administration withholds suspect’s Miranda

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone

administration withholds suspect’s Miranda rights–for now.

Updated at 12:20 PM

More than 12 hours after Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was taken into custody, authorities have yet to read the 19-year-old Boston bombing suspect his Miranda rights.

President Obama said of the investigation Friday night that “it’s important that we do this right.” But Tsarnaev will not be advised of his right to remain silent or his right to counsel before authorities begin questioning him. While this is not the first time the government has invoked what is known as the public safety exception to Miranda, the Boston case will be an important test of the limits of civil liberties and the legal system.

Investigators have said that the exception was necessary in this case because it was unclear whether an possible accomplice was still at large, or whether the suspect had additional explosives.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) issued a statement Saturday morning that laid out its objection to such a broad application of the exception.

“The public safety exception should be read narrowly, it applies only when there is a continued threat to public safety, and is not an open-ended exception to the Miranda rule,” the statement read.

Vince Warren of the Center for Constitutional Rights also called on investigators to follow the rule of law, saying Saturday, “If officials require suspects to incriminate themselves, they are making fair trials and due process merely option and not a requirement. To venture down that road again will make law enforcement accountable to no one.”

According to NBC News , authorities could have as much as 48 hours to question Tsarnaev, an American citizen, before reading him his rights. That would be a far wider window than has been used in previous cases of suspected terrorism.

The “public safety exception” to Miranda has existed since 1984, when the Supreme Court ruled that police could question a suspect without reading his rights about possible immediate threats. But in 2010, Attorney General Eric Holder expanded the exception to include questioning when “the government’s interest in obtaining…intelligence outweighs the disadvantages of proceeding with unwarned interrogation.” The memo was written after the Obama administrtaion came under criticism from Republicans who claimed the White House wasn’t being aggressive on terrorism cases.

The narrow application of the public safety exception has not hampered terrorism prosecutions but it has raised concerns from civil rights groups. In 2009, Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, the Christmas Day “underwear” bomber, was questioned for 50 minutes before authorities read him his rights. Faisal Shazad was convicted in 2010 of plotting to bomb Times Square. He was given a miranda warning after being questioned for a short time and he continued to speak to authorities. Both men were sentenced to life in prison.

The government has successfully prosecuted more than 300 terrorism-related cases since September 11, 2001, but some lawmakers continue to insist that the civilian justice system is not an appropriate venue for such cases. In a statement released Friday night, Sen. Lindsey Graham, the South Carolina Republican and Arizona Senator John McCain suggested that Obama should consider abandoning civil proceedings in Tsarnaev’s case. “Now that the suspect is in custody, the last thing we should want is for him to remain silent.” The statement continued, “Under the Law of War we can hold this suspect as a potential enemy combatant not entitled to Miranda warnings or the appointment of counsel.”

Graham and McCain have led their party’s opposing to closing the detainee prison at Guantanamo Bay Cuba, where 166 men _ many picked up in Afghanistan and elsewhere a decade agao _ continue to languish, almost all without charge. Obama pledged on his first day as president that he would close the facility and use civilian courts to try the men accused of orchestrating al-Qaeda’s attacks on the United States on Sept. 11, 2001. But those efforts were successfully blocked by Congress.

Obama has however refused to send any more men to the facility. Individuals such as Shazad, Abdulmutallab and others captured overseas, including Osama bin Laden’s son-in-law, have all appeared in Federal Court.

Late Friday, Obama seemed already prepared for a renewed debate on the issue now that a suspect is in custody in the Boston attacks.   ”When a tragedy like this happens, with public safety at risk and the stakes so high, it’s important that we do this right,” he told Americans. ” That’s why we have investigations.  That’s why we relentlessly gather the facts.  That’s why we have courts.”

Because the government and prosecutors are the arbiters of what qualifies as “government interest” and an “ imminent threat to public safety, ” this case could raise significant civil liberties issues in the future if this application of the exception holds up in court. The Obama administrtaion’s policy on the public safety exception to Miranda has long upset civil rights groups who see it as a major infringment on an important legal protection.  The American Civil Liberties Union called miranda  “a constitutional rule, not an interrogation policy,” in a 2010 statement and has continue to oppose the loose application of the public safety rule since then.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Human Frontier Mission Puts AI Research on Display

Updated Category News Views 330

A laboratory notebook is about to become the real product in this AI experiment. Human Frontier Mission, or HFM, says it will launch globally on Nov. 24, opening a research program where domain specialists frame scientific and engineering problems while autonomous AI agents develop and test possible answers. The unusual bit is not merely handing models difficult work. It...

Continue Reading
Fractional CIOs Bring Order to Growing Technology Chaos

Updated Category News Views 225

A company can outgrow its technology habits long before anyone notices the smoke. One day the owner is approving another software subscription, the office manager is chasing an internet provider, and the tech person is putting out password fires. None of that looks dramatic in isolation. Together, it is a business operating without a map. That is the useful point in the...

Continue Reading
3TREES Tests a Bigger Asia-Pacific Growth Blueprint

Updated Category News Views 350

A bucket of paint rarely sounds strategic until it sits inside a regional supply chain. That is the useful part of 3TREES chairman and president Hong Jie's message from the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation CEO Summit in Shenzhen on November 17-18, 2026: coatings are not merely a commodity if the supplier can bring materials, energy savings, technical know-how and...

Continue Reading
DataBeyond Puts AI Sorting Before a Waste Mountain

Updated Category News Views 191

Trash is a lousy place to look for technological glamour, which is precisely why DataBeyond's COP31 appearance deserves a sober look. On November 19 in Antalya, Türkiye, the Hangzhou-based equipment provider used a China Pavilion event to lay out its case for AI, optical sensing and robots in resource recovery. That is not a magic-green headline. It is a practical...

Continue Reading
PHONO's 150 MW RE+ Win Tests Its U.S. Solar Staying Power

Updated Category News Views 534

A trade-show order book is not cash in the bank, but 150 MW is still a number worth circling in red. PHONO used RE+ 2026 in Las Vegas, held November 17 through 19, to celebrate 20 years in business, parade its solar and storage lineup, and announce new U.S. orders. In a solar market that has become touchier about provenance, compliance and delivered economics, the company...

Continue Reading
UAE Trust Model Faces Its Hardest Test During Crisis

Updated Category News Views 321

A country’s reputation is usually invisible right up until the machinery rattles. Then people, investors, trading partners and residents stop listening to polished slogans and start watching whether airports function, services hold up, information arrives, and business can keep moving. That was the useful core of Saeed Al Eter’s remarks at Ajman Media Forum 2026: soft...

Continue Reading
D-Wave Investors Face a December 15 Lead Plaintiff Clock

Updated Category News Views 479

August Put the Story Under a Harsh Light Two ugly August trading sessions are doing a lot of work in the case now confronting D-Wave Quantum. The company sits in a field that attracts big dreams, big headlines, and, frankly, plenty of investor imagination. But imagination does not cushion a portfolio when expectations crack. The lawsuits concern people who bought or...

Continue Reading
NatGasHub’s 391% Growth Signals a Real Pipeline Shift

Updated Category News Views 391

Three hundred-plus pipelines is a lot of messy plumbing to tame, and NatGasHub has apparently found a lucrative way to do it. The Houston software company landed at No. 182 on Deloitte’s 2026 Technology Fast 500 after reporting 391% revenue growth from 2022 through 2025. That is a serious number, even in a ranking built to showcase companies sprinting uphill. More...

Continue Reading
Mission Inn’s Lights Enter a Tender New Ownership Era

Updated Category News Views 527

A holiday spectacle can outlive the hands that hung its first bulb. Riverside is about to test that truth in public, under millions of tiny lights and the very large shadow of a family departure. The Mission Inn Festival of Lights returns in 2026 without Kelly and Duane Roberts as hotel owners for the first time in more than three decades. Duane Roberts died in 2025, the...

Continue Reading
Fluence Investors Face a November 27 Litigation Clock

Updated Category News Views 342

Six calendar squares are all that separate eligible Fluence investors from the November 27, 2026 lead-plaintiff deadline. That is not much time to locate trade confirmations, calculate losses, and decide whether taking a larger role in a securities case makes sense. The lawsuit is not a verdict, and anybody pretending otherwise is selling smoke. But the underlying...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Embrace Pet Insurance Breaks Records in Volunteerism and Giving

Updated Category News Views 317

Embrace Pet Insurance Partners in Charity and Volunteerism Despite facing economic hurdles, charitable contributions across the nation showed remarkable resilience, highlighting the generosity of individuals and businesses alike. Recent reports reveal that charitable donations in the U.S. hit staggering heights, exceeding $557 billion in the last reporting year. Embrace...

Continue Reading
Sony's Innovative OLED Microdisplay Sets New Industry Standards

Updated Category News Views 210

Exploring Sony's Innovative OLED Technology Sony Semiconductor Solutions Corporation is about to change the landscape of augmented reality (AR) with the introduction of its groundbreaking ECX350F. This 0.44-type Full HD OLED Microdisplay is remarkable for its unique features, including the smallest pixel size in the industry and outstanding brightness. This innovation...

Continue Reading
Bascom Palmer Eye Institute Claims Top Spot in Medical Rankings

Updated Category News Views 269

Bascom Palmer Eye Institute's Unrivaled Recognition in 2025 For an impressive 24th consecutive year, Bascom Palmer Eye Institute has been honored as the premier ophthalmology hospital in the United States. This prestigious recognition, detailed in the 2025 U.S. News & World Report "Best Hospitals" rankings, underscores the institute's unwavering commitment to providing...

Continue Reading
Insights on Unusual Options Activity for Alphabet Inc.

Updated Category News Views 269

Unusual Options Activity Analysis for Alphabet Inc. Recent trends indicate that prominent financial players are adopting a bearish stance on Alphabet Inc. Our thorough analysis of options history for Alphabet (GOOGL) highlights 20 unusual trades, emphasizing a notable shift in market sentiment. Understanding Trader Sentiment Upon delving into the trade specifics, our...

Continue Reading
A Critical Juncture for uniQure Amidst Regulatory Challenges

Updated Category News Views 191

uniQure's Recent FDA Feedback The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently provided important insights to uniQure N.V. (NASDAQ: QURE) about its proposed gene therapy for Huntington’s disease. This feedback has led to a noticeable drop in the company’s stock price, reflecting heightened investor concern. Understanding AMT-130 AMT-130 is uniQure’s...

Continue Reading