The real story behind that photo of a weirdly unscathed

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board
Steel Reserve
322
The real story behind that photo of a weirdly unscathed house in the rubble of Lahaina

Fri, August 18, 2023



The image has gone viral: The house, with its crisp white facade and cheerful red roof, appears untouched. Surrounding it are piles of scorched rubble left behind by the fast-moving fire that decimated Lahaina last week.

The historic Front Street home was not the only property to survive the fire. Entire subdivisions were spared as flames leapfrogged across the island. But the indelible image of the improbably unscathed house amid a backdrop of devastation is so extreme that some have questioned whether the image was digitally altered.

The situation is all too real, said Dora Atwater Millikin, who owns the house with her husband.

“We lost neighbors in this, and neighbors lost everything,” Atwater Millikin told The Times.

But their home remains, she confirmed. She’s still mulling over why.

The couple, who was visiting family in Massachusetts when the fire started, had recently renovated the home, but not with the express goal of hardening it against flames. The 100-year-old property was once a bookkeeper’s house for employees of the Pioneer Mill Co., a sugar plantation that operated in Lahaina beginning in the mid-1800s, and the homeowners were seeking to restore some of the structure’s original features, she said.

“It’s a 100% wood house so it’s not like we fireproofed it or anything,” Atwater Millikin said.

Working closely with the county and the local historic commission, they replaced the asphalt roof with heavy-gauge metal — the home would have originally had a roof of either wooden shake or thinner-grade corrugated tin, she said. They lined the ground with stones up to the drip line of the roof, which overhangs by 36 to 40 inches.

And they removed foliage that was up against the house — not because they were trying to reduce the risk of ignition, but because they were concerned about termites spreading to the wooden frame, she said. Their only nod toward disaster preparedness was to install hurricane ties, she added.

“We love old buildings, so we just wanted to honor the building,” she said. “And we didn’t change the building in any way — we just restored it.”

It appears these modifications had the effect, however unintended, of making the home more resilient to flames.

“When this was all happening, there were pieces of wood — 6, 12 inches long — that were on fire and just almost floating through the air with the wind and everything,” Atwater Millikin said. “They would hit people’s roofs, and if it was an asphalt roof, it would catch on fire. And otherwise, they would fall off the roof and then ignite the foliage around the house.”

Roofs are the No. 1 factor that contribute to the flammability of a home because they can serve as large landing pads for embers, said Susie Kocher, forestry advisor for the University of California Cooperative Extension, who co-authored a guide on how to harden homes against wildfire. In this case, a regular asphalt composition roof would likely have done just as good a job as metal, as most have a Class A fire resistance rating, she added.

That’s followed by the “near home environment” — the area immediately surrounding the structure, she said. Experts suggest that homeowners clear flammable vegetation in a 5-foot radius and replace it with a hardscape feature such as paving stones or gravel — similar to what the Millikins did, she said.

“If shrubs and bushes, especially flammable ones, are right up next to the house and embers catch them on fire, the heat can burst the window and it goes right into the home from there,” she said.

The home may also have benefited from the fact that it was not that close to neighboring properties, she said, pointing out that it was bordered on three sides by the ocean, a road and a park-like empty lot, respectively.

“One of the biggest sources of fuel is the homes,” she said. “So when one home goes up, if another is very close, the radiant heat can catch the other house.”

That risk is highest when the other building that burns is 30 feet away or less, said Stephen Quarles, UC Cooperative Extension advisor emeritus. Vulnerable components would be the siding, windows or under-eave area, as well as any foundation or attic vents, he added.

It appears that combustibles were largely removed from the under-deck area, and the ember exposure of the deck was lessened because it faces the ocean, he said.

"A 'noncombustible zone' near the home and under the deck is an excellent strategy to reduce the vulnerability of the home to a wind-blown ember exposure," Quarles wrote in an email.

Kocher worries that surreal images such as the one of the Lahaina house can lend themselves to conspiracy theories if people don’t understand the science behind how fires spread. She recalled when Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) speculated that the 2018 Camp fire, which killed 85 people when it destroyed the California town of Paradise, might have been started by a laser beam in space.

Already, some online commenters have suggested the survival of the Millikins' home was evidence that the fire was actually sparked by directed energy weapons or a massive solar flare.

“I think conspiracy theories can flourish when we don’t understand how things happen,” Kocher said.

But when wildfires ignite a neighborhood, it’s fairly common for some homes to remain standing while others burn, as wind drives embers into structures' vulnerable points or surrounding vegetation, and some houses are more resistant to embers than others, she said.

“People generally think that it’s a big wall of flames that is catching houses on fire, but often the mechanism is embers,” she said. “So embers are coming from the flaming front, which could be some distance away.”

Some have also speculated the home was saved by sprinklers, Atwater Millikin said. It did have a sprinkler system, but so did many of the other homes in the area that burned, she said. In any event, by the time the fire reached the home, the electricity was out and the system wasn’t working, she said.

Atwater Millikin is an artist who makes paintings of New England coastal scenery, and her husband is a recently retired portfolio manager. They have owned the home for about three years but lived elsewhere on Maui for about a decade, she said.

They first heard about the fire from a man who lives in Lahainaluna, a neighborhood about three and a half miles away, and uses two rooms beneath the house as a workshop. His home burned first, so he evacuated to the Millikins’. Then he had to evacuate from there, too, she said.

The county informed the couple that their house had survived in a phone call the following day, she said.

She hopes to return as soon as she can and open the place up for neighbors who have lost their homes.

“Many people have died,” she said. “So many people have lost everything, and we need to look out for each other and rebuild. Everybody needs to help rebuild.”

https://www.yahoo.com/news/real-story-behind-...28460.html

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Palm Beach Loan Company Tests Luxury Lending Demand

Updated Category News Views 44

Jewelry in a safe is dead capital until somebody lends against it. That plain fact sits behind Luxury Asset Capital's latest move: the launch of Palm Beach Loan Company, a South Florida brand aimed at wealthy owners of watches, diamonds, art, handbags, gold, collectibles, and other high-value possessions. The company is not asking clients to sell the stuff they spent...

Continue Reading
Red Cat Stock Drama: Revenue Targets and Legal Waves

Updated Category News Views 0

Red Cat's Revenue Predictions Crash and Burn Sitting there on August 6, 2026, Red Cat Holdings had everyone believing they were on a fast track to hitting a hefty revenue target: $150–$180 million for FY2026. CEO Jeffrey Thompson didn't mince words, boasting confidence like a captain before a storm. Fast forward three months, and they're waving the white flag, tossing...

Continue Reading
LA Auto Show 2026: Thrills, Games, and Cars Galore

Updated Category News Views 119

A Family Day Like No Other at the LA Auto Show Kicking into gear this November, the 2026 Los Angeles Auto Show puts the pedal to the metal for families seeking a full day of fun without breaking the bank. We're talking about 10 solid days where auto-mania meshes with interactive experiences, all nestled in the Los Angeles Convention Center. Whether you're a gearhead or a...

Continue Reading
Benicia's Bold Move to Streamline Permitting Pays Off

Updated Category News Views 25

Award-Winning Innovation from Benicia Benicia, California, shoots ahead of the pack by scooping up a highly coveted Helen Putnam Award for Excellence. Why? They chopped down bureaucracy like a lumberjack with a new ax by ushering in a digital revolution for their permitting process. Make no mistake, folks, this ain’t just a pat on the back—it's a blueprint for cities...

Continue Reading
AES Clears FERC, Nearing Its December 2 Takeover Close

Updated Category News Views 5

One more regulatory gate just swung open for AES, and this deal is finally staring at the finish line instead of wandering through the usual approval swamp. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has issued its final order approving AES's acquisition by a consortium led by Global Infrastructure Partners, part of BlackRock, and EQT Infrastructure VI. The last major...

Continue Reading
Avelo Tests Loyalty Math With WeSalute Fare Discounts

Updated Category News Views 81

Airline discounts can look like generosity until the load factor starts talking back. Avelo Airlines has joined WeSalute with fare discounts for active-duty military members, veterans, first responders, nurses, medical professionals, public servants, teachers and eligible family members. It is a sensible move for a young carrier built around smaller airports and lower...

Continue Reading
RBI Prices $1 Billion of Secured Notes Due 2031, 2036

Updated Category News Views 91

A billion dollars of fresh paper just landed on Restaurant Brands International’s balance-sheet doorstep, and this one deserves more than the usual sleepy glance at a financing release. RBI has priced $500 million of 6.00% senior secured notes due 2031 and another $500 million of 6.40% senior secured notes due 2036. The expected closing date is November 24, 2026,...

Continue Reading
Wall Street Gains Hold Amid Volatility Drop

Updated Category News Views 66

A Week of Gains and Regulatory Moves Right out of the gate, it’s been a decent stretch for Wall Street. Weekly gains kept the party going, even as traders navigated the usual hurdles. Stocks finished the week with a solid performance—all the heavy hitters like Dow, S&P 500, Nasdaq, and Russell 2000 ended on a high note, waltzing uphill past where many imagined...

Continue Reading
Toledo Crosswalk Death Lawsuit Raises Hard Questions

Updated Category News Views 154

A painted crosswalk is supposed to mean something, and that is the grim center of the lawsuit filed over Judy Tanner’s death in Toledo. Tanner, 20, was walking home from work on September 10, 2026, when she was struck and killed while crossing the street. Her estate is now suing, alleging that the 31-year-old driver failed to yield as Tanner legally used the crosswalk....

Continue Reading
Texas Community Bancshares Adds a Special Dividend

Updated Category News Views 82

Nine cents is the whole message—for the moment Texas Community Bancshares has put a little extra cash on the table, declaring a regular quarterly dividend of $0.06 per common share and a special cash dividend of $0.03 per share. Together, holders get $0.09 per share, payable on or about December 15, 2026, provided they are shareholders of record when business closes on...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Dr. Moumine Ballo: Trailblazer in Electronics and Graphics

Updated Category News Views 256

Acknowledging Dr. Moumine Ballo's Influence in Technology Dr. Moumine Ballo has recently been honored as a Pinnacle Professional Member Inner Circle of Excellence, a testimony to his exceptional contributions in the fields of Computer Graphics and Electronics Engineering. With over three decades of experience, Dr. Ballo's impact in technology is both profound and...

Continue Reading
SolePursuit Capital Syndicate's Commitment to Governance Growth

Updated Category News Views 190

Introduction to Governance and Transparency Updates SolePursuit Capital Syndicate has taken significant strides in enhancing its governance framework and transparency protocols. Under the leadership of founder Laurence Kingsley, the organization recently shared its Annual Governance and Transparency Update. This document sheds light on the important advancements made in...

Continue Reading
Omni Family Institute's Program Achieves Major Regulatory Recognition

Updated Category News Views 228

Omni Family Institute Celebrates Program Recognition Omni Family Institute, a respected organization committed to trauma-informed care, proudly announces the recent acknowledgment of its flagship initiative, Together Facing the Challenge. This program has successfully achieved a 'Supported' rating from the Title IV-E Prevention Services Clearinghouse, a notable milestone...

Continue Reading
Ideal Power's Q3 2025 Financial Updates and Future Plans

Updated Category News Views 185

Company Overview Ideal Power Inc. (NASDAQ: IPWR) is a pioneering developer and provider of innovative semiconductor solutions, specializing in the B-TRAN® bidirectional power switch technology. This technology enhances energy efficiency across various applications, including electric vehicles and renewable energy. Milestone Achievements Recently, CEO David Somo expressed...

Continue Reading
Latest Developments Surrounding Meta Platforms Insider Trading

Updated Category News Views 409

Significant Insider Trading at Meta Platforms Meta Platforms, Inc. (NASDAQ: META) has recently caught attention due to a notable action taken by its Chief Product Officer, Christopher K. Cox. It has come to light that Cox sold a substantial 20,000 shares of the company’s Class A Common Stock. This transaction, occurring at a price range of $555.00 to $560.25 per share,...

Continue Reading