Gonna be a hard read for ya'll. Paradoxically, the worse

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Bhawks SaltyMutt #116015
181
Gonna be a hard read for ya'll.

Paradoxically, the worse things get, the more it increases despondency, disillusionment, and resentment—the three attributes Republican politicians most effectively mine to maintain their support in rural America.

Rather than offering an agenda for rural development, Republican politicians simply ladle out more steaming hot bowls of resentment and targets for rural anger, be they urban-dwelling liberals, undocumented immigrants, trans kids, beer companies, or the “fake news” media.


White Rural Trump Supporters Are a Threat to Democracy

DEAL WITH IT

A new book shows how many supposed “elitist stereotypes” of rural MAGA voters are true—and backed by hard data.


Michael A. Cohen
Published Mar. 01, 2024 11:08 PM EST
https://www.thedailybeast.com/white-rural-tru...y?ref=home


OPINIONIllustration of a person in a MAGA hat with a pitchfork impaling an eagle
Photo Illustration by Luis G. Rendon/The Daily Beast/Getty

In the popular imagination of many Americans, particularly those on the left side of the political spectrum, the typical MAGA supporter is a rural resident who hates Black and Brown people, loathes liberals, loves gods and guns, believes in myriad conspiracy theories, has little faith in democracy, and is willing to use violence to achieve their goals, as thousands did on Jan. 6.

According to a new book, White Rural Rage: The Threat to American Democracy, these aren’t hurtful, elitist stereotypes by Acela Corridor denizens and bubble-dwelling liberals…they’re facts.

The authors, Tom Schaller, a professor at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, and Paul Waldman, a former columnist at The Washington Post, persuasively argue that most of the negative stereotypes liberals hold about rural Americans are actually true.

They do not mince words about what this means for the future of democracy in America. “Rural voters—especially the White rural voters on whom Donald Trump heaps praise and upon which he built his Make America Great Movement —pose a growing threat to the world’s oldest constitutional democracy.”

And Schaller and Waldman bring receipts.


In a book filled with reams of data to back up their arguments, Schaller and Waldman show that rural Whites “are the demographic group least likely to accept notions of pluralism and inclusion” and are far less likely to believe that diversity makes America stronger.

In rural America, support for Donald Trump’s Muslim travel ban ran 15 points higher than in urban areas. Rural Whites are 13 points more likely to view LGBTQ+ Americans in a negative light, and express fear and anger toward immigrants—both legal and undocumented—at much higher rates than other Americans. Less than half, 46 percent, say diversity in their communities is something they value.

They are the largest segment of the population that incorrectly believes Trump won the 2020 election, at 47 percent. By contrast, only 30 percent of suburban residents and 22 percent of urban dwellers feel the same.

“...rural Americans are more likely to believe that ‘it may be necessary at some point soon for citizens to take up arms against the government.’ Indeed, more than one out of four rural residents agree that Trump should be returned to office by force if necessary.”

Rural Whites are more skeptical of the vaccines to prevent COVID-19, and are more likely to think Barack Obama was not born in the United States. In a survey done in 2009 in North Carolina and Virginia, rural Republicans were 20 percentage points more likely to believe in birtherism than non-rural GOP members. Rural residents are also 1.5 times more inclined to embrace the QAnon conspiracy theory than those who live in urban areas.

But the problems in rural America run deeper than hostility toward minorities and facts. Rural residents disproportionately express hostility toward basic democratic principles. They are more likely to favor restrictions on the press, oppose checks on presidential power, endorse White Christian Nationalist views, and support efforts to restrict voting access.

Finally, rural Americans are more likely to believe that “it may be necessary at some point soon for citizens to take up arms against the government.” Indeed, more than one out of four rural residents agree that Trump should be returned to office by force if necessary. As Schaller and Waldman argue, not all citizens with anti-government views live in rural America, but “rural Americans are overrepresented among those with insurrectionist tendencies.”

After reading this tale of woe, one might shake their head at the state or rural White politics but also wonder about Schaller and Waldman’s claim that such a small segment of the population has “more power than any other large demographic group in America.” After all, rural Americans are 20 percent of the U.S. population—rural Whites are only 15 percent. The other five percent are non-white, a group that the authors ruefully point out is seldom acknowledged in political conversations.

Their power is a by-product of America’s political system, which grants disproportionate power to sparsely populated states. In the Senate, for example, California and Wyoming have two representatives, even though Los Angeles County—with its 10 million residents—has a population that is 17 times larger. Indeed, L.A. County—which is home to just a quarter of California’s residents—also has a larger population than 40 American states.

In partisan terms, Senate Democrats, who currently hold 51 seats in the Senate, represent approximately 193 million people Senate Republicans hold only two fewer seats, yet they represent 140 million people.

Things are just as bad in the Electoral College. Wyoming has 18 fewer electoral votes than California, even though California has a population that is 68 times larger. Since Republicans are so disproportionately reliant on states with large rural populations, they are far more attuned to their interests than would be the case in a political system where rural areas didn’t have such built-in influence.

One might assume that such political influence would translate into tangible benefits. But as Schaller and Waldman note, the opposite is true.


Rural America is in deep economic and social decay, “defined by declining wages, rising unemployment, persistent poverty, and increased government dependency.”

Rural populations are aging as younger generations flee areas with few economic opportunities and increasingly blinkered worldviews. Those who remain in rural areas live shorter lives, have limited access to health care, and on any host of health metrics—from maternal mortality to deaths caused by drug overdoses—have a rate higher than any other geographic group.

Indeed, opposition to Obamacare was perhaps stronger in rural America than in any region of the country, even though no area was more likely to benefit from the legislation. (The Affordable Care Act reduced lack of healthcare access in rural America from 24 to 16 percent.)

In short, rural America has made one of the worst deals in American politics—they slavishly support a Republican Party that not only does little to stop their inexorable decline but actually makes it worse.

The GOP’s anti-abortion agenda means rural maternity wards got shut down. Opposition to public broadband most directly harms rural America, where there is little incentive for private companies to set up service. Republican attacks on higher education have a disproportionate influence on underserved rural universities. And anti-vax attitudes have led to COVID death rates that rival or surpass far denser population areas—an outcome that makes little public health sense but is easily explained by partisan politics.

Yet, none of this has stopped rural Americans from casting votes for Republican politicians. If anything, their support for the GOP has intensified as Trump has taken control of the party. In 2016, 62 percent of rural America voted for Trump. In 2020, it jumped to 71 percent.

Paradoxically, the worse things get, the more it increases despondency, disillusionment, and resentment—the three attributes Republican politicians most effectively mine to maintain their support in rural America.

Rather than offering an agenda for rural development, Republican politicians simply ladle out more steaming hot bowls of resentment and targets for rural anger, be they urban-dwelling liberals, undocumented immigrants, trans kids, beer companies, or the “fake news” media.

And rural MAGA laps it up.

Do Schaller and Waldman have a solution for this sad state of affairs?

I asked this to Schaller (who, in the interests of full disclosure, is an old friend), and he turned my question around. Why, he asked, is it the responsibility of liberals to solve these problems? The expectation that he and Waldman should have a solution to the ills of rural America is, he argued, part of the problem.

These answers can’t come from well-meaning Democrats and liberals; they need to originate from rural America itself. Until rural Americans demand more from their elected leaders, i.e., Republicans, their plight will only get worse.

In Schaller’s view, this doesn’t necessarily mean electing Democrats—but, rather, better Republicans. “If you’re not going to be an advocate for your own material needs,” says Schaller, “then you can’t expect others to do it for you.”

But, as Schaller notes, rural influence is not a constant. Rural populations will continue to wane, and as that happens, their power will decline, too.

The choice for rural America is to demand more or decline further. In the meantime, their problems will only get worse, and the threat to American democracy will remain with us.
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

SanMar’s Lott Tops Promo Products Power 50 Again in 2026

Updated Category News Views 89

Branded hoodies and logo tumblers rarely make Wall Street’s pulse race, but the numbers behind them deserve a hard look. Jeremy Lott, president and CEO of SanMar, was named the most influential leader in the U.S. promotional-products business for the second consecutive year, taking No. 1 in the 2026 Counselor Power 50 ranking. Awards can be fluff. A repeat win beside...

Continue Reading
Palm Beach Loan Company Tests Luxury Lending Demand

Updated Category News Views 57

Jewelry in a safe is dead capital until somebody lends against it. That plain fact sits behind Luxury Asset Capital's latest move: the launch of Palm Beach Loan Company, a South Florida brand aimed at wealthy owners of watches, diamonds, art, handbags, gold, collectibles, and other high-value possessions. The company is not asking clients to sell the stuff they spent...

Continue Reading
AI Echo Study Sharpens a Difficult HFpEF Diagnosis

Updated Category News Views 71

A single echo clip may be doing more useful work than plenty of flashy healthcare AI demos. The November 2026 Journal of Cardiac Failure focus issue puts a hard number on that possibility: pairing an AI read of a routine echocardiogram clip with the H?FPEF clinical score identified 78% of patients with hemodynamically confirmed HFpEF, versus 48% with the score alone. That...

Continue Reading
Universal Haptics Protocol May Cut Integration Friction

Updated Category News Views 291

A controller rumbling at the wrong moment is a small annoyance, but the plumbing behind that rumble has been a stubborn mess for years. The Haptics Industry Forum's Universal Haptics Protocol 1.0, announced November 17, 2026, is an attempt to clean up that mess with a shared language between software and touch-feedback hardware. This is not the sort of release that sends...

Continue Reading
Auria, LSAS Team Up: Japan Space Frontier Beckons

Updated Category News Views 93

Pioneering Ventures in Japan's Space Race Watch out, folks—Auria and LSAS Tec have something cooking. One's a titan in space technology, and the other's a maestro in mission analysis. They're joining forces to tango in Japan's booming space market. If you're into the street-smart equity dance, this partnership ain't just chatter over coffee; it's a leap toward new...

Continue Reading
Triple Crossing Tests a Tough Inland Marine Market

Updated Category News Views 105

Inland marine is where tidy insurance appetites go to get bent out of shape. A contractor’s rented machine, cargo moving between points, a half-finished building, or equipment that is neither parked forever nor easy to classify can turn a standard quote into a week of broker phone calls. Triple Crossing Specialty is stepping directly into that mess, launching a new...

Continue Reading
Midea's Cooling Systems Take Center Stage at DCW ME

Updated Category News Views 64

AI Surge Demands Cooler Solutions Alright, who'd guess that data centers would feel the heat—literally—like a welder's furnace in Abu Dhabi? As AI demand burns hotter across the Middle East, data centers are sweating it out against 50°C-plus temperatures. We're talking about some serious pressure on traditional cooling methods that just can’t cut it anymore....

Continue Reading
Knotch Bets Brands Need Answers, Not More Web Pages

Updated Category News Views 147

Pages are starting to look like expensive filing cabinets A website that cannot answer an agent may soon be expensive wallpaper. That is the blunt premise behind Knotch's Ace for Agents, launched Nov. 17, 2026, and frankly it lands because plenty of big companies have spent years piling pages atop pages until nobody can tell which claim is current. Knotch is pitching an...

Continue Reading
DEFSEC Tackles Nasdaq Bid Price Hurdle with Share Move

Updated Category News Views 25

Navigating Bid Price Deficiency Issues Well, it seems DEFSEC Technologies Inc. found themselves in a tricky spot last week. A nasty gram from Nasdaq’s Listing Qualifications Department pointing out that DEFSEC's shares had dipped below that $1.00 per share requirement for too long—a full 30 business days. Now, don't panic just yet. This isn't about the shares getting...

Continue Reading
Onward Therapeutics Secures $28M to Bolster Oncology R&D

Updated Category News Views 76

Cashing In to Conquer Cancer In the risk-laden world of biotech, Onward Therapeutics has just bagged a hefty NT$900 million—roughly US$28 million—from its Series B financing. That's not pocket change and speaks to the level of confidence their backers have, even as they plant their global headquarters firmly in Taipei since relocating from Switzerland. A Deep Dive...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Surge in Gold Prices Reflects Political and Economic Tensions

Updated Category News Views 283

Gold Prices Reach New Heights Amid Political Turmoil Gold prices have reached unprecedented levels recently, reflecting a surge in safe-haven demand driven by rising political uncertainties in key regions like the U.S. and Japan. As concerns about potential economic instability grow, this precious metal has emerged as a popular choice for investors looking to protect...

Continue Reading
BlackSky Secures Navy Contract to Enhance Satellite Imaging

Updated Category News Views 222

Alright, here’s the scoop: BlackSky Technology Inc. just bagged a major contract with the U.S. Navy, and it’s all about beefing up their Gen-3 imaging satellites. Now, why does this matter? This initiative is a piece of the broader Project Overmatch—a military strategy designed to supercharge the Joint All Domain Command and Control (JADC2) mission. What’s at...

Continue Reading
Discover the Innovative FINGER GRIP for Enhanced Sports Performance

Updated Category News Views 217

Enhancing Sports with the Innovative FINGER GRIP In the dynamic world of sports, having the right equipment can make all the difference. An inventive mind from Pittsburgh has introduced an innovative product, the FINGER GRIP, aimed at elevating performance in games like pickleball and tennis. This new grip is revolutionizing how athletes interact with their paddles and...

Continue Reading
Updated Voting Shares of AB Volvo: Significant Changes

Updated Category News Views 215

Changes in AB Volvo's Voting Shares AB Volvo has recently undergone an important transformation affecting its voting shares. The conversion of 175,000 Series A shares into Series B shares is a key development for the company. This conversion stems from a provision accepted at the 2011 Annual General Meeting, allowing Series A shareholders to switch their shares to Series...

Continue Reading
Warner Bros. Discovery's Q4: Strong Revenue Growth & Future Plans

Updated Category News Views 324

Warner Bros. Discovery Reports Impressive Q4 Results In a recent financial assessment, Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc (NASDAQ: WBD) unveiled its latest quarterly performance, showcasing a fiscal fourth-quarter revenue of $10.03 billion. Although this represented a slight 1% ex-FX decline compared to the previous year, it was just shy of analysts' expectations of $10.19...

Continue Reading