Tuesday, March 05, 2013 The Missing Recovery By Paul

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
SaltyMutt
Tuesday, March 05, 2013

The Missing Recovery

By Paul Craig Roberts

Paul Craig Roberts

Officially, since June 2009 the US economy has been undergoing an economic recovery from the December 2007 recession. But where is this recovery? I cannot find it, and neither can millions of unemployed Americans.

The recovery exists only in the official measure of real GDP, which is deflated by an understated measure of inflation, and in the U.3 measure of the unemployment rate, which is declining because it does not count discouraged job seekers who have given up looking for a job.

No other data series indicates an economic recovery. Neither real retail sales nor housing starts, consumer confidence, payroll employment, or average weekly earnings indicate economic recovery.

Neither does the Federal Reserve 's monetary policy. The Fed's expansive monetary policy of bond purchases to maintain negative real interest rates continues 3.5 years into the recovery. Of course, the reason for the Fed's negative interest rates is not to boost the economy but to boost asset values on the books of "banks too big to fail."

The low interest rates raise the prices of the mortgage-backed derivatives and other debt-related assets on the banks' balance sheets at the expense of interest income for retirees on their savings accounts, money market funds, and Treasury bonds.

Despite recovery's absence and the lack of job opportunities for Americans, Republicans in Congress are sponsoring bills to enlarge the number of foreigners that corporations can bring in on work visas. The large corporations claim that they cannot find enough skilled Americans. This is one of the most transparent of the constant stream of lies that we are told.

Foreign hires are not additions to the work force, but replacements. The corporations force their American employees to train the foreigners, and then the American employees are discharged. Obviously, if skilled employees were in short supply, they would not be laid off. Moreover, if the skills were in short supply, salaries would be bid up, not down, and the 36% of those who graduated in 2011 with a doctorate degree in engineering would not have been left unemployed. The National Science Foundation's report, "Doctorate Recipients From U.S. Universities," says that only 64% of the Ph.D. engineering graduates found a pay check.

As I have reported on numerous occasions for many years, neither the payroll jobs statistics nor the Bureau of Labor Statistics' job projections show job opportunities for university graduates. But this doesn't stop Congress from helping US corporations get rid of their American employees in exchange for campaign donations.

There was a time not that long ago when US corporations accepted that they had obligations to their employees, customers, suppliers, the communities in which they were located, and to their shareholders. Today they only acknowledge obligations to shareholders. Everyone else has been thrown to the wolves in order to maximize profits and, thereby, shareholders' capital gains and executive bonuses.

By focusing on the bottom line at all costs, corporations are destroying the US consumer market. Offshoring jobs reduces labor costs and raises profits, but it also reduces domestic consumer income, thus reducing the domestic market for the corporation's products. For awhile the reduction in consumer income can be filled by the expansion of consumer debt, but when consumers reach their debt limit sales cannot continue to rise. The consequence of jobs offshoring is the ruination of the domestic consumer market.

Today the stock market is high not from profits from expanding sales revenues, but from labor cost savings.

US economic policy has been focused away from the real problems and onto a consequence of those problems–the large US budget deficit. As no interest group wants to be gored, Congress has been unable to deal with the trillion dollar plus annual budget deficit, the continuation of which raises the specter of dollar collapse and inflation.

John Maynard Keynes made it clear long ago, as has Greece today, that trying to reduce the ratio of debt to GDP by austerity measures doesn't work.

Among the countries in the world the US is in a unique position. It not only has its own central bank to provide the money necessary to finance the government's deficit, but also the money that is provided, the US dollar , is the world's reserve currency used to settle international accounts among all nations and, thus, always in demand. The dollar thus serves as the world's transaction currency and also as a store of value for countries with trade surpluses who invest their surpluses in US Treasury bonds and other dollar-denominated assets.

Without the support that the reserve currency status gives to the dollar's exchange value (its price in foreign currencies), the enormous expansion in the quantity of dollars produced by the Fed's years of quantitative easing would have resulted in a drop in the dollar's exchange value, a rise in interest rates, and a rise in inflation. Since my time in government, the US has become an export-dependent economy, and export-dependent economies are subject to domestic inflation when the currency loses exchange value.

To sum up, the corporations' focus on the bottom line has disconnected US incomes from the production of the goods and services that the American people consume, thus weakening and ultimately destroying the domestic consumer market. The Fed's focus on saving banks, which mindless deregulation allowed to become "too big to fail," has created a bond market bubble of negative real interest rates and a dollar bubble in which the dollar's exchange rate has not declined in keeping with the large increase in its supply. Both the corporations and the Fed have created a stock market bubble based on profits obtained from labor arbitrage (the substitution of cheaper foreign labor for US labor) and from banks speculating with the money that the Fed is providing to them.

This situation is untenable. Sooner or later something will pop these bubbles, and the consequences will be horrendous.


This column was originally published at PaulCraigRoberts.org and is reprinted here with the author's position. Dr. Roberts was Assistant Secretary of the US Treasury for Economic Policy in the Reagan Administration. He was associate editor and columnist with the Wall Street Journal, columnist for Business Week and the Scripps Howard News Service. He has had numerous university appointments. His latest book, The Failure of Laissez Faire Capitalism and Economic Dissolution of the West is available here .



Latest Daily Bell Articles
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Evotec’s $2.9M Grant Advances Drug Safety Tech

Updated Category News Views 20

Revitalizing Drug Development with Human Stem Cells Evotec's latest win—a crisp $2.9 million grant from the Gates Foundation—is like a shot of adrenaline for drug safety innovation. This isn't just another drop in the bucket; it's a solid boost toward improving how we screen potential drugs for fetal risks before they're tossed into the costly whirlpool of clinical...

Continue Reading
KINGRVER Boosts RV Comfort with New Water Heater Lineup

Updated Category News Views 349

An Upgrade for the Open Road In the land of RV living, comfort is king—or in this case, KINGRVER. Dropping affordable upgrades for water heaters into the world of RVs, KINGRVER's CT6 lineup is like a warm hug on a chilly campsite morning. Whether you've pulled up to a wooded retreat or parked under the vast desert sky, having dependable hot water shouldn't be a gamble....

Continue Reading
Championing Change: USTA Mid-Atlantic Gala's Impact

Updated Category News Views 360

A Night to Remember: USTA Mid-Atlantic's Gala Who would've thought tennis could wield such transformative power? This ain't your average sport gala. Last Saturday, a crowd of over 300 gathered at the Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner for the USTA Mid-Atlantic Foundation's 2026 Tennis Creates Gala. Hosted by the formidable Malika Andrews, this event wasn't just a fancy...

Continue Reading
LONGi's Four Paths to Global Green Development

Updated Category News Views 79

LONGi's Vision: A Cleaner, Greener Future Amidst the buzz at COP31 in Antalya, LONGi is making waves with promises of a cleaner future. They're not just throwing around eco-friendly slogans—this company's laying down real pathways to tackle climate change, one solar panel at a time. Aiming for Industrial Transformation LONGi's got their sights set on shaking up...

Continue Reading
SOBER CAFFEINE™: Modern Energizer Without the Bull

Updated Category News Views 37

Shed the Cans and Embrace Convenience I'm sure you've had a run-in with the standard energy drink routine. You know, the massive cans, a gut punch of sugar, and the inevitable crash that follows? Sobriety Supplements LLC decided enough is enough and rolled out something that just makes sense—SOBER CAFFEINE™ capsules. This little pill is a godsend for folks sick of...

Continue Reading
Kayla Harrison Dominates UFC 334, Earns Big Win

Updated Category News Views 64

Kicking off UFC 334 with a bang, Kayla Harrison didn't just step into the Octagon—she bulldozed her way through Amanda Nunes to retain her Women's Bantamweight Championship. This showdown didn't just electrify New York's Madison Square Garden, it shook the entire MMA landscape. Harrison, the face of Monster Energy's athlete roster, wasn't content with just defending her...

Continue Reading
Phoenix Contact Achieves Guinness Record in Wiring

Updated Category News Views 69

A Blitz of Wires and Innovation Boy, did Phoenix Contact shake things up in Blomberg. On a crisp November day, a group of fresh-faced first-year students pulled off something astounding—wiring 500 terminal blocks in a jaw-dropping 2 minutes and 20 seconds. This wasn’t just any effort; it was enough to earn them a shiny new Guinness World Record. What they did wasn’t...

Continue Reading
YONDELIS: Thai Approval Opens New Sarcoma Treatment Path

Updated Category News Views 192

New Hope for Thai Sarcoma Patients Alright, we’ve got some good news coming out of Thailand, folks. The Thai FDA just greenlit YONDELIS® (trabectedin) for those grappling with advanced soft tissue sarcoma (STS). Now, this isn’t your everyday drug release—it’s a clinical chess move packing potential for patients who’ve run out of other options. December 1st,...

Continue Reading
Thunes Boosts Bhutan Remittances with Instant Payments

Updated Category News Views 216

Thunes' Network Expands to Bhutan: A Game Changer I'll say one thing clear—Thunes isn't messing around. They've just opened the gates for real-time payouts to Bhutan, and it's going to be a game-changer for those living abroad who want to send money back home. Look, for years, Non-Resident Bhutanese have been diving into hoops just to get their bucks across borders....

Continue Reading
Akeso's Gumokimab Wins NMPA Approval for AS Treatment

Updated Category News Views 17

Gumokimab Approved: A New Dawn in AS Treatment Yeah, the biotech world shifts gears today as Akeso's gumokimab received the green light from China's National Medical Products Administration (NMPA). This approval for treating ankylosing spondylitis, or AS, isn't just another checkbox for Akeso; it's a game-changer in tackling this chronic inflammatory disease. Why should...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Insights from the 2025 Hotel Labor Costs Report for Hospitality

Updated Category News Views 191

Hotel Labor Costs and Efficiency Improvements in 2025 In a year marked by rising wages and fluctuating revenue, hotels across the United States have made significant strides in improving labor efficiency. The latest report for 2025 reveals remarkable insights into how these establishments have optimized their operations. As labor costs increased, hotels made tactical...

Continue Reading
Ritter Sport Expands Partnership with Agritask for Sustainability

Updated Category News Views 421

Ritter Sport Enhances EUDR Compliance with Agritask Ritter Sport, the renowned chocolate manufacturer, has strengthened its alliance with Agritask, a leading crop supply intelligence company. This partnership focuses on bolstering sustainability within its cocoa supply chain, especially in light of the recent European Union Deforestation Regulation (EUDR). As part of its...

Continue Reading
Investor Advocacy: Understanding Telix Pharmaceuticals' Recent Events

Updated Category News Views 240

Recent Developments at Telix Pharmaceuticals In the ever-evolving landscape of pharmaceuticals, investors constantly seek assurance regarding the stability and profitability of their chosen companies. One such company, Telix Pharmaceuticals Limited (NASDAQ: TLX), finds itself under scrutiny recently. With the increasing necessity for transparency in the healthcare sector,...

Continue Reading
Upexi's Transformative Advisory Strategy Fuels Stock Surge

Updated Category News Views 189

Upexi's Stock Performance and Strategic Direction Upexi Inc (NASDAQ:UPXI) has witnessed a remarkable rise in its stock price, showcasing a nearly 90% increase year-to-date as of the latest updates. This surge follows the company's strategic decision to form an advisory committee, announcing Arthur Hayes, a co-founder of BitMEX, as the committee's first member. This...

Continue Reading
Singapore's Economic Growth Surpasses Expectations for 2024

Updated Category News Views 324

Singapore's Economic Performance in 2024 In an impressive turn of events, Singapore's economy has shown remarkable resilience and growth, exceeding earlier forecasts. Prime Minister Lawrence Wong recently announced that the city-state achieved a 4% growth rate for its gross domestic product (GDP) in 2024, surpassing previous estimations which anticipated a moderate 3.5%...

Continue Reading