Friendly policies keep US oil and coal afloat far more

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Bhawks Lmcat #49711
315
Quote:
Friendly policies keep US oil and coal afloat far more than we thought

Most energy subsidies go not to renewables but to producing more of the dirty stuff.


Two months current enough for you? Before losing your shit, please find something as recent, with data as recent, to refute the following

By David Roberts@drvoxdavid@vox.com Updated Jul 26, 2018, 7:54am EDT

shutterstock_371657893.0.jpg
Thanks, taxpayers! |(Shutterstock)

The coal industry and its allies in the Trump administration have devoted considerable energy to arguing that subsidies to renewable energy have distorted energy markets and helped drive coal out of business.

“Certain regulations and subsidies,” Energy Secretary Rick Perry has said, “are having a large impact on the functioning of markets, and thereby challenging our power generation mix.” You can guess which regulations and subsidies he’s talking about.

This is nothing new, of course. It is in keeping with a long conservative tradition of challenging the economic wisdom and effectiveness of energy subsidies.

At least, uh, some energy subsidies.

Energy analysts have made the point again and again that fossil fuels, not renewable energy, most benefit from supportive public policy. Yet this fact, so inconvenient to the conservative worldview, never seems to sink in to the energy debate in a serious way. The supports offered to fossil fuels are so old and familiar, they fade into the background. It is support offered to challengers — typically temporary, fragmentary, and politically uncertain support — that is forever in the spotlight.

So let’s change that. Let’s talk about “certain regulations and subsidies” — namely, the ones propping up US fossil fuels.

Three recent analyses can help. The first does the yeoman’s work of tallying up federal and state energy subsidies. The second shows the effect those subsidies have on oil and gas production. And the third shows how thoroughly the US coal industry is propped up by regulatory policy. Together, they paint a clear picture: The profits of US fossil fuels are built on a foundation of government assistance.

All right then. First: What gets subsidized, and how much?

WASHINGTON, DC - FEBRUARY 16: U.S. President Donald Trump signs H.J. Res. 38, disapproving the rule submitted by the US Department of the Interior known as the Stream Protection Rule in the Roosevelt Room of the White House on February 16, 2017 in Washington

trump_coal.jpg

Here’s Trump allowing mines to pollute more. We’re not even counting that in the subsidies, though. |(Photo by Ron Sachs-Pool/Getty Images)

US fossil fuel production is subsidized to the tune of $20 billion annually

Researchers at Oil Change International (OCI) set out to quantify the level of US fossil fuel subsidies, but before we get to their results, a few important caveats.

OCI is only counting direct production subsidies. As they acknowledge, that leaves out a great deal.

For one thing, it leaves out the annual $14.5 billion in consumption subsidies — things like the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), which helps lower-income residents pay their (fuel oil) heating bills. (There are better ways to help poor people, but let’s leave that aside for now.)

It also leaves out subsidies for overseas fossil fuel projects ($2.1 billion a year).

Most significantly, OCI’s analysis leaves out indirect subsidies — things like the money the US military spends to protect oil shipping routes, or the unpaid costs of health and climate impacts from burning fossil fuels.

These indirect subsidies reach to the hundreds of billions, dwarfing direct subsidies — the IMF says that, globally speaking, they amount to $5.3 trillion a year. But they are controversial and very difficult to measure precisely.

Finally, OCI acknowledges that its estimates of state-level subsidies are probably low, since many states don’t report the costs of tax expenditures (i.e., tax breaks and credits to industry), so data is difficult to come by.

All of which is to say: OCI has produced about the most conservative possible estimate of the subsidies received by fossil fuels in the US. These are solely production subsidies — taxpayer money that goes directly to producing more fossil fuels.

So what’s the verdict?

Adding everything up: $14.7 billion in federal subsidies and $5.8 billion in state-level incentives, for a total of $20.5 billion annually in corporate welfare.

Of that total, 80 percent goes to oil and gas, 20 percent to coal. On the right, subsidies are broken down by stage of production. Extraction gets the most.


OCI_US_Fossil_Fuel_Subs_2015_16_breakdown.jpg

Notice that asterisk by remediation, which refers to the cost of cleaning up environmental messes and abandoned infrastructure left behind by fossil fuels. Shady insurance, bonding, and liability-cap policies mean that taxpayers are probably on the hook for lots more than this in the end, but it’s difficult to quantify in advance.

There are dozens and dozens of fossil fuel production subsidies — OCI’s report has a whole appendix devoted to listing them — but here they are broken down by the biggest offenders:

OCI_US_Fossil_Fuel_Subs_2015_16_categories.jpg
You probably can’t read that text, so here are the top six:
•Intangible drilling oil & gas deduction ($2.3 billion)
•Excess of percentage over cost depletion ($1.5 billion)
•Master Limited Partnerships tax exemption ($1.6 billion)
•Last-in, first-out (LIFO) accounting ($1.7 billion)
•Lost royalties from onshore and offshore drilling ($1.2 billion)
•Low-cost leasing of coal-production in the Powder River Basin ($963 million)

(I listed six because that sixth one is the biggie for coal.)

These kinds of obscure tax loopholes and accounting tricks are not widely known or debated, partially because you have to be a tax lawyer to understand them, and partially because they are simply old. The single biggest one, the intangible drilling deduction, has been around for over a century!

As subsidies age, they start to look less like subsidies. They start looking like fixed features of the landscape, like mountains or rivers, rather than choices we are making. They just look like the status quo.

How does this compare to renewable energy subsidies? In terms of permanent tax expenditures, fossil fuels beat renewables by a 7-1 margin:

OCI_US_Fossil_Fuel_Subs_2015_16_comparison.jpg

You can pick up the rest of the article here. Hint, you'll find nothing to corroborate your 'beliefs':

https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/20...-subsidies

So, let’s take a step back and sum up.

Right now, the US pays rhetorical fealty to a carbon goal that would require stopping all new fossil fuel development and phasing out all coal plants.

Meanwhile, US taxpayers are spending tens of billions of dollars a year subsidizing new fossil fuel exploration and exploitation, and US regulatory policy keeps the zombie coal fleet shambling on.

All the while, conservatives complain volubly about subsidies to renewable energy and the US energy secretary tries to use them as an excuse to dump even more public money on coal companies.

It’s a train wreck.

But still. The oil and gas companies making decisions to develop new fields and the utilities keeping coal plants alive are going to realize, at some point, that their vulnerability to “carbon risk” grows every year. (Arguably, big oil is way ahead of big coal in understanding this.)

The Obama administration identified $8.7 billion a year in federal fossil fuel subsidies to eliminate, but couldn’t get it past Congress. Now both sides of Pennsylvania Avenue are fossil-addled.

But if the US ever does get serious about mitigating climate change, those companies are going to be the ones caught with their pants down, holding a bunch of high-carbon assets that are destined to be stranded.

US fossil fuel companies and utilities are basically gambling on the continued perversity of US energy policy. It’s not a terrible bet — an odds-on winner, historically speaking, and probably for the next few years — but it can’t last forever.

Can it?

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Apani Adds Kelsun Assets to Its Natural Fiber Platform

Updated Category News Views 162

A materials deal with more chemistry than chest-thumping Seaweed and cotton have landed under one roof, which is a lot more interesting than another apparel brand slapping a green label on ordinary fabric. Apani said November 17 it acquired the assets of Keel Labs, bringing Keel's seaweed-based Kelsun fiber alongside Apani's enhanced cotton-cellulose filament technology....

Continue Reading
Snowrise Targets the Blind Spots in CPG Sales Data

Updated Category News Views 35

A sales total can look healthy while the floorboards are quietly rotting underneath it. That is the uncomfortable CPG problem Snowrise is aiming at: brands know what moved last quarter, but often cannot identify which stores, channels, communities, or promotions actually created the result. Plenty of management teams still steer by topline revenue, net distribution gains,...

Continue Reading
illumine Targets Childcare Chain Control and Risk Gaps

Updated Category News Views 10

Expansion Gets Messy Before It Gets Impressive Childcare operators do not usually stumble because they forgot how to care for children; they stumble because the back office fractures as the network grows. One center handles fees one way, another lets enrollment leads work a different funnel, and headquarters discovers too late that its reports are arguing with each other....

Continue Reading
Vuzix Bets on Lightweight Color Glasses for OEM Partners

Updated Category News Views 72

Forty grams is where this story gets interesting, because faces are ruthless product testers. People will tolerate plenty of clever technology right up until it pinches, looks goofy, leaks light, or makes them feel like they are wearing a science project. Vuzix is trying to clear that hurdle with Ultralite Color, a full-color AI eyewear reference platform built for OEM...

Continue Reading
Red Cat Stock Drama: Revenue Targets and Legal Waves

Updated Category News Views 183

Red Cat's Revenue Predictions Crash and Burn Sitting there on August 6, 2026, Red Cat Holdings had everyone believing they were on a fast track to hitting a hefty revenue target: $150–$180 million for FY2026. CEO Jeffrey Thompson didn't mince words, boasting confidence like a captain before a storm. Fast forward three months, and they're waving the white flag, tossing...

Continue Reading
Mantle's Japan Listing Puts $MNT Through a Real Test

Updated Category News Views 117

Japan's crypto gatekeepers just handed Mantle a key, not a crown. The November 18 listing of $MNT on GMO Coin is a meaningful operational win because getting onto a Japanese centralized exchange is not the usual loose-change exercise seen in friendlier jurisdictions. Mantle cleared a review process involving GMO Coin and the Japan Virtual and Crypto Assets Exchange...

Continue Reading
Markel Elevates War Risk Expertise in London Market

Updated Category News Views 73

A Specialty Desk Gets Its Own Weather Vane War and political violence underwriting is not a corner of insurance where a fancy title change can be shrugged off. The ground shifts under the policyholder, the broker and the carrier without much warning, and a bad call can sit on a book for years. Markel Insurance has named Chloe Gordge Director of War and Political Violence...

Continue Reading
Legato Frames Put Tiny AI to a Real-World Hearing Test

Updated Category News Views 231

A hearing aid that never enters the ear is a deceptively brutal product challenge. It has to hear speech through a mess of restaurant clatter, traffic, wind and ordinary human commotion; it has to run all day; and, crucially, it cannot look like a medical concession somebody reluctantly straps on. Legato Frames are aiming right at that knot, with femtoAI providing the...

Continue Reading
MacDill Mold Case Puts Privatized Housing on Notice

Updated Category News Views 194

Four hundred fifty-four people are a hard number to shrug off. The expanded civil case over alleged toxic mold conditions at MacDill Air Force Base now covers 105 military families, up from 39 households when it was filed in September 2025. Their complaint against The Michaels Organization and affiliated entities may be the largest known military-housing lawsuit in the...

Continue Reading
ETCO Targets the Unflashy Weak Link in Battery Storage

Updated Category News Views 16

A battery cabinet can look impressive right up until one lousy connection becomes the problem nobody budgeted for. ETCO Incorporated’s new lineup of standard and custom connectors and terminals goes after that unglamorous part of battery energy storage systems: the physical handoff points carrying power, grounding equipment, and tying auxiliary components together. It...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

AEA Private Debt's Strategic Investment in Weller Metalworks

Updated Category News Views 299

Let's cut to the chase: AEA Private Debt is making some serious waves in the middle market with its latest move as the Sole Provider of mezzanine notes for Weller Metalworks' acquisition of DROP Sprockets, Inc. This isn’t just another deal; it’s a calculated step in an increasingly competitive landscape where metal fabrication firms are vying for supremacy. Weller...

Continue Reading
Medication Management Partners Continues to Excel in Senior Care

Updated Category News Views 196

Medication Management Partners Earns Prestigious Recognition In recent news, Medication Management Partners (MMP), a leading long-term care pharmacy, proudly announces its place on the Inc. 5000 list of fastest-growing private companies in America for the seventh consecutive year. This achievement signifies the company’s steady growth and innovative practices in the...

Continue Reading
AlphaGen Unveils Major Expansion Plans for Power Generation

Updated Category News Views 501

AlphaGen's Ambitious 450 MW Power Generation Initiative Alpha Generation, LLC ("AlphaGen"), based in Stamford, Conn., is taking a significant step towards meeting the escalating demand for reliable electric power across the nation. With plans to add approximately 450 megawatts (MW) of additional electric generation at four existing power stations, AlphaGen aims to bolster...

Continue Reading
STAT Secures a Loeb Award for Outstanding Reporting on Opioids

Updated Category News Views 185

STAT Achieves Recognition for Vital Reporting STAT addiction reporter Lev Facher has been honored with a 2025 Loeb Award for his exceptional work in explanatory reporting. This award, regarded as the pinnacle of accomplishment in business and financial journalism, recognizes Facher's six-part series titled "The War on Recovery." The compelling series sheds light on the...

Continue Reading
Investigation into Nomura Holdings, Inc. Sparks Investor Concerns

Updated Category News Views 67

Introduction to the Investigation of Nomura Holdings, Inc. Pomerantz LLP is currently conducting an investigation focused on claims made on behalf of investors of Nomura Holdings, Inc. (NYSE: NMR). The essence of this investigation revolves around whether Nomura and some of its key officers or directors may have engaged in securities fraud or other illicit business...

Continue Reading