Will US Ever Get to Mass Testing for COVID-19? Dec 03,

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
TedJ
515
Will US Ever Get to Mass Testing for COVID-19?
Dec 03, 2020 | Adam Bonislawski
Premium
Save for later

NEW YORK – Nine months into the coronavirus pandemic, population-scale testing for SARS-CoV-2 remains elusive, but signs suggest we may be reaching a stage in which testing of tens of millions of people in the US on a regular basis may become feasible.

According to data from The COVID Tracking Project, US testing for SARS-COV-2 hit an all-time high over the last two weeks with an average of 1.7 million tests performed per day, including a record 2.1 million tests reported on November 27.


Rising COVID-19 cases numbers and the Thanksgiving holiday drove the increase, which further challenged the country's already strained testing capacity. News outlets reported people waiting in hours-long lines for SARS-CoV-2 testing around the country. On November 24, Quest Diagnostics reported that turnaround times for its SARS-CoV-2 molecular testing had risen to an average of two to three days for patients overall and around two days for priority patients. This followed a warning earlier in the month from the American Clinical Laboratory Association, which represents Quest and a number of other large lab firms, that the increase in demand could lead to shortages of important testing supplies and longer turnaround times.

Even at these record testing volumes, however, the country still fell short of the numbers required for various mass testing programs various researchers and organizations have proposed as way of controlling the pandemic. Since the spring, figures like Harvard epidemiologist Michael Mina, New York University economist Paul Romer, and non-profit organization the Rockefeller Foundation have called for regular population scale testing for the virus as a means of stopping its spread.

In interviews, Romer has suggested around 23 million tests per day would be needed under the plan. Mina has similarly called for in the range of 10 million to 20 million tests per day, while the Rockefeller proposal calls for a somewhat more modest 30 million tests per week. However, even that number significantly outstrips current testing capacity.

There is reason to think, though, that the nation's SARS-CoV-2 testing capacity is on the brink of a dramatic expansion, particularly on the antigen testing side.

A number of in vitro diagnostic firms have launched both instrument-based and instrument-free point-of-care rapid antigen tests for SARS-CoV-2 in recent months. In August, Abbott received US Food and Drug Administration Emergency Use Authorization for its BinaxNow COVID-19 Ag, an instrument-free lateral flow SARS-CoV-2 antigen test that costs $5 and returns results in 15 minutes. The company said it can produce tens of millions of these tests per month. Roche has an instrument-free rapid antigen test under consideration for EUA that it has said it will also be able to produce at levels of tens of millions per month.

Meanwhile, firms including Quidel and BD have been selling instrument-based rapid antigen tests since the summer. On Quidel's recent Q3 2020 earnings call, Quidel CEO Douglas Bryant said the company is currently producing around 2.1 million SARS-CoV-2 rapid antigen tests per week.

While rapid antigen tests aren't as accurate as PCR-based tests for SARS-CoV-2, any population-scale testing would rely on such tests because of their faster time to results and lower costs.

Such antigen tests have significantly expanded testing capacity beyond what was possible relying only on lab-based nucleic acid assays, and an explosion in antigen testing capacity is coming in Q1 2021, said Ted Meigs is cofounder, president, and CEO of Kinematic Automation.

The Twain Harte, California-based firm makes the automated manufacturing systems used to produce medical equipment including the sort of point-of-care assays used to test for SARS-CoV-2. Meigs said that based on the orders and delivery timelines he and others in the business were seeing, he expected test capacity to expand by roughly tenfold in the first quarter of next year. Such an expansion would be more than enough to hit the numbers required by the Rockefeller plan and could even approach the capacity called for by figures like Mina and Romer.

Mara Aspinall, professor of practice, biomedical diagnostics at Arizona State University as well as the former president of CEO of Ventana Medical Systems, coauthored Rockefeller's National COVID-19 National Testing & Contact Tracing Action Plan. Like Meigs, she is anticipating a large expansion of antigen testing capacity in Q1 2021.

"I believe there will be a sea change at the beginning of 2021," she said, adding that she expects to see a quadrupling of volume.

Capacity is only one part of the challenge, though. Another key question mass testing efforts face is how to most effectively deploy that capacity.

Aspinall said that she sees antigen testing as breaking down into three basic categories: home tests, point-of-care test, and lab-based tests.

This latter category has received heightened attention recently as companies like Ortho Clinical Diagnostics and DiaSorin have announced plans to offer lab-based SARS-CoV-2 antigen tests. Most of the discussion of rapid antigen testing has focused on its point-of-care and home applications. However, Chockalingam Palaniappan, chief innovation officer at Ortho Clinical Diagnostics, said that lab-based antigen testing could provide a faster, higher-throughput alternative to molecular testing and could potentially be used to test large numbers of people in a way that is less feasible with point-of-care antigen testing, where the per test processing time makes it impractical to test large numbers of people given that samples must be run serially as opposed to in batches.

"Say you go to a university campus with 20,000 to 30,000 students, you give them all a swab, get them collected, by the next morning, all of those test [results] will be available," he said. "Our machines are located in many central laboratories, and each machine can process around 3,000 tests per day. So ten machines, that is about 30,000 tests."

Aspinall likewise highlighted the potential of lab-based antigen testing.

"I think that a central lab antigen test which is a batch system where you can load a thousand tests and get answers very quickly is absolutely critical to fighting the next stage of the pandemic where we need to be doing fast and frequent tests," she said.

Aspinall noted that even the fastest lab-based molecular tests take at least two hours with most taking significantly longer. A lab-based antigen test, on the other hand, can be done in under 30 minutes.

"So we have the ability to get results out much faster than PCR," she said.

The other obvious path to mass testing is widespread home testing. Mina, in particular, has advocated strongly for regular home testing using inexpensive tests like lateral flow assays that people could perhaps buy in packages containing multiple tests. Such tests would likely be less sensitive than molecular tests, and SARS-CoV-2 antigen tests have run into performance issues with, for instance, the FDA issuing a letter last month warning about the potential for false positive results from SARS-CoV-2 rapid antigen test. Mina and other advocates argue, however, that such performance issues can be accounted for by serial testing; hence the need for these tests to be inexpensive and widely available in large numbers.

The problem is that no such tests exist as of yet. A number of companies including OraSure Technologies and E25Bio are developing home antigen tests while others like Mammoth Biosciences and UbiDx are working on home molecular tests. In November, FDA granted the first EUA for a start-to-finish home-based COVID-19 test – to Lucira Health's Lucira COVID-19 All-in-One home test, which uses real-time loop-mediated isothermal amplification to detect SARS-CoV-2 RNA, though that test will be relatively expensive at around $50 and will not be available nationwide until spring of 2021.

Aspinall is on the board of OraSure, which is developing a SARS-CoV-2 rapid antigen test for three different EUA submissions — for use by a medical professional, for use by patients who are prescribed a test by a medical professional, and as an over-the-counter product. The company plans to make an EUA submission in the first quarter of 2021. It originally planned to submit this fall but has pushed back its development timeline.

Aspinall said that developing a home test with data that ensures accurate and reproducible results is a substantial challenge and one that takes time.

She also noted that FDA has "appropriately" high performance standards for home tests, calling for 80 percent sensitivity and 99 percent specificity for home tests available by prescription and for 90 percent sensitivity and 99 percent specificity for over-the-counter tests.

Advocates of home testing like Mina have criticized these requirements, arguing that lower-performance home tests that returned results rapidly and could be used frequently could still be effective at preventing spread of the virus. Previously, an FDA official told 360Dx on background that these benchmarks are not hard-and-fast cutoffs that tests must hit in order to receive EUA. The official said that the agency was open to considering a variety of SARS-CoV-2 testing approaches including lower sensitivity rapid tests that could be used at home in a serial manner. They highlighted Abbott's ID Now SARS-CoV-2 test as an example of the agency's willingness to consider trade-offs between test performance and convenience and turnaround time. While the Abbott test has shown relatively high levels of false negatives in some studies, the fact that it works at the point-of-care and provides rapid results adds value that compensates for lower sensitivity, the official suggested.

On a September call for labs and test developers, Timothy Stenzel, director of the Office of In Vitro Diagnostics and Radiological Health at the FDA's Center for Devices and Radiological Health, entertained a serial testing scenario much like those proposed by Mina.

"Where our recommended levels of sensitivity may not be achieved with a single test result in a home situation, maybe with the paper strip test, strategies utilizing serial testing, for less sensitive tests, could be deployed," he said, noting that in the case of a test with, for instance, 70 percent sensitivity, "perhaps with a two-pack, two test results you can achieve a greater sensitivity together."

Aspinall noted that while the FDA guidelines call for 99 percent specificity, data published by Lucira on its home test show 98 percent specificity, indicating that the agency may be flexible on its stated performance requirements.

Several lab-based molecular tests have received EUA for asymptomatic testing. No rapid antigen tests have received EUA for asymptomatic testing, though many are being used for that purpose.

Were a plan like Mina's to prove tractable from the capacity and regulatory standpoints, another challenge would remain — ensuring that people use the tests correctly and modify their behavior appropriately in response to the results.

This is an issue for any testing regime, but it is particularly so for a mass testing approach that relies on frequent serial testing to counter relatively low test performance. As organizations ranging from the National Football League to the White House have discovered, access to testing can only do so much to prevent spread of the virus in the absence of close adherence to other practices like physical distancing and mask wearing.

"We need to think about how to make sure people understand both the benefits and limitations of these tests," said Brandon Marshall, an epidemiologist at Brown University who has worked with the Rockefeller Foundation to develop communications materials to help public health experts educate people about asymptomatic COVID-19 testing.

"No test is 100 percent accurate, so it's never going to be a panacea," he said. "It's got to be one tool in the toolbox that includes consistent masking, social distancing, and so forth."

1

Quantum Materials Corp. (QTMM) Stock Research Links

QTMM Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Cadence Marks $2.7 Million for St. Jude Family Care

Updated Category News Views 93

Small Wheels, Serious Purpose Tiny tricycles, flour-dusted bake-sale tables, and family pledges have pushed Cadence Education’s St. Jude partnership to $2.7 million since 2018. That number is not a flashy balance-sheet item, nor should anybody try to dress it up as one. It is the accumulated result of school communities showing up year after year, and in a sector built...

Continue Reading
Qonto's Banking License Raises the Stakes in Europe

Updated Category News Views 100

A regulatory stamp can look dull on paper, yet this one changes the machinery underneath Qonto. The Paris-based finance platform has received a Credit Institution license from France's ACPR and the European Central Bank, giving it a route to offer broader lending and savings products directly to small and midsize businesses across Europe. That is a serious corporate...

Continue Reading
ZAKSIMLAB Tests Kombucha and Salmon Snack Pairing in Cafes

Updated Category News Views 181

A fish-based chip beside a fizzy tea mix is an odd little commercial wager, and that is exactly why ZAKSIMLAB's latest move deserves a look. The Seoul food brand launched Salmon Crunch Protein Chips in September, then put the snack next to its powdered kombucha at the 2026 Cafe & Bakery Fair Season 2. This is not a grand earnings story; no sales, pricing, store-count, or...

Continue Reading
Rehab Equipment Growth Meets a Brutal Access Gap

Updated Category News Views 27

Rehabilitation demand is piling up faster than the equipment can reach people. That is the uncomfortable fact sitting beneath Wissen Research's forecast for a global rehabilitation equipment market rising from $19.1 billion in 2026 to $25.8 billion by 2031, a 6.2% annual growth rate. It is a respectable expansion story, not some rocket-ship fairy tale. More important, it...

Continue Reading
ELEGOO's Formnext Push Tests a Broader 3D Ambition

Updated Category News Views 204

Frankfurt’s show floor is where product promises meet some very unforgiving eyeballs. ELEGOO arrived at Formnext 2026 with more than a refreshed machine or two: it is laying out a wider bet across resin printing, FDM printing, and 3D scanning. That matters because the company is no longer presenting itself as merely a supplier of affordable creator hardware. It wants to...

Continue Reading
Cedar’s Fast 500 Spot Shows Billing Tech’s Momentum

Updated Category News Views 26

A 486th-place finish can look like the last seat on the bus, but Cedar’s 102% revenue growth from 2022 through 2025 is not nothing. Healthcare billing is a miserable, deeply entrenched corner of the economy where legacy systems have had decades to dig in. Growing at all while selling technology into health systems deserves a serious look, even if nobody should confuse a...

Continue Reading
Another Nine's A9OS Puts Software at Center of Golf

Updated Category News Views 9

A golf simulator chain is trying to turn the boring plumbing into its sharpest club. Another Nine’s A9OS is not merely a booking widget dressed up for a franchise brochure; it is meant to run the whole 24/7 operation, from payments and door access to cameras, simulator support and guest help. That ambition deserves attention because this is exactly where a staff-free...

Continue Reading
MIND Takes Its Copilot Security Bet Across Microsoft 365

Updated Category News Views 59

Copilot’s promise gets a lot less charming the minute confidential files start wandering around unchecked. That is the knot MIND is trying to untie with its expanded, generally available integrations across Microsoft Copilot, Microsoft 365, Purview, Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive, Edge and Exchange. The Seattle data-loss-prevention company announced the collaboration on...

Continue Reading
Iberostar's Grand Move: Opening in Zanzibar

Updated Category News Views 267

The Resort That Takes Your Breath Away Here we have Iberostar, boldly wading into the azure waters of the Indian Ocean, planting its flag on the sandy beaches of Zanzibar. This isn’t just another notch on the resort’s belt—it’s their first time setting up shop in East Africa, a move ripe with promise and adventure both. A Suite So Sweet 358 suites, mind you. Each...

Continue Reading
Albany Masonry Waterproofing Is a Quiet Value Play

Updated Category News Views 74

Winter works its mischief one soaked brick at a time. That is the unglamorous truth behind Sean Mulligan's discussion of masonry waterproofing for Albany-area homes. Brick and stone look tough enough to outlast the furniture, the siding, maybe the whole neighborhood. Yet they are porous materials, and in a region where rain, snowmelt, and sharp temperature swings keep...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Exploring Digital Twin Advancements in Aerospace and Defense

Updated Category News Views 435

Innovations in Digital Twin Technology for Aerospace and Defense In the fast-evolving world of technology, digital twins have emerged as a transformative asset, especially in the Aerospace and Defense sectors. Recently, the Digital Twin Consortium (DTC) has published an insightful whitepaper titled Aerospace-Defense: Digital Twin Research and Technology Gap Analysis. This...

Continue Reading
Arlo Technologies to Showcase Innovations at Upcoming Conference

Updated Category News Views 126

Arlo Technologies to Present at Piper Sandler Growth Frontiers Conference Arlo Technologies, Inc. (NYSE: ARLO), a top contender in the smart home security landscape, is gearing up to showcase its latest achievements at the Piper Sandler Growth Frontiers Conference. This esteemed event highlights innovative companies leading the way in technology, and Arlo is set to make a...

Continue Reading
Plug's Innovative Trade Desk Revolutionizes EV Market Dynamics

Updated Category News Views 833

Plug's Groundbreaking Initiatives in the Electric Vehicle Sector With a substantial seed funding of $6.7 million, Plug is making significant waves in the electric vehicle (EV) market by launching its pioneering Trade Desk. This service is tailored exclusively for EVs, setting a new precedent in the automotive industry, as it allows dealerships to assess, price, and...

Continue Reading
Exciting Winter and Spring Events at Long Island Aquarium

Updated Category News Views 215

Exciting Upcoming Events at Long Island Aquarium The Long Island Aquarium is thrilled to share its lineup of engaging events for winter and spring. Visitors can expect a variety of experiences designed to entertain the whole family. Whether you're a local resident or just visiting, there's something for everyone at this spectacular underwater haven. Culinary Delights...

Continue Reading
Bakkt Holdings, Inc. Announces Third Quarter Earnings Call

Updated Category News Views 91

Bakkt Holdings, Inc. Sets Conference Call for Q3 Earnings Bakkt Holdings, Inc. (NYSE: BKKT) is making waves as it prepares to discuss its financial results for the third quarter of 2024. The company has scheduled the earnings announcement for a date soon approaching, promising insights that will interest investors and analysts alike. Details of the Earnings Call The...

Continue Reading