It's for Mike Pence to Judge whether a Presidential

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
energy_wave
218
It's for Mike Pence to Judge whether a Presidential Election Was Held at All

Quote:
By Ted Noel

On January 6, a joint session of Congress will open with Vice President Pence presiding as president of the Senate. His power will be plenary and unappealable. You heard that right. As president of the Senate, every objection comes directly to him, and he can rule any objection "out of order" or "denied." His task will be to fulfill his oath of office to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States and to ensure that the laws be faithfully executed. This is a high standard of performance, and V.P. Pence will have two choices. He can roll over on "certified" electors, or he can uphold the law.

Article II, Section 1 of the Constitution gives state legislatures "plenary authority" as enunciated in Bush v. Gore. This is key, since the counting of votes is discussed in Article II, the 12th Amendment, and 3 USC 15. To this we must add the history of counting and objections recounted by Alexander Macris (here and here). Put bluntly, it's as clear as mud. Add to that the fact that the contested states of Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, New Mexico, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin have sent dueling slates of electors to D.C. This means that the V.P. has to decide how he will handle the situation when two sealed envelopes are handed to him from any of those states.

Macris points out that in 1800, even with constitutional deficiencies in Georgia, Thomas Jefferson blithely counted defective electoral votes from Georgia, effectively voting himself into the presidency. This demonstrates that the president of the Senate is the final authority on any motions or objections during the vote-counting. There is no appeal. That doesn't mean there won't be any outrage. Whatever Pence does, people will be angry. But what does the law demand?

Seven contested states clearly violated their own laws. Rather than list the facts, which have been detailed in multiple articles, we must consider the following:

An election is a process of counting votes for candidates. Only valid, lawful votes may be counted. A valid lawful vote is:

Cast by an eligible, properly registered elector as prescribed by laws enacted by the state Legislature.
Cast in a timely manner, as prescribed by laws enacted by the state Legislature.
Cast in a proper form as prescribed by laws enacted by the state Legislature.

Any process that does not follow these rules is not an election. Anything that proceeds from it cannot be regarded as having any lawful import.

Most commentators suggest that a process of collecting pieces of paper with marks on them is an election regardless of errors, omissions, and even deliberate malfeasance. This is a mistake. Imagine a golf tournament where every bad shot by one player gets a do-over, but the competing player has to follow USGA rules in detail. One player gets to drop freely out of hazards, but the other has to tackle every embedded ball as it lies. The result is a travesty.

The same thing applies to elections. If there are a handful of improper votes, we can suggest that there was in fact an election, perhaps tainted, but the election wasn't materially harmed. But when the people charged with managing the election decide to ignore the law, whatever process they supervise is not the process defined by the law. Therefore, it is not an election.

This leaves V.P. Pence with a dilemma. He is a gentleman who regards our governmental traditions with a degree of reverence, so he will be reluctant to take any bold action. But as an honorable man, faced with massive illegality, he must act to protect the law. Consider how things might go down as the two closed envelopes from Georgia are handed to the V.P. Rather than opening them, he says:

In my hand are envelopes purporting to contain electoral votes from Georgia. They are competing for consideration, so it is essential that I consider the law that governs this. That law, according to the Legislature of Georgia and Article II, Section 1 of the U.S. Constitution is the Georgia statute that includes procedures for signature-matching on absentee ballots, a requirement that all absentee ballots be first requested by a legitimate voter, and that election monitors be meaningfully present at all times while votes were counted.

The Georgia secretary of state, who is not empowered by the U.S. Constitution to make changes to election law, entered into a Consent Decree that gutted these protections enacted by the Georgia Legislature. The processes that he prescribed and were ultimately followed were manifestly contrary to that law. Further, the State of Georgia, in unprecedented concert with other states, suspended counting of ballots in the middle of the night, covering its conspiracy with a false claim of a "water main break." We now know from surveillance video that many thousands of "ballots" were counted unlawfully in the absence of legally required observers.

Finally, the State of Georgia, under the authority of secretary of state Brad Raffensperger, a non-legislative actor, used fatally flawed Dominion voting machines that have been demonstrated to be unreliable. In testing, the error rate of Dominion machines has exceeded 60%, far in excess of legal limits. They are designed to facilitate fraud without creating the legally required paper trail. This alone is far more than enough to swing an election.

Since the state of Georgia has failed to follow the election law established by its legislature under Article II, Section 1 of the Constitution, it has not conducted a presidential election. Therefore, no "presidential electors" were appointed in Georgia. Further, "electors" "certified" by non-legislative actors pursuant to this process are in fact not "presidential electors." The competing slate of "electors" is similarly deficient, having not been elected through a presidential election.

Therefore, the chair rules that Georgia has not transmitted the votes of any presidential electors to this body. Georgia presents zero votes for Donald Trump and zero votes for Joseph Biden.

The central point is that the VP, as the presiding officer and final authority, has the unquestionable authority to declare that the states in question have not conducted presidential elections. There will be wailing and gnashing of teeth, but no one has the authority to override his decision.

The statement says nothing about who might or might not have "won" the contested states. Rather, by not following their own laws, as enacted by their own legislatures, they have violated Article II, Section 1. Thus, they have not conducted an election, and their results are void.

If the votes of all seven contested states are registered as zero, President Trump will have 232 votes, and Joe Biden will have 222. The 12th Amendment says, "The votes shall then be counted. ... The person having the greatest number of votes for President, shall be the President."

In plain language, Donald Trump will be re-elected, since he has a majority of the actual electoral votes. There will be no need to involve the House of Representatives to resolve a contingent election.

Richard Nixon chose not to contest the 1960 election because he felt that winning that way would lead to an ungovernable country. If V.P. Pence does this, that same argument might be made. But is the country governable even now? Blue states such as California, Oregon, Washington, New York, New Jersey, and Michigan are already operating in an openly lawless manner with their "emergency" "COVID-related" restrictions. Their denial of the civil rights of law-abiding citizens is horrific. Their refusal to do basic policing and law enforcement is a recipe for open war. How much worse would things be if the V.P. lived up to his oath and upheld the law?

Ted Noel posts on multiple sites as DoctorTed and @vidzette.


https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2020...t_all.html
big-wave_surfing_01.jpg
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Insider Risk Makes Human Judgment a Security Priority

Updated Category News Views 165

A badge, a password, and a locked gate can all look reassuring right up until the person holding them starts to crack. Signpost Six's new report, The Psychology of Insider Risk, lands on an uncomfortable truth: the most consequential security weakness may not be a system at all. It may be an employee under strain, in conflict, in debt, making a mistake, or being quietly...

Continue Reading
Teachers in Space Takes Its Classroom Model Orbital

Updated Category News Views 107

Two teachers strapped into a research flight may sound like a glossy space-age photo op, but the useful part of this plan sits back in the classroom with the students staring at the data. Teachers in Space wants to send two educators aboard a Virgin Galactic research flight expected in 2027, and it is raising $2 million to fund the broader educational program and mission....

Continue Reading
Hagerty's Fifth Film Win Keeps Its Media Engine Humming

Updated Category News Views 67

A lap record, a camera crew, and five straight trophies make a louder statement than another glossy corporate slogan. Hagerty won Best Journalism Film at the 2026 International Motor Film Awards on Nov. 14, held at the Petersen Automotive Museum in Los Angeles. The company has taken that particular award home five years running, powered again by Jason Cammisa and his...

Continue Reading
Jumia’s Breakeven Retreat Invites Legal Scrutiny

Updated Category News Views 108

Jumia’s credibility problem did not arrive wearing a disguise. The company spent much of 2026 telling investors that a fourth-quarter Adjusted EBITDA breakeven was still on the table, then discarded that target after reporting third-quarter results. For holders of NYSE:JMIA, that kind of reversal stings because the promise was not some stray talking point; it was...

Continue Reading
Marina del Rey's Travel Award Brings Fresh Attention

Updated Category News Views 78

A harbor town just got handed a useful little megaphone. On November 18, 2026, the Marina del Rey Tourism Board said Marina del Rey had been selected as a winner in Good Housekeeping's 2027 Travel Awards. That is not a quarterly earnings event, and nobody ought to dress it up as one. Still, in the visitor economy, recognition from a broad consumer publication can matter...

Continue Reading
Nellie's 50% Booking Jump Reveals a Quieter Luxury

Updated Category News Views 124

Silicon Valley’s rich are apparently tired of performing wealth for strangers, and frankly, that tracks. Nellie’s 2027 forecast says its mostly tech-money clientele is moving past the old trophy case of private jets, famous resort towns, and suites priced like small houses. The prize now is privacy, a clean schedule, and somebody competent fixing the ugly little...

Continue Reading
Norfolk Southern's 200-Year Campaign Meets a Hard Market

Updated Category News Views 61

Two centuries of railroad history can stir the blood, but it does not move a single carload by itself. Norfolk Southern has opened its 200-year railroading celebration with the GeneratioNS campaign, a three-locomotive NS 200 commemorative series, and plans for public events across its network. For a railroad with deep roots and very modern operational pressures, this is...

Continue Reading
Sokin’s UAE License Turns Expansion Into Real Payments Plumbing

Updated Category News Views 118

Dubai expansion headlines are cheap; regulated local money movement is not. That is why Sokin’s newly approved Dubai Financial Services Authority license deserves more than the usual fintech applause line. The company has paired that approval with AED accounts, local payment rails, a One Za’abeel office and a plan to double its UAE staff over the next year. None of...

Continue Reading
Lithium's Next Leg Depends on Storage, Not EV Hype

Updated Category News Views 93

Grid batteries are quietly becoming lithium’s second engine, and that matters more than another flashy electric-vehicle sales headline. The market is projected to rise from $40.87 billion in 2026 to $57.77 billion by 2031, a 7.2% compound annual growth rate. Respectable growth, certainly. But this is not a straight line, and anybody treating a five-year market forecast...

Continue Reading
First US Extends Buyback Clock Through Year-End 2027

Updated Category News Views 123

A buyback extension is not a thunderclap; it is a bank board keeping a useful tool within reach. First US Bancshares has pushed the expiration of its existing repurchase authorization from December 31, 2026, to December 31, 2027. That matters, but investors ought to resist turning a calendar change into a grand earnings prophecy. The company has bought back 2,122,972...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

City National Rochdale Welcomes New Leadership with CEO Appointment

Updated Category News Views 270

New Leadership at City National Rochdale City National Rochdale, LLC is thrilled to announce the promotion of Gregg Giaquinto to the position of Chief Executive Officer. With over 25 years of experience in the financial services sector, Giaquinto is poised to lead the firm into its next chapter. Experience and Strategic Vision Giaquinto's journey with City National...

Continue Reading
Tesla's EV Deliveries Struggle Against Growing Competition

Updated Category News Views 119

Tesla's Challenges in EV Deliveries Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) delivered approximately 1.64 million electric vehicles in a recent year, falling behind competitors like BYD, which surpassed 2.2 million deliveries. This represents a second consecutive annual decline for Tesla, signifying growing challenges within its automotive sector. The significant drop in deliveries during...

Continue Reading
Greenwave Technology Solutions Boosts Rare-Earth Recycling Efforts

Updated Category News Views 208

Greenwave Technology Solutions Expands Rare-Earth Metal Recovery In light of recent supply chain challenges, Greenwave Technology Solutions, Inc. (NASDAQ: GWAV) is intensifying its initiatives to recover rare-earth metals from end-of-life products. With key minerals being restricted from export, such as gallium and germanium, the company's moves come at a crucial time,...

Continue Reading
Eyenovia Explores Strategic Opportunities with Chardan's Help

Updated Category News Views 267

Eyenovia Engages Chardan for Strategic Alternatives Review Recently, Eyenovia, Inc. (NASDAQ: EYEN), an innovative ophthalmic technology company, outlined its plans to evaluate various strategic opportunities. By partnering with Chardan, the company will assess a broad spectrum of options aimed at optimizing its business operations and future growth prospects. Advancements...

Continue Reading
Pandion Optimization Alliance: A Legacy of 100 Years Empowering Collaboration

Updated Category News Views 291

Pandion Optimization Alliance Celebrates 100 Years of Success This month marks a momentous occasion for Pandion Optimization Alliance as it celebrates a century of uniting organizations through collaboration and shared strength. What initiated as a small rural hospital project in 1925 has now transformed into a massive multi-billion-dollar marketplace. The vision of the...

Continue Reading