Why GOP Senators Are Sticking With Trump — Even Though It

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Bhawks
291
Why GOP Senators Are Sticking With Trump — Even Though It Might Hurt Them In November

Aug. 10, 2020,at 5:45 AM

By Matt Grossmann



President Trump during a coronavirus briefing at the White House on July 28, 2020. Jabin Botsford / The Washington Post / Getty Images

https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/why-gop-...-november/

Arizona Sen. Martha McSally handily defeated her primary challenger Tuesday, with the help of an endorsement from President Trump. Her chances of winning the general election are even more closely tied to Trump’s — and she’s embracing that connection.

She has attacked the “liberal hack media” for criticizing the president, predicted he will win Arizona in November and repeatedly appeared with him in his visits to the state, following her advisors’ plan to stay close to Trump, even if that means going down with a sinking ship.

Recommended viewing for Martha and the rest of the GOP 'band members'. Stop rearranging the deck chairs.....they're sliding by you now....and pick up your violins.



She may already be getting a sinking feeling. The U.S. Senate race in Arizona is rated as “lean Democrat” by most analysts. And a recent Marist poll showed her doing even worse than Trump in the state, trailing Democrat Mark Kelly by 12 percentage points. The same survey showed Trump trailing Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden by 5 points.

Now that McSally has made it past a primary challenge, though, she might benefit from shifting gears. Research suggests Republicans running for the House and Senate this year would benefit from distancing themselves from Trump and the national Republican Party. The problem is … that’s a lot harder than it used to be.

A little independence goes a long way

Even in an age of nationalized politics, it still helps to have an independent identity from your party. Voters tend to not like blind loyalty, and prefer representatives who are willing to compromise with the opposition party.

In 2018, Republicans who were endorsed by Trump actually did worse in their general election races than Republicans the president ignored or disparaged, all else being equal.

And Republicans who opposed their party’s major legislative initiative, repealing Obamacare, did better than those who supported it. One study even found that Trump rallies raised more money for Democrats than they did for Republicans.


The reason GOP senators could benefit from some independence from the White House is that drawing attention to a candidate’s ties to Trump helps polarize a race along the same lines of presidential job approval. And that is a particularly troubling trend for a president with poor approval ratings.

For most of his presidency, Trump has had more disapprovers than approvers in Arizona and other states with competitive Senate races, including Colorado and Maine. Linked to Trump, the Republican senators in those states are now getting the same treatment; McSally, Cory Gardner in Colorado and Susan Collins in Maine all have negative net approval ratings.

As political scientist (and co-author of the study finding negative effects of Trump endorsements) Andrew Ballard told me, “Unpopular presidents probably need to be very *strategic and judicious with their usage of their platform to endorse candidates, because in certain situations it can do more harm than good.” Trump failed to follow this advice in 2018 and doesn’t seem to be paying it any more heed this year. And most GOP senators are not effectively keeping their distance from Trump.

* Good luck with that. Two of the 'best words' NOT in Trump's vocabulary.

Senators up for reelection are siding with Trump

Trump may not be able to resist intervening in Senate and House races, given his desire for being the center of attention. But Republican legislators have choices about how to present themselves. So far, they are sticking with Trump.

McSally supported repealing Obamacare, opposed the president’s impeachment and has rarely publicly criticized the Trump administration. That is a big shift from 2016, when she chose not to endorse Trump and bashed his behavior. Moreover, McSally has voted with Trump’s position 95 percent of the time over the last two congressional sessions — far more often than you’d expect based on Arizona’s politics.

In fact, in the Senate, McSally has the fourth highest “Trump Plus-Minus” score, which measures how often a member of Congress votes in line with the president’s position relative to what you would expect from that member based on the partisanship of their state or district.

OK spaceman, that's enough right there to fuel your ad campaign.


Other Republican senators up for reelection this year have also remained loyal to Trump’s positions. Gardner has voted with Trump 89 percent of the time during the 115th and 116th Congresses (he has the second highest “Trump Plus-Minus”), Thom Tillis (North Carolina) with Trump 93 percent of the time, David Perdue (Georgia) 95 percent, Joni Ernst (Iowa) 91 percent and Steve Daines (Montana) 86 percent.

The one partial exception is Collins, who has sided with Trump two-thirds of the time over the last two Congresses (though that is still far more than expected based on Trump’s losing margin in Maine). Collins has clearly tried to put some distance between herself and Trump as her reelection race draws nearer — but not too much.

She did not support Obamacare repeal, though she voted to acquit the president in his Senate trial and voted to confirm his Supreme Court nominees. She went from voting with Trump 77 percent of the time in the 115th Congress (2017-18) to only 46 percent in the 116th (2019-20).

It’s been a tough balancing act that may end up pleasing no one. Indeed, Collins has become the poster child for Republicans’ unwillingness to seriously break with Trump. She has been “disappointed” in Trump without taking action to restrain him so often that “Saturday Night Live” did a skit about it.



Still, Collins may still have a chance to retain an independent reputation, something she’s cultivated for years by necessity in blue-ish Maine. The problem is … that’s harder to do these days.

Why it’s become more difficult to break with the national party

Many members of Congress used to have local reputations independent of their parties, presenting themselves as fighters for local interests and dollars in Washington. Even if most voters hated Congress, they still liked their own representatives and senators.

But the long-term trends are nationalization (voters perceive their representatives through the lens of national and presidential politics) and polarization (voters see the parties as distinct and agree more with one side).

Voters learn less about their own legislators and more about the president, in part due to decreasing reliance on local news. As a result, fewer voters split their tickets, voting for one party’s candidate for president and the other’s for Senate or the House.

Democrats have faced the same problem in trying to distinguish themselves from their party. Voters recognized the independent streak of West Virginia’s Joe Manchin and Montana’s Jon Tester in the 2018 midterms, but Missouri’s Claire McCaskill, North Dakota’s Heidi Heitkamp and Indiana’s Joe Donnelly weren’t able to overcome the Republican lean of their states.

Manchin went so far as to appear in ads showing him shooting at policies he disliked and proclaiming “for me, it’s all about West Virginia.” He won a state that Hillary Clinton lost by more than 42 points.

Nationalization makes it more difficult for senators to be seen as separated from their party’s president and his priorities. So even if Republican senators do break with Trump, fewer voters now learn about it because they no longer see state-specific news.

Since voters tend to assume that partisans vote like their parties, voters are often unable to perceive moderate senators’ divergent policy positions.

And legislators who do break with their party now face a risk of a primary challenger. McSally won her 2018 Republican primary1

facing two candidates closely tied to Trump: Joe Arpaio and Kelli Ward. In this year’s race to defend the seat she was appointed to, McSally this week fended off a primary challenge from Daniel McCarthy, who tried to build support from local pro-Trump groups.

“More [congressional] members are running scared in the primaries,” political scientist Sarah Treul told me. “Even if they’re actually not having quality challengers emerging, they’re afraid of it happening. And I think a lot of them are spending time trying to figure out how [they] can ward off one of those challengers from even coming to the table.”

That usually means doing little to upset the party’s base by breaking with the president.

Can Republicans still jump ship?

Now that primary season is coming to an end, will Republicans start separating themselves from Trump? Some probably don’t need to do so to win reelection. Despite his national unpopularity, senators in more Trump-leaning states, such as Ernst in Iowa and Daines in Montana, may be able to survive with a standard partisan vote.

But McSally, Collins, Gardner in Colorado and Tillis in North Carolina likely need to earn a substantial number of votes from Biden supporters to survive. It’s just not clear whether they will break with Trump in public ways or whether late breaks would be enough to help them win.

That said, they may have one option to rally both the Republican faithful and a few swing voters. It turns out some voters fear giving unified government to the president’s party and desire some balance. If voters expect a Democratic president, they are slightly more likely to support Republicans in Congress, which could perhaps keep the Senate in GOP hands.

So terrible Trump polls could be turned into something useful by Republican senators. They might eventually need to argue that, if Trump is going to lose, voters should trust them to serve as a check on the Democratic agenda.
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

ZTO's Pricing Muscle Shows Up in Third-Quarter Results

Updated Category News Views 116

Ten billion parcels can hide plenty of ugly economics, but ZTO's third quarter does not look like a volume-at-any-cost stunt. The company moved 10.241 billion parcels, up 7.0% from a year earlier, and says that outpaced the industry by 4.1 percentage points. More importantly, revenue climbed 21.0% to RMB14.36 billion while adjusted net income reached RMB2.57 billion. That...

Continue Reading
Benicia's Bold Move to Streamline Permitting Pays Off

Updated Category News Views 127

Award-Winning Innovation from Benicia Benicia, California, shoots ahead of the pack by scooping up a highly coveted Helen Putnam Award for Excellence. Why? They chopped down bureaucracy like a lumberjack with a new ax by ushering in a digital revolution for their permitting process. Make no mistake, folks, this ain’t just a pat on the back—it's a blueprint for cities...

Continue Reading
SanMar’s Lott Tops Promo Products Power 50 Again in 2026

Updated Category News Views 43

Branded hoodies and logo tumblers rarely make Wall Street’s pulse race, but the numbers behind them deserve a hard look. Jeremy Lott, president and CEO of SanMar, was named the most influential leader in the U.S. promotional-products business for the second consecutive year, taking No. 1 in the 2026 Counselor Power 50 ranking. Awards can be fluff. A repeat win beside...

Continue Reading
PSEG Declares $0.67 Fourth-Quarter 2026 Cash Dividend

Updated Category News Views 64

A 67-cent utility dividend rarely sets the tape on fire, and that is precisely the point. Public Service Enterprise Group declared a regular fourth-quarter 2026 common-stock dividend of $0.67 per share, payable on or before December 31 to shareholders of record on December 10. For owners of NYSE:PEG, this is the sort of announcement that belongs in the “steady as she...

Continue Reading
Alpha's Training Bet Reaches Into Aesthetic Care Networks

Updated Category News Views 186

Training is becoming part of the operating machine A certificate course is rarely the headline-grabber in healthcare services, yet this one deserves a closer look. Alpha Aesthetics Partners has launched Practice Aesthetics, a unified clinical education platform tied directly to its expanding network of medical aesthetics practices. This is not a public-market ticker...

Continue Reading
Charter’s $1.5 Billion Tender Tests Debt Discipline

Updated Category News Views 176

Debt cleanup arrives with a hard ceiling Eight far-dated bond issues just got a very specific invitation from Charter Communications: hand them over for cash, but do not expect the company to write a blank check. Charter set final pricing on November 17 for tender offers covering up to $1.5 billion in aggregate consideration, excluding accrued interest and deal expenses....

Continue Reading
EUBG Faces Tough Third Quarter Amid Challenges

Updated Category News Views 226

What's Happening with EUBG? Entrepreneur Universe Bright Group, better known in the markets as EUBG, is navigating some choppy waters if their recent financial numbers are anything to go by. You'd think companies boasting a digital-focused strategy would be printing money in today's tech-driven world, but EUBG's third quarter of 2026 has a different story to tell. The...

Continue Reading
Wonder Create: Democratizing Restaurant Creation

Updated Category News Views 57

Breaking Down Barriers in the Restaurant Industry It's been a long time since someone truly shook up the restaurant scene like this. Wonder Create is stepping in to turn anyone with a wild food idea into a bonafide restaurateur. We're not talking about the ol' franchising route here. We're diving straight into democratizing the culinary world. You seen something this bold...

Continue Reading
Texas Community Bancshares Adds a Special Dividend

Updated Category News Views 109

Nine cents is the whole message—for the moment Texas Community Bancshares has put a little extra cash on the table, declaring a regular quarterly dividend of $0.06 per common share and a special cash dividend of $0.03 per share. Together, holders get $0.09 per share, payable on or about December 15, 2026, provided they are shareholders of record when business closes on...

Continue Reading
Toledo Crosswalk Death Lawsuit Raises Hard Questions

Updated Category News Views 193

A painted crosswalk is supposed to mean something, and that is the grim center of the lawsuit filed over Judy Tanner’s death in Toledo. Tanner, 20, was walking home from work on September 10, 2026, when she was struck and killed while crossing the street. Her estate is now suing, alleging that the 31-year-old driver failed to yield as Tanner legally used the crosswalk....

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Butterfly Network and Rutgers Study Show Impact of POCUS

Updated Category News Views 129

Revolutionizing Hospital Care with POCUS Technology BURLINGTON, Mass. & NEW YORK-- Butterfly Network, Inc. (NYSE: BFLY), a pioneering digital health company, has launched a significant study in collaboration with Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School. This research emphasizes the transformative influence of point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) technology on patient...

Continue Reading
Civista Bancshares Increases Quarterly Dividend to 17 Cents

Updated Category News Views 127

Civista Bancshares Boosts Quarterly Dividend Payments Civista Bancshares, Inc. (NASDAQ: CIVB), the financial cornerstone of Civista Bank, has made a noteworthy announcement regarding its quarterly dividends. The Board of Directors has approved a hike in the dividend to 17 cents per common share. This increment of 1 cent reflects the company's commitment to returning value...

Continue Reading
Argentinians Traveling Abroad for Cheaper Goods and Prices

Updated Category News Views 233

Argentinians Seeking Affordable Goods Abroad Amid rising domestic prices, it seems that many Argentinians are turning their eyes overseas in search of better deals on consumer goods. This trend has become evident as locals prioritize travel to countries like Brazil and Chile, where prices are significantly lower. The ongoing economic situation in Argentina, characterized...

Continue Reading
RomReal's Annual Report Insights and Audit Overview for 2024

Updated Category News Views 229

RomReal's Performance Overview for 2024 RomReal has been navigating a dynamic market landscape, with its annual report revealing insights into the company's financial health and operational resilience. The company has shown remarkable adaptability in the face of fluctuations within the industry, contributing to its performance in the 2024 fiscal year. This overview sheds...

Continue Reading
Microsoft's Flexible Work Policy: A New Era for Employees

Updated Category News Views 303

Microsoft rolled out a major statement back in 2024 that they're not gonna enforce a mandatory return-to-office unless they see productivity tank. Bigwigs at the company made it clear that for now, keeping things flexible is the name of the game. And why wouldn’t it be? With new hires flocking to companies that let them work from home, Microsoft knows they need to play...

Continue Reading