Networks Fact-Check Trump Speech Associated Press

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Jan 9, 2019 at 8:31 PM 132

Quote:

Networks Fact-Check Trump Speech

Associated Press

Published 8 January 2019|

NEW YORK (AP) — Television pundits moved swiftly to correct or challenge President Donald Trump following Tuesday’s Oval Office speech on the proposed border wall, after their networks were the target of an unusual debate over whether they should show him at all.

“Just because you say it’s a crisis doesn’t necessarily make it one,” ABC White House correspondent Cecilia Vega said following the president’s address.

Some network critics had essentially made the same point in arguing for a television boycott, along with saying the president couldn’t be trusted with the truth. It’s rare, but not unprecedented, for networks to say no to a presidential request for airtime.

But refusing to air Trump’s first Oval Office address as president, in the midst of a government shutdown over the funding fight, would have been seen as a provocative act in itself.

So the four major broadcasters and cable news networks showed him, while also airing rebuttals from House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and making provisions of their own to pounce on misstatements.

CNN brought on Daniel Dale, a White House correspondent for the Toronto Star, who has become known for cataloguing Trump misstatements, and he said the president falsely asserted it was the Democrats who had advanced the idea of a steel barrier instead of a wall. NBC’s Chuck Todd made the same point.

“I would say he made a lot of dubious claims,” Todd said.

ABC’s George Stephanopoulos disputed Trump’s claim that the U.S.-Mexico free trade agreement will essentially result in that country paying for the wall. “It has not been approved by Congress and even if it is, there’s no provision there to make Mexico pay for the wall,” Stephanopoulos said.

Shepard Smith conducted a rapid-fire rebuttal of some of the president’s claims during his coverage on the Fox broadcast network. After Trump talked about crimes committed by undocumented immigrants, Smith said, “government statistics show there is less violent crime committed by the undocumented immigrant population than by the general population.” He said that border crossings along the southern border haven been dropping.

“The president said law enforcement professionals have requested the $5.7 billion (for the wall),” Smith said. “It’s he who requested it and he who said he would own the shutdown.”

Smith’s analysis drew an angry response on Twitter from many of Fox News’ conservative fans.

On Fox News Channel, Sean Hannity critiqued the Democratic response, saying Trump’s opponents hadn’t addressed reports of crimes committed by undocumented immigrants, a point the president tried to drive home. Sen. Lindsey Graham joined Hannity to suggest Trump’s stand represents the best chance to improve border security.

None of the networks used chyrons, or onscreen text, to rebut Trump while he was talking. But CNN and MSNBC used that form of fact-checking after he had finished.

One CNN chyron read: “Trump: 90% of heroin comes across the Southern border. Fact: vast majority comes through legal ports of entry.”

Earlier Tuesday, CNN’s Jim Acosta had confronted Trump aide Kellyanne Conway outside of the White House, asking if she could promise whether Trump would tell the truth. That prompted a bitter exchange between the two.

“Let me get back in your face, ’cause you’re such a smart ass most of the time and I know you want this to go viral,” Conway said.

Following Tuesday night’s coverage, the liberal watchdog organization Media Matters for America said the network fact-checking was ineffective.

“The fact-checking came too late for any viewers who turned off their televisions after the president stopped speaking,” said Media Matters’ Matt Gertz. “The networks gave the White House exactly what the president wanted: unhindered access to lie to their audience. He played them, and they let them do it.”

By airing the rebuttal from Pelosi and Schumer, the networks did something that is seldom done for presidential speeches, except for events like the State of the Union address, said former NBC News executive Mark Lukasiewicz, now dean of the Hofstra University communications school. That sets a precedent that may be tough for them to back away from in future events, he said.

Lukasiewicz argued that for the networks, it was an awkward night that would not please either side of the debate over border security.

“The president made no news and no new proposals,” he said. “It is hard to argue this night was about anything other than pure politics — and the networks interrupted programming to accommodate it.”

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Perpetua Wins $40M U.S. Army Deal: Eyes Tungsten Boost

Perpetua's Strategic Move in Mineral Exploration Forget the sleazy diner talk for a sec. We're diving into a strategic American push to revive homegrown tungsten supply. Perpetua Resources is dancing a new jig with a solid $40 million award from the U.S. Army, assisting in this military-driven goal through the Defense Ordnance Technology Consortium. Talk about a smart...

WuXi AppTec Boosts Guidance Amid Strong CRDMO Growth

Unpacking WuXi AppTec's Latest Performance Boost WuXi AppTec, the pharmaceutical giant, isn't just coasting on its past successes. The way they're riding the contract research, development, and manufacturing (CRDMO) train straight through Q1 to Q3 of 2026 shows they're not just here for show. They've hiked up the stakes with strong metrics across the board, warranting a...

Lode Gold Explores Fremont's Untapped Gold Potential

Reviving an Old Gold Story The charm of Fremont Gold Mine lies in its history as much as it does in its potential. Lode Gold Resources Inc., that old miner itching to strike gold like it's 1849 all over again, has set its sights on reevaluating the treasure trove beneath Mariposa County, California. Exploration efforts are charging ahead to uncover whether this mine still...

Kos Biotech Partners Backs Golden Age's Global Push

Unlocking Global Paths for Rare Diseases Diving straight into the biotech hustle, Kos Biotechnology Partners is making waves with their latest strategic move. They've just announced a significant investment in Golden Age Health (GAH), aiming to open new doors for rare disease treatments where they're needed most. Bridging Gaps with Strategic Investment We're talking about...

Nucor's Q3 2026 Earnings: Strong Growth Amid Steel Surge

Nucor's Solid Third Quarter Performance Nucor Corporation is flexing its muscles, reporting a robust third quarter for 2026. With net earnings hitting $1.32 billion and a diluted earnings per share of $5.80, the steel giant has shown it can more than hold its ground in a competitive market. Compare that to last quarter's $1.16 billion - we're seeing serious momentum....

National Civics Day: LIU Unveils Screen-Free Platform

A Tradition Reimagined for a Milestone You ever look at a calendar and feel the weight of history? That's what's happening right now at Long Island University as America hits 250 years in the books. We're not just polishing dusty history statues—on October 27, there's a genuine push to get back to basics. Brian Kilmeade's stepping into the spotlight as he headlines this...

Dysolve Sheds Light on Dyslexia with AI Breakthrough

Turning the Page for Dyslexic Learners The narrative around dyslexia is getting a fresh edit, and it's not just another educational theory on some dusty shelf. Nope, Dysolve, with its trailblazing AI technology, is flipping the script for countless individuals grappling with dyslexia. This innovative breakthrough is reaching for the stars, aiming to demolish the barriers...

Keeper Security Shines in Gartner's 2026 PAM Report

Recognition That Stands Out When you're in the security game, being flagged in the Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ is like getting the thumbs-up from the industry's toughest critic. Keeper Security just snagged that recognition for the second year straight, and what's putting feathers in their cap? A completeness of vision and the chops to execute—no small feat in the wild...

Tough Materials Keep Midland Homes Standing Strong

Midland’s Battle with the Elements Out here in Midland, Texas, Mother Nature plays rough and she doesn’t take breaks. We’re talking relentless sunlight, fierce winds, dust storms, and a thermostat with mood swings more unpredictable than your stock portfolio in a recession. If you’re thinking of putting down roots here, forget the usual paint job and fancy...

CSQR Faces Scrutiny Over Cash Flow Discrepancies

Dalrymple's Short Report Shakes Csquare's Core Csquare, Inc. (NYSE: CSQR) is reeling from a one-two punch: a damning short report by Dalrymple Finance and an 11.8% share tumble. The timing of this financial body blow, coinciding with Csquare's discordant cash flow claims, could mark the beginning of a long battle for investor trust. This ain't the first time the markets...