What the Charles Schwab-TD Ameritrade acquisition

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone
117


What the Charles Schwab-TD Ameritrade acquisition means.



In our capitalist system, the supposed purposes of financial markets are twofold: To coordinate resources, getting them to their most productive economic uses, and to provide corporate governance via the votes that come with stock ownership. By trading assets and pursuing personal profit, investors on financial markets are supposed to power both goals.

This is because trading is presumably happening with some kind of strategy and intent: human beings investigate companies and industries and make their trades accordingly — or they rely on other people who specialize in giving that advice. That's why brokerage giants like Charles Schwab and the somewhat-less-gigantic TD Ameritrade traditionally provided their customers with financial advisers as a core part of their business. They act as financial middle men, linking investors to trading opportunities, facilitating the transactions, and providing financial advice along the way.

On Monday, Charles Schwab inked a $26 billion deal to buy TD Ameritrade. The resulting "goliath" wealth management firm will control a whopping $5 trillion in assets. But just as interesting as the merger itself are the tectonic changes in American financial trading that set the stage for it — in recent decades, financial management by adviser has essentially died off.

Schwab itself more or less delivered the death blow last October, when it shocked financial markets by announcing it would no longer charge customers fees for online trading on stocks, exchange-traded funds, and more. Those fees had already been falling for years, after a 1975 regulatory decision that did away with fixed trading commissions. After that, brokerages started competing on who could offer the lowest price. Another major factor was the mid-1970s invention of the index fund, a form of "passive" investment that simply allocated a trader's money based on each company's market share of a particular index, like the S&P 500. Index funds obviously don't rely on human advice or strategy, and thus can be offered to customers for cheap. As of 2014, index funds accounted for one third of all investment firm activity.

These developments, combined with the increased ability to offer cookie-cutter financial advice online via computer algorithms, meant that actual advice from actual human beings — which is comparatively expensive to offer — was slowly competed out of the market. By the time Schwab made its announcement last October, commissions had already been reduced to 4 percent of its revenue. In fact, it was already getting 57 percent of its revenue from interest on the uninvested cash people left in their accounts.

Today, Schwab is basically a brokerage firm that sits atop a more traditional bank: Its offer to facilitate financial trades encourages people to park their money with the firm, and it pays them interest on it. But that money also allows Schwab to engage in other financial and banking activities like lending, and it gets more interest back on that activity than it loses to its clients. It's making money on the spread, same as a traditional bank. Schwab's stock trading business was already a kind of bonus it offered purely to lure in customers, so eventually Schwab just figured it should offer that bonus for free.

Schwab's rivals like TD Ameritrade and E-Trade were dependent on commissions for a larger part of their revenue — 15 or 16 percent, in Ameritrade's case. And unlike Schwab, they don't own a banking operation themselves; they partner with traditional banks in an arrangement that has much the same ultimate effect. Giving up on trade fees was a bigger blow to their business models. But, facing down price competition from Schwab, they had no real choice. The whole industry rapidly followed Schwab's lead and offered zero-commission trading.

This brings us back to Monday's merger. Given the way Schwab's business model now operates, scale is everything: the more customers park their money with the firm, the more profit it can make. Meanwhile, Schwab's competitors face the choice of having to battle on the same scale-based playing field as an already-bigger rival, or just make as much money as they can now by getting bought out. The merger was in both sides' interest, and more mergers in the industry are probably coming down the pike.

Is this bad for customers? Not necessarily. If advice from real life human beings actually made any kind of noticeable difference in people's financial trades, brokerages would have presumably noticed that value by now, offered the service, and taken advantage of the profit opportunity. Instead, they've moved in the opposite direction. Index funds, for example, have been such a massive success precisely because there's no evidence that relying on a particular adviser with particular theories and strategies actually nets investors any more money over the long haul than just putting their portfolio on autopilot. That suggests customers aren't losing out on anything from Schwab-style changes, and are just benefiting from the lower prices.

That doesn't necessarily mean, however, the Schwab-Ameritrade merger is out of the woods with antitrust regulators. The merged company's next biggest rival will only control $500 billion in assets. And while these brokerages no longer charge fees for the trades they facilitate, they do still serve as a kind of landing pad for independent financial advisers, providing them logistical and administrative support. Schwab controls roughly half of that market, and Ameritrade another third.

Moreover, the argument against concentrated market power is not always just that it hurts customers with higher prices. The case against Walmart, for example, is not that it may eventually gouge shoppers. It's that, by pushing out mom and pop stores and driving down wages, Walmart's market power harms society in other ways. In the case of giant investment firms, they can get so big that they really can't avoid holding significant ownership stakes in multiple companies in the same industry — such as airlines, for example. Studies suggest that situation can lead to dampened competition in those other industries, and thus lower-quality outcomes for their customers.

Finally, there's a deeper existential question here. Like I said, the ostensible purpose of financial markets is to provide the strategic thinking for the whole capitalist system. But if the firms like Schwab and Ameritrade find that not strategizing at all actually gives their investors better value — and if they find it's profitable to merge into de facto central planners, doing their investment on algorithmic autopilot — what does that say about that system?
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Persistent Dry Eye Symptoms Call for a Closer Look

Updated Category News Views 150

Eyes can turn into a stubborn little nuisance long before people realize something more complicated is going on. A bottle of artificial tears is easy to grab, cheap enough, and often perfectly sensible for a rough day of screens, wind, reading, or air conditioning. But Dr. Harlan Snyder’s point is the one worth sitting with: when dryness keeps barging back despite...

Continue Reading
Kyverna Probe Reopens IPO Disclosure Questions for Investors

Updated Category News Views 136

Clinical-trial caveats have a nasty habit of becoming shareholder headaches years later. Kyverna Therapeutics is back in that uncomfortable zone after Kahn Swick & Foti said it has opened an investigation into whether the company’s officers and directors breached fiduciary duties or otherwise violated state or federal law. For holders of KYTX, this is not a verdict and...

Continue Reading
UAE Trust Model Faces Its Hardest Test During Crisis

Updated Category News Views 176

A country’s reputation is usually invisible right up until the machinery rattles. Then people, investors, trading partners and residents stop listening to polished slogans and start watching whether airports function, services hold up, information arrives, and business can keep moving. That was the useful core of Saeed Al Eter’s remarks at Ajman Media Forum 2026: soft...

Continue Reading
Kinross Lawsuit Puts Round Mountain Claims Under Fire

Updated Category News Views 128

A mine can swallow a rosy forecast faster than any spreadsheet admits. That is the ugly center of the proposed securities class action involving Kinross Gold: not merely that production guidance came down, but the allegation that investors were sold too much confidence before the operational reality at Round Mountain Phase S surfaced. NYSE:KGC dropped from $27.62 on...

Continue Reading
Sitting, Lymph Flow, and a Supplement Maker's Pitch

Updated Category News Views 161

By late afternoon, a chair can feel like it has quietly won the argument against your legs. PureHealth Research is leaning into that familiar heavy, puffy-legged feeling with a reminder about lymphatic flow—and, naturally, an eight-ingredient supplement positioned alongside it. The broad message is sensible. The sales layer needs the usual healthy squint. Movement Does...

Continue Reading
D-Wave Investors Face a December 15 Lead Plaintiff Clock

Updated Category News Views 191

August Put the Story Under a Harsh Light Two ugly August trading sessions are doing a lot of work in the case now confronting D-Wave Quantum. The company sits in a field that attracts big dreams, big headlines, and, frankly, plenty of investor imagination. But imagination does not cushion a portfolio when expectations crack. The lawsuits concern people who bought or...

Continue Reading
Human Frontier Mission Puts AI Research on Display

Updated Category News Views 154

A laboratory notebook is about to become the real product in this AI experiment. Human Frontier Mission, or HFM, says it will launch globally on Nov. 24, opening a research program where domain specialists frame scientific and engineering problems while autonomous AI agents develop and test possible answers. The unusual bit is not merely handing models difficult work. It...

Continue Reading
Fluence Investors Face a November 27 Litigation Clock

Updated Category News Views 187

Six calendar squares are all that separate eligible Fluence investors from the November 27, 2026 lead-plaintiff deadline. That is not much time to locate trade confirmations, calculate losses, and decide whether taking a larger role in a securities case makes sense. The lawsuit is not a verdict, and anybody pretending otherwise is selling smoke. But the underlying...

Continue Reading
Fractional CIOs Bring Order to Growing Technology Chaos

Updated Category News Views 175

A company can outgrow its technology habits long before anyone notices the smoke. One day the owner is approving another software subscription, the office manager is chasing an internet provider, and the tech person is putting out password fires. None of that looks dramatic in isolation. Together, it is a business operating without a map. That is the useful point in the...

Continue Reading
Newegg’s GIGABYTE Event Is Brand Work, Not a Catalyst

Updated Category News Views 261

A 2,300-square-foot room can tell a retailer plenty about its tribe. On November 21, Newegg is turning its Diamond Bar Gamer Zone into the home base for GIGABYTE’s AORUS VS40 celebration, a free five-hour event marking the hardware maker’s 40th anniversary. There will be 1v1 VALORANT and League of Legends contests, demo stations, raffles, anniversary merchandise, food...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Important Updates for KinderCare Learning Investors Ahead of Deadline

Updated Category News Views 178

Urgent Notice for KinderCare Learning Companies, Inc. Investors Investors of KinderCare Learning Companies, Inc. (NYSE: KLC) should be aware of an essential deadline approaching shortly. Rosen Law Firm, a prominent name in investor rights law, is urging shareholders to take action as we approach an important date in the ongoing securities class action lawsuit. Why This...

Continue Reading
Exploring Current Trading Trends and Insights on Sea Ltd

Updated Category News Views 320

Understanding the Options Trading Activity for Sea Ltd In recent times, there has been notable bullish positioning by investors concerning Sea Ltd (NYSE: SE). Retail traders should certainly pay attention to these movements. Significant trading activity often indicates that investors may possess undisclosed insights or information related to the company's performance....

Continue Reading
Cornish Metals Expands Share Capital with New Stock Options

Updated Category News Views 214

Cornish Metals Strengthens Its Financial Position Vancouver-based Cornish Metals Inc. (TSX-V: CUSN, LSE: CUSN) is excited to announce a significant move to bolster its financial stature. The company, known for its focus on mineral exploration and development, specifically its permitted South Crofty tin project, has exercised stock options resulting in the issuance of...

Continue Reading
PRA Group Outlines Investor Conferences for Late 2024

Updated Category News Views 94

PRA Group to Showcase at Upcoming Investor Conferences PRA Group, Inc. (Nasdaq: PRAA), known for its expertise in acquiring and collecting nonperforming loans, has announced its lineup for several significant investor conferences in the coming months. This is an exciting opportunity for attendees to gain insights into the company's strategies and performance. Details on...

Continue Reading
Latino Parents Face Financial Strain, Seek AI Help

Updated Category News Views 103

Feeling the Heat: Latino Parents in U.S. Grappling With Rising Costs If you've ever wondered how families can keep floating in this economic sea, take a look at the Latino community in the U.S., particularly those with children. The latest BMO Real Financial Progress Index unpacks a story of strain, adaptation, and a surprising technology push. Parental Challenges: The...

Continue Reading