Thanks for posting this article. Everyone here should read

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (3) Message Board
riskreward007 cphillips82 #49878
1,119
Thanks for posting this article. Everyone here should read this. Most of the other recent articles I've read about the current state of our patent system seem to draw similar conclusions.

What is Alice 101?

Alice Corporation owned four patents on electronic methods and computer programs for financial-trading systems. Alice alleged that CLS Bank International began to use similar technology in 2002. Alice accused CLS Bank of infringement of Alice's patents. The issue in the case was whether certain claims about a computer-implemented, electronic escrow service for facilitating financial transactions covered abstract ideas ineligible for patent protection.

In 2014 Alice Corporation's patents were held to be invalid by the Supreme Court of the US (SCOTUS) because the claims were about abstract ideas, and implementing those claims on a computer was not enough to transform that idea into patentable subject matter. It declared each of Alice's patents invalid because the claims concerned abstract ideas. Abstract ideas are not eligible for patent protection under 35 U.S.C. § 101.[9]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Corp._v._...ernational

By instituting "Alice 101" SCOTUS unknowingly created a huge pandora's box in the patent system. For all future cases, they left up to the lower courts to determine whether a given patent infringement case was based on "abstract ideas" or not. But SCOTUS didn't realize that the lower courts weren't willing to define "abstract ideas" either (and would just kick the can down the road). Hence the current "mess" in the patent enforcement system was created.

Quote:
Because the Supreme Court seems to have very intentionally said we’re not going to define “abstract idea.” What the Supreme Court has said is, “oh, well, the inferior courts or lower courts or people who aren’t us, will figure it out.” And now we’ve got the Federal Circuit saying, “well, if they don’t have to define it, then we don’t have to define it, we just do a matching game. A matching game is doomed to failure.

https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2019/01/30/ibm-cal...id=105754/


Quote:
Re: The "Alice 101" nightmare:

Simply by filing a patent infringement complaint, over half the time, the patentee not only lost the litigation, but also lost its patent right, and 75% of those losses were not appealed.

Of that lucky 25% that had the resources to request Federal Circuit review, fewer than one-half of them, or 57 of the 122 appeals of district court invalidations, received opinions from the Federal Circuit. The rest received the dreaded “Rule 36 Affirmance,” which provides no guidance to the litigants or to others trying to navigate these dangerous waters.

Even today, the Federal Circuit’s post-Alice decisions tell us that no patent is safe from Section 101. And, if you can believe it, no Federal Circuit decision has defined what “abstract” means, even though courts have invalidated several hundred patents as being “abstract.”

https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2018/09/18/alice-a...id=101447/


My conclusions from these articles:

1) The above quotes show you just what an overall mess this is. The problem is not just our (SFOR's) problem, but there is a much larger system-wide problem with "Alice 101" and patent enforcement. No matter how strong the patent enforcement case is, all the other side has to do is cite "Alice 101" to get off the hook, with the courts not even addressing or understanding the merits of the case (which is what happened to us).

2) By not addressing or being willing to define what is inventiveness or "abstract idea" (see above) both SCOTUS and the Federal Circuit courts are just kicking the can down the road, which makes actual patent infringement resolution nearly impossible in most situations, -a frustrating scenario for almost every company that brings clear cases of patent infringement to the court system.

Why did all this happen?

At some point the Supreme Court (SCOTUS) seemed to be unhappy with the USPTO's (United States Patent and Trademark Office) policies and guidance, so they took on "Alice 101". Alice 101 became a precedent in patent infringement cases, and rather than being a fix, it opened up a huge can of worms, which has become an enormous problem for patent enforcement.

What can be done (in SFOR's case) and in the big picture?

Most articles that I have read say that this larger problem needs to be addressed and fixed (either by SCOTUS or by Congress), hopefully sooner rather than later, -in order to straighten out the mess in the patent system that SCOTUS and "Alice 101" created.

SFOR is caught up in the middle of this much larger patent enforcement system problem. At least we didn't lose our patent eligibility (like many patent infringement litigants).

All we can do is hang in there (with our appeals) until the problem is resolved. This is all the more reason why SFOR should continue its pursuit of an appeal, until this larger problem is resolved (because it's not just our problem, it's everyone's problem). It's possible that delays in our appeal process could actually benefit SFOR, (if SCOTUS or Congress were to step up and resolve this problem in the interim).

Originally I posted that the best option for an SFOR appeal probably was to have our case reviewed by the entire panel of 12 Federal Circuit Court judges. But I have since changed my mind (after reading and studying the above), and have concluded that an appeal to the Federal Circuit court is probably not our best option. Instead I think that SFOR should take its case directly to the Supreme Court (SCOTUS).

Why?

Because SCOTUS is the only court large enough to resolve this systemic problem, and because I doubt that the 12 Federal Circuit Court judges would do anything new (either in resolving SFOR's case or in resolving this larger issue). I think the Federal Circuit Court would just continue to kick the can down the road and wait for someone else (SCOTUS or Congress) to solve the problem.
In other words, if we were to take our case to the Federal Circuit Court again, I think we would lose again for the third time.

But there may be hope. Since there is a bigger awareness of this overall problem, there is the possibility that it may somehow get resolved soon.

All IMO.
RR007

Other relevant articles:
https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2019/01/11/new-cou...id=104975/

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Veritran's Bold Move: Acquiring PrismaCampaigns Inc.

Updated Category News Views 58

Veritran's Strategic Leap Forward They're not messing around, folks. Veritran just made a power move by acquiring 100% of PrismaCampaigns Inc., and it’s more than just another day in the office. This marks a pivotal expansion of their American footprint, and they're zeroing in on our banks and credit unions with laser precision. Why This Matters for Financial...

Continue Reading
Daymond John's Four-Center Bet on Longevity Game

Updated Category News Views 42

A Shark's Dive into Longevity Here you go—Daymond John, the face of FUBU and a household name from Shark Tank, is not just talking about living longer; he's putting his wallet where his words are. John is jumping into the longevity game with both feet, joining Ultimate Longevity Center's (ULC) latest venture. We're talking about four new centers across California,...

Continue Reading
Gwen Stefani Kicks Off OCVIBE's New Concert Hall

Updated Category News Views 174

A Homecoming Steeped in Nostalgia Orange County’s about to do a serious throwback, folks! Gwen Stefani is set to headline the opening concert at OCVIBE's spanking new concert hall in Anaheim on March 17, 2027. Curious choice for their opener? Hardly. This gal's practically woven into the county’s tapestry—her roots run deep here, enough to make even the casual music...

Continue Reading
Tenax Class Action: Investors Alley Fight for Redress

Updated Category News Views 15

Tenax Therapeutics in Hot Water Over Drug Trial Results Amidst the ever-unpredictable tides of the pharmaceutical industry, here comes a doozy – Tenax Therapeutics, Inc. is neck-deep in a shareholder lawsuit. If you tossed some money at NASDAQ:TENX anytime between November 13, 2023, and August 7, 2026, you might be feeling the sting of regret, and rightly so. What Went...

Continue Reading
FFR's Michigan Milestone and Major Robotics Update

Updated Category News Views 203

Nobody's going to argue that breaking into new territories isn't a gamble, but sometimes you just need to roll the dice. FF EAI Robotics Ecosystem Inc. (NASDAQ: FFR) is banking on their move with Aegis Ultra robots, making an academic splash at Central Michigan University. This isn't just about ticking off another state; it's about stacking the deck with new...

Continue Reading
Disney+ Teams Up with Tiff's: Blue Cookie Debut

Updated Category News Views 52

A Sweet Collaboration on the Horizon If somebody had told me that cookies could conjure up excitement equivalent to a TV show's new season, I'd have laughed. But here we are—Disney+ and Tiff's Treats are cooking up a storm with blue chocolate chip cookies to celebrate 'Percy Jackson and the Olympians' Season 3 premiere. The Cookie That Packs a Punch Forget ordinary...

Continue Reading
Cognito Unveils Phase 3 Results for Alzheimer Treatment

Updated Category News Views 22

Charting New Waters in Alzheimer's Treatment Well, here's one for the books, folks. Cognito Therapeutics just tossed their latest Phase 3 results from their so-called HOPE study into the ring. We're talking about Spectris AD, a non-drug, at-home gizmo that aims to be the next big thing for Alzheimer's. Yeah, the study didn't exactly hit a home run with the primary...

Continue Reading
Insight Into Midland TX Real Estate Sales Timing

Updated Category News Views 15

How Fast Do Homes Move in Midland? This ain't my first rodeo predicting the real estate rollercoaster in Texas. Midland's housing market is one nifty beast—homes can either sell like hotcakes or just sit gathering dust. You got HelloNation pulling in DeLaura Gammage, a pro who knows the terrain like the back of her hand, to spell out the why and how long it'll take to...

Continue Reading
Midea's R290 Tech: Real Green Cooling Revolution?

Updated Category News Views 282

A Fresh Breeze in Sustainable Cooling In the middle of Kigali’s innovation oasis, Midea RAC stood out at MOP38, the 38th Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol, flexing its sustainable tech muscles. We're talking about their R290 air conditioning technology—a natural refrigerant with zero ozone footprint and a global warming potential of a mere three. This is...

Continue Reading
Epic Legal Battle Yields $63M Verdict Against Chevron

Updated Category News Views 113

A David vs. Goliath Showdown in Court How's this for a courtroom drama? Picture eight lawyers taking on Chevron over a toxic pit buried beneath an unsuspecting family's home. These folks at Ernst Law Group and Trial Lawyers for Justice tackled Union Oil (now Chevron) and bagged a staggering $63 million for their client. This ain't your run-of-the-mill legal squabble; it's...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

BIEL Crystal's Innovative Smartphone Glass Cover Revolutionizes Durability

Updated Category News Views 299

BIEL Crystal's Innovative Smartphone Glass Cover BIEL Crystal, a notable supplier for Apple and a leader in smart device components, has recently introduced its cutting-edge product, the "Witch Cloak." This ultra-hard coating smartphone glass cover represents a significant advancement in the technology used to protect smartphones from daily wear and tear, notably featured...

Continue Reading
Covenant Clearinghouse Triumphs in Legal Battle with Chicago Title

Updated Category News Views 780

Covenant Clearinghouse Triumphs in Legal Battle Covenant Clearinghouse recently achieved a significant legal victory against the Chicago Title Company, concluding a complex litigation case. The case, documented as Chicago Title Ins. Co. v. Covenant Clearinghouse, LLC, revolved around crucial property rights under the Illinois Transfer Fee Covenant Act. Legal Proceedings...

Continue Reading
TTEC CEO's Buyout Proposal: What It Means for Stakeholders

Updated Category News Views 137

TTEC's CEO Buyout Proposal: Evaluating the Future TTEC Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: TTEC), known for its AI-driven customer experience solutions, is currently assessing a buyout proposal presented by its CEO, Kenneth Tuchman. This significant move has prompted the company to engage the services of Rothschild & Co as its financial advisor, alongside legal support from Skadden,...

Continue Reading
Primech AI Unveils HYTRON LITE Bathroom Cleaning Solution

Updated Category News Views 167

Primech AI Launches Innovative HYTRON LITE at Industry Event Primech AI Pte. Ltd. (Nasdaq: PMEC) is making waves in the robotics industry with its latest innovative creation, the HYTRON LITE bathroom cleaning robot, introduced during a significant event focused on facilities management. This gathering, that united key players, took place at Temasek Polytechnic and was...

Continue Reading
The Growth Journey of Travelers Companies: A Five-Year Analysis

Updated Category News Views 255

Understanding Travelers Companies' Market Performance When evaluating the potential return on investment in stocks, it's essential to look at the historical performance of companies like Travelers Companies (NYSE: TRV). This prominent insurance provider has shown remarkable consistency and growth over the years, recently achieving a market capitalization of $63.96...

Continue Reading