Alaska Journal of Commerce Corps receives, but doesn’t

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
NotRichYet2
1,384
Alaska Journal of Commerce Corps receives, but doesn’t release, final Pebble mitigation plan
Corps receives, but doesn’t release, final Pebble mitigation plan
By: Elwood Brehmer
Alaska Journal of Commerce
Post date:
Wed, 11/18/2020 - 9:02am
The Pebble Partnership submitted its final paper to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers two days ahead of its Nov. 18 deadline, but the last key piece of the project that has garnered significant attention from the White House will be kept under wraps for the time being, according to Corps officials.

Pebble’s final compensatory mitigation plan needs to offset the loss or degradation to nearly 3,300 acres of wetlands and 185 miles of streams, largely through direct “in-kind” compensatory mitigation measures to preserve areas within the remote Koktuli River watershed where the proposed mine sites, according to requirements the Corps of Engineers established in late August.

The company was also required to deliver the plan within 90 days in a letter Corps Alaska Regulatory Division Chief David Hobbie sent to Pebble leaders Aug. 24.

A spokesman confirmed via email that the Corps had received Pebble’s final mitigation plan and indicated it is currently under review and will be released when it is deemed compliant with applicable regulations, but when that will be is unclear.

Questions regarding the authority under which the document would be withheld from the public were not answered in time for this story.

Advertisement

Pebble spokesman Mike Heatwole said the company would wait for the Corps to release the mitigation plan.

According to officials for the Alaska Department of Natural Resources officials, which manages state land, the agency also has not received a final copy of Pebble’s wetlands mitigation plan either.

The compensatory mitigation plan is the last piece of Pebble’s plan the Corps needed before issuing a record of decision on the project — the key federal approval or denial.

Ron Thiessen, CEO of Pebble’s parent company Vancouver-based Northern Dynasty Minerals Ltd. said the final Pebble environmental impact statement published by the Corps in July already concluded that the large open-pit copper and gold project can operate in-concert with the Bristol Bay ecosystem and meeting the mitigation requirements will provide further evidence that Pebble “can and will co-exist with commercial, subsistence and sport fisheries in Southwest Alaska.”

“The ‘in-kind’ and ‘in-watershed’ requirement for mitigation the (Army Corps) established for Pebble clearly sets a high bar for offsetting project effects on wetlands and other aquatic features, but it’s a challenge we have embraced and believe we can achieve,” Thiessen said.

With little development in the Koktuli drainage and large tracts of state land, traditional means of compensatory mitigation such as restoring damaged wetlands or preserving areas under the threat of development were largely viewed as very challenged by the Corps’ requirements by project observers.

The Pebble deposit is also on state land.

Former Pebble CEO Tom Collier said in response to the mitigation thresholds that the company would likely focus its mitigation plan on preserving an area several times larger than the aquatic areas impacted by the project.

Collier abruptly resigned from Pebble in September following the release of a recorded videoconference by individuals posing as potential Chinese investors dubbed the “Pebble Tapes” in which Collier and Thiessen were recorded boasting about their relationships with state and federal officials and plans to greatly expand the mine .

The stringent mitigation requirements laid out by the Corps were in sharp contrast to Pebble’s proposed mitigation plan and guidelines issued by the Trump administration in 2018 specifically for Alaska that emphasized flexibility in mitigation requirements for projects in the state given its relative abundance of wetlands.

They also seem to contradict the final EIS, which generally maintained the conclusions in the draft EIS and states there would be “no measurable change” in the numbers of salmon returning to the Nushagak and Kvichak rivers or in the long-term health of the commercial fisheries in the region. The Koktuli River is in the upper reaches of the Nushagak watershed.

Pebble’s initial compensatory mitigation plan released in January relied on a collection of smaller — and likely less costly — mitigation efforts outside of the Koktuli watershed.

The company first planned to replace culverts in the Dillingham area to restore salmon access to about nine miles of spawning and rearing habitat; improve water treatment facilities at villages near the mine site; and periodically clean debris from seven miles of beach around the Cook Inlet port site.

DNR spokesman Dan Saddler wrote that the Division of Mining, Land and Water staff met with Pebble representatives four times, the last time on Sept. 10, to discuss state law and processes regarding wetlands. DNR officials did not discuss Pebble’s plan after the Corps’ August letter, according to Saddler.

“In the absence of any application for state permits, DNR has no role to play in Pebble’s current activity in support of federal permits,” Saddler wrote.

DNR officials have no expectations as to what Pebble will propose to meet its mitigation requirements, according to Saddler.

Meanwhile, Sen. Lisa Murkowski — who has stressed her opposition to the project since late August and has since indicated a desire to preserve additional parts of the Bristol Bay region — unveiled an Interior and Environment spending bill Nov. 10 that directly addresses Pebble as well.

Murkowski chairs the Appropriations Subcommittee for the Interior and Environment.

A committee bill report states the subcommittee continues to monitor Pebble’s EIS process and concurs with the assessment in the Corps’ Aug. 24 statement that the project cannot be permitted as it stands “and appreciates the administration’s commitment to a decision guided by sound science.”

It further states that, “In the absence of a valid mitigation plan that has received all necessary approvals at the federal and state levels, the Committee urges the agencies to continue to withhold the applicant’s Clean Water Act permit.”

Murkowski spokeswoman Karina Borger wrote in response to questions about the intent language that it indicates Pebble’s wetlands fill permit should not be granted and “that the Army Corps should proceed to a denial of the permit application should Pebble fail to produce a fully viable mitigation plan, including all necessary approvals at the federal and state levels, within the agency’s 90-day timeframe.”

Murkowski would prefer the Army Corps deny the permit within the normal process to avoid needing an Environmental Protection Agency Clean Water Act Section 404(c) veto to stop Pebble because of the uncertainty it would bring for future projects, according to Borger.

Sen. Dan Sullivan, who like Murkowski was sharply critical of the EPA’s proposed veto in 2014 before Pebble applied for a wetlands fill permit, has said he supports such an action if it’s necessary to stop Pebble.

Elwood Brehmer can be reached at elwood.brehmer@alaskajournal.com.

Updated:
11/18/2020 - 9:25am

Northern Dynasty Minerals (NAK) Stock Research Links

NAK Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Adcendo’s Early Sarcoma Data Earns a Careful Look

Updated Category News Views 71

Sarcoma data rarely gives anyone permission to pound the table, yet Adcendo’s first look at ADCE-D01 deserves more than a polite nod. In advanced soft tissue sarcoma, where patients have often run through the usual options and second-line response rates historically sit around 4% to 10%, a reported 30% objective response rate on the every-two-week schedule is...

Continue Reading
Birla Carbon's Rayong Bet Tightens Asian Supply Lines

Updated Category News Views 31

Rayong just became a much louder pin on Asia's industrial map. Birla Carbon has inaugurated a 120 kMT carbon black plant in Thailand, and the significance is bigger than a ribbon-cutting photo. This is a capacity-and-location move aimed squarely at the uncomfortable part of industrial supply chains: customers need material when they need it, not after it has spent weeks...

Continue Reading
Ajman Media Forum Puts Trust Ahead of AI Speed in 2026

Updated Category News Views 179

Algorithms may manufacture a flood of words, but they cannot inherit accountability. That was the sensible nerve running through Ajman Media Forum 2026, “The Signal,” inaugurated on November 19 by His Highness Sheikh Ammar bin Humaid Al Nuaimi, Crown Prince of Ajman and Chairman of the Executive Council. For all the fanfare that usually surrounds artificial...

Continue Reading
StoneX Selloff Puts Earnings Quality Under a Harsh Lens

Updated Category News Views 75

A revenue beat can turn downright useless when the profit line springs a leak. StoneX Group delivered operating revenue above expectations and record full-year results, then watched investors hammer the stock after fiscal fourth-quarter diluted earnings per share landed at $0.66. That was $0.15 below the roughly $0.81 consensus cited in the notice, and other estimates...

Continue Reading
Cineverse Sets Wolf Creek Return for March 19, 2027

Updated Category News Views 86

A sunburned serial killer is heading back to theaters, and Cineverse has finally put a date on it: March 19, 2027. WOLF CRE3K, formerly called Wolf Creek: Legacy, brings John Jarratt back as Mick Taylor for the third film in the Australian horror franchise. For NASDAQ:CNVS investors, this is not the kind of announcement that lets anyone pencil in revenue with a straight...

Continue Reading
Evotec’s Second IND Adds Proof to Its Glue Platform

Updated Category News Views 73

Two IND acceptances from one long-running alliance is not nothing, especially in a drug-discovery business where plenty of polished platform talk never makes it to the clinic. Evotec has cleared that modest but meaningful bar again with Bristol Myers Squibb: a second molecular-glue candidate has received FDA acceptance for an Investigational New Drug application. The...

Continue Reading
Baker Tilly Breach Raises Hard Questions on Vendor Risk

Updated Category News Views 5

A Quiet Vendor Failure Can Become a Loud Problem Tax files are not ordinary customer records, and that is why this reported Baker Tilly Advisory Group breach deserves more than the usual shrug people give cyber incidents. Names and addresses are bad enough; the potential exposure of Social Security numbers and other sensitive information turns a systems failure into a...

Continue Reading
SOCi's MCP Push Makes Context the Product Moat Bigger

Updated Category News Views 46

Software agents without decent business context are just eager interns with access to the keyboard. SOCi’s November 19, 2026 announcement gets at that unglamorous truth: the company has made its Model Context Protocol server generally available and says its context layer now connects with more than 140 integrations. It is not a flashy new chatbot stunt. It is a bid to...

Continue Reading
Software-Defined Cars Put $310 Billion in Play by 2035

Updated Category News Views 111

Cars are becoming rolling computers, and that changes who gets paid. Market Growth Reports projects the software-defined vehicle market will rise from $56.94 billion to $310.46 billion by 2035, a 20.74% compound annual growth rate. That is a loud number, no question. Still, investors ought to treat any long-range market forecast like a map, not a mortgage deed. The...

Continue Reading
McDonald's Franchise Wage Suit Puts Compliance on Notice

Updated Category News Views 129

Payroll sloppiness can turn a cheap burger shift into an expensive courtroom problem fast. Zakay Law Group, APLC has filed a proposed class action in Alameda County Superior Court against a long list of McDonald's franchise-related entities, alleging workers were not paid all wages due under California law. The case, 26CV218760, is pending, not proven, and that...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Thunderbird Entertainment Group Announces Q2 2025 Conference Call

Updated Category News Views 123

Thunderbird Entertainment Group's Upcoming Conference Call Thunderbird Entertainment Group Inc. (OTCQX:THBRF), renowned for its award-winning productions, has announced that it will be releasing its fiscal Q2 2025 results to the public. This eagerly anticipated update is scheduled for a post-market close announcement, followed by a conference call on February 20, 2025....

Continue Reading
Africa-Caribbean Trade Potential: A $1.65B Opportunity

Updated Category News Views 203

Untapped Opportunities Between Africa and the Caribbean Who's ready to shake up the trade game between Africa and the Caribbean? According to a fresh-off-the-press report from the International Trade Centre (ITC) and Afreximbank, we could be looking at a whopping $1.65 billion in annual trade between these two regions by 2030. That's right, a billion with a 'B'. But let...

Continue Reading
Trump's Comments Spark Concerns for Taiwan Semiconductor Amid Trade Tensions

Updated Category News Views 268

Trump's Critique of Taiwan Semiconductor on Podcast Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump has taken a pointed stance against Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSM). During a discussion on the Joe Rogan podcast, he accused Taiwan of negatively impacting America's chip industry. This accusation marks his second focused attack on the semiconductor giant....

Continue Reading
Investigation of Data Breach at Fireworks Software by Law Firm

Updated Category News Views 177

Investigation into Fireworks Software's Data Breach In a serious turn of events regarding personal data protection, Federman & Sherwood has initiated an investigation into Fireworks Software following a recent data breach. This comes after the company reported unauthorized access to their network. Safeguarding customer information is essential in our digital age, making...

Continue Reading
Shaquille O'Neal Unveils Big Chicken's Tasty Sandwich Showdown

Updated Category News Views 436

Shaquille O'Neal Unveils Big Chicken's Tasty Sandwich Showdown - A limited-time lineup of sandwiches inspired by iconic sports personalities battles for flavor domination! - Fan participation includes a generous donation to charity based on popular choices. LAS VEGAS / - Big Chicken, the culinary vision of basketball legend Shaquille O'Neal, merges cherished childhood...

Continue Reading