Now that Tim Geithner has resigned as US Treasury

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
SaltyMutt



Now that Tim Geithner has resigned as US Treasury secretary, it is time to survey the damage wrought from four years of his approach to the financial crisis. The “Geithner doctrine” made the preservation of the largest banks, no matter the consequences, a top priority of the US government. Aside from moral hazard, it has also meant the perversion of the US criminal justice system. The US faces a two-tiered system of justice that, if left unchecked by the incoming Treasury and regulatory teams, all but assures more excessive risk-taking, more crime and more crises.

The recent parade of banking scandals, such as the manipulation of Libor rates by Barclays, Royal Bank of Scotland and other major banks, can be traced back to the lax system of regulation before the financial crisis – and the weak response once disaster struck.

Take the response of the New York Federal Reserve to Barclays’ admission in 2008 that it was submitting false Libor rates and was not alone in doing so. Mr Geithner’s response was to in effect bury the tip. He sent a memo to the Bank of England suggesting some changes to the rate-setting process and then convened a meeting of regulators where he reportedly described only the risk but not the actual manipulation of the rate. He then put the government imprimatur on the rate via bailout programmes. His inaction helped permit a global crime to continue for another year.

When it was UBS’s turn to settle its Libor charges, even though a significant amount of the illegal activity took place at the parent company level, only a Japanese subsidiary was required to take a plea. Eric Holder, US attorney-general, demonstrated his embrace of the Geithner doctrine (a phrase coined by blogger Yves Smith) in explaining the UBS decision. He said that a more aggressive stance against the parent company could have a negative “impact on the stability of the financial markets around the world”.

This week we saw the latest instalment of the saga. In fining RBS £390m, the DoJ only indicted one of the bank’s Asian subsidiaries, avoiding the more damaging result that would have stemmed from charging the parent company.

Instead of seeking deterrence and justice, the US government increasingly appears to have fully absorbed the Geithner doctrine into its charging decisions by seeking a result that has a minimal impact on the target bank but will generate the best-looking press release. Some banks today are still too big to fail – and they are still too big to jail.

The lack of robust enforcement is of course not limited to the Libor scandal. It was seen in the recent settlement talks with HSBC, when Treasury officials reportedly pressed the DoJ to consider the broad economic consequences that would follow an indictment. After hearing these arguments the DoJ chose not to criminally charge HSBC.

And, of course, it is seen in the stunning dearth of criminal prosecutions arising out of the crisis. This was all but preordained given who the government turned to when the crisis struck: the same captured regulators who had blindly advanced bankers’ self-serving calls for a “light touch” before the crisis and who unsurprisingly embraced the Geithner doctrine afterwards. Having done so, of course, there would be no criminal prosecutions while the banks still teetered on the brink of collapse. The risk of causing them to fail, and thereby undoing all of the bailout efforts, was too high.

But that these arguments continue to resonate with officials in 2013 shows that the Geithner doctrine, perhaps justified by the conditions in 2008-09, has planted deep roots in our system of government.

This forbearance will have potentially devastating long-term effects, as each settlement on favourable terms reinforces the perception that, for a select group of executives and institutions, crime pays. It is only rational. They know that they will get to keep all of the ill-gotten profits if they go undetected, and on the small chance that they’re caught, most probably only the shareholders will pay – and only a relatively minor fine at that. The lack of meaningful consequences for those committing these frauds encourages future fraudulent conduct. Ultimately, the financial crisis was a game of incentives gone wild, and the lack of accountability in the aftermath of the crisis has only reinforced those bad incentives.

Breaking those incentives requires ditching the Geithner doctrine, which has led to the banks becoming even larger and more systemically significant than they were before the crisis. As a result, the DoJ’s fear of destabilising the global economy through aggressive prosecutions may indeed be well-founded. But that must not be the end of the story.

To reclaim our system of justice, the global threat posed by the failure of any of our largest financial institutions must be neutralised once and for all. They must be reduced in size, their safety nets must be dramatically constricted and their capital requirements enhanced far beyond the current standards. Then, and only then, can the same set of rules apply to all.

The writer is the former special inspector-general of the troubled asset relief programme and is currently a senior fellow at NYU School of Law. He is the author of ‘Bailout’, released in paperback this week

https://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/2...r-doctrine


Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

ELEGOO's Formnext Push Tests a Broader 3D Ambition

Updated Category News Views 53

Frankfurt’s show floor is where product promises meet some very unforgiving eyeballs. ELEGOO arrived at Formnext 2026 with more than a refreshed machine or two: it is laying out a wider bet across resin printing, FDM printing, and 3D scanning. That matters because the company is no longer presenting itself as merely a supplier of affordable creator hardware. It wants to...

Continue Reading
Toledo Crosswalk Death Lawsuit Raises Hard Questions

Updated Category News Views 170

A painted crosswalk is supposed to mean something, and that is the grim center of the lawsuit filed over Judy Tanner’s death in Toledo. Tanner, 20, was walking home from work on September 10, 2026, when she was struck and killed while crossing the street. Her estate is now suing, alleging that the 31-year-old driver failed to yield as Tanner legally used the crosswalk....

Continue Reading
Panduit's AI Cooling Lab Boosts Data Center Innovation

Updated Category News Views 276

Innovation in Cooling: Panduit's Latest Move You hear "AI" and "data center" together and you know it's not gonna be business as usual. Here's Panduit throwing another log on the fire with their newly minted AI Cooling Lab. Panduit's a big cheese in the electrical and network infrastructure world. They've taken their Thermal Lab, given it a face-lift, and now, they’re...

Continue Reading
RCA Mount Dora Widens Addiction Care Insurance Reach

Updated Category News Views 120

Insurance paperwork rarely looks heroic, yet it can decide whether treatment starts before a crisis gets worse. Recovery Centers of America at Mount Dora has added Aetna and Cigna/Evernorth to its in-network roster for every level of substance use disorder care, a practical move with real consequences for patients and families across Central Florida. Coverage matters most...

Continue Reading
RBI Prices $1 Billion of Secured Notes Due 2031, 2036

Updated Category News Views 155

A billion dollars of fresh paper just landed on Restaurant Brands International’s balance-sheet doorstep, and this one deserves more than the usual sleepy glance at a financing release. RBI has priced $500 million of 6.00% senior secured notes due 2031 and another $500 million of 6.40% senior secured notes due 2036. The expected closing date is November 24, 2026,...

Continue Reading
Elisity’s Texas Water Pilot Puts IonQ’s Deal in View

Updated Category News Views 129

Water-system security is not a place for chest-thumping Elisity’s role in Texas Project Watershed 250 lands on a problem that is painfully concrete: water and wastewater utilities have to keep pumps, treatment systems and plant operations running while trying to close cybersecurity gaps. That is a tougher job than selling another dashboard to a corporate IT department....

Continue Reading
PSEG Declares $0.67 Fourth-Quarter 2026 Cash Dividend

Updated Category News Views 44

A 67-cent utility dividend rarely sets the tape on fire, and that is precisely the point. Public Service Enterprise Group declared a regular fourth-quarter 2026 common-stock dividend of $0.67 per share, payable on or before December 31 to shareholders of record on December 10. For owners of NYSE:PEG, this is the sort of announcement that belongs in the “steady as she...

Continue Reading
InPHRED's Award Brings 1310 nm VCSELs Into Focus at IEEE

Updated Category News Views 64

A stubborn mirror problem just put InPHRED on the photonics map. InPHRED, founded in 2023, took the Best Technology award at the inaugural 2026 IEEE Photonics Conference Start-Up Competition, selected from seven finalists. That is a meaningful industry pat on the back, particularly because the company is aiming at a real engineering headache rather than waving around...

Continue Reading
Giovanni Recalde Sues County After False Report

Updated Category News Views 215

Justice and Reputation: A Mix-Up Costs Big When the cops screw up, sometimes they really take the cake. That's what Giovanni Recalde learned, the hard way, when his name got tangled in a mess related to a gambling operation he wasn't even a part of. Prince William County police pasted his name into their daily incident report last year like it was no big deal. But it...

Continue Reading
Texas Community Bancshares Adds a Special Dividend

Updated Category News Views 89

Nine cents is the whole message—for the moment Texas Community Bancshares has put a little extra cash on the table, declaring a regular quarterly dividend of $0.06 per common share and a special cash dividend of $0.03 per share. Together, holders get $0.09 per share, payable on or about December 15, 2026, provided they are shareholders of record when business closes on...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

AWS Unveils New Cloud Infrastructure Region in Mexico

Updated Category News Views 242

AWS Introduces Mexico (Central) Region for Cloud Services Amazon Web Services (AWS), part of Amazon.com, Inc. (NASDAQ: AMZN), has launched its AWS Mexico (Central) Region. This strategic move enhances the options for developers, startups, enterprises, government bodies, educational institutions, and nonprofits seeking to run applications and serve end-users from local AWS...

Continue Reading
Ripple's Investment Boosts Flutterwave's Digital Leap

Updated Category News Views 23

Ripple and Flutterwave Join Forces to Reshape Finance The latest move by Ripple to pump funds into Flutterwave during its Series E funding round is shaking up the digital finance scene in Africa. With this strategic investment, we're witnessing a bold leap toward integrating stablecoins and digital assets into the continent's financial bloodstream. For investors, this...

Continue Reading
Exciting Earnings Announcement from Capital Southwest Corp

Updated Category News Views 37

Capital Southwest Corporation Reveals Earnings Release Schedule Capital Southwest Corporation (NASDAQ: CSWC), an esteemed business development company based in Dallas, is gearing up for the release of its second quarter 2025 financial results. The announcement marks a significant moment for investors keen on following the company's trajectory. Details of the Upcoming...

Continue Reading
Kroger's Ultimate Guide to Crafting Delicious Sandwiches

Updated Category News Views 133

Kroger's Ultimate Guide to Crafting Delicious Sandwiches Crafting a perfect sandwich opens up a world of possibilities, and Kroger is at the forefront of this culinary endeavor. With their latest guide, they provide a wealth of ideas and ingredients, making summer meals not only delicious but also exciting. Imagine sinking your teeth into a variety of stunning...

Continue Reading
NR7 Miner Enhances Mining with Real-Time Optimization Strategy

Updated Category News Views 268

Revolutionizing the Mining Landscape In an exciting development in the world of cryptocurrency, NR7 Miner has launched its Dynamic Chain Optimization System. This innovative upgrade allows users to optimize their mining protocols in real time, significantly increasing their profitability. Embracing Change for Greater Earnings With the launch of this advanced system, NR7...

Continue Reading