets less stable when it uses SAP to explain yesterday's results...

Continue Reading
TNBC Advocate Campaign Targets Gaps in Patient Clarity

Updated Category News Views 93

Triple-negative is a heavy phrase to hand somebody without a map. Tigerlily Foundation and the Breast Cancer Resource Center are trying to close that gap with a national education campaign scheduled to launch publicly on January 11, 2027. The plan is straightforward on paper: train and mobilize 100 patient advocates across the country to explain triple-negative breast...

Continue Reading
EmTech AI 2027 Puts AI Ambitions Through Reality Test

Updated Category News Views 111

A three-day gathering cannot settle AI's biggest arguments, but MIT Technology Review has picked the right fight for EmTech AI 2027: make the industry face a Reality Test. The conference runs May 11–13, 2027, at MIT's campus and online, and that theme lands because the AI conversation has spent plenty of time admiring the engine while skipping the ugly maintenance bill....

Continue Reading
AltaPointe PATH Outreach Puts Housing Waits in Focus

Updated Category News Views 108

Two years is a brutal length of time to ask somebody without stable housing to wait for an income-based apartment. That number hangs over AltaPointe Health's PATH program in Mobile, Alabama, and it ought to. The organization helped 16 people secure permanent housing in the past fiscal year, a figure that can look small if somebody is just skimming a report. It looks very...

Continue Reading
Yiwu Squishies Turn Viral Demand Into Factory Backlogs Worldwide

Updated Category News Views 87

A pizza-shaped stress toy booking more than one million units is the sort of detail that makes a jaded market watcher sit up before rolling his eyes at the word “viral.” Yiwu’s squishy-toy surge appears to have moved beyond a few social-media impulses and into actual factory scheduling, repeat purchase orders and supermarket procurement. That is meaningful. It is...

Continue Reading
SKINformed Bets on Skin Longevity Over Quick Fixes

Updated Category News Views 75

Wrinkle panic has been a very profitable racket for a long time, and SKINformed is trying to sidestep it. The physician-founded skincare brand is planting its flag on “SKINgevity,” a term it uses to describe long-term skin health rather than a frantic hunt for an overnight rewind. That is a sensible read on where beauty consumers appear to be headed: less appetite for...

Continue Reading
AI Forces Learning Teams to Redefine Their Core Job

Updated Category News Views 89

Training Departments Are Not Sitting Still Corporate learning has spent years being treated like the office instruction manual, and AI is making that old arrangement look awfully flimsy. RedThread Research's November 19, 2026 study lands on a point that ought to make senior management pay attention: learning and development leaders are not merely waiting around to be...

Continue Reading
PostalAnnex Adds Roseville Store as Owners Reach Three

Updated Category News Views 97

A third storefront from the same operators says more than a ribbon-cutting ever will. Aarondeep Hira and Manraj Sangha have opened a PostalAnnex in Roseville, California, their third Sacramento-area location after earlier operations in Sacramento and Antelope. For a franchise system, repeat ownership is the part worth noticing. It is not a guarantee of booming sales, and...

Continue Reading
Corner Bakery Bets on Holiday Catering Convenience

Updated Category News Views 128

A $50 carrot on a $350 catering tab tells you exactly where Corner Bakery sees the holiday battlefield: not in one lonely cookie sale, but in the larger group order that can make a restaurant’s day. The chain is pushing holiday catering through November and December, pairing that discount with bakery trays, meals for groups and a promise to handle delivery setup. It is...

Continue Reading
Klarna’s Cash Burn Puts Disclosure Questions in Focus

Updated Category News Views 118

A $383 million operating cash drain can turn a growth story sour in a hurry. Klarna Group plc delivered exactly that kind of unpleasant jolt in its third-quarter 2026 report: a net loss of $65 million, or roughly $0.19 per share, alongside negative operating cash flow of $383 million over the first nine months of 2026. The per-share loss landed worse than the $0.13 to...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Transparency in Securities Disclosure: Learning Technologies' Interest

Updated Category News Views 111

Key Information About Securities Disclosure In the evolving landscape of financial regulations, transparency stands as a foundational requirement for public companies. One of the pivotal rules governing such disclosures is laid out in Rule 8.3 of the Takeover Code. This rule mandates that entities or individuals with interests in relevant securities of 1% or more must...

Continue Reading
Chart Industries Inc. Reports Impressive Q2 Performance

Updated Category News Views 115

Exceptional Financial Growth in Q2 Chart Industries, Inc. (NASDAQ: GTLS) shared its financial results for the second quarter. The company witnessed notable growth compared to the previous year's quarter, marking a significant trajectory in its market position. Quarterly Highlights In the second quarter, Chart Industries recorded orders totaling $1.50 billion, representing...

Continue Reading
Marine Lubricants Market Growth Forecast: USD 7.8 Billion

Updated Category News Views 70

Overview of the Marine Lubricants Market The marine lubricants market is steadily growing, with forecasts estimating its value will reach an impressive USD 7.8 billion by 2032. This growth is driven by a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 2.07% during the period from 2024 to 2032. Key Drivers Behind Market Growth One of the main factors fueling this market's growth is...

Continue Reading
Celebrating Diversity in Arbitration: CCA’s New Class Announced

Updated Category News Views 185

Celebrating Diversity with New CCA Associates Class The College of Commercial Arbitrators (CCA) is thrilled to introduce the new class of Associates for the 2025–2027 mentorship program. This initiative, started in 2022, highlights the CCA's commitment to nurturing emerging talent in the field of commercial arbitration, particularly from underrepresented backgrounds. By...

Continue Reading
Big Bronze Unveils Final K9 Statue to Honor Veterans

Updated Category News Views 211

Big Bronze Completes Veteran's Memorial with Final K9 Statue Big Bronze, renowned for its exquisite bronze sculptures, is thrilled to share the news of completing an important project at Veterans Memorial Park. This milestone marks the addition of the fourth and final statue in a series designed to honor the sacrifices of U.S. veterans. A Tribute to Valor and Sacrifice...

Continue Reading