https://www.twitter.com/ras_nielsen/status/1177635

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
trding
789
https://www.twitter.com/ras_nielsen/status/11...3202871298
“David Reich (inspired by the work of Sean Harrison) has found an error in the UK Biobank data that likely explains most or all of our results regarding CCR5 delta-32. We will work with the Nature Medicine editors to get the publication record corrected. 2/3”

https://www.twitter.com/GaetanBurgio/status/1...1455269888
It appears the results that CCR5∆32 homozygous mutation reduces life span from the UK biobank cohort don't hold following post publication peer review and replications studies. From @RebeccaDRobbins
https://statnews.com/2019/09/27/major-error-u...ens-lives/

Major error undermines study suggesting change introduced in the CRISPR babies experiment shortens lives
By REBECCA ROBBINS @rebeccadrobbins SEPTEMBER 27, 2019
A scientific study published this past spring came with damning implications for Chinese scientist He Jiankui, who created the world’s first gene-edited babies: People with the rare genetic variants that He tried to engineer into embryos, the study asserted, had an increased death rate.

On Friday, the paper’s senior author said his study was wrong.

“The one thing that all scientists fear the most is to find out that a major result they have published was based on erroneous data,” Rasmus Nielsen, of the University of California, Berkeley, wrote on Twitter. He said that he had been notified of an error in the data from the massive genetic database that Nielsen and his collaborator, Xinzhu Wei, had analyzed to reach their conclusion.

The error “likely explains most or all of our results” regarding the genetic variant that He tried to alter, he said.

Nielsen told STAT that the error stemmed from the specific single nucleotide polymorphism, or genetic marker, that he and Wei looked at. In the U.K. Biobank data, the marker they chose to work with had systematic errors related to “genotype calling” at that site in the DNA; that’s the process by which the genotype is determined for each individual in the sample at each site.

The way the genotypes were being called caused certain genotypes to show up less frequently than they should have, Nielsen said, apparently generating the erroneous signal around increased mortality.

“So if there is an effect on mortality,” Nielsen told STAT, “it is certainly not as strong as we previously reported.” He added: “We are very sorry for the confusion we might have spread by publishing these results.”

Nielsen said that he and Wei tried to replicate their results in several other databases, both freely available to researchers and proprietary, and that work reinforces their conclusion that their published finding was erroneous. In doing that work, they also turned up independent errors related to genotype calling at that same SNP in another genetic database, known as gnomAD, Nielsen said.

Nielsen said the evidence suggests that the problem is likely specific to the marker they analyzed and “not a general sign of poor data quality in the U.K. Biobank.”

When the paper was published in June, it generated some pushback online from scientists who took issue with technical aspects of Nielsen and Wei’s approach.

One of those critics was Sean Harrison, a University of Bristol epidemiologist and statistician who has worked with data from the U.K. Biobank. Shortly after the paper’s publication, Harrison wrote in a blog post that he tried to replicate the analysis using U.K. Biobank data. When he did so, “I found… Nothing,” he wrote.

Nielsen told STAT that he and Wei later worked with Harrison to determine that the reason for the discrepancy in their analyses was that Harrison used a different SNP than they did. That led to the alarming conclusion that while the SNP they looked at generated the signal around increased mortality, that signal wasn’t present in nearby markers.

Nielsen said on Twitter that it was Harrison who inspired Harvard scientist David Reich, who has previously studied the CCR5 variant, to probe the results of the study.

Nielsen said that Reich and his team have “shown quite clearly and convincingly that the error is in the marker” that Nielsen and Wei chose to work on.

Reached by email, Reich told STAT: “I think it’s best just to have a scientific discussion and not to comment to the press while this discussion is going on.”

CytoDyn Inc (CYDY) Stock Research Links

CYDY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Worker Pullback Is a Cost Problem Employers Ignore

Updated Category News Views 86

Somewhere between a job description and an unpaid favor, a lot of corporate productivity appears to be quietly leaking out. MyPerfectResume’s July 2026 survey of 1,000 U.S. workers says 78% have intentionally done only the minimum needed to keep their jobs at least once. That is not a cute workplace-culture headline. It is a warning flare about discretionary...

Continue Reading
Midterm Voters Put Cost Relief Ahead of Washington Wars

Updated Category News Views 78

Gas pumps and medical bills have a way of humiliating every grand political slogan ever printed. Seven Letter Insight's latest post-election survey says confirmed 2026 midterm voters want the 120th Congress to deal with costs first, particularly gas prices, health care, restoring health care tax credits and energy bills. That is not a glamorous mandate. It is, however,...

Continue Reading
YYForce Security Win Adds Recurring Singapore Revenue Base

Updated Category News Views 160

A retail-property security mandate rarely makes anyone pound the table, and frankly it should not. Still, YYForce has landed a tangible two-year contract in Singapore worth roughly S$831,120, with subsidiary Uniforce Security Services set to begin work on December 1, 2026. For NASDAQ:YFOR investors, this is the kind of small, operationally real win that deserves a sober...

Continue Reading
Six LIFE Photographers Bring History Into Florida Focus

Updated Category News Views 55

Seventy photographs can make a pretty loud argument when the historical record has been this lopsided. The Ashley Gibson Barnett Museum of Art at Florida Southern College has brought LIFE: Six Women Photographers to Lakeland, and it deserves more than the usual polite nod given to a traveling museum show. Open since November 14, 2026, and running through March 7, 2027,...

Continue Reading
RLX Revenue Soars, but European Margins Need Proof

Updated Category News Views 111

Revenue can wear a fancy suit while earnings arrive in work boots, and RLX Technology's third quarter is exactly that kind of report. The newly consolidated European distribution business pushed third-quarter revenue to RMB1.92 billion, up 69.7% year over year. That is a real jump, not pocket change. But the same acquisition also changed the mix, squeezed the blended...

Continue Reading
Why Dent Repair Estimates Need More Than a Simple Ruler

Updated Category News Views 118

A dent can look harmless in a parking-lot glare and still turn into a stubborn repair job once somebody examines the metal properly. That is the useful, unglamorous point Jason Phelps of Magic Dent makes in a HelloNation article: visible diameter is not a verdict. Anybody shopping for vehicle repairs, managing fleet costs, or watching the collision-service ecosystem ought...

Continue Reading
Sidus Gains Argotec Order, but Investors Need the Math

Updated Category News Views 72

A Real Customer Signal, Minus the Revenue Figure An updated image is the least interesting detail in this release. Sidus Space has landed a purchase order from Argotec Group to manufacture cable assemblies for the HAWK satellite platform, with delivery expected in the first quarter of 2027. That is a legitimate operational win for NASDAQ:SIDU. It brings in a new...

Continue Reading
S&P Global's UBS AI Conference Slot Deserves Attention

Updated Category News Views 88

Thirty Minutes Can Still Matter A half-hour fireside chat is not a quarterly earnings call, and anybody treating it like one is setting themselves up for disappointment. Still, S&P Global CEO Martina Cheung appearing at the UBS Global Technology and AI Conference on December 2 deserves a spot on the calendar for owners of NYSE:SPGI. This is a company sitting in the middle...

Continue Reading
Pennsylvania Housing Finds Its October Holding Pattern

Updated Category News Views 79

Pennsylvania's October housing numbers have the uneasy stillness of a pond before somebody throws a rock. The statewide median sales price sat at $315,000, exactly where it was in September, while sales barely cleared 10,400 and available listings kept inching higher. Nothing in that mix screams boom or bust. Frankly, that is the point: a market can look calm on the...

Continue Reading
Nansha's Trade Pitch Has Numbers, but Questions Remain

Updated Category News Views 61

A Chilean cherry spending 22 days at sea can tell an investor plenty about where Guangzhou's Nansha District wants to sit in Asia-Pacific commerce. Not glamorous, no. But trade infrastructure rarely is until volumes pile up, routes deepen, and somebody else finds they cannot easily replicate the network. Nansha is using the expected 33rd APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting in...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Examining the Latest Trends in Beyond Meat's Short Selling

Updated Category News Views 624

Understanding Beyond Meat's Short Interest Dynamics Beyond Meat (NASDAQ: BYND) has seen an increase in its short percent of float, now at 4.44% higher than the last report. Currently, 24.77 million shares have been sold short, constituting a substantial 39.78% of the total shares available for trading. Given the current trading volume, it would take approximately 10.11...

Continue Reading
Vestis Corporation Faces Class Action Amid Financial Woes

Updated Category News Views 231

Vestis Corporation's Class Action Lawsuit Announcement Pomerantz LLP has formally announced a class action lawsuit targeting Vestis Corporation (NASDAQ: VSTS). This lawsuit stems from allegations of securities fraud and other improper business practices potentially committed by the Company and its executives. Investors who have incurred losses from their investments in...

Continue Reading
Join Ring Energy's Insightful Fireside Chat on Industry Trends

Updated Category News Views 192

Exciting Participation of Ring Energy in Upcoming Fireside Chat Ring Energy, Inc. (NYSE American: REI) has announced its upcoming participation in a noteworthy fireside chat hosted by Water Tower Research. Insights from Industry Leaders This engaging discussion is scheduled to take place at 10:00 AM Central Time, featuring Paul McKinney, the Chairman and Chief Executive...

Continue Reading
SEGG Media's Exciting Leap into NBA Advertising Strategy

Updated Category News Views 191

SEGG Media Strengthens Presence in the NBA SEGG Media Corporation has made significant strides in expanding its brand influence within the U.S. sports landscape. The company, which is the parent organization of Sports.com, has recently announced a strategic initiative to feature full-page advertisements in yearbooks for seven premier NBA teams during the upcoming season....

Continue Reading
Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta Reports Q3 2024 Financial Overview

Updated Category News Views 95

Financial Highlights of Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta The Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta has recently shared its preliminary financial highlights for the third quarter of 2024, showcasing important metrics and performance results. The Bank's quarterly outcomes signal core functionalities and adjustments aimed at sustaining a strong financial foundation. Key...

Continue Reading