The Steele Dossier: A

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board
Bhawks Lmcat #55479
357
Quote:
The Steele Dossier: A Retrospective

https://www.lawfareblog.com/steele-dossier-retrospective

By Sarah Grant, Chuck Rosenberg
Friday, December 14, 2018, 8:00 AM

The dossier is actually a series of reports—16 in all—that total 35 pages. Written in 2016, the dossier is a collection of raw intelligence. Steele neither evaluated nor synthesized the intelligence.

He neither made nor rendered bottom-line judgments. The dossier is, quite simply and by design, raw reporting, not a finished intelligence product.

In that sense, the dossier is similar to an FBI 302 form or a DEA 6 form. Both of those forms are used by special agents of the FBI and DEA, respectively, to record what they are told by witnesses during investigations.

The substance of these memoranda can be true or false, but the recording of information is (or should be) accurate. In that sense, notes taken by a special agent have much in common with the notes that a journalist might take while covering a story—the substance of those notes could be true or false, depending on what the source tells the journalist, but the transcription should be accurate.

With that in mind, we thought it would be worthwhile to look back at the dossier and to assess, to the extent possible, how the substance of Steele’s reporting holds up over time. In this effort, we considered only information in the public domain from trustworthy and official government sources, including documents released by Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s office in connection with the criminal cases brought against Paul Manafort, the 12 Russian intelligence officers, the Internet Research Agency trolling operation and associated entities, Michael Cohen, Michael Flynn and George Papadopoulos.

We also considered the draft statement of offense released by author Jerome Corsi, a memorandum released by House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence Ranking Member Adam Schiff related to the Carter Page FISA applications and admissions directly from certain speakers.

These materials buttress some of Steele’s reporting, both specifically and thematically. The dossier holds up well over time, and none of it, to our knowledge, has been disproven.

As we noted, our interest is in assessing the Steele dossier as a raw intelligence document, not a finished piece of analysis. The Mueller investigation has clearly produced public records that confirm pieces of the dossier.

And even where the details are not exact, the general thrust of Steele’s reporting seems credible in light of what we now know about extensive contacts between numerous individuals associated with the Trump campaign and Russian government officials.

However, there is also a good deal in the dossier that has not been corroborated in the official record and perhaps never will be—whether because it’s untrue, unimportant or too sensitive.

As a raw intelligence document, the Steele dossier, we believe, holds up well so far. But surely there is more to come from Mueller’s team. We will return to it as the public record develops .
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Cost of Living Tops Financial Worries in 2026

Updated Category News Views 1

Financial Stress — The Silent Productivity Killer Down in the trenches of nine-to-five, it’s money that keeps stealing workers' peace of mind. The TELUS Mental Health Index shines a glaring spotlight on this, revealing that 58% of U.S. workers are most stressed by living costs. Now, that's a kicker when stacking it next to retirement or emergency savings. Those take...

Continue Reading
Aardvark Therapeutics Faces Investor Legal Challenges

Updated Category News Views 3

Behind the Screens: Aardvark's Legal Turmoil Oh boy, it's not a pretty sight when a biotech darling like Aardvark Therapeutics (NASDAQ: AARD) hits the skids. We're talking about a major shake-up folks. It seems like just yesterday this company was on the cusp of cracking into new medical terrains, promising hope where there was just uncertainty. But here we are, the...

Continue Reading
M Social's NYC Edition Merges Sport and Community

Updated Category News Views 6

A Bold Move in the Heart of Manhattan You know when a hotel chains itself to a major event like the US Open, it's looking to make a statement—bold, loud, and clear. M Social Hotel New York Times Square did just that, turning its space into a powerhouse hub of sport, culture, and community right in Times Square. Over two days, they brought together some of the top ATP...

Continue Reading
Old Orchard's Fall Festival: Music, Vendors, Fun

Updated Category News Views 3

Big Bend Turns Festive Again When it comes to fall, Old Orchard ain't shy. The quaint corner of Webster Groves is gearing up to transform Big Bend Boulevard into the sort of autumnal bash that would make even Mother Nature kick up her heels. This October 24 and 25, folks will be spilling into the streets as the Merchant & Business Association of Old Orchard (MBAOO)...

Continue Reading
Nozomi Networks: Leading OT Security in 2026

Updated Category News Views 3

One Year of Massive Wins for Nozomi Networks Here's a wild trajectory: Nozomi Networks has been firing on all cylinders in 2026, capturing attention not just from analysts but also from anyone with a stake in the security game. The company’s impressive run was highlighted most recently when they were crowned a Leader in The Forrester Wave: Operational Technology...

Continue Reading
Wheaton Precious Metals Sets 2026 Investor Day Webcast

Updated Category News Views 3

Ready for a Glimpse into Wheaton's Strategy? Gather 'round, folks, because on September 16, 2026, Wheaton Precious Metals is rolling out the carpet for its Investor Day webcast. It's more than a routine session; it's an open window into what's simmering behind Wheaton's illustrious streams of gold and silver. I mean, what's better than having a front-row seat to the...

Continue Reading
How Shelton's Property Taxes Influence Housing Costs

Updated Category News Views 3

Thinking about snapping up a home in Shelton, Connecticut? Well, you might want to keep an eye on those property taxes first. Sure, mortgage rates and listing prices grab all the initial attention, but taxes—oh boy, they know how to creep up on ya. Matt Nuzie from RE/MAX lays it bare: property taxes can make or break the bank for homebuyers in Fairfield County. So,...

Continue Reading
Tradr's Bold Venture: Anthropic ETFs Ahead of IPO

Updated Category News Views 0

Why Tradr Is Diving Into Anthropic's Hype There's a whiff of anticipation in the air as Anthropic gears up for its much-anticipated IPO, and Tradr isn't sitting on its hands here. They've just filed for two ETFs—one long, one short—ahead of the big day. We're talking about ANTT and ANTZ, betting on leveraged and inverse plays on whatever whirlwind Anthropic's stock...

Continue Reading
Panel Eyes AI, Guidelines for Workers' Comp Claims

Updated Category News Views 2

Tackling Workers' Comp Consistency The world of workers' comp is all set for a shake-up come National Comp 2026. With industry stalwarts gathering in Seattle, one hot topic on the table is how to turn evidence-based guidelines into everyday practice for claims. And, trust me, it's not as straightforward as slapping guidelines into a handbook. Evidence and Integration: A...

Continue Reading
Skanska's $57M Deal to Transform Del Mar Traffic

Updated Category News Views 3

A Roadway Overhaul in Del Mar A cool $57 million. That’s the ticket Skanska bought to scoop up the El Camino Real project in Del Mar, California. Think of it as a road facelift, a necessary one—it includes bulking up the corridor to four lanes and swapping in a spanking new San Dieguito River Bridge, taking the place of an old rascal that's been around for 84 years....

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Innovative TACTI COOLER Designed for Outdoor Enthusiasts

Updated Category News Views 152

Introducing the New TACTI COOLER for Outdoor Adventures Inventor-driven innovation has led to the creation of a unique cooler that is ideal for outdoor enthusiasts. This inventive spirit birthed the TACTI COOLER, a versatile cooler that promises to enhance outdoor experiences through improved functionality. The idea behind the cooler stemmed from the need for a solution...

Continue Reading
Growth Concerns Amidst Maturing Debt in the Coming Years

Updated Category News Views 66

Understanding the Debt Maturity Challenge One pressing question that many individuals pose is regarding the vast expanse of US government debt. A staggering amount is set to mature soon. Specifically, a significant portion of the existing US Government debt will require repayment, raising questions about liquidity and growth. With around $30 trillion in total US Treasury...

Continue Reading
Unexpected Challenges in Tesla's Revolutionary Robotaxi Journey

Updated Category News Views 180

Tesla's New Robotaxi Service: A Step Towards the Future Tesla's new robotaxi service represents an exciting leap into autonomous driving. The innovative technology aims to simplify transportation, making rides more accessible and efficient. However, experiences like that of a Tesla enthusiast, Ellie Sheriff, highlight both the promise and the pitfalls of this emerging...

Continue Reading
September Market Insights: Turnaround Tuesday Analysis

Updated Category News Views 39

September's Market Overview As we enter September, it's important to recognize that this month can often present challenges for investors. Historical patterns indicate that the early days of September can look bleak, overshadowing the positive sentiments that typically accompany August's close. Even with September's reputation for difficulties, it's essential to stay...

Continue Reading
Navigating the Market: A Deep Dive into Bitdeer Technologies

Updated Category News Views 194

Bitdeer Technologies Earnings Announcement Insight Bitdeer Technologies (NASDAQ: BTDR) is preparing to unveil its quarterly earnings soon. Investors are keenly awaiting details that could impact the market and influence stock prices significantly. Generally speaking, understanding these earnings reports is crucial for anyone looking to navigate the ever-changing world of...

Continue Reading