Simple. What if obstruction of an investigation actually

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Bhawks Lmcat #62064
149
Simple. What if obstruction of an investigation actually thwarts the finding of an underlying crime?

Quote:
Martha Stewart to Donald Trump: Can there be obstruction of justice with no underlying crime?

By Louis Jacobson on Monday, March 25th, 2019 at 4:51 p.m.

https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/arti...obstructi/

"Then interfering with the investigation is a crime. The reason is that the purpose of the investigation is to find the truth, and if people obstruct an investigation, then the investigation becomes more difficult, wasting government resources."

Obstruction of a non-crime?

Legal experts told us that a president (or anyone) could still be prosecuted for obstructing justice if they believed they might be prosecuted — even if they ultimately never are.

"You can obstruct justice even if a prosecutor ultimately finds you were not guilty of committing the crime that was the focus of the underlying investigation," said Miriam Baer, a professor at Brooklyn Law School.

"Even if a prosecutor ultimately concluded that you weren’t guilty of crime X, that says nothing as to whether you thought that you might be indicted for crime X, or, for that matter, if you thought one of your friends of family members would be indicted for crime X."

Eric Posner, a professor at the University of Chicago Law School, agreed that an obstruction prosecution could have been argued in this case.

"Suppose Trump knew that no crime had been committed but believed that the investigation would uncover politically or personally embarrassing information, or if he believed that the investigation would embarrass or implicate an ally, aide, or family member," Posner said.

"Then interfering with the investigation is a crime. The reason is that the purpose of the investigation is to find the truth, and if people obstruct an investigation, then the investigation becomes more difficult, wasting government resources."

That said, an obstruction case is naturally going to be stronger if there is an underlying crime that’s being prosecuted, said Ric Simmons, a professor at the Ohio State University Moritz College of Law.

It is "technically possible, but the legal and practical challenges in winning such an obstruction case would be great," Simmons said. "A prosecutor would have to prove that the president believed there was a collusion case ‘contemplated’ against him even when he did not engage in collusion. That is theoretically possible, but hard to prove to a jury."

The cases of Stewart and Libby

The highest-profile example of trying a case of obstruction without an underlying crime that our experts could think of was the prosecution of Martha Stewart, the founder of a popular lifestyle and media company. Stewart was tried on charges related to her sale of 4,000 shares of ImClone, a pharmaceutical company, one day before the company’s stock price plummeted.

The charges of securities fraud were thrown out, but prosecutors persisted with charges of obstruction of justice and lying to investigators. She was found guilty of four counts and in 2004 was sentenced to five months of prison, five months of house arrest, and two years of probation.

Stewart "surely feared reputational and business harm" even in the absence of a crime, said Robert Weisberg, co-director of Stanford University’s Criminal Justice Center.

Another notable example is the case of Scooter Libby, a former top aide to Vice President Dick Cheney, said Samuel Buell, a law professor at Duke University. Libby was charged by a special prosecutor with obstruction, perjury and false statements, but not any underlying crime related to the outing of a CIA employee, Valerie Plame. (Trump pardoned Libby.)

What about Watergate?

Legal experts said there are echoes of Watergate in the current situation.

James D. Robenalt, an attorney with the firm Thompson Hine LLP and creator of a continuing legal education class on Watergate, said the parallels are striking.

President Richard Nixon "knew nothing about the break-in at the Democratic National Committee before the Committee to Re-Elect the President caused it to happen, and the White House — but for one, maybe two tangential people — did not know about the crime." So Nixon could not have been prosecuted for the break-in, nor could other key White House officials, he said. Yet "they all covered up and obstructed justice to protect the Committee to Re-Elect the President," Robenalt said
.

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

PAG, HOWL and PSNL Deals Face Fresh Shareholder Checks

Updated Category News Views 60

Three proposed takeovers, three very different headaches, and one familiar question that never gets old: are regular shareholders actually receiving the best available deal? On Nov. 20, 2026, investor-rights law firm Halper Sadeh LLC said it was investigating the proposed transactions involving Penske Automotive Group, Werewolf Therapeutics and Personalis for potential...

Continue Reading
Birla Carbon's Rayong Bet Tightens Asian Supply Lines

Updated Category News Views 130

Rayong just became a much louder pin on Asia's industrial map. Birla Carbon has inaugurated a 120 kMT carbon black plant in Thailand, and the significance is bigger than a ribbon-cutting photo. This is a capacity-and-location move aimed squarely at the uncomfortable part of industrial supply chains: customers need material when they need it, not after it has spent weeks...

Continue Reading
Trip.Best Expands Global Travel Discovery Footprint

Updated Category News Views 123

Sydney just became the map pin for a fairly serious travel-content land grab. Trip.Best, Trip.com Group's ranking brand, has rolled out its 2027 Annual Rankings with coverage of all seven continents for the first time. This is not an earnings release, and nobody should pretend a hotel list magically turns into revenue by lunchtime. Still, the jump from 85 to 98 annual...

Continue Reading
Mimic Bets Virtual Patching Can Calm AI Patch Chaos

Updated Category News Views 119

Three ugly outages in four days can make even hardened technology buyers reconsider the sacred ritual of “patch immediately.” Mimic’s new Virtual Patching offering arrives squarely in that uncomfortable gap: a vulnerability is known, attackers may be moving fast, and the proper vendor update still needs testing before somebody detonates production. The company’s...

Continue Reading
Veterinary Biologics Growth Has a Valuable Catch Ahead

Updated Category News Views 55

Pet allergies and livestock disease are hardly glamorous, yet they are becoming a durable spending lane. The veterinary biologics market is projected to rise from $2.85 billion in 2026 to $3.69 billion by 2031, a 5.3% compound annual growth rate. That is not the kind of growth figure that makes anyone pound the table, and frankly it should not. It is the sort that can...

Continue Reading
Label-Free Detection Has a Solid, Narrow Growth Lane

Updated Category News Views 77

Biologics labs are turning into a far better hunting ground for analytical equipment than the old, broad-brush research story suggests. Label-free detection is not a giant market, and nobody should dress it up as one. But the projected move from $0.58 billion in 2026 to $0.85 billion by 2031 points to a useful 8.1% annual growth lane, driven by work researchers genuinely...

Continue Reading
FFR Adds Academic and Commercial Muscle to Its Board

Updated Category News Views 65

Robotics boards can get crowded with lofty nouns fast, and FFR just added another one with some real-world connective tissue behind it. Carolyn Kissane, associate dean at NYU's Center for Global Affairs, has joined as an independent director. The appointment is not a product launch, a contract, or revenue. It is a governance move. Still, in a business trying to weld...

Continue Reading
Oatly’s $4.13 Tender Offer Is a Legal Detour, Not a Sale

Updated Category News Views 25

A $4.13 cash offer trading against a $7.17 close is the sort of thing that makes investors squint hard, and Verlinvest is practically waving a flag telling them why. This is not a conventional attempt to buy Oatly Group AB. It is a technical tender offer built to satisfy Swedish takeover rules while Verlinvest buys out its joint-venture partner’s interest in Oatly’s...

Continue Reading
Ampace Targets AI Data Centre UPS Safety Needs in Paris

Updated Category News Views 94

Backup power gets interesting only after the grid has disappointed everybody. At Data Centre World Paris 2026, Ampace put its attention on that ugly, split-second handoff: utility power drops, a UPS has to catch the load immediately, and nobody operating an AI data centre gets to shrug if it does not. A Narrow Job With Brutal Consequences The company showcased its PU200...

Continue Reading
CVS Puts Youth Soccer Stories on Its Store Shelves

Updated Category News Views 60

Two kids with real community ties just got a megaphone most grown-ups never receive. CVS Pharmacy has named Caroline, 9, of Holmes Beach, Florida, and Zoe, 12, of Los Angeles, as the first grand-prize winners of its Home Team Heroes youth soccer contest. Each player’s selected nonprofit soccer organization will receive a $25,000 grant, while their stories will appear on...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Accessibility Insights: Boosting Website Rankings Effectively

Updated Category News Views 152

Accessibility Insights for Website Rankings A recent study has highlighted a compelling correlation between website accessibility and search engine ranking. Through extensive research, it has become increasingly clear that adhering to accessibility guidelines significantly impacts organic search success. This analysis underscores the importance of making websites more...

Continue Reading
CVS Health and Cigna Introduce 2025 Medicare Advantage Plans

Updated Category News Views 409

Back in 2025, CVS Health and Cigna took center stage with their new Medicare Advantage plans aimed squarely at seniors. The big pitch? Some members could enjoy $0 monthly premiums for essential prescription drugs—sounds great, right? But let's unpack that. Enrollment Window: Timing is Everything The enrollment period was set from October 15 to December 7, a critical...

Continue Reading
Kodiak AI: Pioneering the Future of Autonomous Freight Logistics

Updated Category News Views 329

Kodiak AI and Ares Acquisition Corporation II Create a New Era in Autonomous Freight Kodiak AI, Inc., a revolutionary player in the autonomous vehicle space, is ready to ignite the future of freight logistics with its recent business combination with Ares Acquisition Corporation II. This pivotal step not only solidifies Kodiak's standing as a leader in AI-driven...

Continue Reading
TRON DAO Enhances DeFi Ecosystem through Chainlink Partnership

Updated Category News Views 97

TRON DAO Joins Forces with Chainlink for DeFi Advancement The TRON network is rapidly becoming a significant player in the decentralized finance (DeFi) space, boasting one of the largest DeFi economies globally. By collaborating with Chainlink through the Chainlink Scale program, TRON DAO is set to accelerate growth and improve adoption in its ecosystem. Chainlink Data...

Continue Reading
Canton Fair Showcases Sustainable Innovations for a Greener Future

Updated Category News Views 387

Canton Fair Showcases Sustainable Innovations for a Greener Future The ongoing Canton Fair has positioned itself as a leader in promoting environmental sustainability and innovation. A remarkable 10,040 companies are showcasing their offerings, highlighting over 300,000 green and low-carbon products. This huge gathering emphasizes the importance of eco-friendly solutions...

Continue Reading