America’s Right Has a Putin Problem March 10, 2022

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Bhawks Goodspeed65 #79376
283
America’s Right Has a Putin Problem

March 10, 2022

By Paul Krugman
Opinion Columnist

Just a few weeks ago many influential figures on the U.S. right loved, just loved Vladimir Putin. In fact, some of them still can’t quit him. For example, Tucker Carlson, while he has grudgingly backed off from full-on Putin support, is still blaming America for the war and promoting Russian disinformation about U.S.-funded bioweapons labs.


For the most part, however, America’s Putin lovers are having a moment of truth. It’s not so much that Putin stands revealed as a tyrant willing to kill large numbers of innocent people — they knew or should have known that already. The problem is that the strongman they admired — whom Donald Trump praised as “savvy” and a “genius” just before he invaded Ukraine — is turning out to be remarkably weak.

And that’s not an accident. Russia is facing disaster precisely because it is ruled by a man who accepts no criticism and brooks no dissent.

On the military side, a war Russia clearly envisioned as a blitzkrieg that would overrun Ukraine in days has yet to capture any of the country’s top 10 cities — although long-range bombardment is turning those cities into rubble.

On the economic side, Putin’s attempt to insulate himself from potential Western sanctions has been a debacle, with everything indicating that Russia will have a depression-level slump.

To see why this matters, you need to understand the sources of the right’s infatuation with a brutal dictator, an infatuation that began even before Trump’s rise.

Some of this dictator-love reflected the belief that Putin was a champion of antiwokeness — someone who wouldn’t accuse you of being a racist, who denounced cancel culture and “gay propaganda.”

Some of it reflected a creepy fascination with Putin’s alleged masculinity — Sarah Palin declared that he wrestled bears while President Barack Obama wore “mom jeans” — and the apparent toughness of Putin’s people. Just last year Senator Ted Cruz contrasted footage of a shaven-headed Russian soldier with a U.S. Army recruiting ad to mock our “woke, emasculated” military.

Finally, many on the right simply like the idea of authoritarian rule. Just a few days ago Trump, who has dialed back his praise for Putin, chose instead to express admiration for North Korea’s Kim Jong-un. Kim’s generals and aides, he noted, “cowered” when the dictator spoke, adding that “I want my people to act like that.”

But we’re now relearning an old lesson: Sometimes, what looks like strength is actually a source of weakness.

Whatever eventually happens in the war, it’s clear that Russia’s military was far less formidable than it appeared on paper. Russian forces appear to be undertrained and badly led; there also seem to be problems with Russian equipment, such as communications devices.

These weaknesses might have been apparent to Putin before the war if investigative journalists or independent watchdogs within his government had been in a position to assess the country’s true military readiness. But such things aren’t possible in Putin’s Russia.

The invaders were also clearly shocked by Ukraine’s resistance — both by its resolve and by its competence. Realistic intelligence assessments might have warned Russia that this might happen; but would you want to have been the official standing up and saying, “Mr. President, I’m afraid we may be underestimating the Ukrainians”?

On the economic side, I have to admit that both the West’s willingness to impose sanctions and the effectiveness of those sanctions have surprised just about everyone, myself included.

Still, economic officials and independent experts in Russia should have warned Putin in advance that “Fortress Russia” was a deeply flawed idea. It shouldn’t have required deep analysis to realize that Putin’s $630 billion in foreign exchange reserves would become largely unusable if the world’s democracies cut off Russia’s access to the world banking system.

It also shouldn’t have required deep analysis to realize that Russia’s economy is deeply dependent on imports of capital goods and other essential industrial inputs.

But again, would you have wanted to be the diplomat telling Putin that the West isn’t as decadent as he thinks, the banker telling him that his vaunted “war chest” will be useless in a crisis, the economist telling him that Russia needs imports?

The point is that the case for an open society — a society that allows dissent and criticism — goes beyond truth and morality.

Open societies are also, by and large, more effective than closed-off autocracies. That is, while you might imagine that there are big advantages to rule by a strongman who can simply tell people what to do, these advantages are more than offset by the absence of free discussion and independent thought. Nobody can tell the strongman that he’s wrong or urge him to think twice before making a disastrous decision.

Which brings me back to America’s erstwhile Putin admirers. I’d like to think that they’ll take Russia’s Ukraine debacle as an object lesson and rethink their own hostility to democracy. OK, I don’t really expect that to happen. But we can always hope.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/10/opinion/pu...a-usa.html
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Modexus Opens a $500 Million Buyback With Real Caveats

Updated Category News Views 68

A half-billion-dollar buyback authorization can make a stock crowd sit up fast, and Modexus Solutions has plainly chosen that moment. On November 18, 2026, the Racine, Wisconsin-based thermal-management company said its board authorized repurchases of up to $500 million of common stock. For holders of NYSE:MOD, that is a meaningful declaration of intent. It says...

Continue Reading
Ampace Fire Test Gives Data Centers Useful Evidence

Updated Category News Views 109

Battery cabinets are becoming the awkward guest in the AI data-center boom: absolutely necessary, expensive to install, and nobody wants to discover their failure behavior during a real emergency. Ampace’s newly presented PU100 large-scale fire-test results deserve attention for that reason. This is not a magic safety stamp, and the company says the findings apply only...

Continue Reading
Google Search Data Sharing Faces a Privacy Reality Check

Updated Category News Views 77

Search queries are messy little confessions, and that is exactly why this case deserves more than a bureaucratic shrug. Woodway Assurance's independent assessment says Google's search-query data could be treated as anonymized for sharing under the Digital Markets Act, but only if the European Commission tightens parts of its July 2026 framework. That is not a clean bill...

Continue Reading
Markel Elevates War Risk Expertise in London Market

Updated Category News Views 73

A Specialty Desk Gets Its Own Weather Vane War and political violence underwriting is not a corner of insurance where a fancy title change can be shrugged off. The ground shifts under the policyholder, the broker and the carrier without much warning, and a bad call can sit on a book for years. Markel Insurance has named Chloe Gordge Director of War and Political Violence...

Continue Reading
Linkind's Best Buy Push Tests Smart Outdoor Demand

Updated Category News Views 77

Holiday lights have quietly become a year-round hardware category, and Linkind wants a louder seat at the table. The smart-lighting brand says three outdoor products have been in Best Buy stores across the United States since October 17, 2026: permanent exterior lights, decorative string lights, and solar pathway lights. That is a real distribution step, not some grand...

Continue Reading
BKV Energy's $400,000 Loyalty Bet Has a Real Point Behind It

Updated Category News Views 13

Retail power customers rarely send thank-you notes; they switch plans, complain about bills, or quietly vanish. That is why BKV Energy putting more than $400,000 into its third annual ElectroShare payout deserves a harder look than the usual feel-good loyalty announcement. A Retention Expense With Some Teeth The payout has climbed quickly: roughly $113,000 in the first...

Continue Reading
Cytonics Refines CYT-108 Trial Plan With Decade OA Data

Updated Category News Views 57

A Better Map Is Not a Working Drug Knee osteoarthritis has chewed up plenty of promising development plans because the disease moves at an aggravatingly uneven crawl. Cytonics has done something sensible before pushing deeper into CYT-108: it went back to long-term untreated patient data and asked which knees actually deteriorate fast enough for a trial to detect...

Continue Reading
Pacific Surfliner Faces Thanksgiving Capacity Test

Updated Category News Views 23

Thanksgiving traffic on Southern California freeways is its own yearly punishment, and the Pacific Surfliner is making a sensible pitch: leave the car parked and let the coast roll past the window. For travelers, that can be a real relief. For anyone watching public transportation, this is also a useful little stress test of whether a busy state-supported rail corridor...

Continue Reading
Unishippers Climbs 18 Slots on 32.4% Sales Growth Run

Updated Category News Views 147

Thirty new franchise units can move the needle fast Unishippers did not inch its way up the Franchise Times Top 400; it put up a number that deserves a hard look. Sales rose 32.4% in 2025, the company added 30 franchise units, and the result was an 18-place jump to No. 81 on the 2026 ranking. In the shipping category, it was named the sales-growth leader. For a business...

Continue Reading
LEPAS AURA Signals a Sharper Design Bet for Future Cars

Updated Category News Views 50

A porcelain-smooth concept car is not a balance sheet, but it can tell you where a young automotive brand intends to spend its attention. LEPAS unveiled AURA in October at its first Global Elegant Lifestyle Week, presenting it as the brand's first global concept car and a fresh expression of its Leopard Aesthetics design language. That matters because AURA is plainly not...

Continue Reading