Opinion - The House Must See the Whole Mueller Report

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board

Apr 1, 2019 at 10:29 AM 181

Quote:

Opinion - The House Must See the Whole Mueller Report

Someday, Trump will not be in office. Congress needs a full accounting of his misdeeds to ensure they don’t happen again.

By Jerrold L. Nadler
Mr. Nadler is the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee.
April 1, 2019

Last Sunday, Attorney General William Barr sent us a letter summarizing what he says are the “principal conclusions” of the special counsel, Robert Mueller. The next day, together with five other committee chairmen, I wrote back to the attorney general, demanding that he provide us with the full Mueller report — not a summary, but the full report and all of the relevant evidence — by April 2.

For nearly two years, the country has waited to read the report. Over those many months, President Trump has raged against the institutions that make our democracy possible — among them, the free press, the courts and his own Department of Justice. When the special counsel indicted members of the president’s inner circle, his attacks got louder.

Before the formal investigation began, Mr. Trump fired his F.B.I. director. He later fired his attorney general. He reportedly attempted to fire the special counsel himself. Despite this profoundly unacceptable behavior, the special counsel persevered and wrote his report.

We — the members of the Judiciary Committee, the House of Representatives and the entire American public — are still waiting to see that report. We will not wait much longer. We have an obligation to read the full report, and the Department of Justice has an obligation to provide it, in its entirely, without delay. If the department is unwilling to produce the full report voluntarily, then we will do everything in our power to secure it for ourselves.

The entire reason for appointing the special counsel was to protect the investigation from political influence. By offering us his version of events in lieu of the report, the attorney general, a recent political appointee, undermines the work and the integrity of his department. He also denies the public the transparency it deserves. We require the full report — the special counsel’s words, not the attorney general’s summary or a redacted version.

We require the report, first, because Congress, not the attorney general, has a duty under the Constitution to determine whether wrongdoing has occurred. The special counsel declined to make a “traditional prosecutorial judgment” on the question of obstruction, but it is not the attorney general’s job to step in and substitute his judgment for the special counsel’s.

That responsibility falls to Congress — and specifically to the House Judiciary Committee — as it has in every similar investigation in modern history. The attorney general’s recent proposal to redact the special counsel’s report before we receive it is unprecedented. We require the evidence, not whatever remains after the report has been filtered by the president’s political appointee.

On its face, the attorney general’s letter raises more questions than it answers. He tells us, for instance, that he declined to charge the president with obstruction in part because there was no underlying crime to obstruct.

Did he discuss that conclusion with Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein — who, while a federal prosecutor, routinely charged individuals with obstruction without charging the underlying crime? Did the attorney general forget that the special counsel indicted 37 other people, including the president’s campaign manager, deputy campaign manager and former national security adviser, for various crimes, including conspiracy against the United States? Did he lose track of his own prosecutors, who effectively named the president as an unindicted co-conspirator in the Southern District of New York?

Second, we require the report because Congress has a role that is fundamentally different from that of the Department of Justice. The special counsel’s mandate was narrow: investigate allegedly criminal conduct stemming from links between the Trump campaign and the Russian government. Our job is to hold the president accountable any time he undermines the rule of law, and is not limited to his involvement with the Russian government during the campaign.

Whether or not the president could have been charged with a crime, even the attorney general acknowledges the existence of evidence that has so far been hidden from view. We have every reason to suspect that the unedited obstruction section of the Mueller report resembles the report that Congress received from the Watergate grand jury in 1974. That evidence showed that President Richard Nixon had attempted to obstruct justice. It did not recommend that the president should be prosecuted. It did not say the president should be impeached. It simply stated the evidence so that Congress could do its job.

Finally, we require the report because one day, one way or another, the country will move on from President Trump. We must make it harder for future presidents to behave this way. We need a full accounting of the president’s actions to do that work.

When the full scope of the president’s misconduct has been revealed, when his lies are debunked and his abuses have been laid bare, I believe that members of Congress on both sides of the aisle will draft legislation to curb the worst of his offenses. Put another way: If President Trump’s behavior wasn’t criminal, then perhaps it should have been.

Related
More on the Mueller report.

Opinion | The Editorial Board
No Collusion, No ‘Exoneration’
March 24, 2019
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/24/opinion/mu...pe=Article

Opinion | Neal K. Katyal
The Many Problems With the Barr Letter
March 24, 2019
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/24/opinion/ba...pe=Article

Opinion | David Leonhardt
William Barr, Media Handler
March 26, 2019
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/26/opinion/wi...pe=Article

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/01/opinion/mu...trump.html

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

HANGCHA's AI-Fork Revolution: Bold Steps to 2030

Forklifts and the Future: A Fork in the Road for HANGCHA There's a movement happening, folks, and I don't mean in the usual stock ticker shift way. We're talking forklifts here—AI-powered, no less. HANGCHA Group, a name that may or may not roll off the tongue but sure makes waves in manufacturing, just held its 4th Global Dealers Conference in Hangzhou, China. If you're...

CGI Shines with Strong Q4, Announces Dividend Hike

CGI Records Impressive Fourth Quarter Growth Well, CGI's got reason to strut its stuff this time around. Clocked in with a fourth-quarter revenue of $4.15 billion - that's a nice 3.3% bump up year-over-year, if you leave the currency noise out of it, it's about 2.5%. The real kicker? Net earnings shot up 20.8%. In a world where everyone’s fighting over scraps, these...

Replit Wins 2026 Microsoft Startup Partner Award

Replit's Triumph in the Microsoft Ecosystem If there's one thing you come to expect from this dizzying dance of technology and business, it's that standout players get their due when they push the envelope. Replit just snagged a gleaming accolade by being named Microsoft's 2026 Partner of the Year for Startups. That's a hefty badge, especially coming from a giant like...

Oracle's Opower Drives Record Utility Success in 2026

Peak Performance: Oracle Opower's Latest Surge Hey, energy watchers, if you don't have Oracle Opower on your radar, it might be time for a check-up! These folks have achieved more peak energy demand reduction this year than you've seen in quite some time. We're talking 1 gigawatt reduced across 70-plus events, no less. Wrap your head around that for a minute! That's like...

Lake Victoria Gold Kicks Off Imwelo Drilling Program

Drill Bit Meets Tanzanian Rock: Lake Victoria's Next Move It's not every day you hear about a company plunging rotary bits into African soil with as much gusto as Lake Victoria Gold, eh? The folks over at LVG have decided it's time to hit the ground—or rather, dig into it—with an ambitious 6,500-meter grade control drilling program at their Imwelo Gold Project in...

Group 1 Expands with Porsche Atlanta Northwest Acquisition

Porsche Atlanta Northwest Joins Group 1 Automotive This ain't just some humdrum industry announcement, folks. Group 1 Automotive, the Houston-based heavyweight, has tightened its grip on the Atlanta car scene by welcoming Porsche Atlanta Northwest into the fold. This development marks the latest notch in Group 1’s belt as they continue gobbling up Atlanta-area...

Virginia Water Alerts: Serving 384K with Flow Tips

Keeping Water Flowing Smoothly in Virginia Water's one of those things you hardly notice until it's not there—or worse, when it throws a wrench in your usual routine. Virginia American Water, a branch of the big-dog utility American Water (NYSE: AWK), is trying its darndest to keep folks from missing a beat. They offer up some sage advice on staying plugged into the...

Webull Faces Class Action Over China Ties Missteps

What's Brewing with Webull? Troubling allegations have bubbled to the surface regarding Webull Corporation, now in the crosshairs of a securities class action. The heart of this legal storm is the claim that Webull, under the ticker NASDAQ:BULL, allegedly disguised its deep-seated ties with China. And boy, when those revelations hit the news on October 7, 2026, it sent...

PHFA Unveils 2027/2028 Plan for Housing Tax Credits

Fresh Blueprint for Affordable Housing in Pennsylvania Alright, folks, it's time we talk about something other than Wall Street hype: the nitty-gritty of housing, but not just any housing. I'm talking about low-income housing and what Pennsylvania's Housing Finance Agency (PHFA) has cooked up for us. They’ve released their much-anticipated 2027/2028 Qualified Allocation...

Vipboss Offers Big Black Friday Deals for Adventurers

Anticipating Next Year’s Adventures Today Outdoor enthusiasts, listen up! Just because the frost is nipping at your nose doesn’t mean you can’t start dreaming about where the open road or sea will take you next. Vipboss, a known figure in the world of reliable power solutions, is rolling out a Black Friday bonanza, ready to electrify your preparation game with...