Neither court has justified its reasoning on their rulings

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (5) Message Board
Hate Liars
755
Neither court has justified its reasoning on their rulings that SFOR's patent is 'Abstract' but now they will have to based on the below changes...

United States: USPTO Issues New Guidelines For Determining Subject Matter Eligibility Under 35 U.S.C. § 101

www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/x/783372/Patent/USPTO+Issues+New+Guidelines+For+Determining+Subject+Matter+Eligibility+Under+35+USC+101

Last Updated: February 22 2019
Article by Gary Abelev and Gregory Miller
Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP

For the fourth time in less than a year, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) issued guidance to examiners on the question of subject matter eligibility under 35 U.S.C. § 101 (Section 101).1 This took place on January 7, 2019, when the USPTO circulated its "2019 Revised Patent Subject Matter Eligibility Guidance" (the 2019 Guidelines), which revised its prior procedures for determining whether a patent claim is directed toward eligible subject matter under Section 101. The 2019 Guidelines provide a significant step toward clearing up the muddy waters that are the current state of affairs regarding patent eligibility in the United States, and potentially reduce the number of rejections in pending patent applications by the USPTO under Section 101. Nonetheless, whether there will be any significant practical change to the current examination of patent applications by the examiners of the USPTO is unclear.

To provide a baseline for the ramifications of the 2019 Guidelines, it would be beneficial to review the prior USPTO guideline on subject matter eligibility. In particular, the 2019 Guidelines revise procedures initially set forth in the 2014 Interim Guidelines on Patent Subject Matter Eligibility (the 2014 Guidelines). According to the 2014 Guidelines, in Step 1 thereof, a determination has to be made as to whether a claim is to a process, machine or manufacture of composition of matter. If the claim is not direct to any of these categories, then such claim is not eligible subject matter under Section 101. In Step 2A of the test, a determination is made regarding whether the subject matter is a law of nature, a natural phenomenon or an abstract idea (a judicial exception). If the subject matter is determined to be an abstract idea in Step 2A, then a determination is made in Step 2B as to whether the claim recites additional elements that amount to significantly more than the abstract idea. The examiners of different art units have varying views on what amounts to an "abstract idea" in Step 2A and what is meant by "significantly more" in Step 2B, and thus there was very little predictability of whether a claim complied with these steps.

Now, the 2019 Guidelines modify the examination procedures in Steps 2A and 2B of the 2014 Guidelines.

Indeed, the most significant change in the 2019 Guidelines is to the prior Step 2A inquiry. Prior to the 2019 Guidelines, Step 2A simply involved determining whether the subject matter is a law of nature, a natural phenomenon or an abstract idea. The 2019 Guidelines split Step 2A into two prongs.5 In Prong One of the 2019 Guidelines, the examiners have to evaluate whether the claim recites a judicial exception. In the past, this was based on the USPTO's "Eligibility Quick Reference Sheet Identifying Abstract Ideas," which was first issued in 2015, and updated in July 2018.

The 2019 Guidelines revise this procedure to be based on subject matter groupings of abstract ideas set forth in Section I of the 2019 Guidelines. These include (i) mathematical concepts, (ii) certain methods of organizing human activity and (iii) mental processes. Thus, when determining whether a claim recites an abstract idea, the examiners must now identify the specific limitation in the claim and determine whether such identified limitation falls within one of these three groups. If a claim is not directed toward a judicial exception, then the inquiry ends at Prong One of Step 2A, and the claim of the patent application is determined to be patent eligible. Otherwise, if the claim recites a judicial exception, then the claim requires further analysis in Prong Two.

In Prong Two of Step 2A, the examiners must evaluate whether the claim recites additional elements that integrate the judicial exception into a "practical application" of the exception. This prong is new to prior Step 2A. In fact, if the recited exception is integrated into a "practical application," then the claim is determined to be patent eligible at Step 2A, and the eligibility analysis is concluded. The 2019 Guidelines state that a claim that integrates a judicial exception into a "practical application" will "apply, rely on, or use the judicial exception in a manner that imposes a meaningful limit on the judicial exception, such that the claim is more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the judicial exception." However, if the elements of the claim do not integrate the exception into a "practical application," then further analysis is required under Step 2B. The "practical application" analysis specifically excludes whether the additional elements in a claim represent well-understood, routine and conventional activity, which is an analysis now performed in Step 2B.

The review of this new addition to Step 2A, on its face, would seem to render more claims as being patent eligible as long as sufficient practical application of the judicial exception is recited in the claim. However, while examples of practical applications are indeed provided in the 2019 Guidelines, the determination of what is covered by the term "practical application" is still not entirely clear. As discussed below, disagreements between examiners and patent practitioners regarding this definition will likely arise, and may still preclude many claims with a seemingly clear "practical application" from being allowed by the examiners, even in view of the 2019 Guidelines.12

Turning to Step 2B in the 2019 Guidelines, such procedure addresses cases in which the claim does not integrate the recited judicial exception into a "practical application." For example, a claim that includes a judicial exception that is not practically applied may still recite additional elements that render the claim patent eligible if the claim provides "significantly more" than the recited judicial exception.13 If an examiner finds that a claim recites significantly more than the judicial exception, then the claim is patent eligible. However, if the examiner finds that there is not significantly more recited in the claim, then the claim would be held as failing the patent eligibility test. In order to determine if a claim recites significantly more, the examiner should determine (i) if the claim adds a specific limitation or combination of limitations that are not well-understood, routine or conventional activity, or (ii) if the claim simply appends well-understood, routine and conventional activities previously known to the industry, which is indicative that an inventive concept may not be present.14 The 2019 Guidelines conclude at Step 2B, where a claim is found to either be patent eligible or patent ineligible under Section 101.

Based on the above analysis, the 2019 Guidelines should make certain claims eligible that were previously held to be patent ineligible by the examiners, for example, claims directed to or reciting software. For example, as discussed above, the "practical application" test in Prong Two of Step 2A appears to render many claims patent eligible, so long as the judicial exception is used or applied in a specific practical way. Thus, in order to overcome Section 101 rejections, according to the 2019 Guidelines, the claims would only need to recite a specific practical application of the judicial exception. However, there is no explicit or clear definition of the term "practical application." Due to this deficiency, the examiners may already be trying to limit the definition of "practical applications" to physical steps performed in the real world based on the judicial exception and to exclude any "practical application" that is performed on a computer. Specifically, not two days after the release of the 2019 Guidelines, during one conversation with an examiner to discuss the new guidelines and a software-based patent application currently under appeal, the examiner stated that the 2019 Guidelines did not change his analysis of the appealed patent application, as "practical application" was limited to real-world, physical steps. This narrow definition would seem to contradict the plain dictionary meaning of the "practical application" of something, especially in the ubiquitous age of computers that we live in where many functions are performed on or using a computer.15 As one example, it would appear to be nonsensical to allege that an image recognition algorithm used for facial recognition has no "practical application" simply because it is performed on a computer. However, until the examiners are provided specific guidance, from the USPTO or the courts, that a "practical application" is not limited to physical, real-world steps the 2019 Guidelines may have less of an impact on the current examination of software-based patents for the determination of patentable subject matter under 35 U.S.C. § 101 than would appear at first glance.
1

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Employer Ghosting Is a Quiet Talent-Cost Problem Today

Updated Category News Views 304

Silence is cheap right up until a company needs talent again. Then the unanswered email, abandoned interview loop, or vanished promise of next steps comes back with a price tag—maybe not neatly labeled in a quarterly filing, but real all the same. LiveCareer’s April 14, 2026 survey of 1,008 employed U.S. adults lands on an uncomfortable point: candidates remember...

Continue Reading
Lymphatic Research Gains Attention Beyond Wellness Claims

Updated Category News Views 211

Ankles leave little clues after a long day: sock grooves, puffiness, that dull heaviness nobody bothers to name. PureHealth Research wants people to look past the usual salt-and-water explanation and consider the lymphatic system, the body’s comparatively unsung network for gathering fluid from tissues and returning it to the bloodstream. Fair enough. This system does...

Continue Reading
Cottage Grove Tests Holiday Demand Across Lake Norman

Updated Category News Views 210

Flour and foot traffic make a pretty honest little scoreboard. Cottage Grove Bakery is putting itself in front of Lake Norman shoppers twice on Saturday, November 21, while also taking Thanksgiving orders and laying groundwork for 2027 workplace and school visits. This is not a public-company earnings story, and nobody should pretend a tray of scones is a quarterly...

Continue Reading
Fluence Investors Face a November 27 Litigation Clock

Updated Category News Views 211

Six calendar squares are all that separate eligible Fluence investors from the November 27, 2026 lead-plaintiff deadline. That is not much time to locate trade confirmations, calculate losses, and decide whether taking a larger role in a securities case makes sense. The lawsuit is not a verdict, and anybody pretending otherwise is selling smoke. But the underlying...

Continue Reading
Human Frontier Mission Puts AI Research on Display

Updated Category News Views 201

A laboratory notebook is about to become the real product in this AI experiment. Human Frontier Mission, or HFM, says it will launch globally on Nov. 24, opening a research program where domain specialists frame scientific and engineering problems while autonomous AI agents develop and test possible answers. The unusual bit is not merely handing models difficult work. It...

Continue Reading
PHONO's 150 MW RE+ Win Tests Its U.S. Solar Staying Power

Updated Category News Views 272

A trade-show order book is not cash in the bank, but 150 MW is still a number worth circling in red. PHONO used RE+ 2026 in Las Vegas, held November 17 through 19, to celebrate 20 years in business, parade its solar and storage lineup, and announce new U.S. orders. In a solar market that has become touchier about provenance, compliance and delivered economics, the company...

Continue Reading
Mission Inn’s Lights Enter a Tender New Ownership Era

Updated Category News Views 296

A holiday spectacle can outlive the hands that hung its first bulb. Riverside is about to test that truth in public, under millions of tiny lights and the very large shadow of a family departure. The Mission Inn Festival of Lights returns in 2026 without Kelly and Duane Roberts as hotel owners for the first time in more than three decades. Duane Roberts died in 2025, the...

Continue Reading
Ajman Memory Gives Heritage a Durable Digital Backbone

Updated Category News Views 138

Archives usually get applause only after somebody realizes a piece of history has vanished. Ajman is trying to skip that miserable part. During the Ajman Media Forum 2026, held November 18 and 19 at the Emirates Hospitality Centre, the emirate launched Ajman Memory, a project built to collect, document and preserve photographs, papers and video recording its development....

Continue Reading
Isar’s Nova Scotia Pad Build Gives MAXQ a Real Test

Updated Category News Views 350

Concrete work is where space ambition stops being a brochure. Isar Aerospace has taken operational responsibility for its dedicated launch infrastructure at Spaceport Nova Scotia, and construction is beginning on the Canadian launch pad it will use. For Maritime Launch Services, this is the sort of update that deserves more than the usual starry-eyed applause. A Site...

Continue Reading
ModuleMD Takes Allergy EHR AI Beyond the Usual Hype Cycle

Updated Category News Views 238

Allergy Workflows Are Where This Has to Earn Its Keep Allergy clinics do not need another shiny dashboard clogging up a workstation. They need less typing, fewer handoffs, cleaner documentation, and fewer administrative chores slipping through the cracks while a packed day keeps moving. That is the practical lens for ModuleMD's ACAAI 2026 presentation in Phoenix: not...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Robinhood Markets Shares November 2025 Operational Highlights

Updated Category News Views 269

Robinhood Markets Releases November 2025 Operational Highlights Robinhood Markets, Inc. (“Robinhood”) (NASDAQ: HOOD) has recently shared its monthly operating data for November 2025, offering an insightful look into its operational metrics and customer engagement. This report emphasizes key growth indicators and trading volume achievements over the month, reflecting...

Continue Reading
Gold Prices Decline Amid Anticipation of Federal Reserve Actions

Updated Category News Views 140

Gold Prices Drop as Federal Reserve Meeting Commences Gold prices experienced a decline as traders adjusted their positions ahead of the Federal Reserve's crucial meeting. The latest updates signal a decrease in spot gold prices, which now hover around $2,646.06 an ounce. Similarly, gold futures, set to expire in February, showed a minor drop to $2,662.44 an ounce. This...

Continue Reading
Understanding Adobe's Current Stock Performance Analysis

Updated Category News Views 239

Market Dynamics of Adobe Inc. Investors are taking a closer look at Adobe Inc (NASDAQ: ADBE) as they adopt varying strategies in the options market. Notably, deep-pocketed investors have shown bearish tendencies, making it a key point of interest for those monitoring market movements. Recent observations have highlighted an unusual upsurge in options activities related to...

Continue Reading
NexPoint Diversified Real Estate Trust's New Preferred Share Offering

Updated Category News Views 212

NexPoint Diversified Real Estate Trust Announces Major Offering NexPoint Diversified Real Estate Trust (NYSE: NXDT), a leading player in the real estate investment trust sector, has unveiled an opportunity for investors with a continuous public offering of its 9.00% Series B Cumulative Redeemable Preferred Shares. With a planned issuance of up to 16,000,000 shares, the...

Continue Reading
Outbrain Dominates the Q4 2024 France Ad Seller Rankings

Updated Category News Views 185

Outbrain Leads the Way in France's Q4 2024 Ad Rankings In a recent release, Pixalate has highlighted the leading programmatic ad sellers in France for the fourth quarter of 2024. This report emphasizes the importance of quality within the digital advertising ecosystem, offering a glimpse into the companies making significant strides in this sector. Understanding the...

Continue Reading