John Kelly Was Always Just Donald Trump With Better

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Dec 11, 2018 at 12:02 AM 189

Quote:

John Kelly Was Always Just Donald Trump With Better Manners

The outgoing chief of staff’s record of casual cruelty and tolerance of bigotry should remind us that moderation means nothing when paired with such toxic ideology.

https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2018/12/j...trump.html

By Jamelle Bouie
Dec 10, 2018•7:07 PM

John F Kelly visits the Aisne-Marne American Cemetery and Memorial in Belleau, France, on Nov. 10.

Where Cadet Bone Spur was just too damned lazy, or too concerned about his doo, to travel to.....the SAME way that Kelly traveled.

For nearly two years, retired Marine Gen. John Kelly has served as chief of staff to President Donald Trump.* On Saturday, he announced that he’ll end that tenure by the end of this year.

He’ll leave the White House as chaotic and disordered as it was when he took the job. But the ins and outs of Kelly’s performance are less interesting than what he stood for in the larger context of the Trump era. If “Trumpism” has any meaning or ideological content separate from Donald Trump himself, it had a representative—if not an embodiment—in Kelly.

What the outgoing chief of staff lacks in Trump’s intemperate attitude and undisciplined behavior, he makes up for in his commitment to basic elements of the president’s ideology—including his casual cruelty and tolerance for bigotry and bad behavior.

We saw these traits during Kelly’s spat with Florida Rep. Frederica Wilson, which started after Wilson criticized the president for his insensitivity toward the widow of a slain soldier, who was black. Kelly accused Wilson of taking false credit for the construction of an FBI field office in Miami, calling her an “empty barrel” more concerned with herself than the FBI agents. Kelly supposedly made this accusation on the premise of Wilson’s speech at the building dedication ceremony, but video of the event shows the opposite—she had not, in fact, taken credit for the building’s funding. Kelly refused to apologize, signaling his disdain for Wilson, part of a pattern of open disrespect for black female critics of the administration.

We saw these traits in an interview with Fox News where he blamed the Civil War on “the lack of the ability to compromise,” and praised Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee as an “honorable man” along with the “men and women of good faith on both sides” of the conflict.

(The Civil War broke out after more than a decade of conflict over the expansion of slavery.)

Compounding the problem of these remarks was the context: They came just a few months after “Unite the Right,” a rally of white nationalists in Charlottesville, Virginia, that ended in violence—one counterdemonstrator was killed and dozens more were injured. In the wake of that tragedy, President Trump used the same “both sides” language to defend the actions of the racist protesters.

Kelly might value normalcy and temperance over chaos and impulse, but he shares the president’s basic worldview.

We saw them again following allegations of domestic abuse against Rob Porter, a senior aide to the president who had previously served as chief of staff for Kelly himself. Porter resigned his position after two ex-wives came forward with accusations and evidence of verbal and physical abuse, including kicking, throwing, and choking. But in the lead-up to that resignation, Porter was defiant, calling the allegations “outrageous.”

Kelly knew that Porter had been subject to a protective order obtained by his second wife. Still, he backed him, calling Porter a “man of true integrity and honor.” Kelly was practically indifferent to the charges, an attitude that might have made this the most consequential scandal of his tenure, if not for what followed.

What followed next was child separation. John Kelly didn’t just defend the administration’s “zero-tolerance” policy toward immigrants who crossed the border illegally, criminally prosecuting them and placing their children in detention camps—he was one of its architects.

And when asked if it was “cruel and heartless to take a mother away from her children,” Kelly shrugged. “The children will be taken care of—put into foster care or whatever,” he said in an interview with NPR.

It was pure Trump: a succinct encapsulation of everything that defines the president’s rotten ideology, from the casual cruelty to the bigotry behind the dehumanization of an entire class of people. And it came from the “adult in the room,” the man who was supposed to tame Trump’s worst impulses and give the world a more measured, responsible administration.

But therein lies the error. Kelly might value normalcy and temperance over chaos and impulse, but he shares the president’s basic worldview.

Even if he could have wrangled Trump into something like a typical president, the Trump administration would likely still display the same enthusiasm for cruelty and contempt for common decency. Indeed, it might have been worse; a more disciplined Trump would be a more effective one, better able to translate his ethnonationalist instincts into concrete, actionable policy. In which case, it’s to our collective benefit that Kelly failed to control the president.

To that point, if there’s any lesson to take from John Kelly’s tenure in the White House, it’s that the appearance of moderation is not moderation.

And while official Washington might pine for someone to take the reins of the administration—for someone to truly be an “adult in the room”—the Kelly experience shows that this is overrated. What matters is the ethos of the administration, and that flows inexorably from the man at the top.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Globe Life Faces Investor Scrutiny Over Leadership

Shareholders Put Globe Life Under the Microscope There's something cooking at Globe Life Inc., and it isn't a savory stew of shareholder satisfaction. See, when an investor rights firm like Halper Sadeh LLC starts poking around, suspecting a breach of fiduciary duty by the folks at the top, you know there's some smoke. Questions are looming over whether some brass at...

Infosys Transforms Syngenta's Tech Core to Boost Agility

Unpacking the Syngenta-Infosys Transformation Forget your run-of-the-mill tech upgrade; Infosys has just spearheaded a massive transformation for Syngenta, delivering a new global SAP S/4HANA setup that’s set to turbocharge their Crop Protection business. We’re talking about more than just another software upgrade here—this is a sweeping overhaul affecting 10,000...

Backroads Invites Families: Adventures Boost Bookings by 20%

Rediscovering Family Time Through Adventure When was the last time a winter vacation got you this fired up? Backroads, the trailblazer in active getaways, is bucking the trend of typical holiday madness. Families are ditching the usual gift-giving grind for something way more memorable: experiences that blend action with bonding across generations. Big Numbers, Big...

Ferrovial's EUR 600M Scrip Dividend: What's Brewing?

Understanding Ferrovial's Latest Financial Maneuver Alright, investors, listen up—Ferrovial's just tossed a hefty EUR 600 million scrip dividend onto the table, giving shareholders the choice between cash or shares. Now, if you've been around the block, this sort of move can mean a few things, and it's best not to treat it like coins rattling in a collection plate. This...

CMS Energy's Q3 Marks Change: Restructuring Boost

A Tale of Two Earnings Few things get my blood pumping like a new quarter's earnings dance, and CMS Energy (NYSE:CMS) is stealing the show right now with its two-faced Q3 results. Digging deep into the numbers, we see this Michigan-based energy player reporting a gauntlet of figures that have investors raising their eyebrows. On one hand, reported GAAP earnings dropped to...

Dotwork's AI Leap: Acquires Arcario to Revolutionize Strategy

Transformations in enterprise management are knocking at the door with Dotwork's latest move. Their strategic acquisition of Arcario Group aims to flip the lid on how companies tie strategies to their daily grind using AI. Let me level with you—this ain't about just spicing up some dashboards or workflows. We're talking about an enterprise-level overhaul in the very way...

Bloomberg Tax Celebrates Global Tax Leaders at IFA

Spotlight on Global Tax Leadership Here's a twist for you: tax law may not scream excitement, but when international tax changemakers get recognized, even the unflappable have to nod in appreciation. Bloomberg Tax just tossed accolades at five distinguished authors who are mapping the complexities of international tax landscapes. This isn't just about numbers—it's...

Pollo Campero Unveils Bold New Sauces Nationwide

New Sauces Add Flavor Punch to Pollo Campero's Offerings Some days, you're just in the mood to shake things up. That's likely the thinking at Pollo Campero with their latest move: rolling out a trio of sauces that promises to give the taste buds something to talk about. These aren't just any sauces, mind you—this is a strategic gem from the chicken joint known for...

Personalis Merger Faces Investigation: $16.25 Offers Scrutinized

Market Storm or Light Drizzle? When the sharks smell blood or the legal eagles start circling, you know something stinks. BFA Law is sniffing around, and it isn’t just for sport. They’re putting their magnifying glass on this curious $16.25 per share transaction where Tempus AI plans to gobble up Personalis lock, stock, and barrel. For investors holding NASDAQ:PSNL,...

AI's Role in Hiring and Building Teams Examined

The Heartbeat of AI in Phoenix's Tech Scene In the wild world of talent and growth, this upcoming Tech Talent Summit 6.0 in Phoenix sounds like the kind of shindig that'll have Arizona's tech bigwigs buzzing about teams and AI's growing influence. Gearing up this November 6, it isn't just any summit—it's a full-blown gathering focused on how AI is reshaping our...