FAST APPROACHING ..... The US Solicitor General has

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
CyberC
624
FAST APPROACHING .....

The US Solicitor General has asked the Supreme Court to take up the Berkheimer v. HP case, and it is hoped they will address this when they come back this fall. Same with the appeal for SFOR. It is a hurry up and wait. Consider the following news report when thinking about how the Supreme Court feels about the Alice 101 ...

A New Court and a New Fix for Alice and Patent Eligibility under Section 101

Henry Schein, Inc. v. Archer & White Sales, Inc, a case examining a judicially-created exception to the Federal Arbitration Act, may hold clues to how the Supreme Court will approach patent eligible subject matter going forward. Specifically, the three judicial exceptions to patent eligibility could be found, unanimously, inapplicable at the Court’s next review of the issue.

In a unanimous Supreme Court decision dated January 8, Justice Brett Kavanaugh authored an opinion applying a statutory construction principle to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) that may foreshadow how the new Court, applying the same principle, will dramatically reshape how federal courts must approach patent eligible subject matter challenges by eliminating the judicial exceptions—abstract ideas, laws of nature and natural phenomenon—and thus moot the debate that has followed (and preceded) the Court’s Alice decision.

No Judicial Exceptions
In Henry Schein, Inc. v. Archer & White Sales, Inc., Case No. 17-1272, the Court considered the Circuit split over whether the “wholly groundless” exception to an FAA provision requiring the arbitrator to decide issues the parties had agreed to arbitrate could be relied on to permit a district court to determine in the first instance whether a particular dispute was arbitrable, notwithstanding that the parties had agreed arbitrability questions should be decided by the arbitrator. The Court unanimously held that the exception does not apply. The reason is simple. As Justice Kavanaugh explained, acknowledging that the FAA had been adopted by Congress and signed by the President: “The short answer is that the Act contains no [such] exception, and we may not engraft our own exceptions onto the statutory text.” Henry Schein, slip op. at 7. Hammering home this rather unambiguous principle, Justice Kavanagh noted: “Again, we may not rewrite the statute simply to accommodate [a recognized] policy concern.” Id. at 8.

That noise you just heard was dozens of decades of jurisprudence applying the well-known three judicial exceptions to patent eligible subject matter—abstract ideas, laws of nature, and natural phenomenon—which do not appear in the Patent Act, flying right out the window. The little pop was the judicially created obviousness type double patenting defense following.

Seismic Shift Ahead?
Does Henry Schein, reflecting a unanimous Court’s interpretation of a statute, reflect a shift to now interpreting statutes such that exceptions not found in the text cannot be applied? Certainly, such an argument can be made, and one might expect the Court to treat all statutes, including the Patent Act, in the same manner, as the Court has done before, e.g., eBay. In other words, the three judicial exceptions to patent eligibility, which courts at all levels throughout the land have struggled over since their inception—and which the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has likewise struggled over and addressed with its parade of guidelines, even now being revised—and which nowhere appear in the text of the Patent Act, could be found, unanimously, inapplicable at the Court’s next review of the issue.

Perhaps this will happen sooner that one would normally expect in the slow world of Supreme Court case law. Indeed, this might just explain why the Court on January 7 asked the U.S. Solicitor General to submit an amicus brief in the Berkheimer case, which is currently before the Court on petition for certiorari. Berkheimer frames nicely the issue of patent eligibility and how district courts should handle motions to dismiss patent infringement claims under Section 101 and Alice. Although the issue framed by the cert petition is whether factual questions underlying an application of judicial exception to patent eligibility require the district court to defer ruling on the motion until the factfinder has resolved those issues, e.g., after trial, this just might be the case that the Court employs to make definitively clear that the 101 motions simply should be denied because the judicial exceptions are not found in the Patent Act and thus no longer apply.

It also might explain why, as the IP press has reported, the two senators are meeting with industry groups to discuss potential legislative amendments to Section 101 as an alternative fix to the current patent eligibility jurisprudence. Clearly, under Henry Schein the Court must intend to strike the judicial exceptions to patent eligibility—because they don’t appear in the statute—and it will be up to Congress to tell us what they really mean about what is patentable subject matter, and what is not. Perhaps Congress can, in a bipartisan way, figure out and put in the text any limits on patenting anything under the sun made by man that is a “new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter …” 35 U.S.C. §101.

Who would have thought patent eligibility would finally be resolved so clearly, simply, and quickly? Hopefully, Congress will move quickly on that legislative effort to avoid a catastrophe from unintended consequences for our already challenged patent system.

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Lululemon Faces Class Action over Alleged Missteps

Updated Category News Views 13

Trouble Brewing for Lululemon Y'ever get that gut feeling when something doesn't smell right? Well, Lululemon Athletica (NASDAQ: LULU) investors are probably feeling that now. A class action's kicking up dust over what some are saying was a downright bumpy ride. The brainiacs at Robbins LLP urge those who've lost bucks riding the LULU train to step forward ahead of the...

Continue Reading
Dawson Struggles With Q3 Losses Despite Growth Prospects

Updated Category News Views 25

Profit and loss dance around like a jittery stock, and Dawson Geophysical is feeling the heat this third quarter. Numbers are in, and we’re seeing a net loss of $5.2 million, translating to $0.17 per share—ouch. Not to mention a negative Adjusted EBITDA of $2 million. Compared to last year's hopes, that's a serious belly flop. Revenue Down, Hopes Up In a fetching...

Continue Reading
Biel Crystal Solidifies Position as Key iPhone UTG Supplier

Updated Category News Views 71

Biel Crystal Hones In On Foldable iPhone Tech Here's the lowdown: Apple's making waves with their first foldable phone, the iPhone Duo, and Biel Crystal? They're the rockstars cranking out that ultra-thin glass making it all possible. You might not have heard their name tossed around as much, but they're heavy hitters in the tech components scene. Biel Crystal's been...

Continue Reading
ELEGRP Makes Dyson Supersonic Global Voltage Ready

Updated Category News Views 36

Plugging Into the Future of Travel ELEGRP's latest move brings the Dyson Supersonic Travel hair dryer into the limelight, all decked out with global voltage compatibility. It's like the Swiss Army knife of hair dryers—one minute it’s working on 100V, next it’s flipping over to a juicy 240V, without breaking a sweat. The ALCI Difference: Safety Takes Center Stage...

Continue Reading
Phoenix Contact Achieves Guinness Record in Wiring

Updated Category News Views 160

A Blitz of Wires and Innovation Boy, did Phoenix Contact shake things up in Blomberg. On a crisp November day, a group of fresh-faced first-year students pulled off something astounding—wiring 500 terminal blocks in a jaw-dropping 2 minutes and 20 seconds. This wasn’t just any effort; it was enough to earn them a shiny new Guinness World Record. What they did wasn’t...

Continue Reading
Mining Equipment Market to Surge, Hitting $42.81B by 2033

Updated Category News Views 86

Forecasts on Market Growth: A Robust Climb Ahead Brace yourself because this mining equipment racket is ramping up like you wouldn't believe. Analysts are telling us the market's supposed to roar from a $28.42 billion check in 2026 to a jaw-dropping $42.81 billion come 2033. That's a 6.0% CAGR—a figure that'll catch the eye of anyone not sound asleep at the wheel....

Continue Reading
YONDELIS: Thai Approval Opens New Sarcoma Treatment Path

Updated Category News Views 254

New Hope for Thai Sarcoma Patients Alright, we’ve got some good news coming out of Thailand, folks. The Thai FDA just greenlit YONDELIS® (trabectedin) for those grappling with advanced soft tissue sarcoma (STS). Now, this isn’t your everyday drug release—it’s a clinical chess move packing potential for patients who’ve run out of other options. December 1st,...

Continue Reading
SANY's Bold AI Showdown at bauma CHINA 2026

Updated Category News Views 0

SANY's Future Vision: AI Agents and Robotic Machinery The construction machinery game is about to get a whole lot smarter, if SANY has anything to say about it. They're rolling out their biggest show ever at bauma CHINA 2026, and the headline act? A fresh breed of AI agents and robotic machinery that promises to revolutionize the industry. Marking its 40-year legacy, SANY...

Continue Reading
RBC Grabs Top Honors for Sustainable Investing Leadership

Updated Category News Views 21

A New Feather in RBC's Cap RBC Wealth Management has racked up more accolades, crowned as the Best Private Bank in Canada and celebrated for its prowess in impact and sustainable investing on the global stage. These distinctions flew in courtesy of the PWM Global Private Banking Awards—a heavyweight recognition in the wealth management world. Award Winning Strategy in...

Continue Reading
Segway Powersports Dominates Baja 1000 with Class 2 Sweep

Updated Category News Views 86

Catching the eye of any betting man, Segway Powersports has turned its maiden outing at the relentless SCORE Baja 1000 into a rousing victory. Their arrival on this unforgiving stage with a one-two in Class 2 isn't just a lucky roll—you don't chance upon podium sweeps in such gritty contests. Dissecting the Drive: Commitment and Coordination Unfolding across Baja's...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Apirone's Transformative Year: Innovations and Achievements

Updated Category News Views 120

Apirone's Transformative Year: Innovations and Achievements As we reflect on the recent progress made by Apirone, a leading cryptocurrency services provider, it is clear that 2025 marked a groundbreaking year in the company’s evolution. With a steadfast commitment to fostering innovation and enhancing user engagement, Apirone has undertaken a series of pivotal...

Continue Reading
Green Rain Energy Enhances Capital Structure with Share Swap

Updated Category News Views 170

Green Rain Energy Takes Strategic Steps to Strengthen Capital Structure Green Rain Energy Holdings Inc. (OTCID: GREH) has made an announcement that reflects its commitment to enhancing shareholder value and addressing market dynamics. The Chief Executive Officer, Alfredo Papadakis, plans to cancel 310 million common shares held through a holding company. This bold move...

Continue Reading
Piper Sandler's Positive View on Webster Financial's Potential

Updated Category News Views 92

Positive Insights from Piper Sandler on Webster Financial Piper Sandler has reaffirmed its Overweight rating on Webster Financial Corporation (NYSE: WBS), setting a steadfast price target of $54.00. This rating reflects confidence in the bank's potential for recovery and growth, despite recent challenges faced by the company. Current Performance Analysis Despite a...

Continue Reading
City Furniture's Grand Opening Sparks Growth in Tampa Region

Updated Category News Views 158

City Furniture Celebrates Exciting Grand Opening CITY Furniture, a leading home furnishings retailer, has celebrated the successful grand opening of its expansive 120,000-square-foot showroom in Sarasota. This event not only marks a significant milestone in the company's growth but also embodies its commitment to transforming the home shopping experience in the Tampa...

Continue Reading
Celebrating Scott Alexander Rose as a Pinnacle Achiever in 2024

Updated Category News Views 238

Scott Alexander Rose Recognized as a Pinnacle Achiever 2024 Scott Alexander Rose has been prominently featured and acknowledged as a Pinnacle Achiever 2024 for his exemplary contributions to education and philanthropy. His dedication reflects a lifetime of service and commitment to making a meaningful impact. A Commitment to Education and Excellence Dr. Rose's academic...

Continue Reading