Amandala Newspaper

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

May 5, 2013 at 11:14 AM

Amandala Newspaper
http://amandala.com.bz/news/prime-minister-ca...usly-wrong
Export date: Sun May 5 15:13:42 2013 / +0000 GMT

Prime Minister calls Justice Legall ruling on petroleum contracts “egregiously wrong”

Legall ruling against 6th Constitutional Amendment “of no practical effect,” he also said

“…the minister can say to the landowner—whether you like it or not—I am making an order that the concession-holder go onto your land”

The Government of Belize does plan on appealing the April 16, 2013 decision of Justice Oswell Legall in which he declared six offshore petroleum concessions to be “unlawful, null and void,” as well as the April 19 decision of the judge in which he ruled certain portions of the Sixth Constitutional Amendment to be “unconstitutional, null and void.”

“I don’t think there is much practical consequence to any of those two judgments,” Prime Minister Dean Barrow commented at his press conference on Monday.

Barrow confirmed that Government’s legal counsels have already prepared documents for the appeal.

“I’ve seen our grounds of appeal and I believe that the lawyers described that as an aberrant ruling on the part of the judge, and I completely and unreservedly endorse that,” Barrow told the media.

The Environmental Protection Act (EPA) does say that you must have an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) once you are intending to proceed with a project. Barrow questioned, however, in a hypothetical case in which there are 4 bids for the petroleum concession, say for a million acres, how will government say, “Go do an EIA on that specific land before?”

“Now the PSA [Production Sharing Agreement] is not the project and the law does say as soon as somebody is granted a PSA, the minister can require an EIA. For him [Legall] to say that, ‘No, the EIA must come even before you grant the PSA,’ makes absolutely no sense at all in my mind,” Barrow stated.

Barrow said that “the judge went egregiously wrong” when he conflated the application for a production sharing agreement (PSA) with a contract.

He said that Government’s worry is that those with a particular intent will try to apply the ruling to terrestrial PSAs.

The concessionaires whose contracts were voided are Island Oil, Miles Tropical Energy Ltd., Petro Belize Company Ltd., Princess Petroleum Ltd., Providence Energy Belize Ltd., and SOL Oil Belize Ltd. These were all PSA’s signed by the previous administration, Barrow said.

“Once you have a PSA, the minister can say to the landowner—whether you like it or not—I am making an order that the concession-holder go onto your land for purposes of an EIA to determine, to shoot seismic or whatever… I am baffled as to how the judge could arrive at the position he did in that regard,” he further commented.

Justice Legall also ruled that the companies who were given the petroleum concessions did not meet the qualifications set out in law. The prime minister did not comment on this aspect of the ruling.

Barrow said that the judge did not issue a quashing order, despite the request made by the claimants. Neither did the suit enjoin the petroleum companies as interested parties, he said, describing this as “a grievous omission.” He did accept that the court has issued an injunction against the Government of Belize.

“That’s for the concession holder to determine whether they will continue with work under the PSA,” Barrow said.

The Prime Minister also commented on the subsequent ruling by Legall, in which he declared portions of the Sixth Amendment to the Belize Constitution to be “unconstitutional, null and void.” The provision in question stipulates that where instruments of appointment for judges are open-ended, those instruments would be deemed to be for a one-year term.

“[Legall] could only do that because he subscribes to this basic structure doctrine, which I believe is rubbish, which is currently before the Court of Appeal for a ruling,” Barrow said, adding that Justice Legall should not have pronounced on that because a ruling is imminent.

On the issue of tenure of judges to the age of 75, Barrow said that “as far as we’re concerned, that again is dicta (a statement of opinion or belief considered authoritative though not binding). That is not to be found in the four corners of the Constitution.”

“We will appeal, but in the meantime, it affects nothing practically” he said.

Barrow announced that Legall, who turns 68 on June 7, has written to the Governor-General to say that he will not be seeking renewal of his contract when it expires on his birthday.

He added that Legall was “unprompted,” and he doesn’t want anyone to say that he sent the judge away.

Post date: 2013-05-03 10:03:58
Post date GMT: 2013-05-03 16:03:58

Post modified date: 2013-05-03 10:05:45
Post modified date GMT: 2013-05-03 16:05:45

Treaty Energy Corporation (TECO) Stock Research Links

TECO Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Dentsply Sirona Faces Insider Troubles: An Investor Call

Are Dentsply Sirona Insiders on Thin Ice? The stock market's a tumultuous sea, and right now, it seems like some of those at the helm of Dentsply Sirona Inc. might be rocking the boat a bit too much. Let me tell you, navigating these corporate storms isn't for the faint-hearted. The latest noise coming from Halper Sadeh LLC suggests that some directors and officers over...

Tech Breakthroughs in Cancer and Space Energy Aired

Science and Technology at the Forefront Saturday nights usually have folks kicking back with some reality shows or maybe cheering on their favorite sports team. But this September 12, savvy viewers have a chance to dive deep into the guts of cutting-edge science and tech on Bloomberg Television. We're talking about 'Advancements with Ted Danson'—where science isn’t...

Hyosung Targets U.S. AI Power Market with Advanced SST

Hyosung's Game-Changing Move in the AI Power Sector Guess what? The AI era's heating up, and it's dragging the power sector along for a wild ride. Hyosung Chairman Hyun-Joon Cho peered into that future and decided it's all-in time for the U.S. power market. With AI and data centers cranking up power demands like never before, those rickety old wires need an upgrade fast....

Regeneron Faces Class Action Over Tumultuous Trial Results

Regeneron's Meltdown: A Bitter Pill for Investors Let’s dive headlong into the mess Regeneron Pharmaceuticals (NASDAQ:REGN) finds itself in—a classic nightmare scenario for investors. News broke like an old valve bursting, and suddenly, the market's love for Regeneron ran ice-cold. Who's to blame this time? Well, you might want to point a finger at the failed Phase 3...

Automotive ECU Market Aims $160B by 2033

Automotive ECUs Under the Spotlight Picture this: By 2033, the automotive ECU market is expected to balloon to a whopping $160.59 billion. That's some serious cash, and it ain't just pocket change. This $47 billion jump from 2026 isn't just happening by accident—it's got everything to do with high-octane changes in the industry. With a 5.1% CAGR, you best believe it's a...

CDTL's E-Drive and EMB Shape Future of Automation

A Bumpy Ride Towards Future of Commercial Vehicles In the midst of a bustling Hannover, CDTL, that plucky contender in e-drive systems, is making noise at IAA Transportation 2026. Now, if there's one thing I've learned watching this circus we call the auto industry, it's that innovation rarely strolls in with a polite knock. It barges through the door, often leaving a...

Consumer365 Highlights Happy Head's Personalized Hair Solutions

Tailored Hair Loss Solutions by Happy Head Imagine trying to fit a square peg in a round hole. That's what one-size-fits-all approaches often feel like in the world of hair loss treatments. Happy Head, recognized by Consumer365, takes that notion and turns it on its head, offering personalized minoxidil formulations for women. The key word here is personalized. More Than...

Universal Music Wraps €250M Share Buyback Plan

Universal's Encore Performance in the Markets Universal Music Group (EURONEXT: UMG), the behemoth in music-based entertainment, just wrapped up its €250 million share buyback program. Talk about a grand finale! In a week’s worth of maneuvering from August 31 to September 4, they snagged 294,340 of their own shares, all for the pretty price of €14.65 a pop. Grand...

Cultural Convergence: Ordos Event Captivates Global Visitors

Ordos: Where Cultures Connect Seamlessly Spanning continents and cultures, the recent 'Warm City' event in Ordos, Inner Mongolia, drew international attention like bees to honey. Now, if you're thinking this is just another cultural shindig, think again. François Tchiegue, an ambassador of China-Africa cultural exchanges, described it best when he noted how the morin...

Dr. Liedtka's LIVE Model: Balance Life’s Priorities

Finding Balance in a Chaotic World Forget the market roller coaster for a second. Let's chat about something else that often feels like a roller coaster—life itself. Dr. Karl D. Liedtka's book, "Be Present, LIVE Fully," dives into that hot mess and offers a way to get a grip on your own sanity. This isn't just another self-help book filled with empty platitudes; it's...