The Deep Roots of Republican Dysfunction AKA, Whence So

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Bhawks Goodspeed65 #111713
173
The Deep Roots of Republican Dysfunction

AKA, Whence So Many Shit-Heels

Oct. 20, 2023


A looming shadow in a entryway in the Capitol in Washington.
Credit...Mark Peterson/Redux, for The New York Times

By Jamelle Bouie
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/20/opinion/ho...reene.html

The collapse of the House Republican majority into chaos is the clearest possible evidence that the party is off the rails.

Of course, the Republican Party has been off the rails for a while before now. This was true in 2010, when Tea Party extremists swept through the party’s ranks, defeating more moderate Republicans — and pretty much any other Republican with an interest in the actual work of government — and establishing a beachhead for radical obstructionism. It was true in 2012 , when many Republican voters went wild for the likes of Michele Bachmann, Herman Cain and Newt Gingrich in the party’s presidential primary, before settling on the more conventionally presidential Mitt Romney. But even then, Romney reached out to Donald Trump — famous, politically speaking, for his “birther” crusade against President Barack Obama — for his blessing, yet another sign that the Republican Party was not on track.

The truth of the Republican Party’s deep dysfunction was obvious in 2013, when congressional Republicans shut down the government in a quixotic drive to repeal the Affordable Care Act, and it was obvious in 2016, when Republican voters nominated Trump for president. Everything that has followed, from the rise of influencer-extremist politicians like Representative Lauren Boebert to the party’s complicity in insurrectionist violence, has been a steady escalation from one transgression to another.

The Republican Party is so broken that at this point, its congressional wing cannot function. The result is that this period is now the longest the House of Representatives has been in session without a speaker. And as Republican voters gear up to nominate Trump a third time for president, the rest of the party is not far behind. The only question to ask, and answer, is why.

One popular answer is Donald Trump who, in this view, is directly responsible for the downward spiral of dysfunction and deviancy that defines today’s Republican Party. It’s his success as a demagogue and showman that set the stage for the worst of the behavior we’ve seen from elected Republicans.

The problem, as I’ve already noted, is that most of what we identify as Republican dysfunction was already evident in the years before Trump came on the scene as a major figure in conservative politics. Even Trump’s contempt for the legitimacy of his political opponents, to the point of rejecting the outcome of a free and fair election, has clear antecedents in conservative agitation over so-called voter fraud, including efforts to raise barriers to voting for rival constituencies.

Another popular answer is that we’re seeing the fruits of polarization in American political life. And it is true that within both parties, there’s been a marked and meaningful move away from the center and toward each side’s respective flank. But while the Democratic Party is, in many respects, more liberal than it has ever been, it’s also not nearly as ideologically uniform as the Republican Party. Nor does a rigid, doctrinaire liberalism serve as a litmus test among Democratic voters in Democratic Party primaries outside of a small handful of congressional districts.

Joe Biden, for example, is the paradigmatic moderate Democrat and, currently, the president of the United States and leader of the Democratic Party, with ample support across the party establishment. And in Congress, there’s no liberal equivalent to the House Freedom Caucus: no group of nihilistic, obstruction-minded left-wing lawmakers. When Democrats were in the majority, the Congressional Progressive Caucus was a reliable partner of President Biden’s and a constructive force in the making of legislation. If the issue is polarization, then it seems to be driving only one of our two parties toward the abyss.

Helpfully, the extent to which the Democratic Party still operates as a normal American political party can shed light on how and why the Republican Party doesn’t. Take the overall strength of Democratic moderates, who hold the levers of power within the national party. One important reason for this fact is the heterogeneity of the Democratic coalition. To piece together a majority in the Electoral College, or to gain control of the House or Senate, Democrats have to win or make inroads with a cross-section of the American public: young people, affluent suburbanites, Black, Hispanic and Asian Americans voters, as well as a sizable percentage of the white working class. To lose ground with any one of these groups is to risk defeat, whether it’s in the race for president or an off-year election for governor.

A broad coalition also means a broad set of interests and demands, some of which are in tension with one another. This has at least two major implications for the internal workings of the Democratic Party. First, it makes for a kind of brokerage politics in which the most powerful Democratic politicians are often those who can best appeal to and manage the various groups and interests that make up the Democratic coalition. And second, it gives the Democratic Party a certain amount of self-regulation. Move too far in the direction of one group or one interest, and you may lose support among the others.

If you take the internal dynamics of the Democratic Party and invert them, you get something like those within the Republican Party.

Consider the demographics of the Republican coalition. A majority of all voters in both parties are white Americans. But where the Democratic Party electorate was 61 percent white in the 2020 presidential election, the Republican one was 86 percent, according to the Pew Research Center. Similarly, there is much less religious diversity among Republicans — more than a third of Republicans voters in 2020 were white evangelical Protestants — than there is among Democrats. And while we tend to think of Democrats as entirely urban and suburban, the proportion of rural voters in the Democratic Party as a whole is actually greater than the proportion of urban voters in the Republican Party. There is, in other words, less geographic diversity among Republicans as well.

Most important, where nearly half of Democrats identify themselves as either “moderate” or “conservative” — compared with the half that call themselves “liberal” — nearly three-quarters of Republicans identify themselves as “conservative,” with just a handful of self-proclaimed moderates and a smattering of liberals, according to Gallup.

This wasn’t always true. In 1994, around 33 percent of Republicans called themselves “moderate” and 58 percent said they were “conservative.” There were even, at 8 percent, a few Republican liberals. Now the Republican Party is almost uniformly conservative. Moderate Democrats can still win national office or hold national leadership. Moderate Republicans cannot. Outside a handful of environments, found in largely Democratic states like Maryland and Massachusetts, moderate Republican politicians are virtually extinct.

But more than the number of conservatives is the character of the conservatism that dominates the Republican Party. It is, thanks to a set of social and political transformations dating back to the 1960s, a highly ideological and at times reactionary conservatism, with little tolerance for disagreement or dissent. The Democratic Party is a broad coalition geared toward a set of policies — aimed at either regulating or tempering the capitalist economy or promoting the inclusion of various groups in national life. The Republican Party exists almost entirely for the promotion of a distinct and doctrinaire ideology of hierarchy and anti-government retrenchment.

There have always been ideological movements within American political parties. The Republican Party was formed, in part, by adherents to one of the most important ideological movements of the 19th century — antislavery. But, as the historian Geoffrey Kabaservice has observed, “The conversion of one of America’s two major parties into an ideological vehicle” is a “phenomenon without precedent in American history.”

It is the absence of any other aim but the promotion of conservative ideology — by any means necessary, up to and including the destruction of democratic institutions and the imposition of minority rule — that makes this particular permutation of the Republican Party unique.

It helps explain, in turn, the dysfunction of the past decade. If the goal is to promote conservative ideology, then what matters for Republican politicians is how well they adhere to and promote conservatism. The key issue for conservative voters and conservative media isn’t whether a Republican politician can pass legislation or manage a government or bridge political divides; the key question is whether a Republican politician is sufficiently committed to the ideology, whatever that means in the moment. And if conservatism means aggrieving your enemies, then the obvious choice for the nation’s highest office is the man who hates the most, regardless of what he believes.

The demographic homogeneity of the Republican Party means that there isn’t much internal pushback to this ideological crusade — nothing to temper the instincts of politicians who would rather shut down the government than accept that a majority of Congress passed a law over their objections, or who would threaten the global economy to get spending cuts they could never win at the ballot box.

Worse, because the institutions of American democracy give a significant advantage to the current Republican coalition, there’s also no external force pushing Republican politicians away from their most rigid extremes. Just the opposite: There is a whole infrastructure of ideologically motivated money and media that works to push Republican voters and politicians farther to the right.

It is not simply that the Republican Party has politicians like Jim Jordan and Matt Gaetz and Marjorie Taylor Greene. It’s that the Republican Party is practically engineered to produce politicians like Jim Jordan and Matt Gaetz and Marjorie Taylor Greene. And there’s no brake — no emergency off-switch — that might slow or stop the car. The one thing that might get the Republican Party back on the rails is a major and unanticipated shift in the structure of American politics that forces it to adapt to new voters, new constituencies and new conditions.

It’s hard to imagine what that might be. It can’t come soon enough.
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Mike Blyth’s Hall of Fame Honors a Builder’s Legacy

Updated Category News Views 147

Recognition earned in the hangar, not a boardroom Aircraft design has a ruthless way of exposing empty talk, which is why Mike Blyth’s November 11 induction into the EAA Homebuilders Hall of Fame carries real weight. The Experimental Aircraft Association’s honor, presented in the Eagle Hangar at the EAA Aviation Museum in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, recognizes a career built...

Continue Reading
LASIK Cost Math Deserves a Careful Second Look Today

Updated Category News Views 114

Thirty years of lens purchases can become a nasty tab Contact-lens spending has a funny way of staying invisible until somebody stacks the receipts into one ugly pile. A new cost-of-vision analysis from the surgeon advisory board of BestLASIKSurgeons.com says the average American contact-lens wearer may spend between $22,500 and $30,000 on corrective eyewear across 30...

Continue Reading
SanMar’s Lott Tops Promo Products Power 50 Again in 2026

Updated Category News Views 102

Branded hoodies and logo tumblers rarely make Wall Street’s pulse race, but the numbers behind them deserve a hard look. Jeremy Lott, president and CEO of SanMar, was named the most influential leader in the U.S. promotional-products business for the second consecutive year, taking No. 1 in the 2026 Counselor Power 50 ranking. Awards can be fluff. A repeat win beside...

Continue Reading
Onward Therapeutics Secures $28M to Bolster Oncology R&D

Updated Category News Views 76

Cashing In to Conquer Cancer In the risk-laden world of biotech, Onward Therapeutics has just bagged a hefty NT$900 million—roughly US$28 million—from its Series B financing. That's not pocket change and speaks to the level of confidence their backers have, even as they plant their global headquarters firmly in Taipei since relocating from Switzerland. A Deep Dive...

Continue Reading
Docusign Pushes Contract Data Into ChatGPT Sales Tools

Updated Category News Views 179

Contracts are where sales momentum goes to get lost, buried under old PDFs, approval chains, and somebody’s half-finished CRM note. Docusign’s November 17, 2026 launch is a sensible attempt to drag that information into the place sellers may increasingly spend their working day: ChatGPT for Sales. The company’s new plugin lets a sales rep pull agreement intelligence...

Continue Reading
MacDill Mold Case Puts Privatized Housing on Notice

Updated Category News Views 38

Four hundred fifty-four people are a hard number to shrug off. The expanded civil case over alleged toxic mold conditions at MacDill Air Force Base now covers 105 military families, up from 39 households when it was filed in September 2025. Their complaint against The Michaels Organization and affiliated entities may be the largest known military-housing lawsuit in the...

Continue Reading
Toledo Crosswalk Death Lawsuit Raises Hard Questions

Updated Category News Views 237

A painted crosswalk is supposed to mean something, and that is the grim center of the lawsuit filed over Judy Tanner’s death in Toledo. Tanner, 20, was walking home from work on September 10, 2026, when she was struck and killed while crossing the street. Her estate is now suing, alleging that the 31-year-old driver failed to yield as Tanner legally used the crosswalk....

Continue Reading
Concierto's Azure Push Puts Sovereignty on Display

Updated Category News Views 78

Sovereignty has become the corporate cloud world's favorite hard-edged word. Concierto is taking that word straight onto the Microsoft Ignite 2026 floor, and frankly, it is a sensible place to make the case. The company, part of Trianz, will appear as a Gamechanger Sponsor from November 17 through 20 at San Francisco's Moscone Center, showing its platform at Booth #5435....

Continue Reading
Max y Noelia Explore Trade at 9th CIIE in Shanghai

Updated Category News Views 60

Influencers at the Heart of Global Trade Exploration Makin' their debut on the big stage of the 9th China International Import Expo (CIIE), Mexican influencers Max y Noelia found themselves caught in a whirlwind of trade and cultural exchanges over in Shanghai. These digital mavens aren't just snapping selfies. Nope, they're capturing the very essence of international...

Continue Reading
Red Cat Stock Drama: Revenue Targets and Legal Waves

Updated Category News Views 110

Red Cat's Revenue Predictions Crash and Burn Sitting there on August 6, 2026, Red Cat Holdings had everyone believing they were on a fast track to hitting a hefty revenue target: $150–$180 million for FY2026. CEO Jeffrey Thompson didn't mince words, boasting confidence like a captain before a storm. Fast forward three months, and they're waving the white flag, tossing...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

GroupBy and adCAPTCHA: A New Era for eCommerce Security

Updated Category News Views 110

Strengthening eCommerce with Cutting-Edge Technology GroupBy Inc., a pioneering SaaS provider in eCommerce search and product discovery, recently announced a vital partnership with adCAPTCHA, a state-of-the-art security verification platform. This collaboration focuses on enhancing digital customer experiences while ensuring robust security measures are in place. The...

Continue Reading
Frost & Sullivan Boosts China Insight with LeadLeo

Updated Category News Views 90

Navigating China's Complex Market Landscape You've got to understand, the stakes in China are like a high-wire act—mystifying and risky, yet bountiful if you play your cards right. Frost & Sullivan's latest maneuver into China's business intel scene is basically the lifeline for navigating this increasingly convoluted market. With China surging ahead in AI, biotech, and...

Continue Reading
Important Update for MoonLake Immunotherapeutics Investors

Updated Category News Views 171

Update for MoonLake Immunotherapeutics Investors Investors in MoonLake Immunotherapeutics, known by its stock symbol MLTX, should pay attention to an important class action development that impacts their rights. It is crucial for individuals who purchased common stock during a designated time frame to understand their options and the benefits of securing legal...

Continue Reading
Upcoming Changes to the Issuing and Paying Agent at WisdomTree

Updated Category News Views 228

WisdomTree Multi Asset Issuer Public Limited Company, based in Ireland, made waves back in 2024 when it decided to switch up its Issuing and Paying Agent as part of an overhaul to improve its operations. Apex IFS Limited had been holding that title, but as the filing revealed, WisdomTree was ready for a change—a transition to Apex Fund Services (Ireland) Limited was on...

Continue Reading
Foxconn India Strengthens Manufacturing with Key Equipment Buy

Updated Category News Views 156

Foxconn India Makes a Strategic Equipment Acquisition Foxconn, a subsidiary of Hon Hai Precision Industry Co., Ltd., has made significant strides in enhancing its manufacturing capabilities in India. The company has successfully completed a notable acquisition of essential electromechanical equipment from CINDA ENGINEERING AND CONSTRUCTION PRIVATE LIMITED. This strategic...

Continue Reading