Amandala Newspaper

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

May 5, 2013 at 11:14 AM

Amandala Newspaper
http://amandala.com.bz/news/prime-minister-ca...usly-wrong
Export date: Sun May 5 15:13:42 2013 / +0000 GMT

Prime Minister calls Justice Legall ruling on petroleum contracts “egregiously wrong”

Legall ruling against 6th Constitutional Amendment “of no practical effect,” he also said

“…the minister can say to the landowner—whether you like it or not—I am making an order that the concession-holder go onto your land”

The Government of Belize does plan on appealing the April 16, 2013 decision of Justice Oswell Legall in which he declared six offshore petroleum concessions to be “unlawful, null and void,” as well as the April 19 decision of the judge in which he ruled certain portions of the Sixth Constitutional Amendment to be “unconstitutional, null and void.”

“I don’t think there is much practical consequence to any of those two judgments,” Prime Minister Dean Barrow commented at his press conference on Monday.

Barrow confirmed that Government’s legal counsels have already prepared documents for the appeal.

“I’ve seen our grounds of appeal and I believe that the lawyers described that as an aberrant ruling on the part of the judge, and I completely and unreservedly endorse that,” Barrow told the media.

The Environmental Protection Act (EPA) does say that you must have an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) once you are intending to proceed with a project. Barrow questioned, however, in a hypothetical case in which there are 4 bids for the petroleum concession, say for a million acres, how will government say, “Go do an EIA on that specific land before?”

“Now the PSA [Production Sharing Agreement] is not the project and the law does say as soon as somebody is granted a PSA, the minister can require an EIA. For him [Legall] to say that, ‘No, the EIA must come even before you grant the PSA,’ makes absolutely no sense at all in my mind,” Barrow stated.

Barrow said that “the judge went egregiously wrong” when he conflated the application for a production sharing agreement (PSA) with a contract.

He said that Government’s worry is that those with a particular intent will try to apply the ruling to terrestrial PSAs.

The concessionaires whose contracts were voided are Island Oil, Miles Tropical Energy Ltd., Petro Belize Company Ltd., Princess Petroleum Ltd., Providence Energy Belize Ltd., and SOL Oil Belize Ltd. These were all PSA’s signed by the previous administration, Barrow said.

“Once you have a PSA, the minister can say to the landowner—whether you like it or not—I am making an order that the concession-holder go onto your land for purposes of an EIA to determine, to shoot seismic or whatever… I am baffled as to how the judge could arrive at the position he did in that regard,” he further commented.

Justice Legall also ruled that the companies who were given the petroleum concessions did not meet the qualifications set out in law. The prime minister did not comment on this aspect of the ruling.

Barrow said that the judge did not issue a quashing order, despite the request made by the claimants. Neither did the suit enjoin the petroleum companies as interested parties, he said, describing this as “a grievous omission.” He did accept that the court has issued an injunction against the Government of Belize.

“That’s for the concession holder to determine whether they will continue with work under the PSA,” Barrow said.

The Prime Minister also commented on the subsequent ruling by Legall, in which he declared portions of the Sixth Amendment to the Belize Constitution to be “unconstitutional, null and void.” The provision in question stipulates that where instruments of appointment for judges are open-ended, those instruments would be deemed to be for a one-year term.

“[Legall] could only do that because he subscribes to this basic structure doctrine, which I believe is rubbish, which is currently before the Court of Appeal for a ruling,” Barrow said, adding that Justice Legall should not have pronounced on that because a ruling is imminent.

On the issue of tenure of judges to the age of 75, Barrow said that “as far as we’re concerned, that again is dicta (a statement of opinion or belief considered authoritative though not binding). That is not to be found in the four corners of the Constitution.”

“We will appeal, but in the meantime, it affects nothing practically” he said.

Barrow announced that Legall, who turns 68 on June 7, has written to the Governor-General to say that he will not be seeking renewal of his contract when it expires on his birthday.

He added that Legall was “unprompted,” and he doesn’t want anyone to say that he sent the judge away.

Post date: 2013-05-03 10:03:58
Post date GMT: 2013-05-03 16:03:58

Post modified date: 2013-05-03 10:05:45
Post modified date GMT: 2013-05-03 16:05:45

Treaty Energy Corporation (TECO) Stock Research Links

TECO Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Julian Sawyer Strengthens Wirex Board with Expertise

Ah, the world of digital payments – it's like the wild west out there, constantly evolving and full of promise, but with no shortage of challenges. Enter Julian Sawyer, a name that echoes in the hallowed halls of fintech. And guess what? He's bringing his chops to the Wirex Limited board as an Independent Non-Executive Director. If you're in the market game, better keep...

Richey May Unveils Guide to Strategic Mortgage Moves

Ditching Day-One Decisions, Eyeing Long Term Here's something to chew on over your caffeine fix: the Richey May folks just rolled out a brand new guide. If you're in the mortgage game, it's worth your while. Now, if you've spent any time trying to make sense of mortgage servicing, you know it's not a 'one-size-fits-all' scenario. And Seth Sprague and his team over at...

Bakersfield Sees Spike in Crashes Post Time Change

Evening Darkness and Safety Concerns Folks, it seems Bakersfield streets transform into a battlefield once the clock falls back. With darkness creeping in earlier, those evening hours right after the time change see a sobering uptick in accidents. According to an analysis by Chain | Cohn | Clark, pedestrian and bicyclist crashes from 5 to 7 p.m. double. It's not just...

Solstice Advances Foam Agent with Eco-Friendly Twist

A New Phase in Foam Blowing Agents You don’t come across a true leap in materials technology every day, and that’s exactly what's unfolding with Solstice Advanced Materials' latest venture. They’re not just talking the talk; they've hit a milestone in developing a next-gen foam blowing agent. This isn't just another tweak in a spreadsheet—it's a potential pivot in...

Lauri Thompson Joins UWSN Board: A New Era Begins

Fresh Faces and New Perspectives In a move that merges legal acumen with community heart, Lauri S. Thompson of Greenberg Traurig has stepped up as a board member for the United Way of Southern Nevada (UWSN). Now, why should we care about this? Because when someone with Thompson's clout and eight-arm octopus of involvement links up with a nonprofit, things get interesting....

Parachute Health Urges HME Transformation Through Collaboration

The Road to Digital Unity in HME Cranking through the gears of the healthcare industry is no mean feat, but Parachute Health seems ready to throw some fresh oil on the machine. In a landscape riddled with complexities, they're sounding the call for a more unified digital infrastructure in the Home Medical Equipment (HME) sector through their latest white paper. We're...

Silver Oak Sells CCS, Setting Stage for Further Growth

Wind Point Partners Acquires CCS: A Strategic Shift All right, let's cut to the chase: Silver Oak just offloaded CCS Facility Services to Wind Point Partners. We're talking about a private equity giant making moves in the janitorial sector. If you find this snoozy, think again. This ain't just about swapping keys of a janitorial firm. It's about money moves and strategic...

ChipMOS Sees 30.9% YoY Revenue Jump in October

ChipMOS's Revenue Surge: More Than Numbers If there's one thing Wall Street loves, it's a good comeback story. ChipMOS Technologies Inc. (Taiwan Stock Exchange: 8150, Nasdaq: IMOS) seems to be writing its own version with a jaw-dropping 30.9% year-over-year revenue growth this October. Time to perk those ears up because this isn't just about numbers; it's about a...

Global Museum of Illusions Comes to San Francisco

Illusions on Market Street The Global Museum of Illusions, the fast-growing sensation in private museums, is setting its sights on San Francisco with a new location opening on Market Street this November 13. They're dangling a juicy 50% off presale ticket offer for the early birds. A Mind-Bending Experience This museum isn't your run-of-the-mill art gallery or historical...

The DOG CATCHER: A New Spin on Pet Waste Cleanup

Revolutionizing the Dreaded Pet Waste Duty Folks, here's a little dose of innovation from the streets of Baltimore: a gadget called the DOG CATCHER. No, it’s not about catching stray dogs, but dealing with their unpleasant leavings. This invention's got a patent pending and all, promising to make the nasty business of dog waste collection a whole lot less disgusting. I...