https://www.uspto.gov/about-us/news-updates/remark

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
gimli
368
https://www.uspto.gov/about-us/news-updates/r...al-meeting

Excerpt on Alice.........


Quote:
Now as to patents: Discussing everything we are doing on the patents front would probably take the rest of this conference, something Henry would probably not be happy about. So in the interest of time, I’ll focus my remarks on a specific proposal for Section 101—patentable subject matter.

As many of you know, we recently issued to our examiners two new guidance memos on Section 101: the first dealing with the “conventionality” step in the Mayo/Alice framework, and the second on “methods of treatment” claims. Our data shows that these two memos have already improved the 101 analysis during examination.

But significantly more work needs to be done, especially on the “abstract idea” exception.

I know that IPO committees have been hard at work on a legislative fix to Section 101. Indeed, IPO and AIPLA have joined forces recently and proposed new statutory language. Should Congress be interested in moving forward with hearings or legislation, the USPTO would be very happy to help. As we all know, however, any legislative effort takes a long time, and the result is uncertain.

In the meantime, the USPTO cannot wait. We have thousands of examiners who struggle with these issues on a daily basis. Our examiners need additional guidance now. And so do patent applicants, patent owners, and the public. Whether through legislation or otherwise, there is a growing consensus that the issue must be promptly addressed.

In fact, several Federal Circuit judges have recently filed concurrences or dissents explaining the uncertain nature of the law and calling for change.

In order to “work its way out of what so many in the innovation field consider are §101 problems,” Judge Lourie—in an opinion joined by Judge Newman—appealed to a higher authority. “Resolution of patent-eligibility issues requires higher intervention, hopefully with ideas reflective of the best thinking that can be brought to bear on the subject.”

Judge Plager, in another case, noted that “the state of the law is such as to give little confidence that the outcome is necessarily correct.” He explained that, given current §101 jurisprudence, it is “near impossible to know with any certainty whether the invention is or is not patent eligible.” And he concluded that we currently have an “incoherent body of doctrine.”

And Judge Linn explained that the abstract idea test is “indeterminate and often leads to arbitrary results.”

I agree with all these sentiments.

Judge Giles Rich, an icon of patent law with an unparalleled understanding of—and impact on—our system, stated, in 1979, the crux of the problem with respect to §101 jurisprudence. He said at the time that problems can arise due to the “unfortunate … though clear commingling of distinct statutory provisions which are conceptually unrelated, namely, those pertaining to the categories of invention in §101 which may be patentable, and to the conditions for patentability demanded by the statute…”

This was almost 40 years ago! How perceptive and prescient Judge Rich was.

Let me put this in my own words: How can a claim be novel enough to pass 102 and nonobvious enough to pass 103, yet lack an “inventive concept” and therefore fail 101? Or, how can a claim be concrete enough so that one of skill in the art can make it without undue experimentation, and pass 112, yet abstract enough to fail 101? How can something concrete be abstract?

These problems confound the most sophisticated practitioners in our patent system. People simply don’t know how to draw these distinctions. If something is not inventive, then invalidate it under 102 or 103. If something is indefinite, or too broad to be fully enabled or described, then invalidate it under 112.

We have decades of case law from the courts and millions of examinations at the PTO which guide us in our 102, 103, and 112 analyses. People know these standards and how to apply these well-defined statutory requirements.

The genius of the 1952 Patent Act, of which Judge Rich is widely viewed as a principal author, was that it categorized the bases for patentability. Our recent §101 case law mushes them all up again. As Judge Rich said, this “may lead to distorted legal conclusions.” And it has. And it must end.

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

TCL CSOT's Oxide Leap Gives LCD a Sharper Fight Ahead

Updated Category News Views 64

Fifty-one point six is the number that makes this announcement worth chewing on. TCL CSOT says it has moved ultrahigh-mobility oxide technology into mass production on an 8.6-generation line, clearing the 50 cm² V?¹ s?¹ threshold that has largely belonged to lab-talk and presentation slides. For display people, that is not decorative science. It could change the old...

Continue Reading
U.S. Employers Signal a Deeper Multilingual Skills Gap

Updated Category News Views 15

A language gap rarely makes the loudest noise in an earnings call, yet it can quietly wreck a sales effort, a hiring plan, or a customer relationship. ACTFL's updated 2026 employer study puts some hard edges around that problem: U.S. businesses say multilingual capability is not a nice cultural accessory. It is increasingly part of operating the business. Demand Has Moved...

Continue Reading
New York's $1.2M Prison Abuse Deal Raises State Stakes

Updated Category News Views 41

One courtroom result can expose a whole warehouse of institutional neglect, and this one lands with a grim thud. New York has agreed to pay $1.2 million to resolve a claim involving sexual assault by a former corrections officer at Bayview Correctional Facility in Manhattan. The settlement came after a two-week Adult Survivors Act bellwether trial concluded on November 17...

Continue Reading
MTI Adds Aviation Veterans as Acorn Builds MRO Plan

Updated Category News Views 95

Two old hands entering a boardroom can matter more than another glossy growth slogan, especially in aircraft maintenance, where a delayed part can ground an airplane and turn a customer relationship sour in a hurry. MTI Aviation has added Tony DiSimone Sr. and Aviv Tzur to its board, a move announced November 20, 2026, after Acorn Capital Management took a majority...

Continue Reading
Arizona's Dry Climate Puts Scalp Health Under Stress

Updated Category News Views 35

Desert weather is unforgiving, and apparently the scalp does not get a pass. In a Nov. 20, 2026 discussion, Scottsdale and Tucson hair-restoration physician Dr. Sharon A. Keene frames Arizona hair concerns around something easy to overlook: the condition of the skin beneath the hair. That is a more sensible starting point than treating every strand in the shower like it...

Continue Reading
PetSmart Charities Adds Strategy Role for Pet Families

Updated Category News Views 347

A pet bowl can become a crisis marker faster than people admit. Housing trouble, empty cupboards, a hurricane, or an unaffordable veterinary bill can turn a loved animal into one more impossible responsibility. That is the uncomfortable reality behind PetSmart Charities' decision to create a vice president of strategic programs and partnerships role and appoint Heather...

Continue Reading
Trump's Reagan Forum Speech Puts Defense in Focus Again

Updated Category News Views 10

A December podium in Simi Valley has suddenly become a market-relevant appointment. The Ronald Reagan Presidential Foundation and Institute says President Donald J. Trump will deliver the keynote at the 2026 Reagan National Defense Forum on Friday, December 4, at 3:00 p.m. Pacific time, or 6:00 p.m. Eastern. That is the whole hard fact pattern so far. No agenda, no...

Continue Reading
Melio’s AP Push Looks Useful, but Read the Fine Print

Updated Category News Views 87

Back-office drudgery rarely gets anyone’s pulse racing, yet it can quietly chew through a small business’s time and cash. That is why Melio’s latest recognition as Software Experts’ top pick for accounts payable automation deserves a look. The product pitch is straightforward: pull bills, approvals, payments and reconciliation into one workflow rather than leaving...

Continue Reading
Duetti, CesiumAstro, and a Busy NYSE Capital Morning

Updated Category News Views 73

Three very different piles of money are jamming up the November 20 NYSE slate, and that contrast is the whole point. Private music catalogs, space-and-defense communications, and a new stock-and-bond ETF do not belong in the same bucket. Yet all three are competing for investor attention before the opening bell, alongside Danaos Corporation's 20th listing anniversary....

Continue Reading
Hope Charities Makes Care Funding Easier to Track Online

Updated Category News Views 72

A treatment bill can wreck a household long before a diagnosis does. That is the uncomfortable reality behind Hope Charities' new Access to Care website, a centralized resource meant to show people in the bleeding disorders community when diagnosis-specific charitable assistance funds are available. This is not flashy technology, nor should it be treated like some grand...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Ragie Launches Advanced Agent Ready Features for Developers

Updated Category News Views 253

Ragie Introduces Innovative Agent Ready Features Ragie is excited to present its latest advancement: the introduction of Agent Ready capabilities. This launch focuses on empowering developers with tools for creating intelligent, context-aware agents. Enhanced features like Agentic Retrieval and support for Right-to-Left (RTL) languages enhance accessibility and robust...

Continue Reading
JNR Stellarc 100K: A Game-Changer in Refillable Vapes

Updated Category News Views 200

Introducing the JNR Stellarc 100K Refillable Vape JNR has officially launched the JNR Stellarc 100K, a remarkable modular refillable vape system that promises to redefine the vaping experience. Engineered for extreme endurance and superior safety features, the Stellarc 100K is set to offer unparalleled value to its users. This advanced vape is not just another product; it...

Continue Reading
Xiao-I Corporation Shareholders Encouraged to Join Class Action

Updated Category News Views 86

Xiao-I Corporation Shareholders Encouraged to Join Class Action Recent events have led to significant concerns for shareholders of Xiao-I Corporation. With allegations of misleading statements and inadequate disclosures surfacing, many shareholders find themselves at a crossroads. It is essential for investors who purchased shares during a specific period to explore their...

Continue Reading
Assessing Bristol Myers Squibb: Analyst Insights and Future Prospects

Updated Category News Views 138

Bristol Myers Squibb: A Low Valuation Opportunity BofA Securities has recently upgraded Bristol Myers Squibb Co. (NYSE: BMY) from a Neutral position to a Buy rating, indicating a positive outlook for the company driven by strong near-term catalysts. Analyst Jason Gerberry highlighted a compelling risk-reward scenario, especially as the company anticipates a flat...

Continue Reading
Carrier's Q3 Performance and Future Outlook: Key Insights

Updated Category News Views 237

Carrier Global Corporation's Q3 Earnings Overview Carrier Global Corporation (NYSE: CARR), a prominent innovator in climate and energy solutions, recently released its third-quarter earnings, showcasing performance that exceeded market expectations. The results highlight not only the financial stability of the company but also the strategic adjustments made to navigate...

Continue Reading