Irani rakes in $372.8 million over 3 years Featured: Ray

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Stock Buff
Irani rakes in $372.8 million over 3 years

Featured: Ray Irani, former CEO, Occidental Petroleum

Originally published: Feb. 23, 2012

Who's the most overpaid CEO? Opinions vary, but a new study points the finger at former Occidental Petroleum ( OXY ) CEO Ray Irani.

Conducted by Swiss research firm Obermatt, the study ranked the 100 largest companies in the U.S. by stock performance and profit growth, then ranked the CEOs of those companies by realized pay.

If rich CEO pay deals brought shareholders better performance, you would expect to see a correlation between performance and CEO pay rankings. But there wasn't any.

This puts to lie the excuse that huge CEO pay deals are justified because boards need to pay up to find the best talent -- and to the notion that richly paid CEOs are worth every penny because they have superpower skills.

So why point the finger at Irani?

Over the three years the study looked at, 2008 through 2010, Irani got $372.8 million in realized pay. That made him tops for pay of all the CEOs.

In contrast, using Occidental Petroleum's stock and profit growth as the benchmarks, the company was far from the best performer. In fact, it ranked No. 65 of 100.

Based on their performance rankings and pay comparisons, Obermatt calculated that Irani should have earned only $48.2 million for the three years. In short, he was overpaid by 674% -- some $324.6 million.

That's convincing enough to make Irani my "One-Percenter of the Week" this week.

Irani stepped down as CEO in 2011 but remained as chairman, following years of raised eyebrows about his pay from investors and pay experts alike. "He has featured in our top 10 highest-paid CEO table three times in the past five years," says Paul Hodgson at GMI, which studies executive compensation. "He was the highest-paid oil executive almost every year, but he was not running the biggest company or the most successful. At one point, we branded Occidental Petroleum a serial overpayer."

Particularly galling was Occidental's practice, at one point, of setting the return-on-equity hurdle -- a common measure of shareholder value -- for some payouts below the level achieved for the prior three years. "That's just giving money away," says Hodgson.

The rich Irani pay deals also attracted the ire of activist investors like the California State Teachers' Retirement System and Relational Investors, which were aggressive in getting a "say on pay" vote before Occidental shareholders a year before those votes became more common. Shareholders voted against Irani's pay, and the board backed down by trimming CEO pay.

Though he's gone as CEO, it's still instructive to ask: How did Irani pull off this feat for so many years? Analysts offer these explanations.

First, boards that are too close to management don't do a great job of looking out for shareholder interests, and that may have been the case here. Next, boards sometimes overpay because they are worried about losing their CEOs. To prevent this, they decide to pay their CEOs above the median. But when too many boards all do this at once "pay moves up, for no other reason," says Hermann Stern, the CEO of Obermatt. "I think that could explain a lot of the upward trend in CEO compensation."

One fix that would cut out much of the excessive pay would be to require company stock to outperform a market index before the CEOs can cash out stock options. This would prevent CEOs from banking big payouts merely because their stocks go up with a rising market.

Occidental declined to comment. But in the past when I have written about Irani's pay, the company has responded that his pay reflects "outstanding leadership" which has brought "excellent performance and exceptional returns for shareholders."

Company filings also state that after Irani became CEO of Occidental in 1990, he helped develop it from a conglomerate of unrelated businesses into the fourth-largest oil and gas company in the U.S.

http://money.msn.com/investing/one-percenter-of-the-week

Occidental Petroleum Corp. (OXY) Stock Research Links

OXY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Fractional CIOs Bring Order to Growing Technology Chaos

Updated Category News Views 41

A company can outgrow its technology habits long before anyone notices the smoke. One day the owner is approving another software subscription, the office manager is chasing an internet provider, and the tech person is putting out password fires. None of that looks dramatic in isolation. Together, it is a business operating without a map. That is the useful point in the...

Continue Reading
Employer Ghosting Is a Quiet Talent-Cost Problem Today

Updated Category News Views 97

Silence is cheap right up until a company needs talent again. Then the unanswered email, abandoned interview loop, or vanished promise of next steps comes back with a price tag—maybe not neatly labeled in a quarterly filing, but real all the same. LiveCareer’s April 14, 2026 survey of 1,008 employed U.S. adults lands on an uncomfortable point: candidates remember...

Continue Reading
Midterm Voters Put Cost Relief Ahead of Washington Wars

Updated Category News Views 100

Gas pumps and medical bills have a way of humiliating every grand political slogan ever printed. Seven Letter Insight's latest post-election survey says confirmed 2026 midterm voters want the 120th Congress to deal with costs first, particularly gas prices, health care, restoring health care tax credits and energy bills. That is not a glamorous mandate. It is, however,...

Continue Reading
Domino's Probe Puts Franchise Disclosure Under Lens

Updated Category News Views 139

A franchisee's shuttered stores can turn cheerful unit-growth talk into a nasty accounting of credibility, and that is the uncomfortable territory Domino's now occupies. Kahn Swick & Foti has opened an investigation into whether Domino's officers and directors breached fiduciary duties or violated state or federal law. That is not a finding of misconduct. It is a legal...

Continue Reading
CCAPP Holiday Training Targets Seasonal Recovery Strain

Updated Category News Views 94

December cheer has a nasty habit of hiding the people barely holding themselves together. CCAPP’s upcoming virtual workshop, Hope for the Holidays: Understanding Depression, Stress & Resilience During the Holiday Season, takes that uncomfortable reality seriously rather than treating it like a seasonal footnote. For behavioral health workers supporting people in...

Continue Reading
QuidelOrtho Faces Fresh Scrutiny Over Savanna Claims

Updated Category News Views 137

A diagnostic launch can turn into a corporate migraine with frightening speed, and QuidelOrtho is staring at exactly that sort of mess. Kahn Swick & Foti said on November 20, 2026, that it has begun investigating whether QuidelOrtho officers or directors breached fiduciary duties or otherwise violated state or federal law. This is not a finding of wrongdoing. It is an...

Continue Reading
Epic Blue Puts $50,000 of Marketing Work to Use Locally

Updated Category News Views 111

A $50,000 pile of donated know-how can look soft on a spreadsheet, until you remember how often a small nonprofit or early-stage outfit gets ignored because it cannot afford someone to sharpen its message. Epic Blue Marketing, a women-owned firm based in Jackson, Michigan, says it provided that amount in donated and reduced-rate marketing, communications and public...

Continue Reading
Maryland Handgun Ban Suit Puts Ruger in Legal Crossfire

Updated Category News Views 111

A January Deadline With Real Commercial Teeth Maryland has turned a trigger-design dispute into a fresh legal and retail headache, and the clock is not polite about it. The National Shooting Sports Foundation filed suit against the state over S.B. 334, which is scheduled to take effect Jan. 1, 2027. The law bars sales of certain pistols with cruciform trigger bars,...

Continue Reading
3TREES Tests a Bigger Asia-Pacific Growth Blueprint

Updated Category News Views 104

A bucket of paint rarely sounds strategic until it sits inside a regional supply chain. That is the useful part of 3TREES chairman and president Hong Jie's message from the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation CEO Summit in Shenzhen on November 17-18, 2026: coatings are not merely a commodity if the supplier can bring materials, energy savings, technical know-how and...

Continue Reading
Human Frontier Mission Puts AI Research on Display

Updated Category News Views 71

A laboratory notebook is about to become the real product in this AI experiment. Human Frontier Mission, or HFM, says it will launch globally on Nov. 24, opening a research program where domain specialists frame scientific and engineering problems while autonomous AI agents develop and test possible answers. The unusual bit is not merely handing models difficult work. It...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Mission Rock Takes Charge of Seasons at Horsetooth

Updated Category News Views 20

Mission Rock Shakes Up Colorado's Apartment Market Here's one for the books: Mission Rock Residential, known for its no-nonsense approach to property management, just snagged a juicy piece of the market by taking over management at Seasons at Horsetooth Crossing in Fort Collins. Fort Collins isn't just some random name on the map—it's a hotbed for real estate, thanks to...

Continue Reading
Teck Resources Confirms Quarterly Dividend for Shareholders

Updated Category News Views 175

Teck Resources Declares New Dividend for Shareholders Teck Resources Limited (NYSE: TECK) has made an exciting announcement that will please its investors. The company has declared a quarterly dividend of $0.125 per share designated for its outstanding Class A common shares and Class B subordinate voting shares. This dividend is set to be paid on March 31 to all...

Continue Reading
Empowering Voices: The Impact of the AWDPI Conference

Updated Category News Views 300

Empowering Women Through Innovative Discussions The recent conference organized by the Asian Women Development Plan International brought together over 10,000 individuals passionate about empowering Asian women. This pivotal gathering, titled "The Conference of Asian Women Development International 2024", served as a beacon for women's issues, fostering a collaborative...

Continue Reading
O2Gold Shares Significant Updates on Quebec Aur Acquisition

Updated Category News Views 205

O2Gold's Exciting Update on Quebec Aur Acquisition O2Gold Inc. (NEX:OTGO.H), a dynamic player in the mineral exploration landscape, is thrilled to provide an update on its ongoing journey towards acquiring a gold mining exploration property in Quebec. This acquisition is through the purchase of Quebec Aur Ltd., with the transaction details specified in a share exchange...

Continue Reading
Skycorp Solar Group Limited Announces Major IPO Initiative

Updated Category News Views 187

Skycorp Solar Group Limited Announces Major IPO Initiative Skycorp Solar Group Limited (PN) has made a notable move by filing for an initial public offering (IPO) that encompasses 2,000,000 shares. The pricing is positioned attractively between $4 and $5 per share, appealing to a diverse range of potential investors. Understanding the IPO Process An IPO is a crucial step...

Continue Reading