Two Colleagues Contradict Brennan's Denial of Reliance on

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Lmcat
573
Two Colleagues Contradict Brennan's Denial of Reliance on Dossier

Former CIA Director John Brennan’s insistence that the salacious and unverified Steele dossier was not part of the official Intelligence Community Assessment on Russian interference in the 2016 election is being contradicted by two top former officials.

Retired National Security Agency Director Michael Rogers stated in a classified letter to Congress that the Clinton campaign-funded memos did factor into the ICA.
And James Clapper, Director of National Intelligence under Obama, conceded in a recent CNN interview that the assessment was based on “some of the substantive content of the dossier.” Without elaborating, he maintained that “we were able to corroborate” certain allegations.


These accounts are at odds with Brennan’s May 2017 testimony before the House Intelligence Committee that the Steele dossier was "not in any way used as the basis for the intelligence community's assessment"
that Russia interfered in the election to help elect Donald Trump. Brennan has repeated this claim numerous times, including in February on “Meet the Press.”

In a March 5, 2018, letter to House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes, Adm. Rogers informed the committee that a two-page summary of the dossier — described as “the Christopher Steele information” — was “added” as an “appendix to the ICA draft,” and that consideration of that appendix was “part of the overall ICA review/approval process.”

His skepticism of the dossier may explain why the NSA parted company with other intelligence agencies and cast doubt on one of its crucial conclusions: that Vladimir Putin personally ordered a cyberattack on Hillary Clinton’s campaign to help Donald Trump win the White House.

Rogers has testified that while he was sure the Russians wanted to hurt Clinton, he wasn't as confident as CIA and FBI officials that their actions were designed to help Trump, explaining that such as assessment "didn't have the same level of sourcing and the same level of multiple sources.”

449039_5_.jpg

National Security Agency Director, Adm. Michael Rogers; FBI Director James Comey; Director of National Intelligence James Clapper; CIA Director John Brennan; and the Defense Intelligence Agency Director, Lt. Gen. Vincent Stewart, testifying before the Senate Intelligence Committee in 2016.


The dossier, which is made up of 16 opposition research-style memos on Trump underwritten by the Democratic National Committee and Clinton’s campaign, is based mostly on uncorroborated third-hand sources.
Still, the ICA has been viewed by much of the Washington establishment as the unimpeachable consensus of the U.S. intelligence community.
Its conclusions that “Vladimir Putin ordered” the hacking and leaking of Clinton campaign emails “to help Trump’s chances of victory” have driven the “Russia collusion” narrative and subsequent investigations besieging the Trump presidency.

Except that the ICA did not reflect the consensus of the intelligence community.

Clapper broke with tradition and decided not to put the assessment out to all 17 U.S. intelligence agencies for review. Instead, he limited input to a couple dozen chosen analysts from just three agencies — the CIA, NSA and FBI. Agencies with relevant expertise on Russia, such as the Department of Homeland Security, Defense Intelligence Agency and the State Department’s intelligence bureau, were excluded from the process.

While faulting Clapper for not following intelligence community standards that Clapper himself ordered in 2015, the House Intelligence Committee’s 250-page report also found that the ICA did not properly describe the “quality and credibility of underlying sources” and was not “independent of political considerations."

In another departure from custom, the report is missing any dissenting views or an annex with evaluations of the conclusions from outside reviewers. "Traditionally, controversial intelligence community assessments like this include dissenting views and the views of an outside review group,” said Fred Fleitz, who worked as a CIA analyst for 19 years and helped draft national intelligence estimates at Langley. "It also should have been thoroughly vetted with all relevant IC agencies,” he added. "Why were DHS and DIA excluded?”

Fleitz suggests that the Obama administration limited the number of players involved in the analysis to skew the results. He believes the process was “manipulated” to reach a “predetermined political conclusion” that the incoming Republican president was compromised by the Russians.

“I’ve never viewed the ICA as credible,” the CIA veteran added.

A source close to the House investigation said Brennan himself selected the CIA and FBI analysts who worked on the ICA, and that they included former FBI counterespionage chief Peter Strzok.

“Strzok was the intermediary between Brennan and Comey, and he was one of the authors of the ICA,” according to the source.

Strzok was reassigned to another department and removed from Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation after anti-Trump and pro-Clinton text messages he wrote to Lisa Pager during the 2016 campaign were discovered by the Justice Department’s IG. Strzok remains under IG investigation, along with other senior FBI officials, for possible misconduct.

Strzok led the FBI’s investigation of Trump campaign ties to Russia during 2016, including obtaining electronic surveillance warrants on Carter Page and other campaign advisers. The Page warrant relied heavily on unverified allegations contained in the Democratic Party-funded dossier.

Brennan has sworn the dossier was not “in any way" used as a basis for the ICA. He explains he heard snippets of the dossier from the press in the summer of 2016, but insists he did not see it or read it for himself until late 2016. “Brennan’s claims are impossible to believe,” Fleitz asserted.

"Brennan was pushing the Trump collusion line in mid-2016 and claimed to start the FBI collusion investigation in August 2016,” he said.

He also pointed out that the key findings of the ICA match the central allegations in the dossier. The House Intelligence Committee concluded that Brennan, who previously worked as Obama’s deputy national security adviser, created a “fusion cell” on Russian election interference made up of analysts from the CIA, FBI and NSA, who produced a series of related papers for the White House during the 2016 campaign.

Less than a month after Trump won the election, Obama directed Brennan to conduct a review of all intelligence relating to Russian involvement in the 2016 election and produce a single, comprehensive assessment. Obama was briefed on the findings, along with President-elect Trump, in early January.

“Brennan put some of the dossier material into the PDB [presidential daily briefing] for Obama and described it as coming from a ‘credible source,’ which is how they viewed Steele.” "But they never corroborated his sources.”

Several prominent Washington news outlets had access to the dossier during the 2016 campaign – or at least portions of it -- but also could not confirm Steele’s allegations.

So they shied away from covering them. All that changed in early January 2017, after CNN and The Washington Post learned through Obama administration leaks that the CIA had briefed the president and president-elect about them.
Then the allegations became a media feeding frenzy. On Jan. 11, 2017, within days of the dossier briefings and release of the declassified ICA report, BuzzFeed published virtually all of the dossier memos on its website.

The House committee found “significant leaks" of classified information around the time of the ICA -- and “many of these leaks were likely from senior officials within the IC." Its recently released report points to Clapper as the main source of leaks about the presidential briefings involving the dossier.

It also suggests that during his July 17, 2017, testimony behind closed doors in executive session, he misled (LIED) to House investigators.


When first asked about leaks related to the ICA in July 2017, Clapper flatly denied “discuss[ing] the dossier or any other intelligence related to Russia hacking of the 2016 election with journalists.”

But he subsequently acknowledged discussing the “dossier with CNN journalist Jake Tapper,” and admitted he might have spoken with other journalists.

On Jan. 10, 2017, CNN published an article by Tapper and others about the dossier briefings sourced to “multiple U.S. officials with direct knowledge of the briefings.” Tapper shared a byline with lead writer Evan Perez, a close friend of the founders of Fusion GPS, which hired Steele as a subcontractor on the dossier project.

The next day, Clapper expressed his “profound dismay at the leaks that have been appearing in the press,” while stressing that “I do not believe the leaks came from within the IC.” A month after his misleading testimony to House investigators, Clapper joined CNN as a “national security analyst."

https://www.realclearinvestigations.com/artic...ssier.html
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

JLL’s Facility Management Push Gets a Useful Nod From Frost

Updated Category News Views 27

A Building Breaks Down Long Before the Earnings Call Notices Facility management is the sort of business that gets ignored until an airport system fails, a data-center cooling unit balks, or a workforce cannot use the building it was told to return to. That is why Frost & Sullivan’s 2026 recognition of JLL deserves more than the usual award-season shrug. It points to an...

Continue Reading
Kyndryl's Gartner Sweep Raises the Execution Bar Again

Updated Category News Views 95

A workplace help-desk ticket may sound dull as drywall, but at a giant enterprise it can become a very expensive little failure. That is why Kyndryl's latest Gartner recognition deserves more than the usual corporate backslapping. The company was named a Leader in Gartner's 2026 Magic Quadrant for Outsourced Digital Workplace Services for a third consecutive year, and...

Continue Reading
Zunyi’s History Tour Carries China’s Story Overseas

Updated Category News Views 196

China’s national story does not travel overseas by accident; it gets carried by visitors, monuments, rail lines, rivers and carefully chosen questions. The Zunyi News and Media Center report follows Tayyab, a Pakistani PhD student in aerospace engineering at Peking University, as he heads from Beijing to Zunyi, Guizhou, carrying a copy of Edgar Snow’s Red Star Over...

Continue Reading
Four Pending Deals Put Shareholder Terms Under Scrutiny

Updated Category News Views 118

Four corporate transactions landed under a legal microscope on November 18, and that is never background noise for shareholders trying to judge whether the paperwork matches the price. Halper Sadeh LLC says it is investigating proposed deals involving WaFd, Personalis, Dana and Baldwin Group for possible federal securities-law violations and/or fiduciary-duty breaches....

Continue Reading
Emaar's Huspy Deal Brings Financing Into Home Sales

Updated Category News Views 51

Mortgage paperwork is nobody’s idea of luxury, yet it can wreck a property sale faster than a bad floor plan. Emaar Properties has partnered with Dubai-based Huspy to give its customers access to mortgage advice and financing comparisons from more than 20 UAE banks. It is not a flashy tower launch or a headline-grabbing land purchase. Frankly, that is why investors...

Continue Reading
Ambition Links Call Scoring to the Coaching Room Faster

Updated Category News Views 81

A sales call dies twice when nobody turns the recording into practice. First it ends with the prospect, then it vanishes into a pile of transcripts, dashboards, and manager good intentions. Ambition’s new Call Intelligence feature is aimed squarely at that second failure. It brings Gong calls, transcripts, scorecards, and trackers into Ambition’s coaching workflow,...

Continue Reading
A €18 Million Mecca Chandelier Tests Austrian Craft

Updated Category News Views 212

Scale Is Easy to Boast About, Delivery Is Not A 34.1-metre chandelier hanging in Mecca is the sort of job that makes ordinary project talk sound downright silly. Lights of Vienna says it designed, built, tested, shipped and installed this monster for the Grand Mosque's Shamiya area, with a contract value of roughly €18 million. That is a serious piece of work for a...

Continue Reading
Pressure Injury Care Needs More Than Awareness Alone

Updated Category News Views 52

Wet skin does not care how polished the awareness campaign looks. That is the uncomfortable truth sitting underneath Worldwide Pressure Injury Prevention Day, the annual observance held on the third Thursday of November. Pressure injuries remain a stubborn problem across healthcare facilities and home care settings because prevention is not one tidy action; it is a chain...

Continue Reading
Humanoid Robots Need Results Before 2035 Hype Peaks

Updated Category News Views 245

A robot climbing stairs is neat; a robot finishing Tuesday’s shift is the investment case. The latest humanoid robotics forecast puts the global market at $3.07 billion in 2026, up from $2.26 billion in 2025, and projects $47.49 billion by 2035. That is a 35.59% compound annual growth rate, the kind of number that makes investors sit up straight. It also demands a...

Continue Reading
Star Catcher Powers a Public-Interest Space Bet Ahead

Updated Category News Views 56

A satellite’s battery budget is a rotten place for humanitarian priorities to die. Common Space and Star Catcher are trying to remove that bottleneck through a partnership that is easy to like on principle and still deserves a clear-eyed look on execution. Common Space, a nonprofit developing an independent, community-governed high-resolution satellite constellation,...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Science Applications Intl's Earnings Preview: Key Insights Ahead

Updated Category News Views 170

Understanding Science Applications Intl's Earnings Preview Science Applications Intl (NYSE: SAIC) is gearing up for its quarterly earnings announcement. Investors are eager to see how the company performs and whether it meets analysts' expectations. What to Anticipate Analysts project Science Applications Intl will report an earnings per share (EPS) of $2.11, which could...

Continue Reading
Innovative Aerogels Paving the Path for Water Harvesting Solutions

Updated Category News Views 285

Introduction to Atmospheric Water Harvesting The world faces an alarming freshwater crisis, with projections indicating that vast segments of the population are at risk of water scarcity. In response, researchers have innovatively turned to atmospheric water harvesting, particularly highlighting the advancements made by the National University of Singapore (NUS). They...

Continue Reading
Class Action Lawsuit Alert for Tronox Holdings Plc Investors

Updated Category News Views 131

Insights into the Tronox Holdings Class Action Lawsuit Investors in Tronox Holdings Plc (NYSE: TROX) should be aware of a class action lawsuit initiated against the company. This legal action centers around allegations of potential securities fraud and improper business practices by Tronox and some of its leadership. The firm Pomerantz LLP, known for its expertise in...

Continue Reading
Rapport Therapeutics Set to Showcase Innovations in Healthcare

Updated Category News Views 128

Rapport Therapeutics to Attend Major Investor Conferences BOSTON and SAN DIEGO — Rapport Therapeutics, Inc. (Nasdaq: RAPP), a biotechnology firm at the forefront of developing small molecule precision medicines targeting neurological and psychiatric disorders, has expressed its excitement about participating in two notable investor conferences soon. Details of Upcoming...

Continue Reading
Northwestern Mutual Achieves Unmatched Financial Strength Ratings

Updated Category News Views 353

Northwestern Mutual Achieves Elite Financial Ratings for 35 Years For an impressive 35 years, Northwestern Mutual has consistently earned top financial strength ratings from the nation's leading rating agencies. This recognition underscores the company’s commitment to maintaining a robust financial foundation, which plays a crucial role in their ability to serve clients...

Continue Reading