https://www.twitter.com/ras_nielsen/status/1177635

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
trding
788
https://www.twitter.com/ras_nielsen/status/11...3202871298
“David Reich (inspired by the work of Sean Harrison) has found an error in the UK Biobank data that likely explains most or all of our results regarding CCR5 delta-32. We will work with the Nature Medicine editors to get the publication record corrected. 2/3”

https://www.twitter.com/GaetanBurgio/status/1...1455269888
It appears the results that CCR5∆32 homozygous mutation reduces life span from the UK biobank cohort don't hold following post publication peer review and replications studies. From @RebeccaDRobbins
https://statnews.com/2019/09/27/major-error-u...ens-lives/

Major error undermines study suggesting change introduced in the CRISPR babies experiment shortens lives
By REBECCA ROBBINS @rebeccadrobbins SEPTEMBER 27, 2019
A scientific study published this past spring came with damning implications for Chinese scientist He Jiankui, who created the world’s first gene-edited babies: People with the rare genetic variants that He tried to engineer into embryos, the study asserted, had an increased death rate.

On Friday, the paper’s senior author said his study was wrong.

“The one thing that all scientists fear the most is to find out that a major result they have published was based on erroneous data,” Rasmus Nielsen, of the University of California, Berkeley, wrote on Twitter. He said that he had been notified of an error in the data from the massive genetic database that Nielsen and his collaborator, Xinzhu Wei, had analyzed to reach their conclusion.

The error “likely explains most or all of our results” regarding the genetic variant that He tried to alter, he said.

Nielsen told STAT that the error stemmed from the specific single nucleotide polymorphism, or genetic marker, that he and Wei looked at. In the U.K. Biobank data, the marker they chose to work with had systematic errors related to “genotype calling” at that site in the DNA; that’s the process by which the genotype is determined for each individual in the sample at each site.

The way the genotypes were being called caused certain genotypes to show up less frequently than they should have, Nielsen said, apparently generating the erroneous signal around increased mortality.

“So if there is an effect on mortality,” Nielsen told STAT, “it is certainly not as strong as we previously reported.” He added: “We are very sorry for the confusion we might have spread by publishing these results.”

Nielsen said that he and Wei tried to replicate their results in several other databases, both freely available to researchers and proprietary, and that work reinforces their conclusion that their published finding was erroneous. In doing that work, they also turned up independent errors related to genotype calling at that same SNP in another genetic database, known as gnomAD, Nielsen said.

Nielsen said the evidence suggests that the problem is likely specific to the marker they analyzed and “not a general sign of poor data quality in the U.K. Biobank.”

When the paper was published in June, it generated some pushback online from scientists who took issue with technical aspects of Nielsen and Wei’s approach.

One of those critics was Sean Harrison, a University of Bristol epidemiologist and statistician who has worked with data from the U.K. Biobank. Shortly after the paper’s publication, Harrison wrote in a blog post that he tried to replicate the analysis using U.K. Biobank data. When he did so, “I found… Nothing,” he wrote.

Nielsen told STAT that he and Wei later worked with Harrison to determine that the reason for the discrepancy in their analyses was that Harrison used a different SNP than they did. That led to the alarming conclusion that while the SNP they looked at generated the signal around increased mortality, that signal wasn’t present in nearby markers.

Nielsen said on Twitter that it was Harrison who inspired Harvard scientist David Reich, who has previously studied the CCR5 variant, to probe the results of the study.

Nielsen said that Reich and his team have “shown quite clearly and convincingly that the error is in the marker” that Nielsen and Wei chose to work on.

Reached by email, Reich told STAT: “I think it’s best just to have a scientific discussion and not to comment to the press while this discussion is going on.”

CytoDyn Inc (CYDY) Stock Research Links

CYDY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Tuya Smart: AI Powers New Energy Wave at COP31

Updated Category News Views 0

Tuya Smart's Bold Move at COP31 Tuya Smart, a name you don't want to ignore in the world of energy innovation, made a commanding appearance at COP31. Their message was loud and clear: as the climate gets harsher, they're not just sitting around waiting for the next storm. They're arming households with AI-driven solutions. AI-Powered Energy Management Takes Center Stage...

Continue Reading
Pony.ai & Toyota Launch 1,000 Gen-7 Robotaxis in China

Updated Category News Views 51

Revving Up the Autonomous Ride Revolution Not every day you see two giants, Pony.ai and Toyota, join forces to shake up the way folks get from A to B. But here we are — they’ve fired up their engines in Guangzhou, unleashing their Gen-7 bZ4X Robotaxis for commercial use. And let me tell you, this is no shot in the dark. With plans to dot about 1,000 of these...

Continue Reading
Sungrow's Keeper Family: Revolutionizing C&I Energy Storage

Updated Category News Views 44

The Next Level in Energy Storage Solutions Well, folks, Sungrow's got something up its sleeve that's shaking up the energy storage scene. They're calling it the 'Keeper Family,' and if you’re deep into commercial and industrial (C&I) energy storage, this might just be your ticket to topping those profit charts. Launched at the Global Energy Pioneer Summit 2026, their...

Continue Reading
InstaHeat 35K: FOGATTI Offers Upgraded RV Furnace Control

Updated Category News Views 493

Winter RV Trips Just Got Cozier There's nothing quite like hitting the open road in an RV during the winter months. But let's face it, nobody wants to return to a cabin that's as frigid as the great outdoors. Here's where FOGATTI steps up its game with the InstaHeat Ultra 35K RV Furnace. They’ve tinkered with the thermostat to iron out more precise control, just in time...

Continue Reading
Championing Change: USTA Mid-Atlantic Gala's Impact

Updated Category News Views 326

A Night to Remember: USTA Mid-Atlantic's Gala Who would've thought tennis could wield such transformative power? This ain't your average sport gala. Last Saturday, a crowd of over 300 gathered at the Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner for the USTA Mid-Atlantic Foundation's 2026 Tennis Creates Gala. Hosted by the formidable Malika Andrews, this event wasn't just a fancy...

Continue Reading
IDEAYA's IDE101: A New Front in Cancer Battle

Updated Category News Views 349

IDEAYA's Bold Move in Precision Medicine IDEAYA Biosciences, no stranger to the frontlines of cancer treatment, is gunning for a breakthrough with their latest pick, IDE101. They're jumping into the ring with a potential first-in-class inhibitor targeting CDKN2A-deficiency—a notorious player in the solid tumor game. They're not just mixing things up for the sake of it;...

Continue Reading
SOBER CAFFEINE™: Modern Energizer Without the Bull

Updated Category News Views 11

Shed the Cans and Embrace Convenience I'm sure you've had a run-in with the standard energy drink routine. You know, the massive cans, a gut punch of sugar, and the inevitable crash that follows? Sobriety Supplements LLC decided enough is enough and rolled out something that just makes sense—SOBER CAFFEINE™ capsules. This little pill is a godsend for folks sick of...

Continue Reading
CVS Study: GLP-1 Drugs Effective But Costly

Updated Category News Views 187

Can GLP-1s Deliver Value at Their Current Price? Alright, folks, here's a real-world gut check from CVS Health. They crunched some numbers using Aetna's anonymized claims data, and the results are eye-opening. These GLP-1s are showing promising health outcomes—lower hospital visits, better clinical results, yada yada. But when it comes to savings, they ain't quite...

Continue Reading
WHO and RCSI Bahrain Join Forces on Health Initiatives

Updated Category News Views 483

Forging a Healthier Pathway In a world where healthcare challenges rise faster than my blood pressure during a stock market crash, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI) – Medical University of Bahrain have inked a deal to tackle these issues head-on. The memorandum of understanding (MoU) signed on November 15, 2026,...

Continue Reading
Local Voices to Shape Mekong's Story in New Alliance

Updated Category News Views 197

Unpacking the New Storytelling Strategy Right off the bat, let's make it clear—this isn't just another run-of-the-mill environmental project announcement. When the National Geographic Society teams up with ThaiBev to empower Southeast Asian storytellers, they're not just waving around the usual conservation banner. Instead, they're betting on local voices to lead the...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Integer Holdings Opens Conversion on 2.125% Senior Notes

Updated Category News Views 151

Integer Holdings Announces Conversion of Senior Notes Integer Holdings Corporation (NYSE: ITGR) has recently made headlines with the announcement that its 2.125% Convertible Senior Notes, due in 2028, are now eligible for conversion. This pivotal move allows holders to convert their notes into either cash, common stock, or a combination of both. The option to convert is...

Continue Reading
Investors Urged to Consider Class Action Against Micron Technology

Updated Category News Views 119

Class Action Lawsuit Against Micron Technology, Inc. Levi & Korsinsky, LLP has alerted investors in Micron Technology, Inc. (NASDAQ: MU) regarding an ongoing class action securities lawsuit. This legal action aims to represent those investors who may have incurred financial losses during a specified period. Investors are encouraged to stay informed regarding this...

Continue Reading
Expansion Grant from Bradford White Boosts ECA Internship Program

Updated Category News Views 88

Bradford White Fuels Growth in ECA Internship Program Bradford White Corporation, known for its innovative water heating solutions, has committed $50,000 towards expanding the Energy Coordinating Agency's (ECA) internship program focused on heat pump technology. This initiative aims to enhance training opportunities for the next generation of plumbing and HVAC...

Continue Reading
Industrial Automation Market Set for Significant Growth Ahead

Updated Category News Views 199

Transformations in the Industrial Automation Market Landscape The industrial automation sector is undergoing a major shift as manufacturers worldwide increasingly adopt Industry 4.0 technologies and artificial intelligence. This evolution is spurred by pressing challenges including labor shortages and the need for enhanced operational efficiency. The market is projected...

Continue Reading
Exploring Competitive Landscape of Amazon.com in Retail Sector

Updated Category News Views 159

Understanding Amazon.com's Competitive Position In today's dynamic business world, understanding how companies perform against their competitors is essential. This article delves into a detailed examination of Amazon.com (NASDAQ: AMZN) and compares it with key rivals in the broadline retail sector. By exploring crucial financial data, market strategies, and growth...

Continue Reading