Euclid - A Man Who Shaped Our World Euclid's geometrical

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone

Euclid - A Man Who Shaped Our World

Euclid's geometrical treatise "The Elements" has been a touchstone for more than 2,000 years.

One of the more curious historical revelations of Steven Spielberg's "Lincoln" is that America's 16th president was obsessed by a Greek mathematician from the fourth century B.C. While traveling from town to town as a young lawyer riding the Eighth Circuit in Illinois, Abraham Lincoln kept a copy of Euclid's geometrical treatise, "The Elements," in his saddlebag; his law partner Billy Herndon related that at night Lincoln would lie on the floor reading it by lamplight. Lincoln said he was moved to study Euclid by his desire to understand what a "demonstration" was, and how it differed from any other kind of argument.

Euclid's notion of a demonstration, or proof, and related topics are explored in David Berlinski's "The King of Infinite Space." He wants to goad the reader into appreciating a textbook that has endured for over 2,000 years. But he is also concerned to convince the reader that the "Euclidean style" endures as a "way of life" and that this style consists in Euclid's fusion of beauty and logic in his proofs. Along the way we learn about the axioms (or "postulates"), definitions and theorems of Euclid's system.

Reading this brief, lively work is like sitting with the author in a French café with too many carafes of red wine and the smoke of hundreds of Gauloises swirling inside your head. "Mathematicians are fussy as cats. And almost as conservative," your host says. "Counting would seem to come first, no? . . . Long live the numbers then. But then there is seeing. Shapes are metaphysically as compelling as numbers. . . . Long live the shapes too." The book's style will put off some readers, especially during the first half, in which we are subjected to numerous stream-of-consciousness musings.

Readers, however, should persist, because in Chapters VI and VII we get to the heart and soul of this book, a discussion of Euclid's proofs. Here Mr. Berlinski depicts Euclid as a mountain climber whose theorems or conclusions are the peaks, and the proofs the record, of his treks upward. In yet more colorful writing, Mr. Berlinski depicts the different kinds of demonstrations we find in the "Elements": "In some, Euclid gets to the top quickly; in others, he is obliged to grunt and slog, and in these he is like some grizzled old climber recalling how he was threatened by congelation of the anus."

In these chapters Mr. Berlinski makes two provocative claims about Euclid's notion of a proof. One concerns the illustrations or diagrams that accompany his arguments. What are Euclid's diagrams for? Are they essential parts of the proofs, illustrative guides, helpful if occasionally misleading visualizations, or something else? Mr. Berlinski proposes that the diagrams and the logical structure of the proofs come together to form a unified whole; they "undergo fusion." This combination of illustration and argument, indeed, "lies at the heart of Euclid's method."

But how can a visual image play a role in a logical argument? Mr. Berlinski defines for us what a proof should do: It "compels belief." But Mr. Berlinski seems to have a controversial understanding of this compulsion. For him it is more psychological than logical, more rhetorical than mathematical, more feeling than fact. Take the author's discussion of Euclid's first proof, a demonstration of the proposition that on a given straight line segment it is always possible to construct an equilateral triangle. After agreeing with modern mathematicians that there are numerous logical lapses in Euclid's argument, Mr. Berlinski nevertheless concludes that his proof succeeds—because, again, its combination of logic and illustration "compels belief."

This view contrasts markedly with the view of Aristotle (who, Mr. Berlinski postulates, might conceivably have known Euclid). For Aristotle, and philosophers ever since, a proof or demonstration is an argument that compels rational belief in the sense of showing that the conclusions must be drawn from the premises, that is, that the conclusion is a necessary consequence of the premises. If there are logical holes in Euclid's first proof, it cannot compel rational belief, even if it persuades some people to believe it.

Even when Euclid's proofs make no logical leaps, they are based on assumptions about points, lines and shapes in space as he conceived it. This "Euclidean space" was taken for nearly 2,000 years to describe the "invisible scaffolding of spheres, cones and cylinders in nature," as the painter Paul Cézanne put it. Non-Euclidean geometries, first developed in the 19th century, showed that there are other ways to imagine space, in which the Euclidean postulates are not only not necessary but false.

For ages, doubts about the necessity of Euclidean geometry focused on the fifth of Euclid's axioms—the one claiming that parallel lines do not converge at a point. This had always been recognized, even by Euclid, as being "shady" (in Mr. Berlinski's phrasing) compared with the other postulates. By the end of the 19th century, many mathematicians could no longer share the robust confidence of Immanuel Kant, who had once proclaimed that Euclidean geometry was not only true but necessarily true, "an aspect of the human mind, the expression of the way the mind confronted the sensuous world of shapes."

"The King of Infinite Space" comes alive in the penultimate chapter, on the rise of non-Euclidean geometries. Mr. Berlinski introduces us to the Hungarian mathematician János Bolyai (1802-60), whose father was obsessed with the parallel postulate and tried to warn his son: "I beg you in the name of God. Leave the parallels in peace." His son would not desist. Neither would the Russian mathematician Nicolai Lobachevsky (1792-1856) or the Italian Eugenio Beltrami (1835-1900), who took things further by devising a physical model of non-Euclidean space, the Beltrami pseudosphere. Later, the French philosopher and mathematician Henri Poincaré (1854-1912) added another pictorial model to the non-Euclidean gallery, the Poincaré disk. In the end, the combination of illustration and logical proof, so important to Euclid, is what led to his undoing.

This sea change in geometry had far-reaching consequences, especially in the 19th century. In an age of political upheaval, this mathematical revolution provoked a great deal of anxiety. If the axioms of Euclidean geometry were not necessarily true but only true of Euclidean space—which was only one type of possible space among many—what could be necessarily true? As the philosopher Bertrand Russell succinctly put it: "If mathematics was doubtful, how much more doubtful ethics must be." It may be that what Lincoln found in Euclid was not only the notion of a logical demonstration but also the comfort of certainty, necessity and stability in a transformative and tumultuous time.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Cottage Grove Tests Holiday Demand Across Lake Norman

Updated Category News Views 97

Flour and foot traffic make a pretty honest little scoreboard. Cottage Grove Bakery is putting itself in front of Lake Norman shoppers twice on Saturday, November 21, while also taking Thanksgiving orders and laying groundwork for 2027 workplace and school visits. This is not a public-company earnings story, and nobody should pretend a tray of scones is a quarterly...

Continue Reading
Duetti, CesiumAstro, and a Busy NYSE Capital Morning

Updated Category News Views 78

Three very different piles of money are jamming up the November 20 NYSE slate, and that contrast is the whole point. Private music catalogs, space-and-defense communications, and a new stock-and-bond ETF do not belong in the same bucket. Yet all three are competing for investor attention before the opening bell, alongside Danaos Corporation's 20th listing anniversary....

Continue Reading
Cloud Optical Demand Is Running Ahead of Supply in 2026

Updated Category News Views 51

Fiber capacity has become the awkward bottleneck nobody can wish away. Dell’Oro Group says the optical transport equipment market expanded 24% year over year in the third quarter of 2026, with large North American cloud providers doing the heavy lifting. More pointedly, optical vendor revenue tied to those cloud customers jumped 75%. That is not a gentle improvement in...

Continue Reading
Four Data Quality Champions Put Trust on the Board

Updated Category News Views 65

A single rotten customer record can gum up an entire operation faster than most executives care to admit. Bad data does not merely make a dashboard look silly; it can foul forecasts, duplicate work, misdirect automation, and leave an AI project confidently spouting nonsense. That is why Infotech's 2026 Data Quality Emotional Footprint report deserves a look, even if...

Continue Reading
GIGABYTE Pitches Local AI Agents to Enterprise Buyers

Updated Category News Views 72

Enterprise AI has reached the awkward stage where a slick chatbot demo no longer cuts it. GIGABYTE used its November 13 AI Partner Summit at the Pacific Palms Resort to make a more grounded pitch: companies need hardware and software setups that can put AI agents to work without casually tossing proprietary information into somebody else’s cloud. That is a sensible...

Continue Reading
E-Rate Risk and Data Center Rules Demand Attention

Updated Category News Views 71

America’s digital plumbing is getting squeezed at both ends: the public connections nobody notices until they fail, and the industrial-scale computing boom everybody suddenly wants built yesterday. Connected Nation’s two bonus podcast episodes from the Broadband Nation Expo in New Orleans put those pressures side by side, and it is a more useful pairing than it may...

Continue Reading
Oatly’s $4.13 Tender Offer Is a Legal Detour, Not a Sale

Updated Category News Views 88

A $4.13 cash offer trading against a $7.17 close is the sort of thing that makes investors squint hard, and Verlinvest is practically waving a flag telling them why. This is not a conventional attempt to buy Oatly Group AB. It is a technical tender offer built to satisfy Swedish takeover rules while Verlinvest buys out its joint-venture partner’s interest in Oatly’s...

Continue Reading
HVAC’s $383.6 Billion Shift Is About More Than Units

Updated Category News Views 163

Server racks are turning cooling gear into a front-row industrial story, and that deserves more attention than the usual sleepy talk about replacement air conditioners. Frost & Sullivan projects the global HVAC equipment market will reach $383.6 billion by 2031, growing at a 7.0% compound annual rate from 2025. That is a sizable market, sure, but the more interesting...

Continue Reading
AMD Faces Fresh Scrutiny Over China Supply Exposure

Updated Category News Views 130

One nasty report can turn a chip giant’s supply chain into a flashing red light, and that is precisely the mess confronting Advanced Micro Devices investors this week. Shares fell more than 7.7% on November 19 after Hunterbrook Media published allegations involving China-linked sales, firmware and manufacturing relationships. Then, on November 20, shareholder-rights...

Continue Reading
Sprocket’s GigaOm Leap Puts PTaaS Claims Under Scrutiny

Updated Category News Views 44

Security vendors love a shiny quadrant, but this one deserves more than the usual polite golf clap. Sprocket Security moved from Challenger and Outperformer in GigaOm’s 2025 Penetration Testing as a Service assessment to a Leader in the version 5 report released in 2026. That is a meaningful jump in a category where buyers are tired of annual testing reports that go...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

DexCom Faces Class Action Lawsuit Over Securities Fraud Claims

Updated Category News Views 104

Overview of the Class Action Against DexCom, Inc. Investors in DexCom, Inc. are currently navigating important developments as a class action lawsuit has been filed. This legal action involves serious allegations of securities fraud against the company. Shareholders who have purchased DexCom securities may be affected, raising important questions about financial integrity...

Continue Reading
Amaroq Minerals Announces AGM Results and Future Directions

Updated Category News Views 209

Amaroq Minerals Ltd. Annual General Meeting Results Amaroq Minerals Ltd. is proud to share the results from its recent Annual General Meeting (AGM), reflecting a robust commitment from shareholders in shaping the future direction of the company. Held in a welcoming atmosphere, the event focused on critical decisions that underscore the corporation's strategic objectives...

Continue Reading
Explore the Theme of Connection and Creation at CIFF 2026

Updated Category News Views 254

Exciting New Developments at CIFF 2026 CIFF, the China International Furniture Fair, is gearing up for its 57th edition in March 2026. With a fresh theme, "CONNECT • CREATE", the event reflects the dynamic landscape of the furniture industry. The fair will facilitate exceptional connections within the furniture supply chain, including production, distribution, and...

Continue Reading
SpaceX's Starship to Showcase Advanced Starlink Technologies

Updated Category News Views 545

SpaceX's Latest Milestone in Satellite Technology Elon Musk's company, SpaceX, is gearing up for an exciting upcoming test flight of its Starship launch vehicle. The mission's highlight is the planned deployment of 10 model Starlink satellites, marking a significant step in demonstrating SpaceX's prowess in the satellite launch industry. The Innovative Starlink Satellites...

Continue Reading
DATAMYTE Introduces AI Efficiency in Mobile Inspections for APQP

Updated Category News Views 354

Transforming Quality Inspections with AI at DATAMYTE DATAMYTE, a leader in manufacturing technology, is truly reshaping the way inspections are conducted in the industry. By utilizing its innovative DIGITAL CLIPBOARD mobile platform alongside the powerful DATAMYTE GPT Artificial Intelligence System, the company is redefining the manual processes traditionally associated...

Continue Reading