Preparing for 101 Change: Preserving Future Arguments By

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
gimli gimli #55524
535
Preparing for 101 Change: Preserving Future Arguments
By Scott McKeown & Matthew Rizzolo on June 4, 2019

Plan Ahead for 101 Change
With the Senate conducting marathon hearings on the subject of patentable subject matter this week (i.e., 35 U.S.C. § 101), and with significant effort to date to move legislation forward, it appears that 101 change is coming — and soon.

Given the imminent legislative reset, what should you do if your patent is invalidated by the Court’s under the current 101 regime?

First, you need to preserve your right to appeal and keep the case alive long enough for Congress to pass its new 101 framework. Depending on where you are in the process, this may require filing an appeal to the Federal Circuit, filing for rehearing or rehearing en banc, or filing for a writ of certiorari to the Supreme Court. Maintaining pendency is essential as it remains unclear whether the new 101 framework will be applied retroactively to existing cases and/or issued but unexpired patents and, if so, how it will be applied.

It seems unlikely that Congress would intend that this legislative framework, if passed, could be used to “revive” patents that have been subject to a final judgment of unpatentability by the Courts (more on that below). But it may opt to apply the law retroactively to any patent cases that are not yet final. It is therefore important that patent owners preserve all eligibility arguments to avoid waiving any rights.

Patent owners may argue that a significant change in law—even during the pendency of an appeal—is sufficient to seek a remand and re-determination under the new regime. For example, we can look to the Federal Circuit’s rulings in the wake of the Supreme Court’s SAS Institute for similar guidance. There, the court recognized that SAS represented a “significant change in law that occurred during the pendency of [the] appeal” and “[p]recedent holds that a party does not waive an argument that arises for a significant change in law during the pendency of an appeal.” Biodelivery Scis. Int’l., Inc. v. Aquestive Therapeutics, Inc., 898 F.3d 1205 (Fed. Cir. 2018) (quoting Polaris Indus. Inc. v. Arctic Cat, Inc., 724 Fed. Appx 948 (Fed. Cir. 2018). Indeed, the Fed Circuit agreed that Biodelivery’s failure to predict that the court would remand for SAS-related issues—even after the PTAB issued new statutory guidance on post-SAS procedures—did not constitute waiver of any arguments under SAS.

Applying similar logic to the current 101 framework, Patent Owners should expect that any change in 101 from Congress may constitute a “significant” change under the law allowing them to move for rehearing and remand under the new regime. Best practices, however, suggest maintaining all arguments to avoid the risk of waiver.

Moreover, it’s also important to keep in mind that claims held to be invalid in district courts are not actually canceled, like those held unpatentable in a PTAB proceeding — the only thing stopping patent owners from re-asserting such claims in the future is the principle of Blonder-Tongue collateral estoppel. If Congress doesn’t ultimately address whether the change in 101 law has a retroactive effect, we could see the situation where claims previously held invalid under current Section 101 law could be re-asserted in district court against new parties or products after legislative changes go into effect. It’ll be interesting to see if any witnesses or Representatives at the upcoming hearings address the potential creation of such “zombie patents.”

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Prospera’s DFW Culture Win Matters Beyond the Plaque

Updated Category News Views 46

Employee survey ballots rarely make pulses race, but this one deserves more than a lazy shrug. Prospera Financial Services has landed on The Dallas Morning News’ 2026 Top Workplaces DFW list for a second consecutive year, placing in the Top Small Workplaces category. For a boutique independent broker-dealer, that is not meaningless wall décor. The people doing the...

Continue Reading
Subsplash Builds a Broader Church Software Stack in 2026

Updated Category News Views 113

Church software has spent too many years behaving like a junk drawer, and Subsplash is plainly trying to replace it with one working system. The company used its November 18 Product Event in Dallas to show off releases from 2026 and preview two additions: Communications, due in December, and Subsplash Intelligence, targeted for early 2027. A Serious Push Beyond the Church...

Continue Reading
D-Wave Investors Face December 15 Lead Plaintiff Clock

Updated Category News Views 94

Quantum dreams met a very earthly spreadsheet problem at D-Wave this summer. The proposed securities class action against D-Wave Quantum Inc. puts a hard date on the issue for investors who bought shares between February 26 and August 25, 2026: December 15, 2026 is the deadline to seek lead-plaintiff status. That does not mean every holder needs to march into court. It...

Continue Reading
Six LIFE Photographers Bring History Into Florida Focus

Updated Category News Views 55

Seventy photographs can make a pretty loud argument when the historical record has been this lopsided. The Ashley Gibson Barnett Museum of Art at Florida Southern College has brought LIFE: Six Women Photographers to Lakeland, and it deserves more than the usual polite nod given to a traveling museum show. Open since November 14, 2026, and running through March 7, 2027,...

Continue Reading
Wenge AI Removes a Small Friction Point for ScienceOra

Updated Category News Views 84

Scientific software rarely loses users because the underlying model is too clever; it loses them because getting through the front door is a nuisance. Wenge AI has addressed that unglamorous problem by adding Google and Apple sign-in options to the international version of ScienceOra, its AI-powered research and decision-support platform. This is not the sort of...

Continue Reading
CITGO Sign Return Caps Kenmore's Careful Rebuild Work

Updated Category News Views 62

Thirty feet upward and 120 feet eastward is not the sort of move that usually stops a city in its tracks, yet Boston’s CITGO Sign was never merely rooftop hardware. Its public relighting in Kenmore Square marks the final phase of the redevelopment at 660 Beacon Street, and the real accomplishment is less flashy than the lights: a beloved, federally landmarked object...

Continue Reading
APEC's Shenzhen Signal Is Bigger Than a Two-Day Summit

Updated Category News Views 72

Shenzhen spent two days trying to turn regional anxiety into a workable agenda. The APEC CEO Summit 2026, held November 17 and 18 at the Qianhai International Convention Center, brought together more than 2,000 political and business leaders from all 21 APEC economies and 13 economies outside the group. That is a serious room, not a ceremonial photo line. Still, investors...

Continue Reading
SHEIN's EU Training Push Targets Seller Compliance Gaps

Updated Category News Views 102

Chemicals buried in a cheap handbag or kids' accessory can wreck a marketplace's credibility faster than any glossy campaign can repair it. That is the uncomfortable backdrop to SHEIN and SPEAC's November 19 session on EU chemical-safety rules for marketplace sellers. This was not a fashion trend webinar; it was a practical warning about high-risk substances, regulatory...

Continue Reading
GreenTree Faces Softer Rooms, Debt and NYSE Deadline

Updated Category News Views 34

A hotel operator can post positive earnings and still leave shareholders with a nasty headache, and GreenTree's third quarter is that kind of report. NYSE:GHG produced RMB243.0 million in revenue, down 22.2% from a year earlier, while net income slipped to RMB49.3 million from RMB59.0 million. This was not a one-line stumble. Room pricing, occupancy, franchise economics...

Continue Reading
Epilepsy Campaign Puts Patient Voices Before Investors

Updated Category News Views 28

An epilepsy diagnosis can turn ordinary family routines into a maze overnight, which is why awareness work deserves more than the usual polite nod and a colored ribbon. Mediaplanet's national Epilepsy Awareness campaign, launched November 20, 2026, brings the subject into a USA TODAY print insert and related digital coverage during Epilepsy Awareness Month. That reach...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

NANO Nuclear Energy Partners with Cambridge Atom Works for ODIN Sale

Updated Category News Views 195

NANO Nuclear Energy Partners with Cambridge Atom Works for ODIN Sale NANO Nuclear Energy Inc. has made a pivotal move by signing a letter of intent to sell its innovative ODIN™ low-pressure coolant reactor technology. This strategic decision not only signifies NANO Nuclear's commitment to optimizing their technology portfolio but also enables a sharper focus on their...

Continue Reading
Project C.U.R.E. and Microsoft: Transforming Global Health Access

Updated Category News Views 244

Transforming Global Healthcare Through Innovative Partnerships In a world where access to essential healthcare is still a significant challenge, Project C.U.R.E. has teamed up with Microsoft to make a meaningful difference. This collaboration aims to change the lives of millions by providing vital medical resources to underserved populations. With over 4.5 billion people...

Continue Reading
How STRADVISION Is Leading the Charge in Automotive Innovation

Updated Category News Views 395

Transforming the Automotive Industry: STRADVISION's Role STRADVISION, a pioneer in deep learning-based vision perception technology, is at the forefront of a revolution in the automotive industry. Their latest edition of the STRADVISION Market Intelligence Report delves into significant trends transforming the automotive landscape, influenced by advancements in autonomous...

Continue Reading
Holdings and Legal Developments: Atkore Inc. Class Action Insight

Updated Category News Views 182

Understanding the Atkore Inc. Class Action Lawsuit In recent developments, Atkore Inc. (NASDAQ: ATKR) is facing a class action lawsuit that has raised significant attention among investors. The lawsuit, officially titled Westchester Putnam Counties Heavy & Highway Laborers Local 60 Benefits Fund v. Atkore Inc., highlights serious allegations against the company and its...

Continue Reading
Brenda Snow's Empowering New Book for Patients on Health Journey

Updated Category News Views 279

Brenda Snow's Inspiring Book on Navigating Health Challenges Brenda Snow's upcoming book is generating buzz as a vital resource for individuals grappling with serious health issues. This essential guide, titled Diagnosed: The Essential Guide to Navigating the Patient's Journey, is set to empower patients and caregivers alike. A Personal Narrative That Inspires In her...

Continue Reading