https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2019/06/30/patent-maste

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (4) Message Board
gimli
621
https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2019/06/30/patent-...id=110847/

June 30, 2019

Senator Thom Tillis
Chair, Senate IP Subcommittee
113 Dirksen Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510

Senator Chris Coons
Ranking Member, Senate IP Subcommittee
218 Russel Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510

Representative Doug Collins
Ranking Member, House Judiciary Committee
1504 Longworth House Office Building
Washington, DC 20515

Representative Hank Johnson
Chair, House IP Subcommittee
2240 Rayburn House Office Building
Washington, DC 20510

Representative Steve Stivers
2234 Rayburn House Office Building
Washington, DC 20515

RE: Patent Eligibility

Dear Senator Tillis, Senator Coons, Representative Collins, Representative Johnson and Representative Stivers:

We applaud your efforts over the last several months to engage stakeholders on the important issue of patent eligibility reform. We view this effort as critical for the future of a variety of high-tech and life sciences industries in the United States.

As was discussed during testimony in recent hearings of the Senate IP Subcommittee, the Supreme Court has refused four (4) dozen petitions for certiorari on the issue of patent eligibility since issuing its decision in in Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank Int’l, 134 S.Ct. 2347 (2014). The assumption must, therefore, be that the Supreme Court is content with its patent eligibility jurisprudence.

Unfortunately, Supreme Court jurisprudence on patent eligibility is irreconcilable and has created tremendous uncertainty in an area where long term certainty is absolutely essential. Innovation typically takes a great deal of time, and commercializing that innovation takes even more time. Without long term stability and predictability investment decisions and incentives become skewed.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has explained in at least several decisions that they feel handcuffed by Supreme Court jurisprudence. But even more problematic is the wide divergence of outcomes among Federal Circuit panels. Put simply, the Supreme Court test for patent eligibility is subjective and unpredictable. Congress must act.

Amidst this uncertainty, and with the fifth anniversary of the Supreme Court’s Alice decision having just passed, last week IPWatchdog.com held a two-day symposium to discuss the state of patent eligibility in the United States. During this symposium overwhelming consensus was achieved by the Patent Masters™ faculty and symposium attendees on a variety of principles and recommendations.

The following statements received unanimous consent during the Patent Masters™ Symposium:

Supreme Court decisions interpreting 35 U.S.C. 101 have harmed the U.S. economy.
Supreme Court decisions interpreting 35 U.S.C. 101 are impeding the progress of the useful arts.
Supreme Court decisions interpreting 35 U.S.C. 101 are impeding the progress of innovations relating to medical diagnostics.
Supreme Court decisions interpreting 35 U.S.C. 101 are impeding the progress of innovations relating to important areas of software innovations, such as artificial intelligence and machine learning.
Supreme Court decisions interpreting 35 U.S.C. 101 have diminished America’s global competitiveness.
The Supreme Court was unquestionably incorrect in AMP v. Myriad Genetics when they said discoveries are not patent eligible. The Constitution explicitly says otherwise, as does 35 U.S.C. 101.
The following statements achieved consent from at least eighty-percent (80%) of those attending the symposium:

The Supreme Court’s decisions on patent eligibility in Funk Brothers, Benson, Flook, Diehr, Chakrabarty, Bilski, Mayo, Myriad and Alice are hopelessly irreconcilable. [91% consensus]
Supreme Court decisions interpreting 35 U.S.C. 101 are driving innovation and investment overseas. [86% consensus]
Supreme Court decisions interpreting 35 U.S.C. 101 violate separation of powers by adding “judicial exceptions” and usurping Congressional authority to define what is patent eligible. [83% consensus]
The 2019 Revised Patent Subject Matter Eligibility Guidance published by the USPTO creates the proper analytical framework for approaching questions of patent eligibility. [82% consensus]
Therefore, it is the recommendation of the undersigned attendees of the Patent Masters™ Symposium that:

Congress should legislatively overrule Alice v. CLS Bank.
Congress should legislatively overrule Mayo v. Prometheus.
Congress should explicitly prohibit “judicial exceptions” to patent eligibility.
In conclusion, we greatly appreciate your work on this important matter, and we enthusiastically support your efforts. We stand ready to help in any way possible. Strengthening the U.S. patent system for future generations is of paramount importance.

Very truly yours,

Eugene R. Quinn, Jr., President & CEO, IPWatchdog, Inc.

Paul Michel, Retired Chief Judge, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

cc: Andrei Iancu, Director of the USPTO



Meredith Addy, Partner, AddyHart, P.C.

James Carmichael, Carmichael IP

Brad Close, Executive Vice President, Transpacific IP

Nicholas D’Andrea, Patent Agent

Kate Gaudry, PhD, Patent Attorney (on behalf of herself)

Robert Greenspoon, Founding Partner, Flachsbart & Greenspoon, LLC

Chris Israel, Executive Director, Alliance for U.S. Startups and Inventors for Jobs

Efrat Kasznik, President, Foresight Valuation Group, LLC

Sherry Knowles, Principal, Knowles Intellectual Property Strategies, LLC

Jack Lu, Founding Partner and Chief Economist, IPMAP LLC

Lissi Mojica, Managing Director, Answers IP, LLC

Mark Nowatarski, Principal, Markets, Patents & Alliances, LLC

Isaac T. Slutsky, Shareholder, Brooks Kushman

Bernard Tomsa, Shareholder, Brooks Kushman

John White, Partner, Berenato & White, LLC

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

CARsgen's CT1182 Data Opens a Careful New CAR-T Test

Updated Category News Views 126

Six very sick lymphoma patients are not a victory lap, but they can still make the whole cell-therapy field sit up straighter. CARsgen has disclosed first clinical results for CT1182, an in vivo CAR-T candidate built on its CARvivo platform, and the early package is plainly more interesting than the usual preclinical chest-thumping. The company reported three complete...

Continue Reading
Persistent Dry Eye Symptoms Call for a Closer Look

Updated Category News Views 332

Eyes can turn into a stubborn little nuisance long before people realize something more complicated is going on. A bottle of artificial tears is easy to grab, cheap enough, and often perfectly sensible for a rough day of screens, wind, reading, or air conditioning. But Dr. Harlan Snyder’s point is the one worth sitting with: when dryness keeps barging back despite...

Continue Reading
Anthropic's Leveraged ETFs Arrive After Wild Debut

Updated Category News Views 731

Nothing says a feverish new listing quite like leveraged products lining up before the opening-week confetti has settled. Anthropic priced its IPO at $83 on November 18, raised roughly $81.3 billion, then opened Nasdaq trading at $111.50 on November 19. That is an enormous gap between IPO price and first trade, and it tells investors the obvious thing: plenty of appetite...

Continue Reading
Cardiovalve's Three-Year Data Clears a Crucial EU Hurdle

Updated Category News Views 98

A failing tricuspid valve is not a spreadsheet problem, and that matters before anybody gets carried away with a glossy conference presentation. Venus Medtech's Cardiovalve unit has reported results from TARGET in a population that was old, sick and largely out of good surgical options. That is precisely where a less invasive replacement therapy has to prove it can do...

Continue Reading
UAE Trust Model Faces Its Hardest Test During Crisis

Updated Category News Views 385

A country’s reputation is usually invisible right up until the machinery rattles. Then people, investors, trading partners and residents stop listening to polished slogans and start watching whether airports function, services hold up, information arrives, and business can keep moving. That was the useful core of Saeed Al Eter’s remarks at Ajman Media Forum 2026: soft...

Continue Reading
PettiChat’s Digital Pet Twin Has Real Consumer Pull

Updated Category News Views 410

A Collar Gadget Is Chasing the Empty-House Problem Leave a dog or cat alone for a few hours and plenty of owners turn into amateur detectives. Did the cat eat? Has the dog been pacing? Why was that one weird noise caught on the home camera? Seattle startup PettiChat is trying to turn that itch into a product category with PettiLive!, a screen-based version of a pet that...

Continue Reading
NatGasHub’s 391% Growth Signals a Real Pipeline Shift

Updated Category News Views 445

Three hundred-plus pipelines is a lot of messy plumbing to tame, and NatGasHub has apparently found a lucrative way to do it. The Houston software company landed at No. 182 on Deloitte’s 2026 Technology Fast 500 after reporting 391% revenue growth from 2022 through 2025. That is a serious number, even in a ranking built to showcase companies sprinting uphill. More...

Continue Reading
PHONO's 150 MW RE+ Win Tests Its U.S. Solar Staying Power

Updated Category News Views 534

A trade-show order book is not cash in the bank, but 150 MW is still a number worth circling in red. PHONO used RE+ 2026 in Las Vegas, held November 17 through 19, to celebrate 20 years in business, parade its solar and storage lineup, and announce new U.S. orders. In a solar market that has become touchier about provenance, compliance and delivered economics, the company...

Continue Reading
ModuleMD Takes Allergy EHR AI Beyond the Usual Hype Cycle

Updated Category News Views 398

Allergy Workflows Are Where This Has to Earn Its Keep Allergy clinics do not need another shiny dashboard clogging up a workstation. They need less typing, fewer handoffs, cleaner documentation, and fewer administrative chores slipping through the cracks while a packed day keeps moving. That is the practical lens for ModuleMD's ACAAI 2026 presentation in Phoenix: not...

Continue Reading
Fractional CIOs Bring Order to Growing Technology Chaos

Updated Category News Views 270

A company can outgrow its technology habits long before anyone notices the smoke. One day the owner is approving another software subscription, the office manager is chasing an internet provider, and the tech person is putting out password fires. None of that looks dramatic in isolation. Together, it is a business operating without a map. That is the useful point in the...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Madison Achieves Top Rank for Employment Opportunities

Updated Category News Views 256

Madison Tops Functional Employment Rankings Recently, Madison has been recognized as the leading metro area in the country for functional employment, a title derived from a comprehensive analysis by the Ludwig Institute for Shared Economic Prosperity (LISEP). This achievement highlights Madison’s robust job growth, higher wage levels, and an overall favorable work...

Continue Reading
Investors Alert: Class Actions Against WEBTOON, Elanco, and Domino's

Updated Category News Views 131

Class Action Lawsuits Overview In recent developments, Bragar Eagel & Squire, P.C., a well-known shareholder rights law firm, has informed investors about multiple class action lawsuits filed against notable companies such as WEBTOON Entertainment, Inc. (NASDAQ: WBTN), Elanco Animal Health Incorporated (NYSE: ELAN), and Domino's Pizza, Inc. (NYSE: DPZ). Shareholders in...

Continue Reading
Navigating the New Multipolar Reality: Insights for Investors

Updated Category News Views 257

The Shift to a Multipolar World: What Investors Need to Know The global landscape has transformed, moving away from a system dominated by one major power to a multipolar world. This significant shift means that traditional geopolitical assumptions guiding investors are no longer reliable. Marko Papic, Chief Strategist at BCA Research, recently underscored this point in a...

Continue Reading
Jim Cramer Discusses Broadcom's Impact on Market Corrections

Updated Category News Views 211

Market Dynamics and Broadcom's Recent Performance As the Nasdaq 100 index faces a notable correction, Broadcom Inc. (NASDAQ: AVGO) has managed to stand out with a remarkable surge of 12.82% during after-hours trading. However, renowned market analyst Jim Cramer expresses skepticism regarding its ability to reverse the overall market decline. Understanding the Market...

Continue Reading
NSFOCUS Achieves 'Stars Companies' Recognition in DDoS Sector

Updated Category News Views 137

NSFOCUS Achieves Notable Recognition in Cybersecurity In a significant development, NSFOCUS has earned recognition as a 'Stars Company' in the DDoS Protection and Mitigation Security sector by the esteemed MarketsandMarkets' 360Quadrants platform. This accolade reflects NSFOCUS's unwavering commitment to innovation and excellence in delivering cutting-edge solutions for...

Continue Reading