Ancora v HTC: Why You Should Draft Patents That Emphasize

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board
Hate Liars
642
: Why You Should Draft Patents That Emphasize Technical Solutions

By Steve Saunders
December 6, 2018

https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2018/12/06/ancora-...id=103866/

The pendulum continues to slowly drift toward patentees in this post-Alice world . Last week, in Ancora Technologies v HTC America, the Federal Circuit reversed a lower court’s invalidity ruling under 35 USC §101 by concluding that Ancora’s claimed subject matter was concrete —not abstract— because it assigned specific functions to specific parts of a computer to improve computer security . The claims at issue were directed toward selectively limiting use of a software application on a computer. To do so, the computer stores certain license data in a specified part of its BIOS memory, and verifies against that stored license data to permit or prevent use of that software on the computer.

The district court ignored the specific requirements of the claims and simply abstracted the concept to “selecting a program, verifying whether the program is licensed, and acting on the program according to the verification.” Reversing the lower court ruling, the court pointed out that this analysis clearly ignores the concrete requirements of the claims—using a part of the computer (a specific portion of the BIOS memory) to solve the technical problem of preventing unauthorized use of software. Instead, this claim focuses on a specific improvement in computer capabilities using the BIOS memory.

To support its position, the court discusses other Federal Circuit cases finding non-abstract concepts that improve computer functionality, including:

A behavior based virus scan (Finjan)

Self-referential tables that improved the way computers operated and handled data (Enfish)

A specific way to store a certain type of data in cache memory (Visual Memory)
A method of making web sites easier to navigate on a small screen (Core Wireless Licensing)

A method of navigating through three dimensional spreadsheets using a specific structure—tabs (Data Engines Technology)

In a manner similar to these past cases, the claims here relate to use of a specific part of the computer that improves computer performance. In other words, these claims involve a concrete way of solving a technical problem in computer technology. The court reiterated that software can make non-abstract improvements to computer technology, particularly when the claims focus on specific asserted improvements in computer technology as opposed to processes in which computers are used merely as a tool[/b.

The court contrasted this case and the patentee favorable cases noted above with another computer security case, Intellectual Ventures v Symantec, in which the claims merely installed virus protection in a telephone network. The court reasoned that the Intellectual Ventures claims were abstract because they neither relate to any improvement in virus scanning, nor solve any problem associated with a telephone network . Indeed, the claims of the Intellectual Ventures case are quite broad.

This case is yet another in a string of post-Alice cases suggesting that patents should be drafted with an emphasis on the technical problem and technical solution delivered by the claims. In other words, for similar technologies, the patent draftsperson should describe and claim how the innovation uses the computer or other technology in a specific, new manner to overcome technical hurdles. In this case, the court also considered Ancora’s discussion, in the patent, contrasting the claimed solution with other prior art technological solutions to the same problem (e.g., writing a license signature on the computer’s hard drive or requiring insertion of a dongle into a computer port), which seemed to help convince the court both that the invention was directed to a problem that arises in technology and that the invention provided an improvement to computer technology. The patent draftsperson thus should avoid generic claims that simply apply old technology to a computer. Instead, claiming improved technology and using a computer or other technology in a specific manner can help improve the odds of protecting commercially valuable software innovations, especially where specific improvements over prior art technologies can be demonstrated. As an added bonus, this approach also will pay dividends when protecting the claimed technology overseas, such as in Europe .

Again, this is why this case SLAM DUNKS SFOR's case !!!

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Avelo Tests Loyalty Math With WeSalute Fare Discounts

Updated Category News Views 237

Airline discounts can look like generosity until the load factor starts talking back. Avelo Airlines has joined WeSalute with fare discounts for active-duty military members, veterans, first responders, nurses, medical professionals, public servants, teachers and eligible family members. It is a sensible move for a young carrier built around smaller airports and lower...

Continue Reading
ZTO's Pricing Muscle Shows Up in Third-Quarter Results

Updated Category News Views 136

Ten billion parcels can hide plenty of ugly economics, but ZTO's third quarter does not look like a volume-at-any-cost stunt. The company moved 10.241 billion parcels, up 7.0% from a year earlier, and says that outpaced the industry by 4.1 percentage points. More importantly, revenue climbed 21.0% to RMB14.36 billion while adjusted net income reached RMB2.57 billion. That...

Continue Reading
GALLS Honors Service With Lexington Hall of Fame Wall

Updated Category News Views 86

A headquarters wall can say more about a company than another polished mission statement ever will. On November 17, 2026, GALLS® unveiled the National Law Enforcement Officer Hall of Fame Wall at its Lexington, Kentucky, corporate headquarters, displaying portraits of every past inductee into the National Law Enforcement Officer Hall of Fame. Recognition, made permanent...

Continue Reading
Floating Solar Gets a Serious Test in Central New York

Updated Category News Views 86

A flooded quarry pit outside Cortlandville is getting a second career, and that is more interesting than another solar announcement draped across empty acreage. Third Pillar Power has started construction on Crown City Solar at Suit-Kote Corporation's active Polkville Crushed Stone Facility, pairing a working mine, asphalt plant, and storage terminal with what the...

Continue Reading
Exiger's CEO Honored for Military Support Excellence

Updated Category News Views 58

Recognizing Civilian and Military Leadership When you hear "recognition in the military sector," it isn't just a pat on the back. It's a whole parade of brass hats and high-flyers giving their nods. So, November 10th wasn't just any regular day—Brandon Daniels, CEO of Exiger, gets a shiny, prestigious Five-Star Award for his "extraordinary support" of our military...

Continue Reading
Sola's 11-Step Push Makes Salon Ownership Less Blind

Updated Category News Views 115

A pristine studio does not pay rent by itself. That is the uncomfortable little truth sitting underneath Sola Salons’ new 11-step roadmap for beauty professionals considering salon-suite ownership. The company is telling stylists, estheticians, nail technicians, massage therapists, and other independent operators to treat the move from commission work to ownership like...

Continue Reading
STORMER LAT Targets Sewer Crews' Costly Access Delays

Updated Category News Views 32

A buried cleanout can turn a simple sewer inspection into a scheduling circus. That unglamorous headache is exactly where FIBERSCOPE is aiming its new STORMER LAT Lateral Launch Camera System, announced November 17, 2026. This is not some flashy consumer gadget hunting for attention; it is field equipment built around a painfully ordinary municipal problem: crews often...

Continue Reading
Voltage Energy's Microgrid Launches at RE+ 2026

Updated Category News Views 147

Voltage Energy Unveils New Power Systems In the swirling chaos of energy innovation, Voltage Energy is trying to carve its path at the heart of RE+ 2026. Out in Las Vegas, amidst the buzz of renewable energy tech, they introduced their Microgrid System (MGS) along with two new electrical balance of system (EBOS) products—the Load Break Disconnect Box (LBD) and Combiner...

Continue Reading
Stand Out For Good Makes a Bold Michigan Avenue Bet

Updated Category News Views 183

A six-floor retail commitment lands with a thud Stand Out For Good is taking on roughly 51,079 square feet at 669 North Michigan Avenue, and nobody should mistake that for a casual expansion. Six levels on Chicago's Magnificent Mile is a proper declaration of intent, especially in a retail district that has endured plenty of empty-window handwringing and big-brand churn....

Continue Reading
Medical School Rejections Carry a Steep Price Tag Too

Updated Category News Views 107

A rejection letter can turn into a remarkably expensive piece of paper. BeMo Academic Consulting's new Medical School Admissions Trends Report argues that the damage from missing medical-school admission goes far beyond bruised confidence: applicants can spend thousands chasing another cycle, lose time entering practice, and, if they never get in, forgo what the report...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Coway's Inverter Dehumidifier 23L Triumphs at Global Design Awards

Updated Category News Views 208

Inverter Dehumidifier 23L Wins Recognition at Good Design Awards - The Inverter Dehumidifier 23L gains accolades for its compact design and user-friendly features at the Good Design Awards 2025. - This recent achievement cements Coway's status as a leading player in global design, recognized by all four major awards this year. Coway's Prestigious Award Recognition Hosted...

Continue Reading
Veru's Enobosarm & Semaglutide: A New Era in Weight Loss Safety

Updated Category News Views 314

Positive Safety Profile from Veru's Clinical Study Veru Inc. (NASDAQ: VERU), a trailblazer in biopharmaceuticals, recently revealed exciting topline safety results from its Phase 2b QUALITY clinical study. This trial examined the combination of enobosarm and semaglutide, uncovering significant advantages in safety and efficacy compared to semaglutide alone. Understanding...

Continue Reading
How a $1000 Investment in REV Group Can Grow Over Time

Updated Category News Views 180

Understanding REV Group's Market Performance REV Group (NYSE: REVG) has demonstrated impressive performance in the stock market over the past five years. This company has not only outperformed the broader market, but it has done so by a remarkable 29.45% on an annualized basis, resulting in an average annual return of 42.83%. With a market capitalization reaching...

Continue Reading
Castellum's GTMR Achieves Key CMMI Level 3 Milestone

Updated Category News Views 172

Castellum's GTMR Achieves Key CMMI Level 3 Milestone Castellum, Inc. (NYSE-American: CTM) has exciting news to share, as it announces its subsidiary, Global Technology and Management Resources, Inc. (GTMR), has achieved a significant milestone by obtaining a Level 3 appraisal under ISACA’s Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI). This recognition highlights GTMR's...

Continue Reading
Discovering Nature Close Up: The MicroCam X1 Launch

Updated Category News Views 162

Introducing the MicroCam X1 by Littpopo Littpopo, an innovative brand dedicated to exploration technology, has launched the MicroCam X1, a remarkable pocket microscope camera now live on a crowdfunding platform. This unique device combines a powerful 400X microscope with a 4K camera, making it an essential tool for educators, content creators, families, and adventurers...

Continue Reading