MONTREAL | News Quebec vaccine plan may be rethou
Post# of 22453
Quebec vaccine plan may be rethought after troubling Israeli data, says provincial adviser
Selena Ross
CTV News Montreal Digital Reporter
@seleross Contact
Published Wednesday, January 20, 2021 5:09PM EST
Last Updated Thursday, January 21, 2021 6:14PM EST
SHARE
MONTREAL -- Quebec could change its vaccine strategy based on new data out of Israel about the efficacy of the first dose, on its own, of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine, says a top adviser in the province.
Israel just provided the world with its first large-scale, real-world hint of how effective the first dose of the Pfizer vaccine is before the booster, and it doesn’t seem reassuring for places that have delayed the second shot, including Quebec and the United Kingdom.
Advertisement
Related Stories
Federal advisory board backs up Quebec's off-label vaccine rollout, but gives time frame
Families of first vaccine recipients threaten legal action against Quebec over second dose flip-flop
Pfizer pushes back after Quebec delays second vaccine doses, says data doesn't exist
Quebec adjusting vaccine plan after Pfizer cuts supply, but will keep 90-day booster delay
“We not only monitor the data that comes from Quebec but also what is observed around the world,” Dr. Gaston De Serres, a chief adviser on Quebec’s vaccine strategy, told CTV News.
“Yes, we are looking at the data from Israel and the [Quebec immunization committee] could make recommendations based on this data if necessary," he said.
Complete coverage at CTVNews.ca/coronavirus
Coronavirus newsletter sign-up: Get The COVID-19 Brief sent to your inbox
Data on 200,000 elderly Israelis suggests that the first shot alone only lowered infections by 33 per cent—about a third of the roughly 90-per-cent rate that many experts around the world have predicted.
It’s “concerning in terms of the single-dose policy decision,” said a U.K. scientist, John Robertson, who had previously written about his concerns about the U.K.’s decision, like Quebec’s, to delay booster shots.
Importantly, in terms of understanding the new data, Israel is not delaying boosters. It’s following the timeline set out by Pfizer and giving the second, or “booster,” shot 21 days after the first.
That means the Israeli numbers pertain only to the short time when the elderly people in question had gotten their first shots but hadn't yet gotten boosters. The numbers suggest that even when giving the shots on schedule, the vaccinees didn’t have nearly the protection that was predicted in that short pre-booster interval.
The data doesn’t call into question how well the two doses together work. Pfizer's trial data showed that together, the doses are 95 per cent effective.
But the Pfizer trial wasn’t meant to prove the efficacy of the first dose alone, so the estimates on how well it works without the booster have been just that—estimates—with scientists looking back at the data and trying to gauge whether delaying the second shots will work.
Delaying the boosters, as Quebec is doing for up to 90 days, is meant to give more people a first shot and some heightened, if imperfect, immunity.
The Israel data doesn't help with a bigger uncertainty in places like Quebec: whether, and how much, that first-dose protection could last after the 21-day mark if the booster isn't given. Pfizer says its trial provided no data on this, and the Israel numbers can't fill that gap either.
On Thursday, Quebec's chief public health officer, Dr. Horacio Arruda, said he’s also following the news from Israel but is waiting to read the written results, when they're available, before acting on them. He said he'll pay special attention to the vaccine's effects on people of different ages.
"We will follow it and if there is some data showing that the efficacy is too low... we're going to change [the approach]," Arruda said.
So far all the reports out of Israel are from experts there speaking to media, rather than published findings. A Montreal infectious diseases expert, Dr. Matthew Oughton, also said Thursday he's waiting for written data.
"There’s no manuscript yet to actually analyze," Oughton said.
ISRAEL'S FINDINGS SO FAR
Israel has moved very quickly on vaccination, inoculating 2.2 million Israelis over the last month. It made an agreement to get rapid delivery of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine in return for tracking the effects and sending the manufacturer detailed data.
Two Israeli experts have spoken about the results in recent days.
According to Israeli news channel i24 News, the leader of the country’s vaccine drive, Nachman Ash, told Israeli Hebrew-language outlet Army Radio that "many people have been infected between the first and second injections of the vaccine," and that it was "less effective than we thought.”
Ran Balicer, an Israeli doctor and epidemiologist, and an adviser to the World Health Organization, spoke to the UK outlet Sky News, explaining more about what was found.
"We compared 200,000 people above the age of 60 that were vaccinated,” the outlet quoted Balicer as saying.
“We took a comparison group of 200,000 people, same age, not vaccinated, that were matched to this group on various variables,” he said.
Scientists then compared the daily rate of positive COVID-19 cases between the two groups. They found at first, unsurprisingly, there was no difference in the first two weeks after the shot—the vaccine takes about two weeks to kick in.
After that, starting at 14 days post-vaccination, “a drop of 33 per cent in [positive cases] was witnessed in the vaccinated group and not in the unvaccinated,” Balicer told Sky News.
He called it “really good news,” considering the group did have much more protection than their unvaccinated peers.
SHORT OF ESTIMATES, THOUGH MANY QUESTIONS
However, that number fell far short of the estimate in recent weeks: Dr. De Serres in Quebec, as well as the UK vaccine advisory committee and many other experts, had all said they believed the first shot would be about 90 per cent effective, at least for several weeks, allowing them to delay the booster.
Pfizer has maintained that its trial data only showed a rate of 52.4 per cent efficacity before the second shot and that it knows nothing about what would happen past 21 days.
One question remains around how well the single dose worked to help people fight off serious infections, even if they tested positive for the virus—a key measure. On Wednesday afternoon, Israel's Minister of Health said Ash's comments had been taken "out of context" on this.
The minister clarified that Ash had been discussing how Israel "[has] yet to see a decrease in the number of severely ill patients," not infections, according to the BBC.
And Balicer suggested the surprise in Israel's data may have come partly from the fact that those studied so far have all been elderly, whereas Pfizer's trial subjects were a mix of ages. The immune systems of the elderly aren’t as strong as those of younger people.
Balicer said he expects the Israeli numbers to rise once more young people are included in the group studied.
He also said that real-world data is not the same as trial data—and on the upside, Israel’s data proves beyond a doubt that the vaccine does work, and on the same kind of timeline the Pfizer trial showed.
"This is not the ideal setting of a randomized controlled trial where everything from coaching maintenance to selection of the population of interest is done in a very meticulous way,” he said.
“This is the real world. And so by seeing the real-world impact so early on in the same direction and in the same timing as we've seen in the clinical trials is something that makes us very hopeful.”
According to the BBC, Balicer also said that after the first 33-per-cent drop in infections, the rate of cases continued to drop—meaning immunity appeared to keep growing stronger, in those vaccinated with the first dose—but it was too soon to know more.
QUEBEC URGED TO TAKE A SECOND LOOK
Robertson, a professor of surgery at the University of Nottingham, said Wednesday that he thinks the Israeli results provide strong evidence for Quebec and similar jurisdictions to change course if they’ve delayed second doses.
Earlier this month, Robertson co-published an opinion piece for the BMJ British medical journal arguing that delaying the second dose wasn’t based in firm science.
“The personal and population risks have even greater relevance and urgency for Quebec given the real-life data reported from Israel,” he said Wednesday.
“The second dose should be given on Day 22 as in the Phase 3 trials and approved by regulatory agencies worldwide.”
Pfizer said it has no comment yet on the new data and can only speak about the results of its Phase 3 trial.
--With files from CTV's Emily Campbell
SHARE
Report Error
Editorial standards and policies
Why you can trust CTV News
WATCH MORE FROM CTV NEWS
falseDr. Bonnie Henry is seen in this combination image. (Images via The Canadian Press)
LIVE NOW: B.C. officials on COVID-19 vaccinations
falseMontreal kid a social media star
Montreal boy on autism spectrum becomes social media star
falseCandy company looking for sweets testers
Sweet job alert: Ont. company looking for 'candyologists'
falsedog turkey
Loyal dog waits days outside Turkish hospital for its owner
falseMontreal city spokesperson Philippe Sabourin
Crews are investigating burst pipe: city
falseWarning signs were missing: report
Warning signs missed before 22-year-old's death
MONTREAL TOP STORIES
A woman wears a face mask as she walks along a street in Montreal, Sunday, January 17, 2021, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues in Canada and around the world. The Quebec government has imposed a lockdown and a curfew to help curb the spread of COVID-19. The curfew begins at 8 p.m until 5 a.m and lasting until February 8. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
Quebec adds 1,631 new cases of COVID-19 and 88 deaths as hospitalizations drop
Water main floods busy Montreal intersection
Boil water advisory for sector of Montreal as 138-year-old water main breaks and floods street
Montreal public health director Mylene Drouin
Montreal to deploy rapid coronavirus tests in hotspot neighbourhoods
SPVM, police
How often are homeless Montrealers ticketed? A lot, with sharp increase in recent years, study shows
Arruda
Today marks one year of coronavirus preparation in Quebec
Paula McMahon prepares a shot of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine, as the mass public vaccination program gets underway, at the NHS Louisa Jordan Hospital in Glasgow, Scotland, Tuesday Dec. 8, 2020. Health Canada approved the vaccine Wednesday. (Jeff J Mitchell/Pool via AP)
Quebec vaccine plan may be rethought after troubling Israeli data, says provincial adviser
FEATURED ITEMS
Montreal kid a social media star
Montreal boy on autism spectrum becomes, briefly, a social media star
A Louer sign in Montreal / For Rent
Montreal rental vacancy rate hits six per cent, highest in years, but prices don't seem to be dropping
Thousands of people marched through downtown Montreal on Sat., Sept. 12, 2020 in opposition to Quebec's regulations requiring masks in in door public spaces.
These Canadians lost their loved ones to Qanon. Is there any hope of getting them back?
Puppy prices skyrocket
High demand, higher prices for dogs leads to fears that missing pets were actually stolen
English on Longueuil website removed
Longueuil councillor calls for better access to municipal website after English-language pages removed
CFCF 12 Opening Day
CTV Montreal celebrates its 60th anniversary
DON'T MISS
falseAtlanta Braves' Hank Aaron hits his 715th career homerun, on April 8, 1974. (Harry Harrris / AP)
Baseball Hall of Famer Hank Aaron dead at age 86
falseA staff with a face mask stands near the venue of a lantern containing the Olympic Flame shown prior to public display Monday, Aug. 31, 2020, (AP Photo/Eugene Hoshiko)
Japan says Olympics will go on despite cancellation rumours
falseFormer presidential candidate, Senator Bernie Sanders (D-Vermont) sits in the bleachers on Capitol Hill before Joe Biden is sworn in as the 46th US President on January 20, 2021, at the US Capitol in Washington, DC. (Photo by Brendan SMIALOWSKI / AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images)
Bundled-up Bernie Sanders Inauguration Day meme goes viral
falseMontreal kid a social media star
Montreal boy on autism spectrum becomes social media star
falseThousands of dollars was found in a donation to a Vancouver Value Village.
$85K in cash accidentally donated to B.C. Value Village
falseFrankie MacDonald
Amateur N.S. weatherman starts GoFundMe page for dad in need
CTVNEWS.CA TOP STORIES
Gov. Gen. Julie Payette leaves along with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau after delivering the throne speech in the Senate chamber in Ottawa on Wednesday, Sept. 23, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyl
UPDATED
PM acknowledges 'difficult situations' for GG Payette's staff, will reassess how successor is picked
A dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine is prepared by Pharmacy Technician Supervisor Tamara Booth Rumsey at The Michener Institute in Toronto on Monday January 4, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Frank Gunn
Ontario reports fewer than 2,700 new cases of COVID-19 as positivity rate continues to drop
Capitol chaos
Capitol chaos: Inside the volatile days leading up to Biden's inauguration
A group of anti-lockdown protesters march in downtown Toronto on Saturday, January 9, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Colin Perkel
UPDATED
'It's garbage': Infectious disease expert debunks 'Facts Not Fear' COVID-19 flyer
In this Aug. 2, 2018, file photo, a protesters holds a Q sign waits in line with others to enter a campaign rally with President Donald Trump in Wilkes-Barre, Pa. (AP Photo/Matt Rourke, File)
Is this the end of QAnon? The reckoning inside the conspiracy theory that snared thousands
Atlanta Braves' Hank Aaron hits his 715th career homerun, on April 8, 1974. (Harry Harrris / AP)
Hank Aaron, baseball's one-time home run king, dies at 86
60th anniversary
MOST-WATCHED
falseWarning signs were missing: report
Warning signs missed before 22-year-old's death
falsePoet Amanda Gorman's grandmother reacts
Poet Amanda Gorman's grandmother reacts
falseAmerican poet Amanda Gorman reads a poem during the 59th Presidential Inauguration at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Wednesday, Jan. 20, 2021. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky, Pool)
'The Hill We Climb' by Amanda Gorman
falseGov. Gen. Julie Payette takes the royal salute from the Guard of Honour as she makes her way deliver the the throne speech, Wednesday, September 23, 2020 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand
CTV National News: Julie Payette resigns
falseA Louer sign in Montreal / For Rent
Montreal vacancy rate hits 6%
MOST-READ
Paula McMahon prepares a shot of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine, as the mass public vaccination program gets underway, at the NHS Louisa Jordan Hospital in Glasgow, Scotland, Tuesday Dec. 8, 2020. Health Canada approved the vaccine Wednesday. (Jeff J Mitchell/Pool via AP)
Quebec vaccine plan may be rethought after troubling Israeli data, says provincial adviser
Water main floods busy Montreal intersection
Boil water advisory for sector of Montreal as 138-year-old water main breaks and floods street
A man jogs along a street prior to a curfew in Montreal, Saturday, January 9, 2021, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues in Canada and around the world. The Quebec government has imposed a curfew to help stop the spread of COVID-19 starting at 8 p.m until 5 a.m. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
Truckers driving at night annoyed by Quebec's ban on tobacco products during curfew
A woman wears a face mask as she walks along a street in Montreal, Sunday, January 17, 2021, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues in Canada and around the world. The Quebec government has imposed a lockdown and a curfew to help curb the spread of COVID-19. The curfew begins at 8 p.m until 5 a.m and lasting until February 8. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
Quebec adds 1,631 new cases of COVID-19 and 88 deaths as hospitalizations drop
Personal protection equipment is seen on the teacher's desk in classroom in preparation for the new school year at the Willingdon Elementary School in Montreal, on Wednesday, August 26, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson
OPINION
Opinion: Time for Quebec public health officials to tell government, 'that's enough!' when it comes to COVID-19 and schools
FOLLOW ON
Political Ads Registry
Use of this Website assumes acceptance of Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy
© 2021Bell MediaAll rights reserved.