Wednesday, March 06, 2013 Is Monetary Stimulation a

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
SaltyMutt

Wednesday, March 06, 2013

Is Monetary Stimulation a Sensible Economic Policy?

By Staff Report

What Saved the Dow? Sensible Economic Policies ... As of the closing bell on Tuesday, the Dow was trading at 14,254—well above the previous all-time peak of 14,198, which the market reached on October 11, 2007. With investors increasingly optimistic about the economy, nearly four hundred issues on the New York Stock Exchange hit new highs. Sticklers will point out that, after accounting for inflation, stock prices are still more than ten per cent below their previous peak, but that's quibbling. Any way you look at it, during the past four years the market has made a remarkable recovery from the post-Lehman crash.- New Yorker

Dominant Social Theme: If not for monetary debasement, the stock market would have foundered.

Free-Market Analysis: This New Yorker article offers us tribute to monetary policy. But certainly there must be a question about manipulating stock averages up using increased money flows. The article ends by challenging free-market types to "acknowledge the success" of politics and the financial system generally in rebounding from the financial crisis and posting such stellar numbers.

Well ... as free-market types, we are perfectly willing to throw in a word of caution when it comes to where the market has been and where it is headed – Dow Jones, Nasdaq and similar US markets anyway. It seems to us that valuations of industry have increased validity when they are subject to investor sentiment rather than Federal Reserve monetary inflation .

In fact, the question becomes – as this article does not seem to notice – whether inflated averages are viable or ephemeral: That is, are they a valid indicator of performance or merely evidence of the power of the printing press. Here's more from the article:

... Take a quick historical quiz. How long do you think it took the market to regain its high after the stock-market crash of 1929? Five years? Ten years? Fifteen years? Twenty years? Keep going. On September 3, 1929, the Dow closed at 381.17, a level it didn't see again until November 23, 1954. That's twenty-five years, two months, and twenty days—more than a quarter of a century. The stock market's recuperation from the Great Depression took almost five times as long as its recovery from the Great Recession.

No big surprise there, you might say. September, 1929, marked the peak of a stock-market bubble, and the Great Depression was a lot more serious than the Great Recession. In the early nineteen-thirties, the unemployment rate reached about thirty per cent, there was widespread hunger, and some serious thinkers believed capitalism was imploding. By the summer of 1932, the stock market had fallen by almost ninety per cent.

Whilst that's all undeniable, nobody should understate the transformation in sentiment over the past forty-eight months. On March 2, 2009, six weeks after President Obama took office, the Dow closed at 6,626.90. In the six months after the collapse of Lehman Brothers , it had fallen more than four thousand points. Compared to its October, 2007, peak, the market was down about fifty-four per cent—the biggest decline it had suffered since the Second World War. Between 1973 and 1975, the Dow dropped forty-five per cent. In October, 1987, it tumbled by a third. But this fall was deeper than either of those.

If, in early March of 2009, you had said the market would rebound to a new high within four years, few would have believed you. With consumers and employers panicking over the ongoing financial crisis, the Gross Domestic Product was falling at an alarming rate, and the economy was shedding more than seven hundred thousand jobs a month. On Wall Street, analysts and investors had roundly booed the initial effort by Tim Geithner , the new Treasury Secretary, to explain how he intended to end the panic.

At the risk of beating a dead horse, and enraging some devotees of Andrew Mellon's approach to economics, it's perhaps worth remembering what turned things around: activist government policies. A combination of government bailouts (which originated in the Bush Administration), emergency-lending programs from the Fed, and bank stress tests organized by the Fed and the Treasury Department stabilized the financial system. The Obama Administration's stimulus program put a floor under the economy at large. And cheap money—a result of the Fed's ongoing efforts to flood the financial system with cash and keep interest rates ultra-low—eventually led to a recovery in stock prices and housing prices, which was what Ben Bernanke and his colleagues wanted to see. In the nineteen-thirties, the initial policy response was very misguided. With Mellon at the Treasury, there were virtually no stimulus programs; meanwhile the Federal Reserve stood by and allowed many banks to collapse. As a result of this inaction, the economy spiraled downward until F.D.R. entered the White House.

This is a standard Keynesian analysis of monetary history. The trouble is that it doesn't go back far enough. It is well known by this time that the newly minted Federal Reserve of the 1920s created the bubble of the Roaring Twenties by printing too many dollars. The reasons for this are somewhat unclear – and may be either malicious or malign, or a combination of both – but the result is not. The Roaring Twenties gave way to the Great Depression of the 1930s.

The article implies that it was activist polices of FDR and now the Obama administration that "saved" their respective financial systems. But the current central banking system is the cause of the problem as well as the solution.

To use a trite metaphor, when the yo-yo going up and down is making you dizzy, put down the yo-yo. The incessant expansion and contraction of the economy based on constant over-printing of money is not healthy for society and is destructive to savings.

For this reason it is doubtful that free-market types will happily endorse the Dow's current higher highs. Every tick upwards makes it more difficult to ascertain what is the result of industrial value and what is the result of monetary policy.

This leads to a further distortion that has to do with how people invest. If investors perceive – as indeed they must – that the market is being unduly influenced by outside forces, then this can lead to a kind of casino mentality where those involved invest for the short term based on external circumstances rather than fundamentals.

If markets are supposed to be a store of value, and are to be treated as such, then less stimulation rather than more ought to be a considered policy. How can policymakers rail against the casino-mentality of larger investors while manipulating the market regularly via central banking super dollars?

Conclusion: It's a contradiction that must be addressed via sounder – or at least more sensible – monetary approaches.

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

ZTO's Pricing Muscle Shows Up in Third-Quarter Results

Updated Category News Views 116

Ten billion parcels can hide plenty of ugly economics, but ZTO's third quarter does not look like a volume-at-any-cost stunt. The company moved 10.241 billion parcels, up 7.0% from a year earlier, and says that outpaced the industry by 4.1 percentage points. More importantly, revenue climbed 21.0% to RMB14.36 billion while adjusted net income reached RMB2.57 billion. That...

Continue Reading
Benicia's Bold Move to Streamline Permitting Pays Off

Updated Category News Views 127

Award-Winning Innovation from Benicia Benicia, California, shoots ahead of the pack by scooping up a highly coveted Helen Putnam Award for Excellence. Why? They chopped down bureaucracy like a lumberjack with a new ax by ushering in a digital revolution for their permitting process. Make no mistake, folks, this ain’t just a pat on the back—it's a blueprint for cities...

Continue Reading
SanMar’s Lott Tops Promo Products Power 50 Again in 2026

Updated Category News Views 43

Branded hoodies and logo tumblers rarely make Wall Street’s pulse race, but the numbers behind them deserve a hard look. Jeremy Lott, president and CEO of SanMar, was named the most influential leader in the U.S. promotional-products business for the second consecutive year, taking No. 1 in the 2026 Counselor Power 50 ranking. Awards can be fluff. A repeat win beside...

Continue Reading
PSEG Declares $0.67 Fourth-Quarter 2026 Cash Dividend

Updated Category News Views 64

A 67-cent utility dividend rarely sets the tape on fire, and that is precisely the point. Public Service Enterprise Group declared a regular fourth-quarter 2026 common-stock dividend of $0.67 per share, payable on or before December 31 to shareholders of record on December 10. For owners of NYSE:PEG, this is the sort of announcement that belongs in the “steady as she...

Continue Reading
Alpha's Training Bet Reaches Into Aesthetic Care Networks

Updated Category News Views 186

Training is becoming part of the operating machine A certificate course is rarely the headline-grabber in healthcare services, yet this one deserves a closer look. Alpha Aesthetics Partners has launched Practice Aesthetics, a unified clinical education platform tied directly to its expanding network of medical aesthetics practices. This is not a public-market ticker...

Continue Reading
Charter’s $1.5 Billion Tender Tests Debt Discipline

Updated Category News Views 176

Debt cleanup arrives with a hard ceiling Eight far-dated bond issues just got a very specific invitation from Charter Communications: hand them over for cash, but do not expect the company to write a blank check. Charter set final pricing on November 17 for tender offers covering up to $1.5 billion in aggregate consideration, excluding accrued interest and deal expenses....

Continue Reading
EUBG Faces Tough Third Quarter Amid Challenges

Updated Category News Views 226

What's Happening with EUBG? Entrepreneur Universe Bright Group, better known in the markets as EUBG, is navigating some choppy waters if their recent financial numbers are anything to go by. You'd think companies boasting a digital-focused strategy would be printing money in today's tech-driven world, but EUBG's third quarter of 2026 has a different story to tell. The...

Continue Reading
Wonder Create: Democratizing Restaurant Creation

Updated Category News Views 57

Breaking Down Barriers in the Restaurant Industry It's been a long time since someone truly shook up the restaurant scene like this. Wonder Create is stepping in to turn anyone with a wild food idea into a bonafide restaurateur. We're not talking about the ol' franchising route here. We're diving straight into democratizing the culinary world. You seen something this bold...

Continue Reading
Texas Community Bancshares Adds a Special Dividend

Updated Category News Views 109

Nine cents is the whole message—for the moment Texas Community Bancshares has put a little extra cash on the table, declaring a regular quarterly dividend of $0.06 per common share and a special cash dividend of $0.03 per share. Together, holders get $0.09 per share, payable on or about December 15, 2026, provided they are shareholders of record when business closes on...

Continue Reading
Toledo Crosswalk Death Lawsuit Raises Hard Questions

Updated Category News Views 193

A painted crosswalk is supposed to mean something, and that is the grim center of the lawsuit filed over Judy Tanner’s death in Toledo. Tanner, 20, was walking home from work on September 10, 2026, when she was struck and killed while crossing the street. Her estate is now suing, alleging that the 31-year-old driver failed to yield as Tanner legally used the crosswalk....

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Riyadh Gears Up for UNIDO 2025: A Step Towards Sustainable Industry

Updated Category News Views 180

Riyadh Gears Up for UNIDO 2025 Riyadh is on the verge of an exciting global event as it prepares to host the 21st Session of the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) General Conference. This significant summit is scheduled to happen at the King Abdulaziz International Conference Centre, where leaders from various sectors will gather to discuss the...

Continue Reading
Deer Park Road Strategizes for Growth Amid CRE Market Changes

Updated Category News Views 205

Deer Park Road Strategies in a Changing CRE Landscape Deer Park Road Management Company, LP, a notable $2.8 billion alternative asset management firm, is honing in on emerging prospects within the challenging environment of the Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities (CMBS) market. The firm’s extensive expertise enables them to consistently identify potential value during...

Continue Reading
iRobot Corporation Faces Legal Challenges Amid Financial Struggles

Updated Category News Views 141

Legal Investigations into iRobot Corporation Investors are currently facing uncertainties surrounding iRobot Corporation as it faces legal scrutiny. The well-respected law firm Faruqi & Faruqi, LLP has initiated investigations regarding potential legal claims on behalf of investors who suffered significant losses. Who to Contact James (Josh) Wilson, a partner at Faruqi &...

Continue Reading
Dr. Andrea Fuyuko Honda Recognized for Medical Innovation Excellence

Updated Category News Views 385

Dr. Andrea Fuyuko Honda's Recent Recognition Dr. Andrea Fuyuko Honda has been prominently recognized as a Pinnacle Professional Member within an elite circle of excellence. This accolade reflects her significant contributions to the field as a Leading Medical Communications Expert and Innovator. With a career spanning over fifteen years, Dr. Honda has demonstrated...

Continue Reading
Centene Corporation Faces Securities Fraud Legal Action

Updated Category News Views 206

Centene Corporation Faces New Lawsuit Over Securities Fraud Investors of Centene Corporation, known by the ticker symbol CNC, have found themselves at the center of a securities fraud lawsuit. Recently, a leading law firm announced the initiation of legal action against Centene Corporation and some of its senior executives. This lawsuit stems from alleged violations of...

Continue Reading