The Steele Dossier: A

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board

Dec 20, 2018 at 6:32 PM 360

Quote:

The Steele Dossier: A Retrospective

https://www.lawfareblog.com/steele-dossier-retrospective

By Sarah Grant, Chuck Rosenberg
Friday, December 14, 2018, 8:00 AM

The dossier is actually a series of reports—16 in all—that total 35 pages. Written in 2016, the dossier is a collection of raw intelligence. Steele neither evaluated nor synthesized the intelligence.

He neither made nor rendered bottom-line judgments. The dossier is, quite simply and by design, raw reporting, not a finished intelligence product.

In that sense, the dossier is similar to an FBI 302 form or a DEA 6 form. Both of those forms are used by special agents of the FBI and DEA, respectively, to record what they are told by witnesses during investigations.

The substance of these memoranda can be true or false, but the recording of information is (or should be) accurate. In that sense, notes taken by a special agent have much in common with the notes that a journalist might take while covering a story—the substance of those notes could be true or false, depending on what the source tells the journalist, but the transcription should be accurate.

With that in mind, we thought it would be worthwhile to look back at the dossier and to assess, to the extent possible, how the substance of Steele’s reporting holds up over time. In this effort, we considered only information in the public domain from trustworthy and official government sources, including documents released by Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s office in connection with the criminal cases brought against Paul Manafort, the 12 Russian intelligence officers, the Internet Research Agency trolling operation and associated entities, Michael Cohen, Michael Flynn and George Papadopoulos.

We also considered the draft statement of offense released by author Jerome Corsi, a memorandum released by House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence Ranking Member Adam Schiff related to the Carter Page FISA applications and admissions directly from certain speakers.

These materials buttress some of Steele’s reporting, both specifically and thematically. The dossier holds up well over time, and none of it, to our knowledge, has been disproven.

As we noted, our interest is in assessing the Steele dossier as a raw intelligence document, not a finished piece of analysis. The Mueller investigation has clearly produced public records that confirm pieces of the dossier.

And even where the details are not exact, the general thrust of Steele’s reporting seems credible in light of what we now know about extensive contacts between numerous individuals associated with the Trump campaign and Russian government officials.

However, there is also a good deal in the dossier that has not been corroborated in the official record and perhaps never will be—whether because it’s untrue, unimportant or too sensitive.

As a raw intelligence document, the Steele dossier, we believe, holds up well so far. But surely there is more to come from Mueller’s team. We will return to it as the public record develops .

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Posterity Health Boosts Network to Six New Markets

Expansion at Breakneck Speed Just like that, we've got Posterity Health making power moves across the country, staking claim in six major markets. Denver's very own fertility platform is on a roll, and this ain't just any rollout. We're talking partnerships like confetti in the air, dotting spots from the sunny Cali shores of Orange County to the bustling streets of...

3TREES Debuts Green Coatings to East African Market

3TREES Rocks East Africa's Construction Scene Nairobi's got a spark this week, and it's radiating straight from 3TREES' corner at the Big 5 Construct Kenya. With the Sarit Expo Centre buzzing from October 21, 2026, this Chinese company didn't just show up—they made one hell of an entrance. Presenting eco-friendly coating solutions, they pushed the 'Create Healthy Life'...

Globe Life Faces 8% Stock Dip Amidst Legal Scrutiny

Trouble Brews for Globe Life Investors Brace yourselves, folks. Globe Life Inc. (NYSE: GL) has found itself slap-bang in the middle of a potentially messy legal quagmire. The $7 million in excess Medicare Supplement claims that popped up due to a snail-like processing delay by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) have sent investors scrambling. And oh boy,...

Heart Attack vs. Cardiac Arrest: Know the Differences

Spotting the Crisis: Heart Attack or Cardiac Arrest? When your heart’s in trouble, knowing whether it’s a heart attack or cardiac arrest isn’t just some medical trivia—it could save a life. According to healthcare whiz Justin Doss from Beaumont, Texas, this difference can be the thin line between life and a dire outcome. What's the Deal with These Heart Events?...

Exploring Manual Lymphatic Massage: Key Benefits & Insights

The Surge in Popularity of Manual Lymphatic Massage There's a whole lotta buzz around manual lymphatic drainage (MLD) these days, and folks want to know if all that hype's got any juice. During National Massage Therapy Awareness Week, the American Massage Therapy Association (AMTA) lent a hand by spotlighting what the latest research has to say about this specialized...

Thermal Barrier Coatings Growth Fuels Industry Shifts

The Heat Is On: Thermal Barrier Coatings Surge The market for thermal barrier coatings is heating up like a Phoenix summer, slated to spike from $1.26 billion in 2026 to $1.55 billion by 2031, riding a tidy 4.19% CAGR. Aerospace engines and gas turbines—these hardcore markets are fueled by rising demand as engineers chase higher efficiency and better heat resistance....

Compal and ARC Cloud Forge AI Partnership

AI Infrastructure: A New Era of Collaboration Well, here's one that's got my old trader veins throbbing with excitement. Compal Electronics and ARC Cloud are shaking hands in a deal that could sketch out a bold new chapter in AI infrastructure. This ain't your run-of-the-mill tech announcement; it's a strategic dance aimed at supercharging the very backbone of large-scale...

Humberto Quintanar Strengthens McKinley Irvin's Seattle Team

Humberto Quintanar Makes His Move In a world where legal battles can shake lives to the core, McKinley Irvin is throwing another heavyweight into the ring. They’ve just pulled in Humberto Quintanar, a guy who knows his way around a courtroom like a cabbie knows a city's backstreets. This isn't just another seat-fillin' lawyer; Quintanar packs years of experience as a...

Venezuelan Crude Hits Texas: NABEP's Bold Move

Venezuelan Crude Docking in Texas Signals New Energy Dynamics Batten down the hatches, 'cause NABEP's Venezuelan crude has made a splashy arrival in Texas. We're talking 1 million barrels, folks, the first of its kind under a fresh U.S. deal. This ain't your grandpa's oil shipment from the Middle East that takes forever to get here—nope, this crude made a pit stop in...

Omnichat's $10M Series A: Scaling AI for Global Reach

Omnichat Secures Funding to Transform Commerce Well, folks, they're calling it a smart move—or a gamble, depending on who you ask. Omnichat just snagged a tidy $10 million from a Series A, led by Openspace Capital. They're pouring this cash into scaling what they call the 'Agentic AI' platform, a bevy of AI agents poised to shake up the marketing, sales, and customer...

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

AgEagle Aerial Systems Expands Defense Sales with 17 Drone Orders

AgEagle Aerial Systems Makes Remarkable Strides in Defense Sector AgEagle Aerial Systems Inc. has recently reached a significant milestone by securing 17 new purchase orders for their highly sought-after eBee TAC drones from various defense and security customers in the U.S. This exciting achievement marks a crucial step in the company's strategy to strengthen its...

Discover the New Tavira Community by Mattamy Homes

Discover Tavira at Twin Peaks The Tavira at Twin Peaks presents an extraordinary opportunity for homebuyers within a serene gated community, comprising only 75 homesites, each showcasing five innovative designs from renowned builder Mattamy Homes. Grand Opening Celebration Mattamy Homes, North America's leading family-owned homebuilder, is thrilled to welcome potential...

Fluff & Boots Launches Premium Products for Cat Wellbeing

Fluff & Boots Launches a New Era in Cat Care Today marks an exciting moment for pet lovers around the globe as Fluff & Boots, a new brand dedicated to feline wellbeing, steps onto the scene with thoughtfully designed products. This innovative company embraces a mission to enhance the lives of cats and their owners by focusing on essential instinctual behaviors like...

Statkraft Elevates Strategy to Enhance Renewable Energy Leadership

Statkraft Enhances Strategic Focus on Core Competencies Statkraft, Europe's largest producer of renewable energy, aims to further solidify its competitive edge by prioritizing its versatile hydropower fleet in the Nordics while expanding its solar, wind, and battery operations in Europe and South America. Refined Strategic Approach Under New Leadership Under the new CEO,...

Boardwalktech Partners with Sophic Capital for Growth Strategy Boardwalktech Software Corp. (OTCQB: BWLKF), a digital ledger platform and enterprise software solutions pioneer, has recently engaged Sophic Capital Inc. for essential capital markets advisory services. This collaboration marks an exciting chapter for Boardwalktech, enhancing its investor communications and...